Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have no sympathy for DS

162 replies

chucklesatwork · 25/09/2022 15:29

DS is 17, he has a very on/off relationship with his ex and she blocks/unblocks him constantly, DS really likes her so he won't block her and everytime she unblocks him, he thinks this time they'll get back together etc.

I put £80 in his account a month for food at college, the bus etc. He knows this money isn't for anything else. This morning, he told me he needs more money, I asked him why as I only put some in a few weeks ago so he should have some left, after a lot of ‘i don't knows’ he told me his ex asked for £50 and he gave it her and they spoke for a bit until a few days later she asked for more and he said he didn't have it, and she blocked him a few days after that.

I have no sympathy for him as he knows this money is for college but DP (not his dad) has said I'm BU as DS is upset and he has ADHD which makes him more vulnerable.

AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
IVFfirsttimer91 · 30/08/2023 22:51

Ahh poor kid. He tried to do what he thought was right and got his heart broken again and is now down £50. He’s young and hasn’t worked out the ways of the world yet. Id give him the £50 again on this occasion and let him know that it won’t be happening again if the situation repeats itself. Imagine the stress he was under trying to work out how to deal with getting to school etc on £30 for the rest of the month, then having to tell you about it when he knew you’d be cross. It’s a mistake, but glad it’s one he made early rather than later on in life when proper amounts of money could have been lost

junipermarten · 29/09/2022 04:21

I have ADHD and agree with the PPs who say give the money little and often rather than monthly.

I'm amazed that he's only run out of money once before when he bought a game. Sounds like he's been doing great.

I fell in love for the first time at 17. I would have done anything for that guy, it was embarrassing. And the RSD was crippling back then.

Cut him some slack. And learn more about ADHD.

stillvicarinatutu · 29/09/2022 04:00

Kids with additional needs are so easy to take advantage of tho

I'd sort him out this time and explain the consequences of falling for this again

I couldn't turn my back. I never have with my adult dc. They've both become self sufficient but I can't see what good making g the lad live on nothing will do ?

greenteafiend · 29/09/2022 03:55

I think the OP knows her son best.

If she feels that it's probably best to let him feel the consequences this time, she's probably right.

Blueink · 29/09/2022 03:53

The wording of her message about the money is really odd and controlling. I would speak to her parents. I would want to know if my DC was behaving this way. YANBU to be annoyed but he is obviously struggling in this ‘relationship’ so YABU not to be sympathetic about that.

LilacPoppy · 29/09/2022 03:53

£80 is on the low side have you helped him claim pip? Does he not get a bursary as you are a low income family.

Fraaahnces · 29/09/2022 03:02

I think you did the right thing. He won’t listen to you, he won’t listen to his friends and he won’t even listen to her saying “Leave me alone!”. He needs to learn to respect people’s boundaries and to respect himself. The only way that is going to happen is if he learns to stand on his own two feet.
Maybe it’s time he got himself a part time job. Then he won’t have enough time to obsess over her, and he might have a better understanding of the value of money.

Blobblobblob · 29/09/2022 02:54

I'm with you OP. Hard lesson for sure, but its easy to give money away when you never feel the consequences.

Cheekymaw · 29/09/2022 02:12

Your poor lad,OP. She sounds a right nasty madam. Thing is ,he will have to realise himself. I agree with other PP's ; bus ticket, lunch made up to eat , small flask of hot chocolate etc
Do he have a part time job ,Op? Nothing like earning your own cash to develop a sense of intolerance for grifters.

Mothership4two · 29/09/2022 02:09

@Isaidnoalready

Well I would have zero sympathy but buy him a bus ticket and give him sandwich stuff to make himself lunch no more cash

^^ This and a painful lesson learnt. I would also contact the parents, but expect to be disappointed. And I would make sure he knew she was banned from the house.

Somethingneedstochange · 29/09/2022 01:54

She's using him, the next time she unblocks him he needs to block her and have done with her.

Ecllips · 29/09/2022 01:23

What is your priority, being a grade A jerk?

Ecllips · 29/09/2022 01:20

The mother has probably been putting up for this behavior for a long time and has come near to the end of her "empathy rope", is why she probably worded it the way she did. You are an awful person and I hope you never have any children, ever.

TheRAW · 29/09/2022 00:44

YABU.

Your tough love is misplaced. I would agree with you if not for the ADHD, which can be excruciating in this circumstance. He is clearly being taken advantage of.

I noticed no concern for your son's mental and emotional well-being, just concern about the money he spends. What exactly is your priority?

Clarinet1 · 28/09/2022 20:58

Haven’t RTWT but I’m with those who say take steps such as a bus pass and packed lunches or maybe a GoHenry with no cash withdrawals. However, although I don’t know much about ADHD, if he is not helped to learn about money and relationships, I think there would be a risk that this young man could fall victim to an OLD romance scam.

mrswibblywobbly · 28/09/2022 20:48

Waterfallgirl · 25/09/2022 15:36

He is in an abusive relationship.
I would yes, it’s a life lesson but he needs support with this.

I second this

Sally573 · 28/09/2022 12:56

@BuildersTeaMaker Jesus I hope none of your kids have adhd

Doingprettywellthanks · 28/09/2022 09:55

BuildersTeaMaker · 28/09/2022 09:20

Fuck that.
I would be livid if a son of mine gave £50 of MY MONEY to a random “girlfriend” who is manipulating him, or any random girlfried,
when he earns the money himself he can choose what to do with it and give it away to who he likes if he’s that stupid.
but while I am supporting him from my earnings for his essentials I’d be reading him the riot act. Absolutely no way would I be giving him any more, or giving him £80 up front. I’d start by giving him money for each spend and asking for receipts. If he can’t be trusted with my money I’d be going back to basics and stop handing it out for him to mismanage

You would be “livid” with your teen son, in love with adhd, not having done this before?

Doingprettywellthanks · 28/09/2022 09:52

Tbh OP

I think it’s quite remarkable that he hasn’t done this before or similar in terms of mismanaging his money given he has ADHD

BadNomad · 28/09/2022 09:32

BuildersTeaMaker · 28/09/2022 09:20

Fuck that.
I would be livid if a son of mine gave £50 of MY MONEY to a random “girlfriend” who is manipulating him, or any random girlfried,
when he earns the money himself he can choose what to do with it and give it away to who he likes if he’s that stupid.
but while I am supporting him from my earnings for his essentials I’d be reading him the riot act. Absolutely no way would I be giving him any more, or giving him £80 up front. I’d start by giving him money for each spend and asking for receipts. If he can’t be trusted with my money I’d be going back to basics and stop handing it out for him to mismanage

Even if your son has learning difficulties?

BuildersTeaMaker · 28/09/2022 09:20

chucklesatwork · 25/09/2022 15:29

DS is 17, he has a very on/off relationship with his ex and she blocks/unblocks him constantly, DS really likes her so he won't block her and everytime she unblocks him, he thinks this time they'll get back together etc.

I put £80 in his account a month for food at college, the bus etc. He knows this money isn't for anything else. This morning, he told me he needs more money, I asked him why as I only put some in a few weeks ago so he should have some left, after a lot of ‘i don't knows’ he told me his ex asked for £50 and he gave it her and they spoke for a bit until a few days later she asked for more and he said he didn't have it, and she blocked him a few days after that.

I have no sympathy for him as he knows this money is for college but DP (not his dad) has said I'm BU as DS is upset and he has ADHD which makes him more vulnerable.

AIBU?

Fuck that.
I would be livid if a son of mine gave £50 of MY MONEY to a random “girlfriend” who is manipulating him, or any random girlfried,
when he earns the money himself he can choose what to do with it and give it away to who he likes if he’s that stupid.
but while I am supporting him from my earnings for his essentials I’d be reading him the riot act. Absolutely no way would I be giving him any more, or giving him £80 up front. I’d start by giving him money for each spend and asking for receipts. If he can’t be trusted with my money I’d be going back to basics and stop handing it out for him to mismanage

America12 · 28/09/2022 09:17

Has he got a job ? Can he do any extra hours ?

Brefugee · 28/09/2022 09:17

it's ok to have sympathy because she is using him. It's also ok to have sympathy with her because he ís pestering her (she is using that)

He needs to learn somehow to stop contacting her. Help him do that.

Tell him to send her a message the same as she sent him "do you want to give me 50 quid" and see what happens? of course if she's blocked him, that's not possible.

But you need to make sure the 80 pounds per month is going on the right things. So either cut it into smaller chunks of money/time, or go through it with him - every day if necessary - so both of you can see where it's going. This is a good habit for him to get into anyway at his age.

For the now: make sure his bus fares are covered and he can take packed lunches (or you can sub him to buy some). If you really want the lesson to sit, work out a payment plan (from the 80 pounds) or have him "work off the debt" in the household or something.

America12 · 28/09/2022 09:16

By him a bus pass.
Tesco do a student / parent prepaid card.

jeaux90 · 28/09/2022 09:05

He has ADHD. My DD13 also does.

It means they are less emotionally mature and this makes them vulnerable.

You are ok to be angry with him but talk it through and make sure he understands not to lend money.

Does he struggle with friendships? My DD will often use her money to treat her friends, I think she does this so they like her which makes me sad. Despite talking to her about it she still does it because she really doesn't have many friends.