Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

the writer Lisa Jewell's parenting style

161 replies

Lordofwrongness · 25/09/2022 17:17

I listened to a podcast with the writer Lisa Jewell last week that I keep thinking about. She was saying that when her two girls were toddlers, she met a woman at a party who had four teenage girls. Lisa said that must be a tough gig and the woman said no, it's lovely. Her secret: Let them do whatever they want to do and always be kind.

Lisa now has two teens - a fifteen year old and a nineteen year old. She adopted that philosophy and swears by it. Home was harmonious, she was always a big soft pillow regardless of how her kids talked to her and they're not perfect, they've made a lot of mistakes (the girls) but it seems to have worked. The eldest, who was a pain in the ass, is now gorgeous and wonderful etc.

It made me think. I struggle so much with boundaries - I worry that if we let DS, for example, do whatever he wanted, he'd literally never stop gaming. This is a genuine fear. He's MAD about screen. But maybe I should just become completely hands off, never ever react, be kind and soft - and trust it will pull through!

Just interested in what people think about this approach

OP posts:
Connie2468 · 25/09/2022 19:14

I have a couple of friends who had this kind of parenting as they grew up - no rules, no boundaries. Could go clubbing if they wanted as teenagers, stayed out all night, did whatever they wanted.
Got through it and have turned into responsible members of society but experienced a lot of dangerous and scary situations as teenagers and now feel they were kind of neglected.

Definitely not raising their own children the same way.

5128gap · 25/09/2022 19:11

jamoncrumpets · 25/09/2022 18:54

My four year old gets it @5128gap - it's not impossible

How? If both he and the teacher want to speak at the same time, how does he know who should be listened to respectfully?

ArgieBargie · 25/09/2022 19:11

@charliee112 watching a film or the tv is just more screen time though? Just a different screen…

Pallisers · 25/09/2022 19:07

I never actually punished my children - not even real time outs or naughty step when they were little. Instead I made it clear whatever the behaviour was would not be tolerated. It worked for them and they've turned out fine - very kind and responsible. It mightn't have worked with different children.

But letting them do whatever they wanted ... no way. Surely a child/teen whose mother says "whatever you want" to anything realises that their mother doesn't care enough to intervene?

threegoodthings · 25/09/2022 19:06

DD11 is autistic and struggles with a lot...if I let her do whatever she wanted, she would never wash or clean her teeth, she wouldn't wear weather appropriate clothes, she wouldn't do her homework, she'd eat nothing but sugar and would stay up until midnight watching YouTube. I don't think so.

QueenoftheAngles · 25/09/2022 19:04

jamoncrumpets · 25/09/2022 18:54

My four year old gets it @5128gap - it's not impossible

I could have said the same about my knock and running 12 year old when he was 4. Beautifully behaved at school (still is actually), he won the practically perfect pupil award at the end of reception (yes it was a thing 🥴 ).

gnilliwdog · 25/09/2022 19:04

QueenoftheAngles · 25/09/2022 18:50

If you start anything with “I don’t mean to be rude” then you’re being rude. Just own it.

You’re clearly a far superior parent to me and thanks for being so condescending. How do you know it didn’t occur to your children, maybe you just never found out?

Sorry, I am just pointing out I would find it concerning if my 12 year old was engaging in behaviour like this, as do you, I suppose. I would be concerned about who they were hanging around with and why they are wandering the streets upsetting people. We do have children like this in my area, even teenagers who do this, and they have graduated to throwing eggs and milkshakes at people's windows and vandalism. I am not saying your son would do this, but that I would be concerned. My children do not wander around with these groups and nobody in the village has ever complained about them, so I know this isn't something they would do.

Thepeopleversuswork · 25/09/2022 19:00

I dunno...

I was raised around quite a lot of kids who had very permissive parents (leafy middle class town with lots of wealthy liberals). It worked for some but in other cases a lot of kids had literally no restrictions on what they could do and were staying out all night from the age of 14 or 15 and it didn't end well for them at all. Quite a few of them ended up with drug problems.

I think the signal that style of parenting can inadvertently send is that the parents couldn't really give a shit about what the kids get up to.

With kids who are naturally fairly chilled and tend to follow rules it could work but I think most kids need structure and some boundaries.

Kanaloa · 25/09/2022 18:59

jamoncrumpets · 25/09/2022 18:54

My four year old gets it @5128gap - it's not impossible

Your four year old has a complex understanding of mutual respect and kindness and applies this to being able to comprehend when a teacher is talking that he mustn’t try to speak? I doubt that. I think it’s more likely that in the school environment he’s/the class is told to be quiet and therefore he does it. He isn’t sitting there thinking ‘I must make sure I’m listening attentively in the spirit of mutual kindness - otherwise it would be unfair to Miss Smith who has obviously put a lot of effort into planning this lesson.’

Angelinflipflops · 25/09/2022 18:58

It's got nothing to do with money as one pp suggested

Zedcarz · 25/09/2022 18:55

jamoncrumpets · 25/09/2022 18:32

Children who are raised in an environment of mutual kindness and respect generally wouldn't talk over or interrupt teachers.

I have explained in previous posts, intuitive parenting, helping kids learn autonomy etc, (not keen on connotations of 'kind parenting') still includes helping kids understand manners, respect, societal expectations of politeness as well as kindness .
I don't agree that children should not be allowed to question or challenge teachers when they don't agree or when the teacher is spouting crap.
Teacher don't know everything and are often wrong, (along with doctors, nurses , politicians etc)
Kids should be encouraged to question , challenge and debate, lively discussion fosters way more learning than being talked at and made to copy facts ad infinitum

Kanaloa · 25/09/2022 18:55

I wouldn’t do it. I am kind to my children but I don’t like the idea of being a ‘big fluffy pillow’ if they’re rude or unkind to me. I don’t think it’s doing them any favours. They need to see me and DH as people of our own too, not as mum and dad who exist to serve and shower kindness down while smiling placidly as you disrespect them and refuse to cooperate. I don’t want to smile while anybody is rude to me - even my own kids.

jamoncrumpets · 25/09/2022 18:54

My four year old gets it @5128gap - it's not impossible

5128gap · 25/09/2022 18:54

jamoncrumpets · 25/09/2022 18:32

Children who are raised in an environment of mutual kindness and respect generally wouldn't talk over or interrupt teachers.

Bit unfair to expect a 5 year old to understand the nuances of when he should be kind and respectful and let the teacher talk and when the teacher should be 'kind and respectful' and let him talk. Much clearer to just tell him he mustn't talk when the teacher tells him to be quiet, rather than leave him to navigate that for himself?

jamoncrumpets · 25/09/2022 18:52

It's not naive @QueenoftheAngles because I lived it. It's my experience. I was also a teacher in tough inner London comprehensives and I taught with the same ethos, unconditional positive regard. Don't tell, show. Wait for silence, never shout. Wait at the door at the start of every lesson and greet every single child as they enter your class to show them how much you value them as people. I had a leadership role within four years of starting and steered on behaviour so I must've done something right.

QueenoftheAngles · 25/09/2022 18:50

gnilliwdog · 25/09/2022 18:46

I don't mean to be rude but a 12 year old should have the emotional maturity to know that we don't harass or play tricks on neighbours. It would never have occured to my children at 12 years old to do this with friends. Possibly if they were a lot younger. Anyway, it's good you have explained to him now that it's unacceptable. I'm not a hands off parent but generally find discussion and modelling works better than laying down the law.

If you start anything with “I don’t mean to be rude” then you’re being rude. Just own it.

You’re clearly a far superior parent to me and thanks for being so condescending. How do you know it didn’t occur to your children, maybe you just never found out?

Zedcarz · 25/09/2022 18:50

cansu · 25/09/2022 18:30

Zedcarz the school isn't there to replace parents. Kids who disrupt the learning of others are given sanctions. How would you deal with kids talking over the teachers and pissing about? The teachers are there to teach the curriculum.

The environment and the curriculum is inflexible and research has long shown that very few kids thrive in the classroom setting being taught at.

Nobody's making the slightest effort to adapt the environment to suit the kids who disrupt the class nor to understand thdir specific barriers to learning.
everyone is expecting choldren to adapt to a hostile environment
kids not allowed to go the toilet when they need to, how can anybody think is is normal or even humane?!
Every school I've ever worked in, the teachers are bigoted and unkind about the children and families who find it difficult.
Middle class teachers , often from a teaching family have no idea of the real life of many of their pupils and the lack of insight, compassion, empathy and skill is letting these kids down.

Unfortunately teachers are only taught to teach one way and when the many many kids are unresponsive to this, the teachers lose control andthe kids are punished.
I've worked within many schools as well as been a pupil in many schools and multiple times over forty odd years, have heard teachers shouting.

even the schools my kids are in today have teachers who lose it so badly they're yelling.

Kids are sent out, excluded, punished, have rewards withdrawn, managed moves and ultimately disengage and often end up jobless and unemployable.
The one size all teaching system is broken.
The academy school system is awful.
Removing Connexions workers from school has been fatal.
There's nobody in the schools to be a buffer for those kids who can't cope in that environment.
Too many NQTs walking into jobs with rigid, unimaginative head teachers and bullying older staff suppressing any new ideas and bullying younger staff
Not enough teachers with specialist training for the thousands of neurodiverse kids who don't fit the special school criteria.
It's all about money, outcome and results

Vintagevixen · 25/09/2022 18:50

Let me emphasise that this style is far from 'lazy" parenting. I invest a lot of time in my DD, try really hard to never be dismissive (even when I'm knackered after work!) because if you listen to small stuff they'll tell you big stuff.

I made sure to spend loads of time with her, doing what she enjoyed and enjoying it with her. I mean I didn't want to spend all that time building Lego or watching Minions but it was important to do. I always make it clear that I value her company.

For those implying this means no boundaries - that's not true. Boundaries are set by modelling behaviour - eg. she always sees me not being rude to strangers so she isn't, she never see's me screaming at people so she doesn't etc

gnilliwdog · 25/09/2022 18:46

QueenoftheAngles · 25/09/2022 18:25

I agree children should be treated with respect and kindness and good behaviour should be modelled. I think most parents try their very best to do this but how does the hands off, never react approach work when they do something that doesn’t just impact on them?
My neighbours came round this summer to complain about my DS12 and his friends doing knock and run, and generally being pains. We told him off, explained how upsetting it could be for the neighbours, gave the other parents in the group the heads up about their behaviour and took him round to say sorry. What would a hands off parent do in that scenario, should I have shrugged my shoulders at the neighbours and hoped they’d stop before someone called the police??

I don't mean to be rude but a 12 year old should have the emotional maturity to know that we don't harass or play tricks on neighbours. It would never have occured to my children at 12 years old to do this with friends. Possibly if they were a lot younger. Anyway, it's good you have explained to him now that it's unacceptable. I'm not a hands off parent but generally find discussion and modelling works better than laying down the law.

Fairislefandango · 25/09/2022 18:43

Children who are raised in an environment of mutual kindness and respect generally wouldn't talk over or interrupt teachers.

That's just not true I'm afraid. I've been a teacher for a very long time. Loads of children from nice, kind families talk when the teacher is talking and indulge in other minor misbehaviour (and sometimes not so minor). Unfortunately, being nice and kind is not a guarantee that your children won't misbehave.

QueenoftheAngles · 25/09/2022 18:38

jamoncrumpets · 25/09/2022 18:32

Children who are raised in an environment of mutual kindness and respect generally wouldn't talk over or interrupt teachers.

This is so naive. Of course they would, bring raised with kindness and respect doesn’t make them perfect. On of my DS’s favourite friends whose family are the most lovely kind people us famous for not being able to shut up and interrupting in class.

Zedcarz · 25/09/2022 18:37

moita · 25/09/2022 17:59

A friend of mine's parents had this parenting style - she finds it very hard dealing with big emotions and conflict because her mum would take it all and never showed her how to cope with anger etc.

Just a thought.

There's still a role for parents to enable their kids to understand their feelings and how to articulate them and deal with them effectively and appropriately.
I think there's some biteback on here because people are misunderstanding the difference between enabling and supporting autonomy and independence and self advocacy .
It doesn't mean neglect but it does mean not being fixed on controlling and punishment and children being submissive and passive.
Someone upthread mentioned a child with adhd.
Even more important for kids who are neurodiverse to have autonomy to be able to self advocate. Kids who can't express themselves effectively and be understood are of course more likely to make poor decisions and compelled into risky behaviours.
Adhd traits are so misunderstood that it can traumatise a child forever to be constantly told they're wrong and everything about them is wrong because it doesn't fit within the confines of our tightly controlled english society.
Our systems are letting down kids and families across the board.
We are still a nation of screwed up pent up tense people.
Kind parenting is absolutely the way forward and being kind also involves helping your kids learn about emotions, self respect, responsibility and how to treat other people.
There are other ways to treat people than punishment and withdrawal of things that are important to kids.

Recycledcurtains · 25/09/2022 18:35

Hmm I’m sensing here an extension of this whole ‘if you are super relaxed with your baby, they will be super relaxed too’… usually said by people whose baby is completely chilled, a great sleeper, and who have plenty of loving, hands on support.

The only purpose this seems to serve is making people feel like shite that they can’t relax as their baby is fussy etc, and feeling like it’s their fault.

All children are people with different personalities, one style of parenting doesn’t fit all.

My eldest needs strong boundaries, the 2nd one is more likely to toe the line. Jury is out on the youngest 2!

(By the by, I’ve noticed most of this laid back stuff is said by parents of one laid back child, usually no more children in the mix)

Fairislefandango · 25/09/2022 18:35

I think it's a terrible idea. There needs to ge a middle path. I very much believe in not sweating the small stuff, but there need to be some limits and boundaries, otherwise you risk letting them get into very bad habits.

Most children aren't intrinsically and automatically motivated to do things they need to do. And if they copy the bad behaviour and unpleasant language they hear at school, and use it towards you, surely if you just let them, they think 'Oh apparently that's ok then' and carry on doing it?!

It's one thing having a go at letting your child self-limit with things like screen time and seeing how they manage. It's a completely different thing to just deliberately gove them free rein to do what they like with no limits or boundaries from you.

QueenoftheAngles · 25/09/2022 18:34

jamoncrumpets · 25/09/2022 18:31

I ever did knock and runs because, in hindsight, my mum would engineer a conversation (if she heard it was going on) about how scary they can be for old people and how unkind it is. So I just wouldn't join in with stuff like that.

Well good for you. I wouldn’t have expected my usually very lovely 12 year to do it either. He’s usually extremely kind and empathetic but he did do it because he’s not perfect and makes mistakes