Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That Neurodiversity is becoming an issue

360 replies

mamainlove · 25/09/2022 21:05

Sorry about the thread title:

I have been umming and arrring posting this thread. I'm not able to be speak about this with family/friends (due to lack of knowledge about the area) and some colleagues, as I may seem like a monster if I shared my views.

But I currently work as a speech and language therapist for NHS. The Neurdiversity trend has really changed our practice which I feel may be detrimental to our young people with ASD.

To point out. The support for neurodiverse peopje is minuscule. Children with ASD receive the least amount of provision and if you have a co-morbid conditions, even less so as it's about changing the environment and not about specialist interventions.

Currently, my team are scrapping some of the "typical" interventions that children with ASD usually receive. The idea behind this is that we shouldn't be using interventions that follow a neurotypical path.. for example, if a child with ASD likes to stim with cars, we shouldn't change this (agree) but we shouldn't model and try to teach the children functional play skills, imaginative play, turn taking, "social skills", conversations as that is neurotypical expectations.

I am happy that there is an awareness of neurodiversity but I'm worried that there's a harm in reducing services for children with ASD. A little bit frustrated with the team as it appears that we all have to conform and it's making me reconsider my career choice.

I'm not sure how I could go around this or is the problem with me?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ItsAlmostSpring · 19/03/2023 01:48

Neurodiversity is used as a get out clause to explain further cuts in services due to funding issues across the public sector - and I say it as NHS worker as well as a mother of autistic child. Both child as well as adult services are affected, but especially CAMHS. Most managers cannot even use the correct terminology....

NoYouSirName · 18/03/2023 23:36

Mustreadabook · 18/03/2023 20:49

Maths doesn’t come naturally to some children. We still try and get them to learn it. Because it is useful to help them function in society. Is this wrong?

It doesn’t go against their neurology though or force them to pretend to be someone they are not? I think learning a subject is different from changing the whole way we engage with the world.

Mustreadabook · 18/03/2023 20:49

Maths doesn’t come naturally to some children. We still try and get them to learn it. Because it is useful to help them function in society. Is this wrong?

5zeds · 28/09/2022 14:21

I don’t think it’s ever too late to introduce new ways of communicating. It also gives a clean slate so carried through confusion can be avoided.
The most helpful thing for generalising for ds was writing the vocab under the pec/picture. It meant that support workers and teachers used the same words because their eye had fallen on “jersey” not jumper/sweater/whatever and consistently used that word. Ds couldn’t “see” pictures at all for a long time but he could read and he could hear the words but not join them together himself. I think any form of picture exchange or timeline’s real value was that it reduced vocab in the environment.

Neurodiversespeechies · 28/09/2022 12:55

@Changingnames20 If you read back actually giving those teens iPads and supporting the use of them has developed their language. They were previously limited to pecs (which I totally agree isn’t functional and shouldn’t have been used for so long) but now 2/3 are able to use an app to communicate a range sentences for different functions. That is language development.

Neurodiversespeechies · 28/09/2022 12:51

@Changingnames20 That’s impressive, I’m really pleased for your son that you have found something that works. Parents are so often the best teachers for their child and the little and often approach with the right prompting can go a long way. I’d be interested to know if you think the same could be achieved by a salt doing a session a week without the carry over from a parent? In this case it sounds like you’ve been far more effective than a professional could have been due to how well you know your boy and how often you were able to do these activities.

It is also the most useful thing for generalisation to have things done by someone who is able to use those strategies/prompts in everyday situations

5zeds · 28/09/2022 08:32

My son could not pick up language just by being in life. In fact he absolutely hated being even in a toddler group, and hated anyone talking to him.
I don’t think this is what’s being described though. I think the teaching is happening 1:1 (with supervision) and then being generalised in a group setting.

For my child this would in effect be small times when he was being taught and then longer times when he wasn’t. He might enjoy it and get other things from the experience, just as a more mainstream child might learn to read in class but not in assembly.

My child ISN’T nonverbal though. He IS severely language disordered/delayed so the impact of the different environments and models will be different. We had an extraordinary speech and language therapist when he was very young and I found ideas from both Montessori and Asperger lead me to better ways of thinking/doing.

Changingnames20 · 28/09/2022 03:08

@Neurodiversespeechies
If you could link a study that proves that you can successfully treat a language disorder in a preverbal teen with autism in a way that successfully generalises to everyday activities i’d be really interested to read it!
Well I have managed this with my own son, I had to do years of one to one regular language work with him, but he is now generalising it as with all his skills. It takes a very, very long time to get language if you are not picking this up naturally from the world around you.

My son could not pick up language just by being in life. In fact he absolutely hated being even in a toddler group, and hated anyone talking to him. Apart from me.

He basically needed continuous carers - ones that understood him very well. And that was mainly me. I needed to match my language to his understanding. He didn’t like Pecs, so I didn’t use it. Some other parents found it helped but not him. I trialled a number of approaches, never ‘withholding’, forcing, overtalking. Mainly getting down on his level, and working on language by matching words with high interest objects or simple song rhymes but leaving out a tiny bit and ‘waiting expectantly… ‘ leaving gaps in language for him to fill in but never for long.

This isn’t rocket science but there isn’t a professional who advised me, not a school or a placement who did any direct or one to one work with him. Nothing. He did start, very, very slowly to say his first words and to understand his first words. It takes great patience but also one to one - lots of it - for years!

I can’t tell you how many professionals told me ‘he won’t generalise’. Well he does. He speaks, understands and can’t stop writing. He loves language.

I find it totally baffling that professionals could think bunging someone an AAC, Pecs or stuffing them in a loud noisy classroom and just ‘creating the right environment’ would actually help develop speech and language!

Millie2008 · 28/09/2022 00:15

Greenapplesandpears · 25/09/2022 21:25

I have asd as well and I vividly remember the pain caused to me by my own mothers ‘de sensitisation ‘ programme (basically her way of trying to ‘normalise’ me) I was forced into all the situations that caused meltdowns ot shutdown I was humiliated and made to practice conversations and social situations over and over . If I did it wrong I was ridiculed as a way to make me try harder. I know this is an extreme example but the theory behind it I suppose is the same - to make a person with asd act as if they don’t have asd

So sorry you went through this, sounds horrendous

Millie2008 · 28/09/2022 00:12

BryceQuinlanTheFirst · 25/09/2022 21:14

I'm a parent of a child who receive SLT. I am happy he won't be forced to do imaginary play and other things he has no interest in. Why does he have to? If my son saw a line of animals, he would make them into interesting patterns, he wouldn't pretend they moo or roar. Why is that way right?

I wish more SLTs would work within a child's interests. Every time I've gone to our session, they have a load of toys my son has zero interest in. I keep asking if they can provide x,y,z and they just don't. But realistically, the support is no minimal that 4 sessions twice a year which is what we get, is utterly pointless to make any meaningful impact anyway. And no time for them to get to know the child. The whole system is so so broken.

I love Meaningful Speech and Sensory SLP on instagram. They both use fantastic tactics to get engagement from autistic kids. Wish more British SLTs were like this.

Agree with all this

mamainlove · 27/09/2022 23:49

Neurodiversespeechies · 27/09/2022 23:21

Any chance you’d be able to private message me the study? I’d be really interested to read

Yes!! I'll be happy to Smile

OP posts:
5zeds · 27/09/2022 23:48

I assume the pecs bit wasn’t aimed at me?

Most autistics find focus extremely difficult in crowded environments, most language disordered people find hearing what is said when delivered by multiple voices, with other voices muddled in and and over and changes in who is talking to who very challenging. I can only speak from my own experience which is with one individual over a couple of decades, so more hours than a professional but without the breadth. I’d express similar concerns if someone was attempting to teach a reception class to read in a busy train station.

Neurodiversespeechies · 27/09/2022 23:31

forgot to tag @5zeds in that previous post

Neurodiversespeechies · 27/09/2022 23:30

As I said in my post I don’t consider pecs to be a functional commutation method. One of the things I actually agree with the neurodiversity movement about!

I also haven’t said anywhere that I required these teens to do pecs/ gain certain skills before they were allowed high tech aac. Gate keeping of skills isn’t what has happened,

In this case I have don’t the best I can for the teens whos’ care has been recently transferred to me and that has involved introducing high tech aac.

I think you’ve also misunderstood my definition of coaching. I wasn’t providing training as such. What I did was spend time in their classroom modelling to the adults how they could be using the iPad more in the lesson. I also took each teen separately with a TA and modelled an example of an activity where they could be reinforcing the core vocabulary words (functional words such as help, want, more, stop etc). I’ve left the class with a clear guidance of what to practise before my next session. That’s what functional speech therapy is looking like for that little group of young people with autism at the moment. It’s not less, it’s not worse quality because it’s not ‘direct’ or taking place 1:1 away from the classroom. It’s based around their current needs and maximising their use of the tools they have available to them in functional ways.

Neurodiversespeechies · 27/09/2022 23:21

Any chance you’d be able to private message me the study? I’d be really interested to read

5zeds · 27/09/2022 23:03

The implementation of an high tec AAC should have been implemented way way sooner- rather than the child reaching some level of "competency" before moving onto PECS. there’s a lot of gate keeping of skills that impedes progress.

mamainlove · 27/09/2022 22:31

*moving onto a high tec AAC that should say- I'm on my phone so my grammar is all over the place with the stupid autocorrect.

OP posts:
mamainlove · 27/09/2022 22:27

@Neurodiversespeechies

Interestingly what I’ve never managed to find and would be really interested to read is a study that compares results when therapy is delivered directly by a salt with therapy that is delivered by a well coached/ trained parent/ teacher/ TA with supervision from a salt

I don't want to out. myself on this thread and don't wish to link the research articles as THAT will definitely put me. But there is a recent paper on this very comment you are querying about it.

In a short answer, for children who have significant language disorders therapy is better when it is delivered by trained speech and language therapists.

There is some evidence that therapy is also effective (communication wise) when it's delivered by a parent. But that's only when they have very close supervision with the the SALT and there is regular coaching from a qualified therapist. 3 or 10 visits a term from an SLT, training teachers and parents is not going to cut it, even if the parent has some training here and there. Parents and TA's require regular ongoing coaching, training and modelling an SLT. If you have very clued up parent, then that's amazing and something different.

Having Therapy done by a TA would not yield much results for children with significant language disorders,the evidence pointed out that children with mild language disorders benefited actually were the ones who benefited from therapy where your average TA's had modelling, guidance from an SLT.

The qualifications and experience of the TA is crucial and will lead much better results for children with significant SLCN. So if you have a TA who has a number of years experience working with children with SLCN, has a degree or advance education status, has conducted trained suited for those with SLCN and is given regular support, coaching and guidance from an SLT, then that is gold and that's when you would really see a difference in the children with SLCN. I used to work with an ex dyslexia trained now TA who was Amazing. Any interventions, she took it on the chin, she knew exactly what she had to do, how to step up/down.

... I have worked with pre verbal teens but that's not really my area. Would I do 1:1 therapy with a preverbal teen on a weekly basis-no, it would be much more functional but I would argue that he should have received 1:1 weekly SLT in his younger years (even if he was non verbal). I also would not expect a pre verbal teen to transition from PECS to an high tec AAC. The implementation of an high tec AAC should have been implemented way way sooner- rather than the child reaching some level of "competency" before moving onto PECS.

OP posts:
5zeds · 27/09/2022 22:05

You can be a highly intelligent person with autism and still have significant needs in multiple other areas.
obviously

If you don’t understand what the Ed psych assessment provided, how does it inform your practice? My experience would suggest that group teaching with multiple teens with differing needs and multiple support workers receiving training and a trainer would not be ideal in anyway and I can’t imagine how it would be better for any of the teens involved.

Neurodiversespeechies · 27/09/2022 21:59

@mamainlove I’d also be interested to hear what your 1:1 direct language therapy for preverbal teens with autism would look like?

any ideas for activities are always welcome

Neurodiversespeechies · 27/09/2022 21:57

An unfortunate accidental posting too soon there…

and because I believe that there’s such a wide gap between the people shouting for neurodiversity affirming therapies and those I am seeing for therapy I try not to base my practise on those opinions.

Neurodiversespeechies · 27/09/2022 21:53

@5zeds they have been assessed by an Ed psych though, not being a trained Ed psych myself, I can’t comment on what exactly that assessment will have provided.

I think a tricky thing is though that autism is a disorder not a delay. This means that every person with autism has a spiky profile of strengths and needs and therefore intelligence can’t be compared in the same way as it would to a neurotypical person. You can be a highly intelligent person with autism and still have significant needs in multiple other areas. This does not always mean that we are able to bring all skills in line because if that was possible we would be curing autism and unfortunately that’s something we just can’t do. We need to build on what we can with the resources we have.

im not someone who is buying into the neurodiversity movement in all ways. I fully believe that the type of autism I work with every week is very different to those who are able to articulate themselves so well on line to argue that much of my work is wrong or cruel or ablest.

LottiePa · 27/09/2022 21:51

NHS SALT is an absolute waste of time.

We waited 16 weeks for an hour appointment to be told they would Give DS targets and review in 6 months (he is 3 next month and has 5 words but SALT don’t seem to care / want to help)

I’ve been fighting for help for DS for 18 months. Everyone goes on about early intervention but no one intervenes!

Neurodiversespeechies · 27/09/2022 21:44

@mamainlove
Out of interest have you ever done 1:1 direct therapy with a a pre verbal teen with autism for prolonged periods of time and has it been more effective in achieving functional communication than aac within a classroom.

If you could link a study that proves that you can successfully treat a language disorder in a preverbal teen with autism in a way that successfully generalises to everyday activities i’d be really interested to read it!

The teens I saw today have successfully transitioned from pecs (which I would not consider a robust or functional language system) to an iPad. One was typing sentences using the keypad (the sentences showed little sign of ‘language disorder’), one was using a combination of typed words and symbols and may have a language disorder and need some work on structuring this to make it more functional and one was just beginning to join sentences.

All 3 are making progress, all 3 have more communication than they did a few months ago and none of them are appearing stressed by the implementation of this communication system.

I agree that Down’s syndrome is a different kettle of fish and direct language therapy is needed alongside work in all other domains of communication and interactions. Interestingly what I’ve never managed to find and would be really interested to read is a study that compares results when therapy is delivered directly by a salt with therapy that is delivered by a well coached/ trained parent/ teacher/ TA with supervision from a salt.

5zeds · 27/09/2022 21:10

It’s been hugely problematic for us @mamainlove and don’t honestly know what the solution is. Understanding of how it needs to drive support is so limited that sometimes we get a better outcome if we don’t try to explain.