Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That Neurodiversity is becoming an issue

360 replies

mamainlove · 25/09/2022 21:05

Sorry about the thread title:

I have been umming and arrring posting this thread. I'm not able to be speak about this with family/friends (due to lack of knowledge about the area) and some colleagues, as I may seem like a monster if I shared my views.

But I currently work as a speech and language therapist for NHS. The Neurdiversity trend has really changed our practice which I feel may be detrimental to our young people with ASD.

To point out. The support for neurodiverse peopje is minuscule. Children with ASD receive the least amount of provision and if you have a co-morbid conditions, even less so as it's about changing the environment and not about specialist interventions.

Currently, my team are scrapping some of the "typical" interventions that children with ASD usually receive. The idea behind this is that we shouldn't be using interventions that follow a neurotypical path.. for example, if a child with ASD likes to stim with cars, we shouldn't change this (agree) but we shouldn't model and try to teach the children functional play skills, imaginative play, turn taking, "social skills", conversations as that is neurotypical expectations.

I am happy that there is an awareness of neurodiversity but I'm worried that there's a harm in reducing services for children with ASD. A little bit frustrated with the team as it appears that we all have to conform and it's making me reconsider my career choice.

I'm not sure how I could go around this or is the problem with me?

OP posts:
MsCactus · 25/09/2022 23:42

There's a branch of academic psychology that argues all mental illness/disorders labels are damaging as it makes people identify with the illness, think 'its part of them' and not work on techniques to improve their function.

This argument follows that instead of labelling someone as 'nerodivergent' for example, we should look at whether someone is able to function at a basic level, and offer tailored intervention and support when they aren't.

I think this plays into this discussion - lots of people identify as neurodivergent when they are still able to talk, function, work etc and then think they can speak on behalf of people with more severe forms of asd or adhd who cannot speak/live functionally and spend their lives in institutions.

Actually, they probably need very different forms of support and their experiences won't be particularly comparable.

FeelingDown8 · 25/09/2022 23:36

I have autism and I work with autistic clients I am really struggling with the idea that we need to prioritise teaching NT behaviours to ND children in order to increase forms of communication. Every person I have ever met who has autism and has the capacity to mask does so. In order to work, have relationships and live their life. Every autistic person I have met who doesn't have the understanding required to mask successfully, will never have that understanding - and nor should they feel like they should have to (Not masking is a good thing in my experience). NT people either accept ND or they don't. The whole world feels like a NT classroom though, we really don't need that many lessons in how that works. I feel that we should teaching ND children not to mask and to be more congruent, not less. Because this is what you are taking away when you deny integral autistic traits. Congruency and the opportunity to be true to yourself.

Oh wait a minute though.... Am I just an articulate autistic person advocating for all ND? Should I shut up and get out of the way so that NT paper pushers can make decisions instead?

Motheranddaughtertotwo · 25/09/2022 23:32

AntlerRose · 25/09/2022 21:26

But how woukd a child indicate whether they did or didnt want a friend and what if they did want one but just didnt know how so just stuck to a safe thing like playing alone.

No wonder you have concerns.

This! My son did want to play but he just didn’t know how. Once he learnt some basic social skills he now loves spending time with other kids.
I agree with you OP it is worrying. I change lots of things to suit my son (as I do with my neurotypical child) but he does need to fit into society and hopefully live a happy life in this world. I’m a teacher too and I see the reduction in services, it really is so sad, our children deserve better!

mamainlove · 25/09/2022 23:32

WinterSpringSummerorFall · 25/09/2022 22:15

I used "so called" high functioning to indicate it was not an acceptable turn or phrase in the autistic community.

But I will leave this thread now. I believe the OP is trying to support autistic people.and so am I.

Please don't leave this thread. The problem within the SLT field is that their is a lack of diversity (and I mean cultures, genders, life experiences) and we need to conform. We need to hear opposing voices and more questions about our practice.

OP posts:
IvorCutler · 25/09/2022 23:27

I think I’ve probably read the op wrong (half asleep). Just ignore me!

NoYouSirName · 25/09/2022 23:26

Following that thread through to it's conclusion, I could see Local Authorities making the argument that, if the child with ASD does not need to meet the sorts of targets set in EHCPs then some of the justifications for the EHCP (variance from peers, specific support needed, involvement from external agencies, etc.) will no longer be seen as valid because they could say that the child is: "fine as they are". Heck, the eventual end of the line conclusion could be: "It's ableist to ask children with ASD to attend mainstream schools.

Wouldn’t the more logical conclusion be that mainstream schools need to become more inclusive? Or that more specialist provision needs to be available?

NoYouSirName · 25/09/2022 23:24

You will be surprised that some of these children with ASD, who I'm talking about, do not have co current difficulties. Some of my non verbal students with ASD has above average cognitive abilities. But coupled with the lack to support earlier, and reduction to services, they have developed- what others deem, challenging behaviours and are not safe to be in the public domain.

No, I’m not at all surprised because I am parent to three autistic dc with varying support needs, none of whom have learning difficulties. The issue is, what support would be helpful to them. I can’t agree that coaching them to behave in a neurotypical way is the goal. The challenging and unsafe behaviour, in the absence of learning disabilities, usually arises as a result of mental health needs, and ‘upskilling’ as you put it, where the assumption is that autistic people lack skills, is a sure fire way to wreck mental health.

When you say

*No one is saying that we should be encouraging masking. I never said this in my post. I've said it's important to teach ASD children skills.

The issue comes with seeing ASD being a difference vs a disability. If I had a student who has cerebral palsy and I took him/here to physiotherapy in the hope that he/she can walk or gain enough function in her limbs in order to navigate safely- is that ableist?*

you are seeing neurodivergence as a deficit. You are taking the view that neurodivergent children need to be ‘taught’ something that they are lacking. Gain functioning, ‘ups kill’. They already have perfectly good skills, and it will serve them better to recognise them rather than teach them that they are inherently deficient.

With the example of the autistic child who seemed happy alone at break time, but in fact didn’t know how to join a group… rather than assuming his skills are deficient, it’s important to see that there is difficulty in both sides. He is unable to relate to his neurotypical peers, and they are also struggling to relate to him. He is no more deficient than they are. Awareness will help. Teaching him to act neurotypical in order to be accepted might look like a success but is actually setting him up for a lifetime of being unable to be himself. Rather than teaching someone to walk, it’s more like teaching someone who is gay to act straight. You might see it as success when they get married and have kids but that person is deeply unhappy.

IvorCutler · 25/09/2022 23:23

I don’t really understand what you’re getting at with your post op (I’m not being snarky). You’ve mentioned the neurodiversity ‘trend’… that sounds off to me.

Ds is autistic and I was very happy with the SLT support he received when he was younger.

I don’t begrudge other children (not diagnosed ASD) potentially getting further support ahead of my child. Lots of us need help and I’m sure their needs are valid too.

Somethingneedstochange · 25/09/2022 23:21

I think she's basically saying severely autistic children have other ways of communicating they're need's so don't need speech therapy.

A lot use signing or picture symbols so that should be the focus. Sometimes when they can see a picture they will say the word. You cannot force speech from an autistic child. You need to find another way.

One size does not fit all but SALT is not really fit for the needs of children with the most severe disabilities. The more able might get more out of it. I'm not an expert no just a mum of two with severe autism/ADHD.

5zeds · 25/09/2022 23:20

Assess, advice and discharge.
here they skip advice in my experience. It’s assess, discharge.

I think it’s ableist to try a teach significantly above (or below) an individual’s developmental level, because rushing them along or dragging them back has real and lasting impact. “Treating” someone for something that is not broken an is in fact their norm isn’t always helping. For example forcing a nt child to walk months before they are able isn’t a treatment, teaching a child far beyond their understanding of language is dreadful. Similarly insisting they use language like a nt 4 year old before they learn to read or they use pecs before they use any other communication method is just daft. So many wasted years and wasted opportunities to really help people.

mamainlove · 25/09/2022 23:15

FamSender · 25/09/2022 23:02

What is the evidence base for new neurodiverse appropriate therapy approaches for children?

Are any old interventions "ND approved"?

Or is all intervention based on a medical model and therefore not warranted, and we should look to social/environmental changes? Is there research on this?

The research is very new. In terms of interventions/ not much, research is just looking into the whole neurodiversity and how this presents in ASD (again!). That's the problem, academic scholars have done tons of research on the ethology of Autism, how it manifests, what it looks like etc etc and little research into quality of life, interventions etc.

OP posts:
PizzaFunghi · 25/09/2022 23:15

My understanding of what the OP might have meant by "neurodiversity trend" was the greatly increased tendency lately for neurodiversity to be accepted and embraced by various people with the conditions (diagnosed or self-identified), particularly online - almost a 'reclaiming' of the words, a feeling of 'finding your tribe', understanding your differences, accepting them, not masking etc. - lots of positive aspects to it, people much more willing to share their conditions publicly, and so on.

Although this might be connected to the increased awareness and diagnosis of ASD, it feels like a slightly separate thing - it's more of a positive movement surrounding the conditions, not just the fact of increased awareness and diagnosis.

And I can see what the OP means that in some cases, this could lead to reduction in services. While many ND people might agree that they are divergent not disordered, and in no need of any sort of therapy to change the way the communicate or interact, there are others who do want or need this, either because they are distressed at not being able to interact as NT people do, or because they need some basic level of 'fitting in' in order to be able to advocate for themselves for safeguarding or generally surviving in a society that is the way it is. And it is hard to determine where the balance is between teaching some of these skills, even if they are not needed or wanted at that point. And particularly hard when you are talking about a young child, where you don't know whether they want friends or want to be able to speak in class or go to a shop or order a meal. I think there is a danger of the mood shifting to "if you just accept neurodiversity, then they don't need any SLT", and all services end up withdrawn. I may have spent much of my childhood masking, and I don't think I was taught well in some aspects, being dropped in the deep end and forced to do things until I showed no anxiety on the outside, but at the same time, they are skills I needed and have enabled me to do things that have made my life much better, so if I'd just been left as I was, that would not have served me well. I'd rather be taught how I was making and why and how to cope with its effects, and how to do it better and less stressfully. I'd have preferred a gentler way of teaching that went at my pace. But I would not have wanted to be told I was fine as I was, and that the world should adapt to whatever way I wanted to communicate.

FamSender · 25/09/2022 23:14

How do you know?

SheldontheWonderSchlong · 25/09/2022 23:09

TrainspottingWelsh · 25/09/2022 23:01

@Tumbleweed101

The nd, or natural, instinctive part of my brain makes me want to just reply with a less polite version of shut up.
However I understand the acceptable nt response would be to explain why you’re wrong in flowery terms and adhere to rules about how to offer constructive criticism and educate etc.
Instead I’m already compromising by attempting to illustrate we often already modify our behaviour without people like you ever realising.
I don’t expect you to understand, nor on a personal level do I care what you think. However in return for the compromises nd people make everyday, it would be great if you could meet us halfway and try, at least in public to mask your ignorance and contain your natural urge to share your uninformed opinions.

Agreed. Plus the whole 'NT people mask too y'know' is so ignorant. It is not comparable at all imo.

mamainlove · 25/09/2022 23:08

sunshineflowerdaisy · 25/09/2022 22:51

I'm an NHS SLT in a different field.

We don't offer therapy to ANYONE anymore. That's the NHS. Assess, advice and discharge. I'm not sure if that's what you're trying to say? I think calling the 'neurodiversity trend' the reason for it is quite insulting and I'd be wary of throwing that around as a professional.

Also - what is your evidence based for either approach? That's the backbone of any intervention.

Well that's the problem. Assess and diagnose, asses and diagnose and then what? No support, no therapy, nothing for parents on how to support their children with ASD. No one is challenging our service provision. That's the problem. We just accept it as it is.

OP posts:
PyongyangKipperbang · 25/09/2022 23:05

I get it. Oddly, my son does in fact have Cerebal Palsy and never has it crossed my mind that helping him to live independently would be considered ableist!

Its the mind set of "some people cant, so no one else should" that is worrying. Some people can learn certain skills, others can't, but they should all be offered the opportunity to try and if, as you said, its not their thing, then ok and move on to other things that do suit them. Sometimes people can surprise you! I was told 30 years ago that my son would never walk, unlikely talk and need care 24/7 for the rest of his life. Shortly before he took himself to (his own) home today we had a chat about the business he is starting. So........

Offering everyone the same opprtunity to learn a skill is not ableist, its the absolute opposite!

Supersimkin2 · 25/09/2022 23:05

Under argument B) you can put every illness and injury covered by the DDA. So, er, why would an NHS exist if treating say, cancer or MS is discriminatory?

‘It’s not a brain tumour, it’s a difference.

‘Go home.’

FamSender · 25/09/2022 23:02

What is the evidence base for new neurodiverse appropriate therapy approaches for children?

Are any old interventions "ND approved"?

Or is all intervention based on a medical model and therefore not warranted, and we should look to social/environmental changes? Is there research on this?

TrainspottingWelsh · 25/09/2022 23:01

@Tumbleweed101

The nd, or natural, instinctive part of my brain makes me want to just reply with a less polite version of shut up.
However I understand the acceptable nt response would be to explain why you’re wrong in flowery terms and adhere to rules about how to offer constructive criticism and educate etc.
Instead I’m already compromising by attempting to illustrate we often already modify our behaviour without people like you ever realising.
I don’t expect you to understand, nor on a personal level do I care what you think. However in return for the compromises nd people make everyday, it would be great if you could meet us halfway and try, at least in public to mask your ignorance and contain your natural urge to share your uninformed opinions.

Xmasbaby11 · 25/09/2022 23:01

My DD 10 has ASD and benefits from help with her communication skills. She needs to know how conversations work, not just in the big wide world but at home, with her family, in the classroom, in social situations. You can't avoid dealing with people. Even for children who aren't bothered about friendships, they should aim for basic communication skills. DD struggles with things like:

turntaking (she will speak over everyone)
asking questions, following up (just talks about herself, doesn't know how to show interest)
intonation (angry, polite, enquiring)
facial expressions
non literal language

polite language

She is receptive to being taught explicitly about these by us and activities set up at school. She's very sociable and is desperate to have friends, so these skills are important. She still doesn't follow the rules all the time and forgets when she is emotional or tired, but she is getting there and able to communicate better with her peers. Of course they try to be tolerant when they know (eg her classmates) she has ASD but they would still misunderstand her or be put off working with her, being friends with her.

And yes, other social rules like don't hug people unless they are ok with it, don't take food off people's plates.

mamainlove · 25/09/2022 23:01

FamSender · 25/09/2022 22:43

It is interesting to me that this is such a battle.

SLTs trying to make sure they are giving the right support to all the autistic children and families they work with, based on current research and feedback.

Autistic adults.and parents of autistic children trying to make sure the right intervention is delivered to autistix individuals.

Aren't you all pulling in the same direction?

Yes, vocabulary used might not be 100% perfect all the time, but isn't it better to focus togehther on what will work that pick apart the language of the debate?

Not if there is a risk to access of services and funding for these individuals. Then language really does matter,

OP posts:
Supersimkin2 · 25/09/2022 23:00

So you’re saying that ASD DC are at risk of not getting SLT because:

a) stakeholders say reducing ASD behaviours via this text therapy is disablist and wrong
b) the NHS is using the discrimination argument to reduce therapy and save money
c) even though ASD DC, who already get precious little therapy, may benefit from
the therapy even if they risk being seen or judged as neurotypical as a result.

mamainlove · 25/09/2022 22:59

Onceuponatimethen · 25/09/2022 22:43

Some of what you say sounds good - I don’t think there is any point aiming to teach imaginative play to dc like my dc who have very HFA but will never play imaginatively. And in my view that’s fine - we need to be less impairment focus and value not belittle any different skills.

But I do have real concerns about the friendship stuff and there I agree with you. My dc honestly very weak in this at 3-6 but now has friends after years and years of SALT and support at home. Friendship makes them so happy which they say themselves. So risky to extrapolate lifelong preference not to socialise from youthful difficulty with the social rules.

Yes.

I had an SLT colleague say to me "well if I see an Autistic child by themselves and they are happy, I won't teach them turn-taking, friendship skills, he is happy on his own".

I then turned around and said "Well I had a similar scenario, I too saw an ASD child, who was playing by himself and seem content, happy actually. When we did our 1:1 session I asked him "Z, you seemed liked you enjoyed yourself in the playground". He replied to me and said "Did I? No I didn't. I didn't have no one to play with. I want to have friends but I don't know how". I then further added and said to my colleague "well... I was lucky he was able to verbalise this to me how much more for children who are not able to do this or communicate this effectively".

OP posts:
Chrissmasjammies · 25/09/2022 22:57

@sunshineflowerdaisy that’s shocking - how does your trust justify that, it’s such a fundamental part of what an SLT does. What about the evidence base for that? What about duty of care? Regulatory requirements, keeping up knowledge and skills etc. it must be such a difficult way to work and very stressful for staff. I’m a publicly employed SLT and although our levels of service are very low that’s another level.

mamainlove · 25/09/2022 22:54

NoYouSirName · 25/09/2022 22:42

*Please don’t take this the wrong way.

But there are children with ASD who have high support needs, are not able to function at all, have no communication, who are either in prison or in institutions. My worry is mainly for these groups of children/adults not adults with ASD who can relatively function in society and have adequate communication skills to function day to day.*

To be fair, you don’t know what my support needs are, or day time day functioning, those are assumptions on your part based on the fact that I can type a message and express myself here.

I spent a large proportion of my young adult life in ‘institutions’.

However, I do know that there are some autistic people with concurrent learning difficulties. Of course there are. My point still stands. Encouraging masking isn’t helpful for them either, it never could be. It’s all the more important to encourage acceptance of different ways of communicating, when someone is completely non verbal and has no voice to express what they need, surely?

No one is saying that we should be encouraging masking. I never said this in my post. I've said it's important to teach ASD children skills.

The issue comes with seeing ASD being a difference vs a disability. If I had a student who has cerebral palsy and I took him/here to physiotherapy in the hope that he/she can walk or gain enough function in her limbs in order to navigate safely- is that ableist?

OP posts: