Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to be pissed off that vegetables and nuts aren't vegan?

188 replies

autyspauty · 25/09/2022 15:39

I was watching a clip from QI where they said that avocados and other fruits and vegetables and nits aren't actually vegan because Bees are boxed up and sent to the farms/ orchards etc to pollinate the crops.

I can't believe it.

I'm not even vegan but I do my best to be as eco conscious as I can and there are just so many ways that even a peice of fruit is ladder with tonnes of CO2. Not only do I have to consider the moles my food has travelled to get to the warehouse/ factory to be transported to be packaged and then transported to the shops, but now I have to think about BEES being transported in lorries to pollinate the food before its even fucking grown?

You can't avoid plastic packaging on your food, you can't avoid air miles or road miles on your food but I didn't even think about the fucking road miles on the pollinators to pollinate the food.

There is a photo doing the rounds of a fruit cup picked in Thailand, packed in Venezuela and then shipped to US. Its a joke, the fruit in that cup has travelled more miles than most of the people buying it but you wouldn't even guess about the fucking Bees being shipped over to pollinate in the first place. (countries may be wrong but you get the ideA)

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 25/09/2022 16:15

What you're objecting to is the extra food miles from transporting the bees and the deliberate exploitation of the bees, I assume. I know vegans won't eat honey. If we stopped eating plants that have been pollinated by animals, we'd all starve.

I am an omnivore, although I do try not to eat much meat and fish. One of the reasons I knew decades ago I could never be a vegetarian (never mind a vegan) was reading a Vegetarian Society leaflet about foods and other products you'd have to eliminate if you became a vegetarian. One was malt whisky, which mystified me, but it was explained that whisky is matured in sherry or port casks, and some sherry/port producers filter their product using gelatin. Far too many what ifs for me there.

Luredbyapomegranate · 25/09/2022 16:15

You can eat mostly local produce though, and buy fruit from Europe. Bees are part of the natural fertilisation process anyway.

There’s much to be concerned about in industrial farming but not sure the vegan or not status of avocados is it.

Bergamotte · 25/09/2022 16:12

That's just QI wanting to have a clever fact that will surprise people- I don't think any vegans avoid insect-pollinated crops.

You could say the miles and miles of monoculture in the USA are technically not vegan because (unlike Teds allotment) farmers are actively using the bees' labour. They transport the hives to each crops as it comes into season. So say when almond trees are blooming, the bees will be taken there- and the fields are so big that they can't reach any other plants, so have a diet of only almond nectar & pollen. Then they are moved to *maize fields, and again can only eat maize nectar & pollen. And so on through the year.
This is bad for the bees. The stress of being moved around all the times, the poorer nutrition, exposure to more diseases etc makes them more vulnerable to Colony Collapse Disorder. (Which is worrying for all of us humans, as we depend on bees for so many foods!)

Many vegans might campaign for more sustainable farming practices, and might choose to generally buy certain fruit / veg from smaller farmers.
But no one should say that having a bit of almond milk in your tea makes someone not vegan.

*example only! But they are trucked around to different crops in turn.

fyn · 25/09/2022 16:12

No food unless you have grown it yourself is vegan. It’s fertilised with animal manure and blood and fish bone, animals are culled in huge numbers to protect crops, animals are used in rotation grazing stubble crops and leys to restore nutrients to arable crops and combat disease/pest build up.

Alopeciabop · 25/09/2022 16:12

Nothing doesn’t hurt animals. How easy do you think it is to grow crops without animals and insects trying to eat them?
you have to clear fields (of animals) you have to keep fields clear (of animals) before you get to the transporting etc.

why vegans don’t mind moles, toads, birds, slugs, foxes etc being killed to facilitate crops is a bit of an unaddressed question.

totally fine if you just don’t want to eat animals or animal products but let’s not pretend veganism is without its cruelty. Because it is. Unfortunate but true.

Eeksteek · 25/09/2022 16:11

Ted27 · 25/09/2022 15:46

bees being transported is a separate environmental issue

but I dont see why you think bees pollinating plants mean that they are not vegan.
Bees do their thing and in the process transfer pollen. The pollen is from the plant, not the bee. I have loads of bees on my allotment busy doing their bee thing, doesnt mean my veggies arent vegan

I think there is a difference between wild bees (and even for me well kept captive bees with fixed hive, but I’m not vegan) and bees who live a horrible stressed existence on the back of a truck being permanently moved around millions of acres of almonds with high rates of attrition. Everyone’s different though.

Wheresmymoneytree · 25/09/2022 16:01

I completely agree, I’m not eating the tomatoes in my garden because my cat looked at them….. this is the level you are going to! Bees need plants to survive, if we kept them off of the plants to keep the plants “vegan” then the plants and bees would die.

UWhatNow · 25/09/2022 15:46

Good Lord - is this really a distinction that matters? Bees will have rubbed themselves against loads of crops and I hope they continue to for the good of the planet and us all. You are not consuming any part of an animal when you eat a carrot ffs.

Ted27 · 25/09/2022 15:46

bees being transported is a separate environmental issue

but I dont see why you think bees pollinating plants mean that they are not vegan.
Bees do their thing and in the process transfer pollen. The pollen is from the plant, not the bee. I have loads of bees on my allotment busy doing their bee thing, doesnt mean my veggies arent vegan

autyspauty · 25/09/2022 15:46

Yes. I watched a documentary about soil erosion and some people believe we only have a few years (50-100) of workable soil left.

There has been a massive outcry for forrest gardening, no dig etc, that small scale market gardens and allotment guys and garden veg patch gals are shouting about and I just can't see why these big farms can't change their ways?! Even planting hedgerows in between fields of native bushes, trees and plants boosts the local eco system. that means more pollinators. That means better fucking pest mitigation and pollinate.

Elimination, a lack of education-
Big mama

OP posts:
PeekabooAtTheZoo · 25/09/2022 15:43

If you get to that level nothing is actually vegan. I mean animals died to make the oil for the transport so… 🤷‍♀️ You have to draw a line somewhere and decide what you’re comfortable with.

GreenEggsAndBabycham · 25/09/2022 15:41

Welcome to late stage capitalism.

Basically nothing is without its ethical dilemmas.

But you can start by eating mostly local produce. Nobody needs to eat a fucking "fruit cup" that's travelled most of the way round the globe! Just buy an apple from the farm shop...

bellac11 · 25/09/2022 15:41

I think its a big thing in the US because of miles and miles of mono crops. I saw a programme about it but cant remember the full details.