Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to be pissed off that vegetables and nuts aren't vegan?

188 replies

autyspauty · 25/09/2022 15:39

I was watching a clip from QI where they said that avocados and other fruits and vegetables and nits aren't actually vegan because Bees are boxed up and sent to the farms/ orchards etc to pollinate the crops.

I can't believe it.

I'm not even vegan but I do my best to be as eco conscious as I can and there are just so many ways that even a peice of fruit is ladder with tonnes of CO2. Not only do I have to consider the moles my food has travelled to get to the warehouse/ factory to be transported to be packaged and then transported to the shops, but now I have to think about BEES being transported in lorries to pollinate the food before its even fucking grown?

You can't avoid plastic packaging on your food, you can't avoid air miles or road miles on your food but I didn't even think about the fucking road miles on the pollinators to pollinate the food.

There is a photo doing the rounds of a fruit cup picked in Thailand, packed in Venezuela and then shipped to US. Its a joke, the fruit in that cup has travelled more miles than most of the people buying it but you wouldn't even guess about the fucking Bees being shipped over to pollinate in the first place. (countries may be wrong but you get the ideA)

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
whatsup00 · 26/09/2022 12:52

I've wondered this about nail salons because of how shellac is made.

justasking111 · 26/09/2022 12:11

autyspauty · 26/09/2022 10:11

How can local food be more damaging than food shipped from xyz?

Just as an aside, me and my sister were chatting (idle not anything) and she said that rabbits mate like crazy. ehy don't we eat and farm them? Is it because they are so lean? why are chickens ok but rabbits no?

See also horse?

We eat rabbit in the winter bulks out pies, stews etc tastes like free range organic chicken. You'll find it in markets in cities. Manchester, Birmingham used to anyway. Have a Google.

We've had outbreak of heamorraghic fever in the area so very few rabbits now.

I've eaten horse meat abroad many years ago unknowingly. Bit strong and tough. Goat meat another good one to try.

Honestly we eat more fish and vegetables these days. Last night pea risotto with a bit of chorizo. Herbs and spices are underused

LindaEllen · 26/09/2022 11:29

Pick your battles. Nobody can take on the whole world on their own.

MintJulia · 26/09/2022 11:04

I've not been to Shetland so I can't say but you can get rabbit from any decent butcher.

Rabbit casserole is easy in a slow cooker. Add onions, carrots, a spoon of wholegrain mustard, some redcurrant jelly, a couple of tablespoons of stock, thyme and a little butter. Four hours later, serve with mash. Perfect autumn supper😋

autyspauty · 26/09/2022 10:11

ButterYourMuffin · 26/09/2022 08:59

Eating locally produced food is still more damaging re carbon footprint than plant based diet (see Food and Climate Change book for detailed analysis and actual peer reviewed research).

Also as someone who eats a plant based diet, my omnivorous DC eat (or at least would like) many more avocados than I do.

How can local food be more damaging than food shipped from xyz?

Just as an aside, me and my sister were chatting (idle not anything) and she said that rabbits mate like crazy. ehy don't we eat and farm them? Is it because they are so lean? why are chickens ok but rabbits no?

See also horse?

OP posts:
autyspauty · 26/09/2022 10:08

Funkyblues101 · 26/09/2022 04:13

Fertiliser used on crops also contains animal blood and bone from the slaughter industry, so vegans can't really eat anything, sadly.

I don't mind this. It's similar to the leather argument. The animals are going to be slaughtered regardless so using the left ivers seems OK to me.

OP posts:
ButterYourMuffin · 26/09/2022 08:59

Eating locally produced food is still more damaging re carbon footprint than plant based diet (see Food and Climate Change book for detailed analysis and actual peer reviewed research).

Also as someone who eats a plant based diet, my omnivorous DC eat (or at least would like) many more avocados than I do.

Funkyblues101 · 26/09/2022 04:13

Fertiliser used on crops also contains animal blood and bone from the slaughter industry, so vegans can't really eat anything, sadly.

AchatAVendre · 26/09/2022 02:15

MintJulia · 26/09/2022 01:19

OP, yabu. Bee hives have always been moved to where they are needed for pollination, even in mediaeval Britain.

As for finding vegan food, it's not difficult, just look to your local farm shop and not to things that have been flown in from the other side of the world.

This weekend I picked peaches and figs grown completely naturally in Hampshire. I've been bottling fruit and packing hazel nuts in honey, to eat this winter, all grown in the home counties.

Lunch yesterday was a courgette and cheddar quiche. Wholemeal flour, eggs, onions, garlic, courgettes, mint all travelled less than ten miles. The cheese, butter and milk weren't vegan, but they're British. It was delicious. And easy.

Eat local and seasonal. You'll do a lot less harm.

MintJulia Eat local and seasonal. You'll do a lot less harm.

Life isn't going to be much fun for a vegan somewhere in Britain like the Shetland Islands, or even north of Fife! Certain brands of potatoes (not really north of Inverness), no wheat or barley north of Orkney I don't think, but grass and some berries can be grown? Also cabbages, onions, apples and pears, although not particularly sweet or large ones. And some oats.

MintJulia · 26/09/2022 01:19

OP, yabu. Bee hives have always been moved to where they are needed for pollination, even in mediaeval Britain.

As for finding vegan food, it's not difficult, just look to your local farm shop and not to things that have been flown in from the other side of the world.

This weekend I picked peaches and figs grown completely naturally in Hampshire. I've been bottling fruit and packing hazel nuts in honey, to eat this winter, all grown in the home counties.

Lunch yesterday was a courgette and cheddar quiche. Wholemeal flour, eggs, onions, garlic, courgettes, mint all travelled less than ten miles. The cheese, butter and milk weren't vegan, but they're British. It was delicious. And easy.

Eat local and seasonal. You'll do a lot less harm.

Eeksteek · 26/09/2022 01:10

autyspauty · 25/09/2022 22:45

Quite.
also avocados seem to be at the forefront of the Vegan 'movement'. when I dabbled (few weeks before I gave up on the idea) most of the 'how to start as a vegan' videos and articles started with avocado as a main source of 'good fat' and protein(?)

it just seems that every little thing I have or I buy seems to have a million ethical problems and it's all becoming a bit too much to keep up with.

one day I'd love to have a little market garden and a to y caravan for me and dh in the middle of all of our food, delivering groceries on our bike and cooking on gas from our special toilet but we don't have money in the bank so it's still just a dream.

It’s bloody hard work (not that I’ve done it to that extent, but probably more than most!)

I found out about it from a David Attenborough documentary. State of the planet I think. But it’s obvious to anyone who gardens that veganism isn’t sustainable. You need soil inputs for fertility, and vegan subs like pleather are always plastic, which you’d have to live under a rock not to know is a sustainability problem. What we need is about 90 percent fewer people really. So if you really want to make a difference, only have one child (or none), and send a lot of money to third world countries to educate and emancipate women. Will do more to conserve resources than all the pleather, Facon and avocados you can eat. Not quite so instagramable though. (Probably explains why it hasn’t caught on) And it doesn’t make any money for anyone, so no one is advertising it.

MangyInseam · 26/09/2022 01:03

veganism, imo, is a well meaning lifestyle choice but I don’t believe it’s sustainable or as environmentally friendly as people claim.

No it really isn't, because in order even to attempt it you have to reject all the natural interrelationships in ecosystems.

And that's always a fool's choice. I this case it typically means people making choices - like using petroleum based fertilizers or clothes as you mention - which are actually less sustainable and ultimately more destructive to live.

And what's maybe worse in the end, though it's difficult to put a value on it - it means people don't really have to come to terms with the ethical costs of their own life, which is, other lives. There is, at least ideologically, an opt-out. In reality it means other people do the dirty work.

Eeksteek · 26/09/2022 00:56

HangingOver · 25/09/2022 23:59

Found the article ourworldindata.org/food-choice-vs-eating-local

Environmentally, the "just buy local" thing has been being crapped on for a while. It sounds logical but apparently not.

To some extent, that depends what it is. Local beef in the midlands, where the cows graze outside etc etc is going to be better than corn fed, indoor reared cattle in the USA, not just because it hasn’t travelled, but because of the intensive way it’s reared. It isn’t a straight comparison, no matter how far it’s flown. There is also the question of land not being suitable for cultivation being grazed.

When is also going change footprint massively. A locally grown strawberry is going to have massively different footprint in July to January. Seasonally is also important. So yes, imported will be better. But not eating strawberries in January is even better than that (which is….not very complicated!)

But we’re also taking about transformation of land, and monoculture. And small producers (which by definition make up a variety environments) are going to be far more sustainable and not form the type of sterile monocultures discussed here. As usual, you can’t just consider one thing. Less meat (not none. You can’t farm like that) more local food in season and smaller producers. It won’t be be impactless - that’s not possible - it’s just the best we can do, we can’t just cease to exist!

QualityStreetsmallertin2 · 26/09/2022 00:32

I was thinking more volume of seaweed products, not just sushi & samphire, such as kelp forests

I actually have some seaweed crisps

justasking111 · 26/09/2022 00:07

HangingOver · 25/09/2022 23:56

The vast majority of meat emissions come from the production, not the transport. For beef the getting it to you bit is like 1% of its footprint, so the "buy local" thing isn't really that big a deal from an emissions perspective.

Not true our Welsh lamb mostly exported because it's so expensive. It goes to auction I attend now and again, goes onto wagons alive and is shipped far and wide to be slaughtered wherever it lands up. It's worth £200 million a year to us in export

HangingOver · 25/09/2022 23:59

Found the article ourworldindata.org/food-choice-vs-eating-local

Environmentally, the "just buy local" thing has been being crapped on for a while. It sounds logical but apparently not.

HangingOver · 25/09/2022 23:56

The vast majority of meat emissions come from the production, not the transport. For beef the getting it to you bit is like 1% of its footprint, so the "buy local" thing isn't really that big a deal from an emissions perspective.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 25/09/2022 23:53

MariosMagicMushrooms · 25/09/2022 18:49

Wouldn’t the animals run/fly away before the harvester got close to them? Those things are bloody loud... I highly doubt a healthy animal would just sit there and chill if they heard a harvester approaching.

A lot of ground nesting birds and mammals have the instinct to freeze in order to not trigger a pounce or attack from a predator - hares/leverets, deer/fawns, peewits, for example. Even chickens freeze when something they perceive threatens them/looms over them from above (it's a convenient way to catch them when they're refusing to go into their house). And a small creature compared to a bloody great combine has no way of knowing they need to run in a particular direction to get away from it or isn't large enough to cover the sort of distance needed to outrun it.

mathanxiety · 25/09/2022 23:47

now I'm thinking almond milk probably kills more than cow milk.

Almond milk takes a huge toll on the environment. Almond production in the Central Valley of California, where most of the world's almonds are grown, requires an insane amount of water.

mathanxiety · 25/09/2022 23:39

Pedant note, oats are wind pollinated and don’t require bees. Same with most grains, maize, corn.

But what about fertiliser?
And birds poop on crops...

justasking111 · 25/09/2022 23:20

Back in the day granny thought recycling rubbish was throwing it into the coal boiler which heated the water for washing up and bathing. Now a log burner is verboten according to many. My other granny had a big range coal fed which cooked meals, heated water, warmed up the home.

Electricity is okay if it comes from solar wind sources, my grannies who thought indoor plumbing was a luxury would be aghast at all our hair shirt attitudes

Getofftheladder · 25/09/2022 23:16

Discovereads · 25/09/2022 21:40

Yep, agree it’s all about information. So important too that we show that commercial pollination services are different in the U.K. from the US because of better welfare standards. So, yes, perhaps oat milk made in U.K. is ok, but almond milk made in US not ok because while both use bee pollination services, one is done how you showed and the other done how I showed.

Pedant note, oats are wind pollinated and don’t require bees. Same with most grains, maize, corn.

Clymene · 25/09/2022 23:14

Umbellifer · 25/09/2022 16:22

The most ethical diet - environmentally - is a locally-produced one. Whether or not you want to make that vegan or omnivore or somewhere in between is an individual choice, but buying stuff grown near where you live, or in your county or region or country (the uk) generally means higher welfare standards, reduced or no pesticide or hormone use, and no air miles. Eat seasonally and you’ll be doing even better.

This is what I try and do. I eat meat but I shop local.

autyspauty · 25/09/2022 23:07

Eeksteek · 25/09/2022 20:43

Farmed bees in monocultures of things like almonds are harmed. They aren’t happy wild bees, and can’t be because there’s nothing else to live on for miles in any direction once the almond flowers are over. They are constantly moved on, and any bee who doesn’t make it back to the truck in time just dies alone. Bees can’t survive without their colony and they can’t survive in a monoculture once the flowers are gone. It’s a pretty stressful life for them. .

I know they’re only insects, and I’m not vegan. I do (or did when I wasn’t so broke) my best to eat local, sustainable and very high animal welfare food. And I wouldn’t knowingly eat products with bees used in that way. It is cruel, and people should know and be able to make a choice about whether they are ok with it or not.

I think this is where I am finding my problem.

alot of these things seem to be not widely known or discussed. it feels a bit slimey.

Especially as vegans is supposed to be the answer to climate change. Its often touted as ethical and now I'm thinking almond milk probably kills more than cow milk.

OP posts:
RampantIvy · 25/09/2022 22:58

Buy locally grown produce from the farm shop and/or grow your own?