Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To call my daughter’s manager

142 replies

Bunnyfuller · 25/09/2022 13:42

DD is 16 and is doing her first part time job, working as a Barista at a chain coffee shop. She was given her contracts to sign a few weeks ago, and given an employee handbook. In it it says pay should go up once ‘customer trained’ and again when barista trained. She’s definitely completed the assessments for both of these, and when she asked the shop manager about the rise as laid out in the handbook, the manager said ‘oh, I think that’s wrong, that book is from last year’.

Nothing since. I’ve said to DD to ask for the most current handbook, but immediately got bellowed at for hassling. She just says she’ll quit if her pay doesn’t go up.

I’d like to get to the bottom of it. Would it be very bad of me to call the manager and ask for clarification? There seems to be quite widespread exploitation of these kids starting out, her friend got similarly underpaid by a chain garden centre, and she just quit.

YABU - don’t call, if your daughter accepts it, or quits, it’s her choice

YANBU - a quiet request for the current handbook will let the manager know you’re onto her

OP posts:
TokyoTen · 25/09/2022 14:48

Please step back from your daughter's job and let her manage her life. She needs to do this herself, not because you are on to it. If I had someone's mother contact me then they would go down in my estimation - I'd think if they can't manage simple things from their own life admin how can they manage my customers.

justasking111 · 25/09/2022 14:45

Doingprettywellthanks · 25/09/2022 14:43

Oh come on - he got a “kick back” for keeping wages down. Really?

Have you never heard of bonuses in the hospitality industry. 🙄

SeaToSki · 25/09/2022 14:44

At 16 its a mixed bag, you are helping them grow into adults still and part of that is helping them to navigate these sorts of tricky situations so that they dont become doormats and also dont become ‘perpetually angry life isnt fair and so I will opt out of everything’ adults

I would sit down and help her talk through her options, what are three different routes you could take to solve this. In each of the routes what are the upsides and downsides, each time ask and let her answer before adding your 2 cents. Then suggest she takes 24 hrs to decide which route she wants to take (always good to sleep on a big decision - more learning for the future) and then support her in her decision. If it goes tits up then help her reassess and learn that sometimes it can take two or three tries at something to get a good solution.

And in the background be ready to step in and handle things if you think she is being exploited dangerously…. And tell her that, knowing you have her back if there is a big problem is very confidence building for teens

Doingprettywellthanks · 25/09/2022 14:43

justasking111 · 25/09/2022 14:35

We had this with DS head office know full well he was entitled but the individual manager got a kick back for keeping wages down and turnover up. Your daughter needs to find another job my DS did

Oh come on - he got a “kick back” for keeping wages down. Really?

WagathaChristieMystery · 25/09/2022 14:43

Please don’t call on your daughter’s behalf, OP.

If your daughter shouted at you for hassling her (as you write in your OP), I don’t think it’ll go well if you approach your daughter’s manager without talking to her about it first. I do understand where you’re coming from, but I think this is on your daughter to sort.

Doingprettywellthanks · 25/09/2022 14:41

First off… your 16 year old “bellowed at you” for asking a question? And “she will quit” if she doesn’t get a pay rise? 🤔

As for finding out pay - if it’s a matter to nationwide chain, no doubt a quick Google will confirm situation

justasking111 · 25/09/2022 14:35

alloutoflunchideas · 25/09/2022 13:43

It’s up to your daughter, but if it’s a chain there will be a head office and hr team she can contact

We had this with DS head office know full well he was entitled but the individual manager got a kick back for keeping wages down and turnover up. Your daughter needs to find another job my DS did

imtoooldforthiscrap · 25/09/2022 14:26

Help her draft an email asking the uplift referrers to in the staff handbook

Bunnyfuller · 25/09/2022 14:24

@YellowTreeHouse that must be it, although she has friends working in other branches, in different counties, who have the same experiences. So, like many things, perhaps the training is as you say, but many of them aren’t putting it into practice.

thanks for the advice, everyone. I will follow DD’s lead and help with emails/wording etc if she asks.

OP posts:
Howdoyoulikeyourtea · 25/09/2022 14:22

It’s awful isn’t it @Bunnyfuller , you want to help them and protect them but it’s their job so really it’s their responsibility, even if they don’t feel up to challenging things.

I had to help dd find out her rights when her employer treated her horrendously but she then had to go back to them armed with those rights herself. I rang ACAS in that instance. Strangely enough they started treating her better from then on, once they knew she would stand up to them.

As it’s a chain could you email head office for clarity, not naming the branch involved let alone dds name?

YellowTreeHouse · 25/09/2022 14:21

The managers in these places seem to not get much in the way of training in leading people, developing them and effective communication and as such there is little cohesiveness or protection from poor practice.

Incorrect. McDonalds managers receive world class training, so much so they are regularly sought after and poached from other companies.

They are, however, franchises, so if your local franchise doesn’t give a shit, you will see that reflected in their practices.

NC7778 · 25/09/2022 14:20

Please don't do this, she's not in school, this is a job. They won't talk to you and Tbh I wouldn't even agree to take your call. All comms are better done in writing anyway so help her write a grievance letter. She has to work out herself how to cope with these situations in the working world, they'll be many over the years and mummy can't always fix it. Teach her how to handle it but don't do it for her

iloveeverykindofcat · 25/09/2022 14:19

They will not talk to you anyway even if you do contact them as she is the employee (and talking to you would go against all data protection legislation).

That's what I was going to say. They literally can't. I've had university students' parents call me to discuss their children's grades. They're usually quite surprised to hear that all I can legally tell them is that x is or isn't a student enrolled at the university.

mountainsunsets · 25/09/2022 14:19

I used to work in retail management and there's absolutely no way I would speak to a parent about this if they called. You're not their employee and, legally speaking, it's nothing to do with you.

Your DD needs to sort this out on her own, or speak to another more experienced colleague about it and see if they can help her.

Blix · 25/09/2022 14:19

Well you know the answer.
It's another tough phase of parenting. You can only help and advise you cannot actively intervene. It can be tough when it's a health issue as your role as a parent is no longer to act on their behalf.
I had similar problems when DS was 16, he was very exploited working in a takeaway. I had to view it as a learning experience for him.
I agree with others, sit her down and talk through her options , help her to word an email to head office, warn her what may or may not happen, that she will have to learn to be assertive and deal with bosses and colleagues when she works in any job, and ultimately let her decide.

WhatALotOfAFussAboutNothing · 25/09/2022 14:16

YABU 100%

Three things:

  1. It’s her job, so she needs to be the one asking the questions.

2)If my mum had rang my manager at 16, I’d have been furious (she wouldn’t have done so though).

  1. They will not talk to you anyway even if you do contact them as she is the employee (and talking to you would go against all data protection legislation).
Quirrelsotherface · 25/09/2022 14:13

It's my opinion, which I'm entitled to on a public forum. I can't imagine this happening when my generation was this age and I do worry that we are and have pandered to our children so much that they are just not able to cope in the big, wide world. It will become a big problem in society in the future.

If your daughter is old enough to go out to work, she's old enough to deal with an employer. it's not like at school where you go speak to the teacher.

alfagirl73 · 25/09/2022 14:12

Definitely don't speak to the manager/employer - that is for your DD to learn to do herself, however, there is nothing wrong with you working WITH your DD to help her figure out what to do about it eg. go through her contract, research employment law, contact ACAs etc... a worthwhile exercise in any event. But don't do it FOR her.

whynotwhatknot · 25/09/2022 14:11

get her to email if that makes her feel better about asking-i find they all lie about salay duties though its just to get you in then they just make up excuses

Bunnyfuller · 25/09/2022 14:11

@JackieCollinsExistentialQuestionTime exactly this! I suspect the manager is keeping wages low to boost her margins, especially thinking about how she’s openly said head office want better sales.

yes to all the things you’ve said, exploitation and abuse of young employees is rampant. My other daughter works for MacDonald’s and some of the things she tells me about horrify me. The managers in these places seem to not get much in the way of training in leading people, developing them and effective communication and as such there is little cohesiveness or protection from poor practice. My daughter was unwell one day, but forced herself in. She ended up fainting, so the manager gave her 10 minutes in the crew room then back out working. I obviously didn’t know until after the event, and haven’t done anything about it.

and presumably I’d be making a snowflake if I did! All part of our brave new world where we accept poor treatment, and are not bothered about it happening to those with limited ability to fight it themselves!

One of my first jobs was in an old people’s home. One of the residents kept exposing himself to me, and trying to, as I now know, masturbate. The manager there did nothing about it so one day I just refused to go. The staff thought it was funny. I was 14.

OP posts:
YellowTreeHouse · 25/09/2022 14:01

Of course YABU. You are not employed by them, so they won’t speak to you.

I work somewhere where we employ a lot of under 18s and we don’t engage with their parents. They are not our employees.

Bunnyfuller · 25/09/2022 13:59

Thanks all, I suspected as much. It’s an interesting time going through the change of it being your child who you sort everything for, and allowing them to learn to be the adult she wants to be.

@PortiaWithNoBreaks that’s a good idea, if she wants to

@CheezePleeze good point! Quite possibly!

@Quirrelsotherface really necessary?! This is all new to me, and I’m navigating it. I asked here for a bit of clear and honest thinking, not name calling. My daughter hasn’t asked me to sort it for her, it’s my sense of injustice in overdrive because it’s my daughter!

OP posts:
MaChienEstUnDick · 25/09/2022 13:59

You can't do it for her - I absolutely get that you want to, my DS had a similar situation, but you can't. They don't even need to speak to you, you're not anyone to them.

When DS was struggling with a couple of things we'd do an email together. That way I could make sure it was ticking a few official sounding boxes, and it teaches them that there's no harm in a paper trail...

JackieCollinsExistentialQuestionTime · 25/09/2022 13:58

Thestagshead · 25/09/2022 13:53

If it’s a chain there is fuck all reason the manager would under pay your kid. She’s not making a profit and would likely get into trouble if she did. So I’d assume it’s right. Your daughter has to deal with it on her own, has she spoken to others?

Not true unfortunately. Our managers would do everything they could to avoid paying anyone more than the absolute minimum. They want to be efficient with the budget so that they can get promotions. I know people who still work for the same company but different chains and it’s the same.

FTM2B1 · 25/09/2022 13:58

Help her construct an email or prepare for a conversation if she wants to pursue it, but you can't do it for her. Situations like this unfortunately occur and she needs to learn to make her own decisions and deal with thi gs herself. This is your daughter's job - if she doesn't want to have the confrontation and would rather vote with her feet, that's up to her.

For what it's worth, I had a similar experience to this when I was about 17. I got a job in a cafe after a trial shift and was told I'd be paid every fortnight. At the end of the fortnight I was told I'd be paid for 3 weeks a fortnight later because it wasn't a trial shift it was a trial week. When I queried it with the manager she very sweetly told me I'd clearly misunderstood and that she had never once said trial shift, that a week trial unpaid was very common. I knew she was taking the piss because I was young and I decided i didnt want to work for someone like that. So I apologised for the misunderstanding, confirmed my shifts for the following week and just never went back.