Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How can we help to better support Neurodiverse children in schools?

41 replies

Trying2Learn · 25/09/2022 19:38

Kind of a TAAT. Based on another poster who is saying they had no idea of what it would be like to parent a ND child.
Seeing lots of posts about how schools aren't geared up to support.

Background: I work in education but not as a teacher, work with schools across the country supporting a specific demographic but we have a lot of SEND. I've done the job for a while and am seeing a huge shift in how many ND children we support.

I am really interested to hear parents or carers opinions on this, as I don't get chance to engage with them in my role.

What would be your recommendations for a perfect school environment for a child who is Neurodiverse (either in a special or mainstream school)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Hurdling · 26/09/2022 22:37

Smaller classes would be of huge benefit then individual needs could be met and children wouldn’t have sensory overload.

AntlerRose · 26/09/2022 22:34

when my child moved to an sen school, was he was in a class of 6, all had the same primary area of need.

In his mainstream there were 6 children with an ehcp all with wildly different areas of need. Plus the rest of the class. So i do see why its a challenge.

I also think it shows all schools are special schools - but special schools are specialists if that makes sense.

chillipopcorn · 26/09/2022 22:23

Zedcarz · 25/09/2022 23:23

Listen to each individual child. Listen to the parents. Don't blame them or accuse them or disbelieve them.
Don't punish kids for not being able to conform to arbitrary rules.
Understand sensory needs.
Training for every single staff member that is more than just a nod to general sen.
Intensive training about all the aspects of neurodiversity and an understanding that there are many ways of being neurodivergent .
Training from people who are also neurodivergent, many of whom work within education already
Listen to the real experts.
Always ask the child. Be prepared to change the lessons, the seating, the lighting, the colour of the white board, the queues at lunch, times to access the toilet, how lunchtime and breaktimes work, not only rewarding the 100% attenders.
Bringing in speakers who are neurodivergent who have excelled in their field, adults and other kids, adults who are and have interesting jobs.
Making lessons more Interactive and practical
Understanding that nd kids are likely to have nd parents too, but that all families are under pressure, most parents are working now, so take off some of the pressure for everyone, less homework especially at high school.

This thread is so interesting and this post encapsulates the absolute dilemma for individual teachers. Zedcars says 'be prepared to change the lighting, the seating, the lesson plans etc etc. make more lessons stimulating and interactive' this might work for some ND children but for others would be a nightmare! I have so much sympathy for the parents posting on this about what would help their child, but as a teacher you're trying to manage sometimes completely opposite needs. I have several children who benefit from a very quiet, extremely routine-led environment. It helps them feel safe and comforted and is important in soothing their anxiety. How do I match this against the sensory seeking needs of others who need to make loud noises, twirl their fidget toys , chew their chewies loudly and are very impulsive and easily dysregulated? I can't provide completely distinct environments for different children of wildly differing needs in the same class. It's heartbreaking as a teacher when you realise vulnerable children can't have what helps them as it buffs right up against what helps someone else. Really hard.

Trying2Learn · 26/09/2022 15:08

Thank you to everyone who has posted. Going to re read and digest some of this info, in the hopes that I can make a small difference for some children

OP posts:
ShootingForTheMoonLandingOnMyArse · 26/09/2022 00:47

I have to disagree that this happens already. I asked DS’s primary for a referral for an assessment on many occasions after numerous complaints of theirs regarding behaviour, working at levels, social interactions etc. I actually went into school to discuss before he started in Reception as I knew he’d struggle. All blamed on him being immature and naughty (exact words) and our methods of discipline. Not taking into account his twin brother was a high achieving little angel. Much later I read a memo from the Head of Foundation year written after I’d met her before DS started there saying to the effect that I was trying to get in there first to excuse DS’s behaviour and they had a problem child on their hands!

They didn’t agree to assess until he was 9 and in Yr5 when they couldn’t ignore how behind he was any longer. He was diagnosed with severe learning difficulties at age 11 after starting at secondary school as it took 2 years to get the assessment. He was excluded from school trips in Yr6 due to ‘silly’ behaviour even after I offered to be responsible for him as he needed to be taught a lesson,

Later diagnosed at 17 (should have been diagnosed at 11 as well) with ASD after years in mainstream secondary where they tried everything to manage him out and didn’t even get an EHCP until the end of Yr10 as school refused to support one despite complaining that his LDs didn’t explain his lack of engagement and lack of social skills! Completely wasted years of education and I’m still battling to get him one now.

I sincerely hope no other child and parents have to go through what we have.

Iamnotthe1 · 25/09/2022 23:36

AloysiusBear · 25/09/2022 22:17

Outcomes could be vastly improved if schools listened to parents about their child's struggles at age 4 and brought in professionals at that point, rather than fobbing them off and gas lighting them for years until the wheels come off. Some kind of screening process at the end of reception to identify possible SEN.

This happens already but honestly the answer is often that no money is made available to support until the wheels come off.

This with bells on. The biggest issue with our current system is that it is set up to limit support and funding to cases where you can already prove the wheels have well and truly come off. If the child can't be shown to be significantly struggling, naff all is available to you.

By the time a child gets what he/her needs, the years of inadequate support have already taken their toll.

Zedcarz · 25/09/2022 23:25

Sometimeswinning · 25/09/2022 22:45

I have about 6 (minimum) in my class. 1 Highly challenging. Disruptive, cannot be in class. About 3 who fall into the cannot work without intervention. 2 who just need extra guidance to work at the level they can. 1 of me. 1 teacher for the whole class.

My choice is limited to the one challenging child in the class. I have to remove and spend my time nurturing his choice of a school day. Please stop thinking it's more training. It's not. It's more support staff.

If there was no structure then we have to accommodate the other 20 children. That's another 3 staff then.

It's a luxury to be so open minded when you don't actually work in a school!

Be more supportive of parents in this case. Promote ehcp, provide substantial evidence for ehcp, that informs where the funding goes for extra support.
Mainstream schools in my experience are really shit at supporting ehcp and making it a worse experience for everyone than it needs to be

Zedcarz · 25/09/2022 23:23

Listen to each individual child. Listen to the parents. Don't blame them or accuse them or disbelieve them.
Don't punish kids for not being able to conform to arbitrary rules.
Understand sensory needs.
Training for every single staff member that is more than just a nod to general sen.
Intensive training about all the aspects of neurodiversity and an understanding that there are many ways of being neurodivergent .
Training from people who are also neurodivergent, many of whom work within education already
Listen to the real experts.
Always ask the child. Be prepared to change the lessons, the seating, the lighting, the colour of the white board, the queues at lunch, times to access the toilet, how lunchtime and breaktimes work, not only rewarding the 100% attenders.
Bringing in speakers who are neurodivergent who have excelled in their field, adults and other kids, adults who are and have interesting jobs.
Making lessons more Interactive and practical
Understanding that nd kids are likely to have nd parents too, but that all families are under pressure, most parents are working now, so take off some of the pressure for everyone, less homework especially at high school.

Sometimeswinning · 25/09/2022 22:45

I have about 6 (minimum) in my class. 1 Highly challenging. Disruptive, cannot be in class. About 3 who fall into the cannot work without intervention. 2 who just need extra guidance to work at the level they can. 1 of me. 1 teacher for the whole class.

My choice is limited to the one challenging child in the class. I have to remove and spend my time nurturing his choice of a school day. Please stop thinking it's more training. It's not. It's more support staff.

If there was no structure then we have to accommodate the other 20 children. That's another 3 staff then.

It's a luxury to be so open minded when you don't actually work in a school!

AloysiusBear · 25/09/2022 22:19

Get rid of, or significantly reduce, assemblies. Honestly, they are pretty pointless a lot of the time and very boring. Trying to get kids to sit in a straight line, not talking, listening to things that just aren’t meaningful to them, especially the younger ones.

This. They mainly exist due to the historical influence of christianity in british schools and the continuing requirement for daily collective worship.

Get rid and get rid of the religious influences at the same time.

AloysiusBear · 25/09/2022 22:17

Outcomes could be vastly improved if schools listened to parents about their child's struggles at age 4 and brought in professionals at that point, rather than fobbing them off and gas lighting them for years until the wheels come off. Some kind of screening process at the end of reception to identify possible SEN.

This happens already but honestly the answer is often that no money is made available to support until the wheels come off.

OneWildNightWithJBJ · 25/09/2022 22:11

Lots of good suggestions here already. As a parent of two DC with different SN and an ex-teacher, I would say the biggest thing we need to do is accept that school just isn’t a suitable environment for lots of children, especially autistic children.

Even special schools with smaller classes aren’t going to be the right place for some kids. I think there needs to be a completely different approach to how we school our children. We can start by accepting that we’re all different and just because something works for one person doesn’t mean it will work for the next, even if the diagnosis is the same.

More easily doable though is more thorough training for all staff on different needs. Listen to the children and their parents. Don’t blame them.

Less work to cram in as well. When I was teaching, the days were so rushed and it just felt stressful. I’m sure the kids felt it as well. Days where we can just spend time on a project, exploring, having fun… That would be wonderful. Get rid of exercise books for some subjects. Not everything needs to be written down.

Get rid of, or significantly reduce, assemblies. Honestly, they are pretty pointless a lot of the time and very boring. Trying to get kids to sit in a straight line, not talking, listening to things that just aren’t meaningful to them, especially the younger ones.

Thanks for asking 😀.

SoftwareDev · 25/09/2022 21:53
  • Decent training for all teaching and support staff.
  • Specialist, targeted support - with a focus on early intervention.
  • Sound systems that amplify the teacher's voice (broadcasting on channels children with hearing aids can link directly into).
  • Scrap whole class behaviour charts and other such "reward" schemes.
  • A move away from the awful trend of "open" classrooms with no front wall/door. Who exactly does this benefit? The amount of children that struggle with noise travelling/constant distraction of adults/pupils walking past is outrageous.
  • Bigger classrooms that are spacious and wheelchair accessible.
  • Nurture rooms as an annex to classrooms for children to electively use when they are feeling overwhelmed.
  • Ongoing lessons for pupils about inclusion/anti-bullying.
  • Whole school standard signage (with visual aids).
Wavingnotdrown1ng · 25/09/2022 21:38

There are lots of really simple strategies that work well with ND (and of course NT) children. The PP above spoke of leaving longer pauses for questions to be processed before answering. Using visual cues like having page numbers written on the board before lessons in a dedicated space, always starting a question or instruction with the child’s name, giving thinking or planning time before expecting verbal answers to questions, having an age-appropriate visual timetable on the board, having quiet times, allowing ADHD children to have movement breaks and my own parental bugbear, giving information in timely fashion about ‘first days’ so that anxiety about which room, where to line up, how long is pastoral time etc do not spoil the last weekend/ last two weeks of the summer holiday each year and anxiety can be quelled. Also, allowing children to have their coat on or hat on/ hood up if it’s going to provide a sensory comfort. The number of times as a secondary teacher when I have had to shut down staff coming into my room from pulling up children for this ( and many ASD girls have eating disorders and feel cold a lot so want to wear their coat) when they’re not aware of the invisible disability and co-morbid MH issues is annoying. Also, training for teachers about how to use their voices so they’re not threatening and an awareness that many ND young people don’t ‘read’ body-language or tone of voice like NTs or mean to be rude - and also that the volume of a voice, not to mention a lively classroom for an ND child ( or smell/temperature/ light/ texture if uniform etc) can be much harder to tolerate than one would imagine as an NT person.

NotNuggetsAgain · 25/09/2022 21:33

AntlerRose · 25/09/2022 20:18

I think the key is identifying each child's needs early and getting in an EP, SALT and OT at an early stage and then following their advice with proper follow ups. My son is 13, he now gets weekly OT from an OT. He needed it aged 4.

At the moment they system is: ignore parent, lets see if they grow out of it, lets use a generic set of sensory strategies without knowing if they are what this child needs, all done inconsistently.

This. Outcomes could be vastly improved if schools listened to parents about their child's struggles at age 4 and brought in professionals at that point, rather than fobbing them off and gas lighting them for years until the wheels come off. Some kind of screening process at the end of reception to identify possible SEN.

Schools actually putting in place the provision in EHCPs etc, they promise so much in Senco meetings but then it doesn't happen and there's always an excuse.

Consistency, it's incredibly frustrating when it seems like they are describing completely different children in parents evenings, school reports and referrals/input to pathways.

More money for Ed Psych, OT, SALT etc

SuperSue77 · 25/09/2022 20:54

My suggestion, and what is necessary for my son, is to listen to the child. My son’s teacher last year was brilliant at this. My son was asked to move in assembly for “making a bad choice in who to sit next to” and he started getting very upset about this. Rather than tell him off for not doing as he’s told, his teacher asked him what the problem was and he explained that he needed to sit at the end of the row and couldn’t sit in the middle as asked. So his teacher told the other child to move and problem solved. My son calmed down and other child was fine. Had she just told him off and insisted he move it would have escalated considerably and not been a nice outcome for anyone.

MrsMariaReynolds · 25/09/2022 20:53

More money, more staff, more resources

None of which is going to happen with this current government.

Geneticsbunny · 25/09/2022 20:52

I think all secondary schools should have an integrated resource. This would allow them to specialise in supporting a certain need group e.g. learning disabilities, or asd or ADHD and parents could select a school which had specific expertise in supporting children similar to theirs.

It would also force secondary schools to be more inclusive environments as all kids would share spaces with kids with significant disabilities.

NoYouSirName · 25/09/2022 20:48

Being really flexible. The option of part time attendance / flexischooling. Really good communication with parents so we can prepare them for what’s coming. Preparation for trips including a timetable for the day. Quiet spaces for sensory breaks. Lots of talk about neurodivergence and not encouraging masking but accepting and embracing their neurology.

secular39 · 25/09/2022 20:47

AceofPentacles · 25/09/2022 19:55

I'd say maybe a focus on not excluding secondary pupils with SEN and rather on meeting their needs before it gets to that point

Advocacy for parents (if not provision then signposting)

Parent peer support groups (drop ins after drop off)

I'm an inner city support worker (sort of) and these things are the most often requested

Yess!!! 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽

I work in an area (think Local service provisions). Fuck it. I'm just going to say it. Speech and language therapy and my team want to go to stake holders and have a say about neurodiversity (on how our reports should not be negative, that we shouldn't use certain approach which conform to neurotypical standards and blah) but no mention about going to the stake holders for better access and services for children with ASD.

AntlerRose · 25/09/2022 20:43

From my working in a school hat, rather than a parent hat ..

The cheap things that helped most where whole school communication training by an autism outreach service - even the caretaker and me in the office. We were all taught to leave a much longer gap than felt normal to let the children reply to questions. Adults tend to fill in the gaps before children have processed information.

secular39 · 25/09/2022 20:41

Magnanimouse · 25/09/2022 19:45

"Neurodiverse" covers anything which is not "neurotypical". It's not one category.

I know neurodiverse children who need incredible levels of structure & routine and others who can't cope with it.

I know neurodiverse children who need constant challenge and stimulation and others who become overstimulated quickly.

etc etc

I really don't think there's an answer other than to say that diversifying what's on offer within and between different schools, so that parents/children can seek out a form of education which works for them.

Can I just say "Thank you!!!". Neurodiversity is being trumped around my place of work and it's grinding my gears. It's becoming a trend and I hope it soon passes as it's affecting the provision of children with ASD, where I am. All children are different and some approaches works for some and not for all.

TwitTw00 · 25/09/2022 20:39

Reduce teacher workload. I could make much better resources for my SEND pupils if I were wasting less time on other things. I don't know how you since this one but more 'space'. If you have several children who all use the sensory break out room when they need to, this becomes problematic when they need it at the same time. And often schools that are supportive of SEND pupils (as obviously all schools should be but aren't) attract further pupils with additional needs, and this then becomes even more difficult.

SecretMoomin · 25/09/2022 20:38

And what @Sevensilverrings said.

SecretMoomin · 25/09/2022 20:37

Make sure the SENCO has a good knowledge of autism, beyond the usual expectations that it’ll be obvious.
(The senco at ds’s primary actively blocked children from being assessed, refused to start proceedings for EHCPs and had zero understanding of anxiety in ND children).

Mothers are very often an untapped source of information. We want our child(ren) to succeed. We may also be autistic ourselves, so may not come across as well as we’d like! Sadly this often means we’re ignored or are blamed, which, apart from being traumatic and upsetting for us, also means that you’re missing out on a great deal of knowledge that will help you to get the best out of our children.

I’d also highly recommend talking to autistic people. I attended several training sessions aimed at teachers, and from an autistic point of view, found it very one size fits all and bland, also it was relatively easy to identify areas that could make a real change (eg cluttered walls in the classroom, less formal atmosphere leading to lots of noise and chaos, smart boards on and buzzing, harsh lighting), but some of the things OFSTED like classrooms to have so they weren’t changed (laminated everything covering the walls), other things it was felt they couldn’t change, so despite knowing that a classroom was likely to be a problem for certain children, nothing at all was done, meaning that the childrens stress levels are intolerably high just by being in the room, let alone adding in more people, noise, expectations to work etc.

Swipe left for the next trending thread