Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

do you think a school bully can end up as a good adult friend?

110 replies

northernlurker85 · 25/09/2022 20:28

hello. genuinely interested in your thoughts here. i had a friend request from a person we all hated at school this was over 20 years ago. i am happy to forgive and forget as we were both very different people,nothing more than kids but do you think people like that can change?

OP posts:
extrasushiplease · 25/09/2022 21:53

I had a terrible bully when I was young: she truly lashed out at random and would cycle through main targets week to week. During a school year, her parents were involved in a murder suicide in front of her and her sister. After that, the bullying turned into a very withdrawn young girl. That was a shocking wake up call to me about cause and effect.

YEARS later she sent me a friend request: She looked happy and had a young, grinning son. People can live many lifetimes within just one. If you instinctually want to remain guarded, that’s understandable and I wouldn’t judge you, but I also don’t think it hurts to give people a chance. Maybe she’s cool now, maybe she’s not, but either way, you may learn something from finding out.

Tobletone · 25/09/2022 21:50

I'm guessing that someone who talks about "rising above it" has never experienced or even witnessed bad bullying. It's not just a bit of name calling. Try reading some of the bullying threads on here. Serious bullying can devastate lives.

user1471554720 · 25/09/2022 21:47

To the people saying, be kind etc. What if you are still frightened of your bully and want to keep away from them??? I cannot make myself be 'unfrightened' of them!!!!

I know bullies can't beat you up but can be very smart and hurtful.

I would be afraid to be friends with them. They could make hurtful comments under the guise of a joke. I know people change etc but it is better for them to make friends with new people who did not know them years ago and are not wary of them.

Thatiswild · 25/09/2022 21:41

People can change but I wouldn’t be letting any of the people who bullied me at school see anything about me now. I’d just have no interest to know about them or them see what I’m up to. I don’t hate them or anything, I’m over it, but they’re not my friends, I just say no.

Bobbybobbins · 25/09/2022 21:40

I think it depends. I was bullied at school both ongoing by one girl, who I would never want to see again, and casually by some others in my form in year 7 who I would say jumped on the bandwagon - these I could.

In fact when we got into year 11 I was quite friendly with one of them and plucked up the courage to ask her if she remembered saying she hated me in year 7, and why she said it. (This was not the only occasion) She couldn't remember it at all and was mortified. Showed how what was a flyaway comment to her was so hurtful to me but we got past it.

FairlyIncognito · 25/09/2022 21:40

I think I’d likely respond . I always teach our DC that anyone unkind is often unhappy deep down and it’s important to rise above it and just be a good person. I got in touch with a girl I boarded with aged 8 and it was quite cathartic and to know she’s ok (in my case I felt guilt I hadn’t looked after her more but I was so young and struggling myself. And it turned out she immediately thanked me for being so kind to her so I guess recollections on events can vary too!)

LiveInSunshine · 25/09/2022 21:33

I met someone who tried to bully me often at school, tried to start fights and was physically threatening. Very tall girl and quite scary. She’d trip me in corridors, take swings at me and even threatened to cut me up.

As adults I was taller than her and she’d matured into a different person, we had a pleasant chat and I’d see her again. I think to be that angry and violent something, in retrospect, must have really been going wrong in her life. Maybe I, as a clearly secure and loved child, provoked a jealousy I didn’t understand at the time? The adult her was so different, and she clearly had bounced back as a good mum from a tough start from what I saw. I didn’t force the point but she clearly was a bit embarrassed to see me.

Redbone · 25/09/2022 21:33

Sad to say NO, once a bully always a bully.

NationMcKinley · 25/09/2022 21:31

Yes. I am friends with a girl who was awful to me at school. Really nasty. We bumped into each other in the park when our DC were small. She literally ran up to me, hugged me and told me how sorry she was. Unbeknownst to me, she’d had a really shitty time, incl some abuse. She’s actually a lovely lovely person and a fab mum. Her teenage self just couldn’t deal with her life at that time and that’s how she expressed it.

I was not a bully but I’d hate to be judged now, at 40, for the massive twat I was at 14. Saying that, obviously all circumstances are different and I’d prob be wary of a social media request tbh. This was a spontaneous chance meeting and I’m really glad it happened. I think @Psychopomps says it well.

Tobletone · 25/09/2022 21:29

If everyone at your primary school hated this person, that's not a typical bully scenario. Just from that sentence I'd guess that it was the widely hated person who was the victim of group bullying. It doesn't sound as though you were necessarily singled out and picked on by this person. Perhaps that's why you've recovered so well.

Anycrispsleft · 25/09/2022 21:27

This happened to me a few years back. I ignored the friend request - why on earth would I want to waste time pretending to be friends with someone who was horrible to me? I googled her a few years later and she was part of a high profile domestic violence case, apparently very materially successful but was hiding a miserable life. It didn't really make me have mich sympathy though. So she probably suffered a lot of childhood trauma. So did I - it was doubtless the abuse I suffered at home that made me such an easy target at school. The difference is I didn't try to take it out on anyone else.

northernlurker85 · 25/09/2022 21:24

thanks all. i am now a very well rounded adult lol. i went to a bording school and i had no contact at all in the years since with this person. we all went our separate ways. but i sometimes think its easy to brand people when they are kids and when you don't know what happened to them and just believe they can never change for the better.

OP posts:
KoalaCape · 25/09/2022 21:24

Personally I would not accept the request. Why does this person, who clearly hasn't been a positive part of your life (or any part of your life) between school and the present say, need to "friend you" online? I'd be worried they actually wanted to just have a snoop and see how you turned out.

The people that bullied me in school are of no interest to me and nor would I want them having any access to information about my adult life. They may be the nicest people ever now, but I have no need to link with them online or in person.

I think in OPs situation it depends if you think they actually want to befriend you, perhaps apologise (assuming they were the bully- your post isn't actually clear about this) and make amends or if they've just seen you as a friend suggestion and are curious.

User98866 · 25/09/2022 21:21

I probably wouldn’t be friends with my bully, certainly not on Facebook as it’s meaningless. (I ignored Facebook friends request from her). I do think that as adults we can recognise why they might have behaved that way and gain a bit more understanding. The girl who was absolutely vile to me at school lost her mum as a teenager. I didn’t know this until years later but it explains a lot and I do feel really sorry for her. She ended up with a less than desirable life from what I can tell. Having said that I also had a really turbulent childhood including losing a parent and I wasn’t a twat to others. So whilst I had sympathy I wasn’t going to extend it to Facebook friends when our real life paths didn’t need to cross, despite living in close proximity to her as an adult. I do think it depends on the situation and I do think people can change.

Tobletone · 25/09/2022 21:18

This person doesn't want to be your friend. They probably want you to accept them as a Facebook friend so they can tell themselves and maybe others that what they did at school was insignificant. And if you're considering accepting their request, then the bullying probably was at the lower end, or maybe it was directed at others more than at you.

Psychopomps · 25/09/2022 21:13

I think you’re confusing ‘friend request on social media’ with actual friendship. All this person has done is asked to be added. It’s not any kind of significant gesture.

donttellmehesalive · 25/09/2022 21:13

*only

donttellmehesalive · 25/09/2022 21:12

It's o my a friend request. I'd accept it for nosiness purposes. If she posts crap, or never comments anything worthwhile on your posts, or tries to dm you, unfriend.

Darbs76 · 25/09/2022 21:12

If they were a bully in general or bullied me directly - the answer to that would depend on my view. But yes people do change, especially when they have children themselves

CequeJaroayJeka · 25/09/2022 21:10

Depends. If they can recognise and apologise for the hurt they have caused, and have processed and dealt with whatever trauma sent them down that path in the first place, and have learned healthier ways to interact now, then yes possibly. I wouldn't be holding a grudge, but it might be healthier for them to make new friends who don't have memories of their bullying days.

Tobletone · 25/09/2022 21:09

I seriously doubt these people genuinely get what they've done, or care. They downplay it. And I don't buy them having suffered trauma in early childhood either. Obviously, some will have. But a lot of these people are Alpha girls getting a kick out of doing as much harm as they can to someone.

sst1234 · 25/09/2022 21:07

Up to you if you want to give time of day to a nasty, vile person. You must have a lot of time to give.

Arbesque · 25/09/2022 21:06

Yes people can change. Some school bullies were very unhappy and insecure people. If they realise their behaviour was wrong and are genuinely sorry for it then they shouldn't be forever tarnished by the way they behaved as an unhappy or misguided child or teenager.

PerpetualStudent · 25/09/2022 20:54

It’s a nope from me. I was horrifically bullied in primary school, no way that individual was ever going to be on my level. For better or worse you reap what you sow

AperolWhore · 25/09/2022 20:51

Absolutely not, these school bully type people tend to forget all the misery they caused and like top don’t themselves in a good light. Avoid, avoid, avoid!