Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the US tipping culture is completely alien to British people

353 replies

Butterflyfluff · 25/09/2022 18:49

Inspired by a thread about spending money in NYC but it’s what puts me off going to US or Caribbean again.

It seems everything has to be tipped

  • All food servers
  • Toilet attendants
  • Room cleaning each day
  • Every drink service, even in an all inclusive hotel
  • Meal, even in a buffet where you serve yourself
  • Basically anything where someone else is doing something for you

Why is this so ‘expected’?

OP posts:
Mybestyear · 25/09/2022 19:54

We got chatting to a bar tender in New York and he explained that his wages were practically nothing - literally like $10 a shift but he got health care paid by his employer. So he was literally working for health care and living off his tips.

We cruise a lot and the tips can be added as part of your package ie included in the price. I don’t like the model but as others have said, it’s a different “culture” so you’ve got to factor it in when considering the cost of the trip. A bit like booking a 5 quid Ryanair flight then moaning you had to pay “extra” for luggage, sitting together etc.

Butterflyfluff · 25/09/2022 19:54

It’s easier to work out what’s expected against menu prices - even if it is annoying that it’s expected no matter how bad the service

What really baffles me is the expectation of tips in the toilet, or for housekeeping, or the hotel receptionist or in an AI hotel each time you get a drink

OP posts:
candycaneframe · 25/09/2022 19:52

Mrsherdwick · 25/09/2022 19:20

People on Mumsnet are always saying nurses in the UK are paid plenty for the work they do.
40 years as a nurse = £15 per hour
Housekeeper at Disney $17 per hour

Their union fought for that pay rise, previously it was well under the $16 minimum which it's currently set at.

Florenz · 25/09/2022 19:51

When you go to a bar or restaurant in the US just mentally add 20% to the price. That's what it costs including the tip. If the service is amazing add another 10%. If the service is diabolical deduct 10% and don't go there again.

candycaneframe · 25/09/2022 19:50

YellowTreeHouse · 25/09/2022 18:57

Because they don’t pay a decent wage.

I still refuse to tip over there.

From you that's not surprising.

mathanxiety · 25/09/2022 19:50

@Butterflyfluff

It's a mistake to consider it discretionary.

It's really not.

Restaurants and hotels are little economic systems all unto themselves. The owner pays the chef and food prep people whatever it costs to get decebt, reliable food preppers, pays the servers and bus and wash up staff the going rate in whatever city they're in, and the servers and bus staffs' wages are topped up by the customer, who gets a meal out of the deal.

You factor in the cost of the service on top of the meal price listed on the menu just as you would factor in taxes in the US, or the cost of delivery if you ordered a meal to be delivered to your home, or shipping if you order something from Amazon.

bob78 · 25/09/2022 19:50

You forgot housekeeping, that was a new one I learned the other month. I do tip for meals in the US, but we had a very awkward exchange with a bellboy (or whatever the PC term is!) as we didn't have change (we asked to take ourselves up!) I don't do the housekeeping thing though. There was a really bizarre competitive thing on UK Disney groups of people trying to out do each other, it got to the point people were leaving goody bags with British chocolate Hmm patronising if you ask me. I read the other day about giving airline crew biscuits?!

candycaneframe · 25/09/2022 19:49

Well most cultural norms are a bit alien to those outside that culture.

But it's something you expect to deal with when travelling.

It's expected because pay in those roles is piss poor and they make up their salary in tips.

itsaich · 25/09/2022 19:49

Moreshroomsplease · 25/09/2022 18:51

No idea but following for interest. I also think it’s completely crazy and it seems that if you don’t tip enough let alone not at all, great offence can be taken by the server/establishment. Doesn’t really seem optional does it?

I have experience of this. I asked in a bar to not pay the tip but to leave my own tip, so they were asked to remove the tip from the bill so I could do that but the lady banged on the table and shouted at me and tried to guilt trip me, threatened to call security, and basically mugged me. I paid as I didn't fancy an altercation with security whilst in a foreign country.

Midnights · 25/09/2022 19:48

We go to the US often on holiday - it was explained to us that they make below min wage, as the expectations are that tips will make it up to at least min wage. They also tip out chefs / bus boys / bar staff, to share it about.

I think whether you agree with it or not, by not tipping you aren't making a difference / taking a stand in a way that anyone will notice that has any sort of decision making power, it'll only impact the server that's spent time looking after you.

I don't personally agree with it, as imo they're doing their jobs and it isn't my problem they have terrible labour rules - however I know that if I stiff them, it only impacts my server who is relying on it to make a decent wage. Same for tipping hotel room cleaners or toilet attendants. I just add it mentally to my order now with tax so I know what to expect! It's the culture over there, so I just expect it when on holiday.

Florenz · 25/09/2022 19:48

It seems to work in the US. When I went to New York I got speaking to some girls staying in the same hotel, they were from somewhere else in the US but came to NYC in the summer because they could earn $2000 a week in tips working in bars and restaurants.

It wouldn't work here because people are too tight.

Mrsherdwick · 25/09/2022 19:47

But I’m in the US atm and always tip servers 20%. It’s not fair on them if you don’t.
They are short of staff everywhere.
Housekeeping at a Disney hotel - empty trash and fresh towels every two days, no beds made - you can have clean sheets on day 7.

No499 · 25/09/2022 19:45

YellowTreeHouse · 25/09/2022 18:57

Because they don’t pay a decent wage.

I still refuse to tip over there.

@YellowTreeHouse , may I ask why you refuse?
Isn't it customary to follow the the ways/customs of the country you're visiting where possible..
It's well known that the US service industry is based on tips. To refuse is an insult to the service they have provided you

Kualma · 25/09/2022 19:45

Oh OP, I feel your pain. I visited the US in February this year and was fed up by the end of the trip with tipping. I recently visited Qatar and loved the fact I didn't have to tip anywhere.

I don't find dining in the US to be any cheaper than the UK! Why are customers subsidizing workers' wages? I can remember about a year ago, Biden said he will make sure waiters/waitresses get at least minimum wage? What has happened to that?

J0y · 25/09/2022 19:44

I hate it. I got confused too. Am I being stingy or throwing money away. I agree, it,d put you off going to USA again. Just pay staff a normal wage fgs!

red4321 · 25/09/2022 19:44

I imagine it works both ways... if an American went to say Japan and tried to leave a tip they wouldn't be able to understand how that act has caused massive offence and has left an employee feeling insulted and embarrassed.

We were quite confused on a recent trip to a ski resort in Switzerland. We tried to tip in a restaurant but they refused the tip and said it's only appropriate in 5 star restaurants. Not entirely sure why as we'd wanted to tip for very good food and service but we did as they asked.

I understand that 15-20% is the norm in the US but tipping at an all inclusive for every drink seems a bit much. Quite like the policy on our last cruise (American company) that all tips were explicitly included in your fare and split out by where it went.

Mumtobabyhavoc · 25/09/2022 19:43

TinySaltLick · 25/09/2022 19:38

It's just a different business model and culture, getting irrationally irritated by it is xenophobic and close minded

Plus colonialist.

mathanxiety · 25/09/2022 19:41

@YellowTreeHouse

I applaud your principled stand.

It probably hasn't gone unnoticed by the restaurant industry or Congress or the people who run the IRS.

Stiffing the little people is guaranteed to make a huge difference.

Hmm
Butterflyfluff · 25/09/2022 19:41

TinySaltLick · 25/09/2022 19:38

It's just a different business model and culture, getting irrationally irritated by it is xenophobic and close minded

It’s really not - if a certain tip is expected, include it in the bill

Anything discretionary should be just that

OP posts:
Mrsherdwick · 25/09/2022 19:41

@x2boys 8-8 Mon-Fri, bank rate so lower. No enhancements. They did try and give us bottom of band 5 at first, think it was £12.97 per hour.

SausageinaBun · 25/09/2022 19:39

Between tipping and prices not including sales taxes, it must be really difficult budgeting for things in the US.

TinySaltLick · 25/09/2022 19:38

It's just a different business model and culture, getting irrationally irritated by it is xenophobic and close minded

x2boys · 25/09/2022 19:36

Mrsherdwick · 25/09/2022 19:31

@x2boys last year working in a vaccine centre band 5 £13.42 per hour. I’m on holiday atm or I would photo it.

I was a top band five ,where you not paid weekend enhancements?
I always worked in wards so it was shift work.,with extra enhancement, s etc .

Butterflyfluff · 25/09/2022 19:36

but that’s exactly what is it for.

Except it’s not if you have to pay regardless of how good or bad the service is

OP posts:
Strokethefurrywall · 25/09/2022 19:35

I live in the Caribbean and tip 18%-20% minimum when we're in US - especially after Covid where servers are put upon and expected to have a smile on their face for less than minimum wage.

Here in cayman we tip well, again because our minimum wage if $6 per hour and service staff should be able to eat.

UK I always tip but understand it's not customary.

If you're not used to it though, it can take some getting used to.

Swipe left for the next trending thread