Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

do you think a school bully can end up as a good adult friend?

110 replies

northernlurker85 · 25/09/2022 20:28

hello. genuinely interested in your thoughts here. i had a friend request from a person we all hated at school this was over 20 years ago. i am happy to forgive and forget as we were both very different people,nothing more than kids but do you think people like that can change?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
northernlurker85 · 26/09/2022 18:04

thanks all and to those who have found it hard to move forwards after such experiences i am sorry if some of you thought i was underestimating how difficult it is i know its not,its actually dam hard. for my first year or so out of the situation i struggled then just something clicked, don't know what it was, i found myself thinking "i can't screw the rest of my life because of what happened. no way if he had got in touch after just a single year i would have wanted anything at all to do with it but with 2 decades passing since them days i suppose i was just curious,could he had changed etc. thanks all for these replies. i am new here and so this has been an interesting first post.

OP posts:
Revolvingwhore · 26/09/2022 17:37

My partner has been known to change direction to avoid his secondary school bully. Don't minimise the impact bullies have.

Fenella123 · 26/09/2022 17:33

Well I guess you can always unfriend them again if it doesn't work out!
You could message them and say something polite but to the point,
"Hi X, Did you mean to friend me or did you mistake me for someone else? Because you did make my life hell for years at school. I get that sometimes external pressures make people behave badly and that they can change a lot for the better in adulthood - but I'm sure you can understand why I'm cautious. Be interesting to hear what your situation was. Bert"
And see what the reply is and go with your gut.

Looking back, my own parents' poor socialisation was handed on to me, and until about say, 30, I wasn't brilliant at getting along with people. Better influences, helpful life experiences and general reading of self-help manuals made me a somewhat more agreeable personality. So yes, people can learn to be a much better version of themselves. But that doesn't always happen!

drpet49 · 26/09/2022 17:19

Starsinyoureyes13 · 26/09/2022 11:53

Bullys never change unless something earth shattering in their lives happen to humble them. The worst bullies ive encountered are now care assistants and if I'm honest I wouldn't trust them with a cactus let alone another human being. They may forget but the people they bullied haven't.
I'd avoid and reject persons friend request. They will add nothing to your life but bad memories esp if they flood their newsfeed with how happy they are.

Completely agree

Starsinyoureyes13 · 26/09/2022 14:46

northernlurker85 · 26/09/2022 13:59

wow so many conflicting thoughts. this might have been better in the "other subjects board" as i am not really asking if i am reasonable or unreasonable. until the friend request i had only ever heard little snapshots about what he was doing now with his life he has 2 teenage dd's according to a friend and has quite a good job apparently. i think if he lived down the road i would feel a bit less easy about it but there's like 60 m distance between us and so the chances of him asking for a meet would be slim. i have always believed in second chances. i can think of kids at school who i didn't like at all. one of whom followed me to college and i was dreading it when i heard but we landed up really good friends.

I won't ever be friends or acknowledge anyone who made me feel as if I was nothing. I still remember being spat on, hounded every single minute in school, I remember the horrible names I was called, what should of been the happiest days of my life was a living nightmare. I'd sit and hide in toilets during class time missing out on valuable learning time because I was scared of the humiliation. I lost the chance to do something great with my life, so I would never give anyone a second chance who thought it was OK to terrorise me. They may have moved on, I can't, it's a lifelong misery of memories.

northernlurker85 · 26/09/2022 13:59

wow so many conflicting thoughts. this might have been better in the "other subjects board" as i am not really asking if i am reasonable or unreasonable. until the friend request i had only ever heard little snapshots about what he was doing now with his life he has 2 teenage dd's according to a friend and has quite a good job apparently. i think if he lived down the road i would feel a bit less easy about it but there's like 60 m distance between us and so the chances of him asking for a meet would be slim. i have always believed in second chances. i can think of kids at school who i didn't like at all. one of whom followed me to college and i was dreading it when i heard but we landed up really good friends.

OP posts:
Starsinyoureyes13 · 26/09/2022 11:53

Bullys never change unless something earth shattering in their lives happen to humble them. The worst bullies ive encountered are now care assistants and if I'm honest I wouldn't trust them with a cactus let alone another human being. They may forget but the people they bullied haven't.
I'd avoid and reject persons friend request. They will add nothing to your life but bad memories esp if they flood their newsfeed with how happy they are.

LucyInTheSkyWithDiamond · 26/09/2022 11:47

Tobletone · 26/09/2022 11:42

Being "mean to each other" is completely different from being bullied. Isn't that obvious from this thread?

Well, they're similar things tbh. I was bullied by someone else at school. We never became friends, but I don't hate her and if we met I'd be friendly enough. I did say at the end of my post you've just quoted that it depends on how bad the bullying is. I don't think it's impossible if it's fairly low level bullying. If you disagree then fair enough 🤷‍♀️

DisappearingGirl · 26/09/2022 11:45

I think it depends on a lot of things.

A friend request on social media I'd probably ignore as I'd suspect they were just being nosey and I'd have no evidence they had changed. But if our paths crossed naturally and they seemed to be a nice person as an adult then it may be different.

Also depends on the level of bullying. One girl at high school honestly just seemed to enjoy bullying those less socially powerful than herself, including me, and I never want anything to do with her again. Conversely, another girl had elements of being spiteful towards me at the start of secondary school, but I know she had a hard time at home, and once we got to sixth form and she was away from her former crowd, the dynamic changed and she seemed a fairly nice person and we became quite friendly.

I think it depends on a lot of things, but ultimately it's up to you. You shouldn't feel an obligation to befriend your former bullies though.

Tobletone · 26/09/2022 11:42

LucyInTheSkyWithDiamond · 26/09/2022 11:24

I have a really close friend who was my sworn enemy at one point at school. We were quite mean to each other. We then got chatting at a party and realised we loved each other and have been really good friends ever since. So I do think it can happen. Depends on how bad the bullying was though I think

Being "mean to each other" is completely different from being bullied. Isn't that obvious from this thread?

DillonPanthersTexas · 26/09/2022 11:41

Several years ago I bumped into the 'school bully' down the pub when I returned to my old home town to see my folks. Although I only had a few runs ins with the younger version of this man and his gang he made other peoples lives an utter misery. It was interesting listening to him reminisce about school, seemingly completely oblivious to the pain he had caused so many people. He seemed like a normal guy, professional job, mortgage, wife and kids, you would not suspect what a malicious shit he was as a teenager. I felt a bit awkward talking to him while he was being all jovial about the good old days. He started asking questions about who I was still in touch with from school, I mentioned several names, some of them being the people he bullied and there was not a flicker of remorse. As I made my excuses to leave he made noises about some kind reunion drinks at which point I did challenge him as to why would any of his victims want to meet him? The smile dropped off his face, not sure if that was a penny dropping moment of genuine realisation of what he had done or not.

IncompleteSenten · 26/09/2022 11:36

No.
I'm sure there are a few who have a personality transplant but I don't think most people do change all that much.

The basic person you were as a child - the strongest parts of your personality - are normally the same. What happens more often than a personality change is the ability to hide those parts of you that you use to hurt others and refine them so they can be deployed in a far less noticeable way. Or, best case scenario, recognise them as unacceptable and fight them. But I don't think they routinely disappear. I think the core of you is how it always was.

Wishyfishy · 26/09/2022 11:36

Psychopomps · 25/09/2022 21:13

I think you’re confusing ‘friend request on social media’ with actual friendship. All this person has done is asked to be added. It’s not any kind of significant gesture.

This!

A lot of people literally add everyone they can find they went to school with.

The chance of this person wanting to reach out and talk to you are very, very low.

iekanda · 26/09/2022 11:34

A bully is a bully IMO. I’d ignore the bully as an adult. It’s not really about forgiveness/resentment, it’s about self protection.

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 26/09/2022 11:30

Certain ones no. There's always bitchiness between teenage girls, but fallings out return to friendships in school, and stay friends outside. But the actual bullies who you never got on with? Nope. I wouldn't ever be friends with people like that, they aren't worth my time.

Maves · 26/09/2022 11:28

Redbone · 25/09/2022 21:33

Sad to say NO, once a bully always a bully.

I agree it's just in people

Ticksallboxes · 26/09/2022 11:28

Absolutely they can change IME.

There was a bully in my school who we were all terrified of. She turned up at my sixth form college after I hadn't seen her for years and was the sweetest person - I literally couldn't believe it. She was incredibly apologetic about being a bully.

Maves · 26/09/2022 11:27

No cos people that were bullied never forget. I wouldn't want to be friends with someone like that she was old enough to know what she was doing.

LucyInTheSkyWithDiamond · 26/09/2022 11:24

I have a really close friend who was my sworn enemy at one point at school. We were quite mean to each other. We then got chatting at a party and realised we loved each other and have been really good friends ever since. So I do think it can happen. Depends on how bad the bullying was though I think

isittheholidaysyet · 26/09/2022 11:23

Whilst I do think people can change, I don't think most people do. Most people mature a bit, but I think most people are fundamentally the same person as they were at school, with the same beliefs and values. I know I am the same, just a little more confident and outgoing. (Which I put down to not being bullied every day,and being surrounded instead by people who like me enough to be around me!)

I would never make friends with my bullies, I dropped all school people at the age of 18, and although I may sometimes bump into them when at my parents home town, I would not take the relationship beyond polite small talk.

I think I have forgiven them, but would never trust them. 'We were just kids' is no excuse.

stayathomer · 26/09/2022 11:04

DimplesToadfoot
Have you had help since? Is there good in your life? I hope you’ve met people who have convinced you there’s some good somewhere x

ScampiFlies · 26/09/2022 10:38

I do think people can change. I do think a school bully can be a good friend. But I can't see a time when a person who bullied me in school would be my good friend. While I have largely forgiven what happened to me at school I can't forget the anxiety and dread I felt going there most days.

northernlurker85 · 26/09/2022 10:36

@tobletone i do totally have respect for those children because i was one of them. a lot were too scared to speak out against it. and it really is easier said than done when your in that situation but if you let it affect the rest of your life,that bully has won. i messed up my education because i let it all get to me. but its the future now you learn so much as you get older,you change in so many ways.

OP posts:
BadNomad · 26/09/2022 10:35

Tobletone · 26/09/2022 10:25

I think you should show a bit of respect and understanding of those "sensitive" and defenseless children this person went for. He's looking for people to tell him that what he did was ok, just something young boys do, doesn't affect their opinion of him. I don't think you should give him that, no.

This.

Bullies don't reach out to you after all this time because they regret what they did to you. They do it for themselves. To make themselves feel better. So they can say "Well, if northernlurker85 is ok with me, then I can't be that bad."
It's extremely selfish and narcissistic to think you have the right to insert yourself into someone's life after this length of time because you want forgiveness or to be excused from the damage you caused to others.

10HailMarys · 26/09/2022 10:31

It's only a Facebook friend request. It's really not that deep - it's not like she's asking you to actually be real-life friends with her. If you haven't seen for 20 years and actively disliked her even back then, it's perfectly reasonable not to accept the friend request. But it won't be remotely significant if you do accept it. It's a Facebook friend request, not a dinner invite.

I suspect what you're really asking is 'AIBU to accept a friend request from someone I was never actually real friends with and who I haven't seen for 20 years, just out of curiosity so I can a good old nose at what she's up to these days?' in which case YANBU, that's pretty normal on Facebook.

Swipe left for the next trending thread