Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

do you think a school bully can end up as a good adult friend?

110 replies

northernlurker85 · 25/09/2022 20:28

hello. genuinely interested in your thoughts here. i had a friend request from a person we all hated at school this was over 20 years ago. i am happy to forgive and forget as we were both very different people,nothing more than kids but do you think people like that can change?

OP posts:
BeggyMitchell · 26/09/2022 10:29

I honestly don't think people change that much. Their relationships, their trappings? Sure. But essentially who they are, no. I would trust your instinct.

Tobletone · 26/09/2022 10:25

northernlurker85 · 26/09/2022 04:19

hi all. just to answer a question about how long i knew this person. we went through secondary together. from year 7 right up to 6th form it happened. what i think is its easy as a kid to see life very black and white. you don't know what happened to them as its all rightly kept confidential. maybe he was hitting out. he didn't pick on those who would fight back, it was always the sensitive kids who would get upset by him. we did talk on fb and it was like talking to a different person and how can i be resentful towards a person who i knew in literally a different lifetime? i don't see how you can move forwards if your holding resentment towards things that happened in your past? easy said than done i know.

I think you should show a bit of respect and understanding of those "sensitive" and defenseless children this person went for. He's looking for people to tell him that what he did was ok, just something young boys do, doesn't affect their opinion of him. I don't think you should give him that, no.

Tobletone · 26/09/2022 10:19

I also doubt that many people change fundamentally. Bullying doesn't just happen at school. It's rife in all areas of life, in particular at work. The bullies at work are probably the people who were bullies at school. It's about status, popularity, the enjoyment of power. People who say they're sorry are highly unlikely to understand or to care about the effect they had on that person. It's just shallow words by someone who hasn't examined what they did and why.

CulturePigeon · 26/09/2022 10:05

No - unless they actively show remorse and sort of 'confess' their crimes.

Children are uninhibited forms of ourselves and I think bullies learn to behave more acceptably, but are fundamentally the same people. They'd have to be very humble indeed for me to contemplate a relationship with a school bully.

I used to say to my daughter 'if you don't like someone, OK, but there's no need to be mean - just keep away from them.' Hasten to add - she was NOT a bully herself, but witnessed a lot of it and couldn't understand it.

They are a special sort of person who actively enjoy inflicting pain.

superplumb · 26/09/2022 09:17

I couldnt be friends with any of my bullies.i dont forgive and forget though and I'm quite a bitter person.

Sittingonabench · 26/09/2022 09:10

The way I see it there is a huge gap between forgiveness for behaviour that may have been due to personal circumstances and the pressurised school environment and allowing that person back into your life. I would work on forgiving them as it can turn into a toxic part of yourself and cause you distress but that forgiveness doesn’t need to be communicated. I wouldn’t accept a friend request. If the person was in some way connected to my social circle then I might take baby steps in allowing them in the periphery but there seems to be no benefit to either party in such cases as yours.

HelpMeGetThrough · 26/09/2022 07:54

I'm sure people can and do change for the better or worse.

I came face to face with my school bully, when they joined a club I'm a member of.

Their excuse was "Don't take any notice of what I did, I was a prick at school". Told them as far as I was concerned, once a prick always a prick.

I certainly didn't want anything to do with a person that made my life hell, before they got kicked out, no matter how long ago it was.

northernlurker85 · 26/09/2022 07:50

these responses are very interesting. and I am so sorry some of you have had such horrific experiences at the hands of school bullies. i know this sounds all a bit hippy but the 37 year old me kind of looks back at all that in very much a different way now. he taught me a lot about myself in the respect that no way would I ever let myself or anyone else i knew be the victim of bullying and would hapily stand up against such vile people without a care what the consequences may be for me moving forwards. where as back then i just as a 14 15 year old just went straight to teachers instad of trying to stand up for myself.

OP posts:
Rinatinabina · 26/09/2022 07:18

I believe people can change definitely, your brain doesn’t fully mature till you are 25 and you never know whats going on with someone else. BUT some people are genuinely just giant arseholes. I wouldn’t want to be their friend tbh.

IwishIwasSupermum · 26/09/2022 07:03

No, I would absolutely be discouraging DD to have any form of any future relationship with the bullying gang who made her life hell, that caused major disruption to our family life, that we had to change schools for.

@DimplesToadfoot 💐

UnderCoverFieldAgent · 26/09/2022 06:42

I was horribly bullied by someone at school. I won’t hijack your thread with the details but no way would I have been able to be friends with her. I would be wondering if she actually wanted to be my friend or whether she was reaching out just to make herself feel better about the past.

RememberWhatMatters · 26/09/2022 06:41

My school bully did the same, her and her co-bully bullied me on my final year of primary school and made me terrified what they'd do to me when I reached high school. The physical bullying stopped suddenly when my dad went to her door, where he discovered her mum was a co worker of his. She was mortified. Lots of excuses , her dad had left. 11 year old me didn't care, I just wanted it to stop.

She still made herself a nuisance to me at high school.
Years later I was visiting a friend in hospital and there she was, a nurse. She at least had the decency to look embarrassed to see me and got out of my way. That's when she then sent me a FB request. Why do they all do that?
I have no idea if she's still a nasty, violent person but I don't care. I wouldn't engage with her, those years were so frightening. I would have no urge to have any contact or conversation to find out.

tranquiltortoise · 26/09/2022 06:38

People can change, especially in the transition from children to adults - we learn a lot about the world.

However, bullying has such a deep impact and I would wonder whether you could really have a friendship with someone who bullied you at school, because of the emotional trauma.

I certainly couldn't because I would still have residual negative feelings, however much they had changed.

FourTeaFallOut · 26/09/2022 06:23

Honestly? I can't imagine why you'd bother. What are you going to get out of this friendship?

Do yourself a favour and keep him out of your life. Honour your younger self and close down the opportunity for him to have another shot at eroding your self esteem.

Mothership4two · 26/09/2022 06:14

I ignored a friend request from the school bully. She didn't bully me but made many others miserable (many of them boarders who couldn't get away). One friend had nightmares about her for several years after leaving school. She may have had personal reasons for being like that and may be an absolute angel now, I don't care, I would rather not have any contact with someone who did that.

HoneyIShrunkThePizza · 26/09/2022 06:01

I personally wouldn't accept the request unless you live in a remote hamlet of 10 people, 6 of which are children, your school bully is one of the only three other adults and so you're THAT short of friends.

There are so many other people in the world. Even if he has changed...eh...what's the point in dragging all that trauma up.

autienotnaughty · 26/09/2022 05:57

A reach out to apologise I would accept although I doubt I would be friends with them. A friend request seems dismissive of your experience, I'd ignore it.

Eastie77Returns · 26/09/2022 05:26

I don’t know how far people really change. A child bully may present as a pleasant adult later in life because they’ve learned how to conceal the darker side of their personality when needed. I personally think bullying is an innate part of someone’s personality and not sure I buy into the theory that it’s usually connected to the individual suffering some kind of trauma.

I bumped into our vile class bully in sad circumstances as we were both attending the funeral of an old classmate. She had apparently undergone a transformation, turned into a nice person and worked as a nurse. Our local Gazette had actually given her a community award. We chatted for a while and to begin with it was fine but she then began making awful comments about some of our mutual friends (“I heard x has a disabled son, serves her right as I never liked her haha”) and off came the nice mask to be replaced by the vicious bully I remembered.

stayathomer · 26/09/2022 04:52

I met our class bully a few times. She was one of the popular girls and was mean to so many people that my brother used to ask about her- even though he was years ahead and in another school he’d heard of her. She’s now in a caring profession and has the loveliest husband and daughter and every time I talk to her I’m trying not to let my jaw drop. Cannot believe it

northernlurker85 · 26/09/2022 04:19

hi all. just to answer a question about how long i knew this person. we went through secondary together. from year 7 right up to 6th form it happened. what i think is its easy as a kid to see life very black and white. you don't know what happened to them as its all rightly kept confidential. maybe he was hitting out. he didn't pick on those who would fight back, it was always the sensitive kids who would get upset by him. we did talk on fb and it was like talking to a different person and how can i be resentful towards a person who i knew in literally a different lifetime? i don't see how you can move forwards if your holding resentment towards things that happened in your past? easy said than done i know.

OP posts:
BadNomad · 26/09/2022 02:44

A number of years ago, when I got Facebook for the first time, my childhood bully sent me a friend request. I accepted it, thinking "we were kids, the past is in the past". Then she blocked me that very same day, and so did her pals who had also added me! For that moment, it was like being back in school. Some people just never grow out of being nasty.

In your case, I would probably accept out of curiosity, but I wouldn't get involved in any friendship.

CherryGenoa · 26/09/2022 02:14

@DimplesToadfoot 💐

Echobelly · 26/09/2022 01:59

TBF, this is only a friend request - they're not likely to come back to make your life hell. But yes, people who were bullies as kids can be (and I think usually are) decent adults.

Joshanddonna · 26/09/2022 01:55

@DimplesToadfoot I’m so very sorry x

Joshanddonna · 26/09/2022 01:54

The girl who made my life utterly miserable at school and often beat up other girls is now a local yoga teacher and therapist.
She approached me in the supermarket with a big grin on her face. I let her prattle on a bit about the good old days then reminded her about what an unpleasant, vile, cruel, violent bitch she had been and told her to f**k off. It was delightful. I also looked fabulous. ( unusually) because I’d come back from holiday the day before and spent the morning at the hairdressers getting me highlights and nails done!
I don’t care what kind of person she is now she was appalling.