Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To give my cousins money out of guilt

37 replies

Quaggainexcelsius · 25/09/2022 20:26

Long story!
My DM had me when she young, unemployed and homeless. My grandparents bought a house for 18k outright for her and her sister to live in. This was in the late eighties.
My aunt moved out two years later and my grandparents gave her half of the house money (10k) for a deposit for her new house. My DM stayed there, with me, paying them back the 18k, until she got married when I was a teen. I then stayed in the house throughout uni, and into my mid twenties.
Then I got pregnant. My DP and I told my mum and grandparents that we intended to move out and rent. They said that they thought it was a waste of money and why don't we stay in the house. Looking back, we definitely should have used those years of not paying rent, only bills, to save. I was studying and then in low paid jobs but could have saved.
Later my grandparents said they intended to sell the house and we could use some of the money from the house sale for a deposit on a new house. I was thrilled but asked if it wasn't unfair on my cousins. They promised that they would also give my cousins a deposit when they came to buy. But then my mum said that as she was now in a house with my stepdad I could sell the house and use all of the money to put into a deposit.
I felt reassured and we were able to buy a lovely three bed in a nice area but I've always felt guilty. Guilty that I didn't work for it, guilty that my mum paid only 18k interest free and now has been able to pass on a 200k house to me and that my aunt won't be able to do the same as she took her half early. Guilty that we haven't trained to a similar level as my cousins yet have a house which they can't afford. Guilty that I had a baby when I wasn't in a financial position to do so.
When I speak to my cousins they do not seem to have been told that they will be helped with a deposit. They are all talking about buying one bed flats or moving to cheaper parts of the county, far away from family :( I'm wondering if I should do something.
In reality a bank would only loan me and DP enough for a one bed flat in this town. I don't know if I can change our lives that drastically out of guilt. And after all, my grandparents reassured me that they had something for my cousins anyway (although I very much doubt they have 200k for each of them, they're not that rich!)
I thought maybe I could buy another house (we're moving anyway for other reasons) which is closer to what we could have bought if we hadn't been so lucky and give my cousins 10k each? It's not a lot but it's realistically the most we could give without living in a shack.
My DP isn't keen Hmm he says that they're all in good jobs and have enough money for a deposit (maybe not for a house like ours) and that my mum paid off the house fair and square so it was hers to give to me. I'm not sure and I don't think I can enjoy a new house without feeling the guilt I have felt for all these years especially when my cousins start having kids and wanting to buy.
Thanks for reading Star

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Catsmakemehappy · 14/05/2023 08:03

I think the emotions you are feeling are the core issue here . The guilt the not feeling worthy . These are what you should be addressing . I don’t think giving your cousins money will make you feel more worthy . Everyone chooses a different path and their is no right or wrong path to take its fate . You are /where you are meant to be . Enjoy the position you are in and let the feeling of guilt go. You where/are not responsible for you aunt taking her share out early. I how you find peace in this situation .

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 26/09/2022 16:04

You seriously need to look at why you feel so guilty for a situation you didn't create.
Don't get me wrong, I am not disputing your caring and generous nature, but I think it should be more focused on your DH and yourself and your future family just as your mother and grandparents did.
I've never heard of anyone taking on the burden of so much guilt on themselves over decisions made by older relatives - all adults - all capable of speaking up for themselves - decades ago... and feeling it's their duty to do something for cousins - who also were not involved in the original arrangement.

Just because your cousins are hard working - so what? They are independent - they have generous grandparents -just like you and their mother may also benefit them. ...So who appointed you to be their caretaker? I could understand if they were actually suffering, in extreme need or had diminished prospects but do they?.
Why do you feel so guilty about something for which you have so little responsibility. Is this something that you feel in every day life? if so I worry that you need to look into it as people may well take advantage of you. Other pps have mentioned low self esteem. This is not intended as an insult but merely that you may need to look into this and re evaluate how you think of yourself. Why can't you live with this guilt? You haven't done anything wrong? Why do you think of yourself in this way?

The grandparents helped both daughters out when they needed it. - your Aunt took her money out of the property - just because it was only £10k at the time, doesn't mean she didn't get value out of it. It was worth a good amount in real terms and would have been a substantial property deposit at the time if a house was worth £18k. I don't think either daughter was hard done by.

Your mother paid the £18k back - so she owes nothing and therefore you owe nothing.
It seems like you feel you owe everyone for living in the house, when your mother has paid for it. You were a child at the time. You also talk about your cousins in the plural and you don't mention siblings so possibly you are getting more from your mother than your aunt has to split between the cousins - but again, you are not responsible for the fact that your aunt had more children than your mother did.
You should carefully consider accepting your good fortune. Your cousins have also been fortunate, and also look at why you feel guilty and less deserving. Also look at the impact this could have on your DH because they share your life and it is money given to you by your relatives who wanted you to have it, and it seems unfair that you should give it away without very good reason.

user1471457751 · 26/09/2022 15:55

So you got to benefit from living rent free for however many years plus your grandparents have given you money (their share of the house?) as a deposit.

It's up to your grandparents to make it fair in terms of the deposit. As for the living rent free, if your grandparents did still own a share of the house and it wasn't all your mum's then yes you have been treated more favourably than your cousins. And, honestly, if I were them I would be pissed off. It sucks being the one doing everything right when someone else is getting rewarded for being irresponsible. But ultimately that again comes down to your grandparents.

Loics · 26/09/2022 15:47

They're not due anything as your aunt decided to take her share years ago. She could have done the same as your mum and ended up with more, but she didn't. That's why your cousins didn't get more, not due to anything you did. Plus, no-one is entitled to an inheritance anyway.,

Sweetmotherofallthatisholyabov · 26/09/2022 15:30

But your mom and aunt got the same didn't they? And your mom paid back what she was given? So you're mom owns the house and it has nothing to do with anyone else?

Howyiz · 26/09/2022 15:22

Honestly, you sound like a twit!
Your grandparents gave their daughters the same start, nothing to do with you.
Your mother has very generously given you a great start.
Now you want to virtue signal to everyone, for what? So that you can put your own child in a poorer position?
Give your head a wobble! This doesn't make you look like a great person, it just makes you look like an idiot.
There is no sense to the narrative you have created in your head.

Comfyslippers74 · 26/09/2022 15:13

There are basically 2 ways to get on the housing ladder now. You can be a high earner (or a slightly less high earner and save like mad), or you can be lucky and come into some money. You're the latter. We can't go back in time and predict what a stroke of luck it was to have purchased property in the 80s. It's nothing to feel bad about. Arguably this is your DC's money you're thinking of giving away. Honestly, hang onto it and don't say anything.

SlouchingTowardsBethlehemAgain · 26/09/2022 15:00

Don't be daft love, enjoy your house. You don't owe your cousins anything. Your aunt took her share a long time ago.

Longdarkcloud · 26/09/2022 14:10

Your grandparents may not have £10k disposable income to gift your cousins NOW, but how much is their house worth? Maybe they have it in mind to leave all their estate savings and hose) to just your cousins? They could end up being better placed financially than you are. Would your cousins then decide to gift you money to equalise the situation? It is very doubtful . They’ll say well, the OP had her share earlier, now it’s our turn.
BTW it isn’t unusual for testators, when omitting certain family members from their wills to state in the will, their reasons.
Also, for all you know, your grandparents have been waiting for your cousins to start house hunting before they offer assistance.
Enjoy the nice home you can provide for your family and avoid discussing the subject.If I was your husband I’d feel annoyed that you are considering reducing the family’s lifestyle out of misplaced loyalty and what about his share of your matrimonial property should the marriage end?

Nogreens · 26/09/2022 14:08

Stay out of your own way and be grateful for your mother's sense.

EmiliaAirheart · 26/09/2022 13:52

I think it’s fair to feel no pride in the fact that you made poor decisions and are doing better than your cousins who made better decisions. Let’s not sugarcoat it.

You’ve already wasted some of the chances given to you (to save while living rent free). All the more reason to focus on what you can do from here to set up the next generations - and on the back of your own efforts, combined with the huge leg up you received.

Your grandparents worked hard to give you (via your mother) a legacy. Will your grandchildren be able to say the same about you?

UnderCoverFieldAgent · 26/09/2022 13:48

No. Your aunt took her money early when the house was worth what it was worth. If anything, the aunt is to ‘blame’ (although not really). You have got nothing to be ashamed of at all. You’ve had a bit of luck and that’s all. Do you seriously think they’d share with you?…

SoWhat21 · 26/09/2022 13:46

Honestly OP you are really overdoing the guilt thing here. You have absolutely nothing to feel guilty about. Your Mum paid for the house fair and square. Your aunt got €10k which she presumably invested in property that has also appreciated in value. This is what your cousins will inherit in due course. What you Mum does with her house is nothing to do with your cousins, just as you will not be entitled to anything from your Aunts property.

More than this while gifting €10k to your cousins may make you feel better it would be an incredibly foolish thing to do. it could be seen as an admittance of some type of liability being owed to them when none exists. It may make them feel that they are entitled to more. It may raise bad feelings that are not currently there. You have a responsibility to your own family now and you will seriously disadvantage your child by taking the actions you are considering.

YellowTreeHouse · 26/09/2022 13:38

You are being absolutely ridiculous and if you feel this much guilty over absolutely nothing it’s probably a good idea to seek help.

Thinkingblonde · 26/09/2022 13:31

Who actually owned this house? Your grandparents or your mother?

Zero19 · 25/09/2022 22:50

I think you’re opening up a can of worms and I would just leave it shut . You could be opening yourselves up to starting a family feud over money and it might not end well .
Would your family feel the same in your position ?

Fifthtimelucky · 25/09/2022 22:49

I don't quite understand all the ins and outs of the money but it seems to me that you have benefited because your mother moved in with a new partner, no longer needed her old home, and passed it on to you.

Your aunt presumably hasn't done the same so still needs to live in her house and cannot yet pass it on to her children.

Whowhatwherewhenwhynow · 25/09/2022 22:30

Quaggainexcelsius · 25/09/2022 22:20

I suppose it's because they did everything the 'right' way, studying useful subjects, waiting until their financially stable to have kids, saving. Whilst me and my mum didn't/ haven't, but haven't really faced hardship.

That’s just life though. Rarely is it the case that those with the most have worked the most. I think luck plays as much, if not more, of a role In peoples lives than hard work.

Luredbyapomegranate · 25/09/2022 22:25

You are really overdoing it on the guilt Op.

Firstly, your aunt has a house and she’ll leave it to your cousins, in the same way your mum has done for you.

Secondly, going to university doesn’t make them more deserving of help than you. Why would it?

Your feelings about this appear quite obsessive and exaggerated. Is this low self esteem do you think?

Enjoy your good fortune and focus on living your life.

honeylulu · 25/09/2022 22:22

Grandparents bought a house for 18k. Mum and aunt lived there. Aunt left and was given a separate 10k towards property. Your mum repaid Grandparents the full 18k. So she owed nothing.

No idea if aunt repaid any of her 10k.

I don't think you owe anything to anyone. Your mum benefited from a interest free loan and paid it back. Your aunt benefited from free accommodation and then an interest free loan and didn't (?) pay it back.

Quaggainexcelsius · 25/09/2022 22:20

*they're

OP posts:
Quaggainexcelsius · 25/09/2022 22:20

I suppose it's because they did everything the 'right' way, studying useful subjects, waiting until their financially stable to have kids, saving. Whilst me and my mum didn't/ haven't, but haven't really faced hardship.

OP posts:
Georgeskitchen · 25/09/2022 21:43

If I have read the post correctly you owe your cousins nothing. Your aunt took 10 grand and you say yoir mum.paid off the remainder . I don't understand why you think you owe them anything??

BirdinaHedge · 25/09/2022 21:42

I think it’s up to your grandparents to even it out between their 2 daughters. You have been treated far more lavishly than your cousins and you’ve not done anything much to “deserve” it.

I have an old friend who bought a flat with her sister with their parents’ help. Said sister was apparently a nightmare to live with and bullied my friend. My friend sold up her half at a bad time for property values and lost a valuable investment. Her sister profited.

You don’t know why your aunt moved out. I don’t think you should have more than your cousins just because your mother stayed in a house bought for her and her sister.

Vikinga · 25/09/2022 21:21

Your mum repaid the money and your aunt used her €10k for a deposit for another house so everything is even Stevens?