Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

the writer Lisa Jewell's parenting style

161 replies

Lordofwrongness · 25/09/2022 17:17

I listened to a podcast with the writer Lisa Jewell last week that I keep thinking about. She was saying that when her two girls were toddlers, she met a woman at a party who had four teenage girls. Lisa said that must be a tough gig and the woman said no, it's lovely. Her secret: Let them do whatever they want to do and always be kind.

Lisa now has two teens - a fifteen year old and a nineteen year old. She adopted that philosophy and swears by it. Home was harmonious, she was always a big soft pillow regardless of how her kids talked to her and they're not perfect, they've made a lot of mistakes (the girls) but it seems to have worked. The eldest, who was a pain in the ass, is now gorgeous and wonderful etc.

It made me think. I struggle so much with boundaries - I worry that if we let DS, for example, do whatever he wanted, he'd literally never stop gaming. This is a genuine fear. He's MAD about screen. But maybe I should just become completely hands off, never ever react, be kind and soft - and trust it will pull through!

Just interested in what people think about this approach

OP posts:
NuffSaidSam · 25/09/2022 21:04

I'd always like to hear from other people in these children's lives when I hear about this type of parenting. She claims it's worked brilliantly. I wonder if everyone else who encounters these kids who haven't been told no, haven't been given any boundaries, haven't been pulled up for lack of respect, have been led to believe they can do what they like and have a big cuddle at the end of it think it's been as successful?

A lot of managing kids behaviour is about how they behave outside of the house. I can't imagine you can turn a complete blind eye without upsetting several innocent bystanders (stop kicking that seat, stop screaming, don't pull stuff off the shelves of the supermarket, don't play insanely loud music all day, every day in the school holidays etc). Be good to hear how this parenting impacts everyone else.

Firecarrier · 25/09/2022 20:56

georgarina · 25/09/2022 20:41

There's a difference between unconditional love and being a doormat imo.

I am a person and will be treated with respect just like anyone else. I have some friends and family members (mothers) who are basically the family punching bag because they never react and it's seen to be their duty to take everyone's shit.

I love my children unconditionally but if they're acting like dicks they will be pulled up on it.

Absolutely 😁

underneaththeash · 25/09/2022 20:55

Contented even!

underneaththeash · 25/09/2022 20:54

We have significant restrictions on screen time and bed times and my teens are happy, contended and well-behaved.

Firecarrier · 25/09/2022 20:54

Zedcarz · 25/09/2022 18:22

Schools are training our kids to be factory machines.
All the positivr focus is on the model students, the exemplary ones. The ones who dont thruve in this environment are the excluded ones, the constant detention kids, the ones always on a warning.
theres no middle ground and the environment doesn't nurture, particularly in high school, they dont promote thriving.
Between the coddling of nursery and the move towards adulthood and independence at college, high school is bizarrely stuck in the past, so many teachers and heads are about power and control.
They dont respect the kids or the parents.
if we don't give our kids space to learn autonomy and give them a voice l, we're just rearing another generation of stressed and overworked adults with no resilience.

people who are used to being bullied, turn a blind eye to it, get bullied or become bullies.
If the schools aren't safe spaces for our kids to learn and grow then their home needs to be that place.

People with no decision making capacity perpetuates our mental health crisis, reliance on wine, beer, coke, weed porn, shopping, gambling, sex etc
Giving kids autonomy doesn't mean letting them do everything they want all the time
it means giving them options and choices and allowing them space to make mistakes and decisions whilst giving guidance and advice .
Wrt to statig on gaming 24/7, your role is to open their eyes to the other activities which will be fun, stimulating, engaging and ideally active enough that time in front of the screen is valid because they've done enough activity.
Screen time is also really helpful for kids who have sensory issues, struggle in school environment, other pressures etc, its a safe place and absorbing, there is a place for it.
It's all about balance.

Great Post, I absolutely despise British High schools. The amount of time they spend putting them 'in reflection' for totally unimportant things like having a number 1 instead of a number 3 haircut etc it's like they try to squash every tiny bit of individuality out of them with the excuse that it gets them ready for work which is bollocks cus most work isn't like that.

I went to view one the other day for my youngest and it all looked 'good' but sooo controlled and I heard a teacher talk really nastily to a year 7 because he apparently wasn't walking sensibly enough down the corridor for her liking.

It's weird because working in a college, we have such a great and caring relationship with the students and they have freedoms in the stuff that doesn't interfere with their learning.

Bearsan · 25/09/2022 20:51

It's smug parenting and sounds quite neglectful. Everyone thinks their dc are so lovely nowadays but I doubt anyone else gives them a second thought. Remember the thread where the teenagers held court at the dinner party that they weren't even invited to. Indulged rather than lovely

Piglet89 · 25/09/2022 20:45

@Squashpocket amen.

Googlecanthelpme · 25/09/2022 20:44

My kids nearly killed themselves 7 times today, including falling from a tree, running up a road, jumping off the window ledge onto a homemade “slide” and a few other things.

I can’t just let my kids do what they want because they absolutely will hurt themselves or someone else, they are almost feral in how they approach life. They will literally do anything that looks fun, with zero risk assessment.

So no I can’t just let them do anything but I do try to let them do things which are risky and am just there to wipe the tears when it inevitably goes wrong.

Like anything, there is balance, it is not black and white. and it’s a lot to do with luck and privilege like PPs have said

DoIHaveTooo · 25/09/2022 20:42

Also, to the poster who said their 16 year old won't study but they're hoping he does at some point. Words fucking fail me. Your children aren't a science experiment that you get to observe but not interact with. It's your job to help! And when did you stop encouraging them with schoolwork etc? Or did you never start?

My god, I'm going to hide this thread it's fucking terrifying how some parents fuck up their kids lives.

Vintagevixen · 25/09/2022 20:42

Yes I've both known some VERY dramatic uncompliant girls and some very laid back compliant boys - not sure you can play into stereotypes based on biological sex!

georgarina · 25/09/2022 20:41

There's a difference between unconditional love and being a doormat imo.

I am a person and will be treated with respect just like anyone else. I have some friends and family members (mothers) who are basically the family punching bag because they never react and it's seen to be their duty to take everyone's shit.

I love my children unconditionally but if they're acting like dicks they will be pulled up on it.

Zedcarz · 25/09/2022 20:37

I have two high energy rumbustuous neurodiverse kids (I am also nd)
I have Physical disabilities too chronic paIn and fatigue which are increasing fast with age .
Parenting working and managing a house etc has been horrendous
Following others' advice on how to manage, discipline and control my children has brought worse pain tiredness and stress.
The meltdowns and fightback from the kids was killing me and I felt like a terrible parent.

Since I learned more about their needs and sensitivities and became more responsive to them, their meltdowns and anxieties have dissipated on a huge scale.

Helping them to redirect their physical energy into physical pursuits has been invaluable for stress relief.

The academic achievement has come on massively just through helping them self advocate, understand their own mind and body , plus learning enough so that I can also advocate appropriately where needed

I also don't accept being disrespected or mistreatment of each other and it's still clear who the parent is, despite being compassionate and giving fluffy cuddles.

And to the poster talking about it being easy if you have 'compliant girls', do you know any girls?!

Vintagevixen · 25/09/2022 20:37

QueenoftheAngles · 25/09/2022 20:28

But the OP says the philosophy is “let them do whatever they want to do and be kind” so how is that a misinterpretation?

I’m not being snarky at all but I don’t understand. How do you deal with it if what they want to do is harmful to either themselves or others?

Yes fair point! I see it does say that in the Lisa Jewell article! But I think it means different things to different people.

It's hard to explain - we literally have no rules in our house but my DD just doesn't want to do things that are harmful to herself or others. She doesn't like drama, she doesn't like rudeness and we respect each other, and that attitude extends to those outside the house too. It's just generally a harmonious atmosphere all round, despite the teen years!

BUT...I have said before that I respect everyone's situation is different - there's only us two so I can't speak for bigger families etc but it worked for us.

Movinghouseatlast · 25/09/2022 20:36

My friend did this with her two children. No boundaries, never told 'no'.

One was an absolute horrendous shit who said the most dreadful things to people at dinner parties as she was not taken to bed. Parents just smiled at " I wish you would die" etc. She had a personality transplant at around 17 and became lovely. Now at 21 has emigrated and keeps her distance from her parents.

The other child developed a psychological disorder and refused to go to school from age 12. Again was never told 'no" and now is 18 with no qualifications. Parents refused all help and support.

It is totally obvious to everyone around them why this has happened.

DoIHaveTooo · 25/09/2022 20:31

As a mum of 2 boisterous boys, I'm always fascinated to hear what a mum of lovely, compliant girls has to say about gentle parenting.

Me too! I have a boy and a girl. I'd honestly be mortified if I had brought either of them up to be so submissive and compliant. Imagine how they are going to interact with world as adults, too timid to speak out, no fight in them.

Children need to have boundaries at home to push against where its safe. Give them a voice, but also let them know when they are being disrespectful.

I think what a lot of the parents on this thread are advocating for is lazy parenting. You can't be bothered to parent and so dress it up as if you're raising some compliant stepford child. Very strange. They'll rebel in some way and I imagine you'll be all so shocked as to why 😒 you're not equating them for the real world and you all seem proud of this?

I wonder what will happen when they're adults and are told no for the first time. That won't go well.

SelDeFleur · 25/09/2022 20:30

And they are anything but compliant!

SelDeFleur · 25/09/2022 20:29

Floatingpenguin · 25/09/2022 20:14

I used to teach Lisa's children. I have no idea what they were like at home (or when they were at secondary school) but at primary school they were polite, kind, friendly children who always tried hard, achieved well and didn't have any major friendship issues. Her eldest's creative writing was fantastic and I have very fond memories of them. I'm really interested to listen to the podcast now!

I'm a name changer for obvious reasons. I've been friends with Lisa for years and know her daughters very well. They're still lovely!

I haven't listened to the podcast but I will. I can tell you that she is very close to both girls and they talk to her about pretty much everything. It's a relationship based on mutual trust

QueenoftheAngles · 25/09/2022 20:28

Vintagevixen · 25/09/2022 19:52

I don't think that's true - some people keep misinterpreting this kind of parenting and saying it is but it isn't.

But the OP says the philosophy is “let them do whatever they want to do and be kind” so how is that a misinterpretation?

I’m not being snarky at all but I don’t understand. How do you deal with it if what they want to do is harmful to either themselves or others?

tyyger · 25/09/2022 20:27

Personally I think it's also healthy for dc to be a little bit naughty, break some "rules" & deal with conflict & consequences.

SarahAndQuack · 25/09/2022 20:27

Squashpocket · 25/09/2022 20:05

As a mum of 2 boisterous boys, I'm always fascinated to hear what a mum of lovely, compliant girls has to say about gentle parenting. If I hadn't raised my voice or laid down the law once or twice, my boys might honestly have died in a horrific accident by now.

Some children are more challenging than others.

Hmm

Yes, I'm sure the fact your children have penises has so, so much to do with it all.

Have you ever met little girls who are boisterous? Or little boys who are lovely and compliant?

The gentlest child in my DD's class is a little boy and he's a darling.

Menora · 25/09/2022 20:26

I don’t know if I am the person for this thread, I always wanted to be like this but being realistic I am a nag and a lecturer 🤣. Saying that I do have nice DC, although they are independent now it’s not always in a good way… now they are older I don’t really like some of their decisions but I accept that they are making their own choices. I still feel close to them but often wish I had been harsher on them, who knows, it might have been different. I never really stopped them from doing things they wanted to do but I also had a set of expectations of them at home. If one wanted to dye her hair purple I would have let her but I would still expect them to help at home.
my Dsis has used gentle parenting and now has an 8yo girl nightmare on her hands, it isn’t always a good thing…

SarahAndQuack · 25/09/2022 20:25

I agree with those saying it depends on your child.

I am not always soft and kind, because I am just not that person. But I probably could be for 90% of the time with DD, because she is innately a rule-lover. She likes knowing what is considered good behaviour and what isn't. It is an ongoing surprise to me and DP, both of whom were innately much more devious and dishonest as children. It's not that she's not naughty or a pain; she can be an absolutely huge pain. But she is motivated by the desire to be seen to be toeing the line. I wasn't. Horses for courses.

Luredbyapomegranate · 25/09/2022 20:23

Squashpocket · 25/09/2022 20:05

As a mum of 2 boisterous boys, I'm always fascinated to hear what a mum of lovely, compliant girls has to say about gentle parenting. If I hadn't raised my voice or laid down the law once or twice, my boys might honestly have died in a horrific accident by now.

Some children are more challenging than others.

Well that applies to any kids, it’s not a boy/girl thing.

Luredbyapomegranate · 25/09/2022 20:22

I think you just apply the same boundaries to your kids as you do yourself - I have to limit screen time, not live on chocolate, tidy up, go to work, exercise.. I’d rather not do these things half the time but I have to.

If you give your kids boundaries it makes it easier for them to apply them later.

I am all for not being over strict and trying to make it a positive - let’s go out to the park rather than get off that screen - but Kids are different, and some will have to be stopped from pushing it.

tyyger · 25/09/2022 20:20

Sometimes dc need to know if they’ve stepped over a boundary, including one to do with basic manners and that it’s not acceptable to speak to people in certain ways.

I agree, I don't know who Lisa Jewell is but did her dc grow up in a safe, privileged bubble?

Also hugely depends on the child imo.