Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

the writer Lisa Jewell's parenting style

161 replies

Lordofwrongness · 25/09/2022 17:17

I listened to a podcast with the writer Lisa Jewell last week that I keep thinking about. She was saying that when her two girls were toddlers, she met a woman at a party who had four teenage girls. Lisa said that must be a tough gig and the woman said no, it's lovely. Her secret: Let them do whatever they want to do and always be kind.

Lisa now has two teens - a fifteen year old and a nineteen year old. She adopted that philosophy and swears by it. Home was harmonious, she was always a big soft pillow regardless of how her kids talked to her and they're not perfect, they've made a lot of mistakes (the girls) but it seems to have worked. The eldest, who was a pain in the ass, is now gorgeous and wonderful etc.

It made me think. I struggle so much with boundaries - I worry that if we let DS, for example, do whatever he wanted, he'd literally never stop gaming. This is a genuine fear. He's MAD about screen. But maybe I should just become completely hands off, never ever react, be kind and soft - and trust it will pull through!

Just interested in what people think about this approach

OP posts:
jamoncrumpets · 25/09/2022 18:32

cansu · 25/09/2022 18:30

Zedcarz the school isn't there to replace parents. Kids who disrupt the learning of others are given sanctions. How would you deal with kids talking over the teachers and pissing about? The teachers are there to teach the curriculum.

Children who are raised in an environment of mutual kindness and respect generally wouldn't talk over or interrupt teachers.

jamoncrumpets · 25/09/2022 18:31

QueenoftheAngles · 25/09/2022 18:25

I agree children should be treated with respect and kindness and good behaviour should be modelled. I think most parents try their very best to do this but how does the hands off, never react approach work when they do something that doesn’t just impact on them?
My neighbours came round this summer to complain about my DS12 and his friends doing knock and run, and generally being pains. We told him off, explained how upsetting it could be for the neighbours, gave the other parents in the group the heads up about their behaviour and took him round to say sorry. What would a hands off parent do in that scenario, should I have shrugged my shoulders at the neighbours and hoped they’d stop before someone called the police??

I ever did knock and runs because, in hindsight, my mum would engineer a conversation (if she heard it was going on) about how scary they can be for old people and how unkind it is. So I just wouldn't join in with stuff like that.

cansu · 25/09/2022 18:30

Zedcarz the school isn't there to replace parents. Kids who disrupt the learning of others are given sanctions. How would you deal with kids talking over the teachers and pissing about? The teachers are there to teach the curriculum.

Wafflesnsniffles · 25/09/2022 18:26

Boundaries help I think, not super strict but enough to provide some sort of structure and framework. The kids/families we know that have the approach as described in the op mostly havent turned into fabulous teenagers/adults. My approach has always been boundaries, respect, responsibility, some structure, some flexibility - ie a middle road. Its worked Id say based on how my two are now (early 20s, late teens)

QueenoftheAngles · 25/09/2022 18:25

I agree children should be treated with respect and kindness and good behaviour should be modelled. I think most parents try their very best to do this but how does the hands off, never react approach work when they do something that doesn’t just impact on them?
My neighbours came round this summer to complain about my DS12 and his friends doing knock and run, and generally being pains. We told him off, explained how upsetting it could be for the neighbours, gave the other parents in the group the heads up about their behaviour and took him round to say sorry. What would a hands off parent do in that scenario, should I have shrugged my shoulders at the neighbours and hoped they’d stop before someone called the police??

charliee112 · 25/09/2022 18:24

megletthesecond · 25/09/2022 17:38

I'd guess it's parenting for people with a lot of money and no fear of social services.

I can tell you I've not got a lot of money and do this type of laid back parenting and have had no problems. It just depends on the child and parent.

jamoncrumpets · 25/09/2022 18:23

My mother parented like this and we all had a lovely childhood. She modelled kindness, gratitude, patience to us. We were so close growing up, and until the second she died. I think about her every day and raise my children the same way. Our cousins had much more structured time and more boundaries, their parents were better off and middle class, and they were noticeably less close to their parents as teenagers and even more so now as adults. They had rules, chores, punishments etc, they hated them. I never understood why. I did the washing up because I wanted to help.

riotlady · 25/09/2022 18:22

J0y · 25/09/2022 18:20

By let them do what they want I interpreted that differently. I didnt let my kids eat crisps before dinner but if my dd wanted to dye all her clothes black, I let her! I let her spend her money on more lipbalms when she already had a collection. That kind of thing.

That’s not “whatever they want” though, is it? That’s just allowing them to make some choices for themselves and not others, which is totally standard normal parenting

Zedcarz · 25/09/2022 18:22

Schools are training our kids to be factory machines.
All the positivr focus is on the model students, the exemplary ones. The ones who dont thruve in this environment are the excluded ones, the constant detention kids, the ones always on a warning.
theres no middle ground and the environment doesn't nurture, particularly in high school, they dont promote thriving.
Between the coddling of nursery and the move towards adulthood and independence at college, high school is bizarrely stuck in the past, so many teachers and heads are about power and control.
They dont respect the kids or the parents.
if we don't give our kids space to learn autonomy and give them a voice l, we're just rearing another generation of stressed and overworked adults with no resilience.

people who are used to being bullied, turn a blind eye to it, get bullied or become bullies.
If the schools aren't safe spaces for our kids to learn and grow then their home needs to be that place.

People with no decision making capacity perpetuates our mental health crisis, reliance on wine, beer, coke, weed porn, shopping, gambling, sex etc
Giving kids autonomy doesn't mean letting them do everything they want all the time
it means giving them options and choices and allowing them space to make mistakes and decisions whilst giving guidance and advice .
Wrt to statig on gaming 24/7, your role is to open their eyes to the other activities which will be fun, stimulating, engaging and ideally active enough that time in front of the screen is valid because they've done enough activity.
Screen time is also really helpful for kids who have sensory issues, struggle in school environment, other pressures etc, its a safe place and absorbing, there is a place for it.
It's all about balance.

Namechangeforthis88 · 25/09/2022 18:21

If I'd adopted that approach I'd still be back in 2011 waiting for him to get dressed for nursery and very late for work.

I didn't, he needed boundaries and direction as well as hugs and love, and is now an adorable 13 year old to be proud of.

Vintagevixen · 25/09/2022 18:21

My parenting is a bit like this I suppose. But bear in mind I only have one DD who is nearly 15 so I don't know how well it would work with different personality types or more than one! Plus it is only us two as I'm a single parent.

She doesn't have chores, or screen time limits and I'm generally super laid back about most stuff. BUT her personality type is very like mine - totally laid back, very polite and hates any drama. I think the example you set to young kids in your own behaviour is one of the biggest things in shaping them.

I really don't ever yell, we share a very dry sense of humour so if I'm trying to make a point about a situation she responds to and learns from my slightly sarcastic humour.

I suppose I'm like a big cushion in lots of ways to her! Really thinks she knows I'm always on her side and so far she has been able to talk to me about issues. She works hard at school, is always polite and well behaved and just loves being home with me. It's her favourite place - and mine when she's there!

charliee112 · 25/09/2022 18:21

Lwren · 25/09/2022 17:29

I do this, it's great.
My kids are lovely, they love being at home and they seek me out for snuggles and playtime.
My eldest loves cuddles on the couch watching horror films and I put a face mask on him etc.
We treat them with respect and kindness and that's how they learn to treat people.
It's hard for people to grasp and I use natural consequences to punishments, never had a problem and my eldest is nearly 16. My younger kids are really kind as well, try it with your DS, when you're worried about screen time etc find a reason for him to come and spend time with you, even a hot chocolate and a gossip, break up the day a bit!

This is what I was trying to describe how it's like with my daughter but couldn't explain it as well lol.

J0y · 25/09/2022 18:20

By let them do what they want I interpreted that differently. I didnt let my kids eat crisps before dinner but if my dd wanted to dye all her clothes black, I let her! I let her spend her money on more lipbalms when she already had a collection. That kind of thing.

charliee112 · 25/09/2022 18:19

I do this. It works really for us. She has screen time but after a hour or so she's off and we watch films together or tv. We go out together, cinema etc. She's 11 now. There's no boundaries. She's always been a good, nice kid and we're very very close. She's never been in any trouble in or out of school.It's hard to explain it well on a forum but it's what works for us.

riotlady · 25/09/2022 18:16

If I let my child do whatever she wanted she’d be eating crisps for breakfast, be an hour late for school every day and spend her free time leaning out of open windows and drawing on the walls.

Incidentally I’ve worked with a lot of kids and the most pleasant ones definitely didn’t have parents who let them do whatever they wanted.

J0y · 25/09/2022 18:16

I have wished my brother would help me out guiding my so a bit, towards being more communicative and respectful and hardworking. He has spoken to my son a few times and my son listened to him. So it's depressing that I've raided a son who HEARS my brother but ignores me. I still wish my brother would 'guide' him q bit more, with studies and choices. It's really hard as a single parent to an angry teen.

ICanHideButICantRun · 25/09/2022 18:12

As a PP said, screens are the big problem here and of course if a child is naturally lazy then letting them do what they want (eg getting up five minutes before he/she has to leave the house) would be incredibly stressful. What if they didn't want to do the dishes or bring their plates downstairs?

J0y · 25/09/2022 18:09

BeanieTeen · 25/09/2022 17:30

Yeah I’ve heard of it - parenting for doormats who can’t deal with conflict basically. There’s this delusion that you somehow have some control by ‘letting’ them do what they want, when basically you have relinquished control completely. Personally I think it sets an awful example to your kids.
Also ‘they’re not perfect’ is the same as when someone who has a very badly behaved child starts talking about them by saying ‘they’re no angel but…’ It’s just downplaying the situation.
It’s also a privilege thing. Someone well to do lets their kids do what they like and it’s deemed a clever parenting style. Meanwhile, mum on benefits living in affordable housing takes the same approach and no doubt most people would call it shit parenting.

Yeh I can see that this is the path I've gone down.

But dc1 age 19 always made self-invested choices (studying, making friends, studying, working part time).

Her younger brother age 16, well, he can be hostile and silent. But going head to head with him only highlights to him that I have no control over him. So I just have to hope that he chooses to study. He hasn't started yet. But it is his life.

I dont think I ever thought that it was my responsibility to control them. Have shaped them a bit I guess but although my son is not communicative or working hard atm, I don't think that talking about his failings would be something he'd respond to.

My mother micro managed my thoughts so I value just sitting back and seeing who they become I guess.

5128gap · 25/09/2022 18:08

Lwren · 25/09/2022 17:29

I do this, it's great.
My kids are lovely, they love being at home and they seek me out for snuggles and playtime.
My eldest loves cuddles on the couch watching horror films and I put a face mask on him etc.
We treat them with respect and kindness and that's how they learn to treat people.
It's hard for people to grasp and I use natural consequences to punishments, never had a problem and my eldest is nearly 16. My younger kids are really kind as well, try it with your DS, when you're worried about screen time etc find a reason for him to come and spend time with you, even a hot chocolate and a gossip, break up the day a bit!

So when will you teach your DS no then?
Obviously you don't want to raise a man who will have to be coaxed away from his X box by his partner promising another treat instead. So when will he learn that sometimes you just have to do things you don't want to do?
I'm not being snidey with you BTW. Genuinely curious as to how the approach works.

moita · 25/09/2022 17:59

A friend of mine's parents had this parenting style - she finds it very hard dealing with big emotions and conflict because her mum would take it all and never showed her how to cope with anger etc.

Just a thought.

TheGlitterati · 25/09/2022 17:57

One of my friends parents like this and nobody wants to spend any time with her or her children. They’re SO rude, no manners, full of ‘I wants’ and have never been told no.

5128gap · 25/09/2022 17:52

Its ridiculous. If LJs daughters have turned out 'lovely' it's despite this nonsense not because of it.
Some children have naturally less challenging personalities. They are more passive, more risk adverse, conflict avoidant by nature. They gravitate to the activities you would want them to do. You could quite reasonably get away with that sort of non parenting with them.
Other children (most) will display behaviours or wish to do things that are harmful for themselves or others, and they don't have the awareness or maturity to guide or control themselves.
That said, I'm a believer in as few rules as possible, so do as you please, but within boundaries, and those boundaries strictly enforced.

Lordofwrongness · 25/09/2022 17:51

PermanentTemporary · 25/09/2022 17:45

What Mardyface said.

I do believe that kids pick up a lot just from being around you and I know ds has acted out at times when I've been stressed but thinking I was hiding it. He also eg had a fear of heights when dh had a fear of heights, and did loads of art when dh was an artist. Both these things faded rapidly after dh died. However, he continued with a couple of hobbies that dh loved and still loves them.

A well off parent with a job they enjoy and levels of stress they find manageable is in general going to have a less stressed and easier home life. Children who fit in at school and don't have major health challenges will generally take life a bit easier. Stuff still happens though.

I think that's really true about having a job one loves, levels of stress at home - it all makes a difference to how you can parent with ease

OP posts:
Lordofwrongness · 25/09/2022 17:51

Lwren · 25/09/2022 17:29

I do this, it's great.
My kids are lovely, they love being at home and they seek me out for snuggles and playtime.
My eldest loves cuddles on the couch watching horror films and I put a face mask on him etc.
We treat them with respect and kindness and that's how they learn to treat people.
It's hard for people to grasp and I use natural consequences to punishments, never had a problem and my eldest is nearly 16. My younger kids are really kind as well, try it with your DS, when you're worried about screen time etc find a reason for him to come and spend time with you, even a hot chocolate and a gossip, break up the day a bit!

How do you know I don't do this? We spend LOADS of time together. He's very kind and respectful. Your response was a wee bit patronising, if you don't mind me saying.

OP posts:
PermanentTemporary · 25/09/2022 17:45

What Mardyface said.

I do believe that kids pick up a lot just from being around you and I know ds has acted out at times when I've been stressed but thinking I was hiding it. He also eg had a fear of heights when dh had a fear of heights, and did loads of art when dh was an artist. Both these things faded rapidly after dh died. However, he continued with a couple of hobbies that dh loved and still loves them.

A well off parent with a job they enjoy and levels of stress they find manageable is in general going to have a less stressed and easier home life. Children who fit in at school and don't have major health challenges will generally take life a bit easier. Stuff still happens though.