Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Spending money for a week in New York?

184 replies

Feofjwonxoaks · 25/09/2022 12:54

Well 6 days. My partner and I, no children. We'd like to book onto some tours etc. As well. Would need some sort of subway pass.
Want to try new places to eat but i don't think we'll be eating in restaurants for every meal, probably some quick takeaway stuff too.
Wondering if £300 each (obviously converted) would be enough?

OP posts:
FlounderingFruitcake · 25/09/2022 16:25

The combo of inflation and the current exchange rate means you’re going to need way more than you think. $300 per day would still involve budgeting but you could have a nice time on that. $300 for 6 days is laughable unless you only do free stuff (walking basically) and eat shit fast food. DH was there last week and said he spent $37 on a Pret lunch, unsure what he bought and thankfully on expenses, but still, that’s insane!

Sd352 · 25/09/2022 16:24

Oh gosh, no, that would be very tight. About $1k per person for 6 days I think. A “normal” restaurant meal out with shared appetiser, mains, one drink each is likely to work out to at least around $80 for two, and that is if you are being quite restrained in what you order and not going anywhere fancy. Museums etc are quite expensive too — we did a one hour tour at the Tenement Museum and that was $30 each!

You could manage for cheaper — eat only at food trucks / markets (of which there are plenty with all kinds of delicious food), go to museums on free days (you will need to research when this is), go to a bar with a great view instead of going to Empire State Building (even cheaper — take in the view from New Jersey or Brooklyn without paying Manhattan prices), but it will take planning and research and a willingness to get off the beaten tourist path.

ThatsGoingToHurt · 25/09/2022 16:21

I went to NY 15 years ago and took £500 for 4 nights/5 days (the exchange rate was much better then as well) and it was fine but I didn’t do a lot of shopping. £300 is not enough!

WonkasBooboofixer · 25/09/2022 16:17

Nope you could double that easily and then some, the dollar is awful 1.09 to the pound yesterday. New York is very very spendy. And dont forget to tip

catfunk · 25/09/2022 16:17

I'd guess £150-200 total per day.

Igotoworktopaybills · 25/09/2022 16:12

We went in June.

Spent a lot more than that! and that’s with pre booking a fair bit before we left. Statue of liberty is around 22 dollars, top of the rock is around 40 dollars each, the 9/11 museum was expensive, the intrepid has free evenings on a Friday I think you’d have to check, we watched a film there was lovely, a bottle of water was 4 dollars, a beer around 10 dollars, and a cocktail can be up to 20 dollars, I had a head ache and the us version of paracetamol was 14 dollars…

It’s around 100 dollars per meal including the tip, and that’s not even at really decent places. At decent places you’re looking between 250-400 and that’s not even the most expensive restaurants. Even general food is expensive I did a picnic in Central Park and it cost be about 80 dollars for the food. You can get some really decent street food but again it’s between 3 to 15 dollars and you can’t be too picky. Los tacos no 1 was good but again nearly 5 dollars for one taco and they are not filling.

get the subway pass it’s about 33 dollars each, even with taking the sub way we walked between 5 and 10 miles a day so take comfy shoes,

before you go work out what you want to do, we did this and put it all on google maps which helped us work out what do each day with the locations.

dont forget sales tax it’s added to everything over a certain amount so what is on a label isn’t what you pay. Macy’s did effectively give me the sales tax back for being English but it depends on who serves you.

there are some fab free things to do, grand central station, dumbo street art, the flat iron building, Brooklyn bridge, Roosevelt’s island and the tram is free, walk the high line etc

have a look on YouTube and find some videos of people who live there, sarah funky and here be barr I think his name is.

Cosmos123 · 25/09/2022 16:04

For me was a waste of money. Honestly there has been better holidays than New York.

Shinyhappyperson22 · 25/09/2022 16:00

I’ve been to New York a few times and the last time in 2019 and we had £500each for 4 nights and was fine. Not shoppers or big spenders but more walking, sight seeing and transport/ food/drinks. I’m not a scrimper on holiday but we don’t do exclusive expensive type places either.

Some things can absolutely be done cheaper . sounds like you really need to do some research! Google /research New York tips on a budget too. Some you tube vlogs may help but if you can afford more I’d take it. With it being post pandemic and the pound being crap you’ll need it!

hattie43 · 25/09/2022 15:55

No way is £300 enough . I'd be taking at least £2k

Ontobetterthings · 25/09/2022 15:54

We got Go city passes and booked tours through there. We are going next month. Worked out a lot cheaper.

I read you need at least £30 a day just for tips alone.

gogohmm · 25/09/2022 15:49

Oh and take comfy shoes, we walked and walked, great way to see the city. My dp has a very good job so money isn't and issue but even he commented we were burning through money like no tomorrow ... it was a trip of a lifetime type trip for us but still, very expensive despite trying to be canny eg downloading restaurant saving apps in advance, online deals for the museum and getting standby tickets (tip: the Met Opera was a lot cheaper than Broadway)

scarletisjustred · 25/09/2022 15:48

I've just been and it was insanely expensive. I probably ate one of the most expensive meals of my life - it was very nice of course - but the price was stratospheric. This was was a nice restaurant but we're not talking Michelin star.

gogohmm · 25/09/2022 15:44

It's very very expensive. Things that cost £10 in the U.K. cost $40. That said the subway is cheap, you can use your card, street vendors can be cheap and there's cheap pizza for instance $3 for 2 slices and a can of soda near our hotel. There's "markets" sort of grocery stores but with hot food everywhere, a good option for cheaper food, some have tables, and in residential areas they cater to the many New Yorkers without proper kitchens or the inclination to cook.

The most reasonable tour and a full day is the Statue of Liberty and Ellis island because the actual attractions are free, you are only paying for the boat, book as far ahead as you can. Another tip is there is a free jazz museum in Harlem we found, you can walk around the 9/11 monument for free (museum was very pricey so we didn't bother). If you are in midtown, the Hell's Kitchen area had some cheap bars with $5 drinks, remember to add tip and tax though! Upside is portions are generous so eat brunch late and skip lunch, don't be afraid to ask to share, most places won't bat an eyelid

Philandbill · 25/09/2022 15:37

It's fabulous but painfully expensive. We went this summer and had a great holiday but we had picnic lunches every day and cooked for ourselves every evening as we had a hotel room with a kitchenette. We had three breakfasts out and they averaged 25 dollars each. A pre packed sandwich (standard, not huge) was 7-8 dollars from a very ordinary supermarket and coffee and a small cake or cookie at the Met café was 12 dollars each. A coffee at a very ordinary coffee shop was 5 dollars. And it cost at least 25 dollars per person to get into a gallery or museum. We saved up for years to go, and DH and I and our two teenagers loved it, but we won't go back.

sparklecement · 25/09/2022 15:35

3 of us in January are going. We plan on £1k each and an extra £1k just in case.

Not sure what you'd get for £50 a day. A bagel and a bottle of water
Perhaps.

FormerlySpeckledyHen · 25/09/2022 15:34

Don’t forget transport from the airport, and return.

CharlotteRose90 · 25/09/2022 15:26

I’ve done New York twice now 2015 and 2018. The first time I saw all the tourist bits, splashed out on nice restaurants and bought a load of clothes and make up etc spent about £2000 . The second time I did it cheaper and did the bits I hadn’t seen plus a Broadway show. We ate at one expensive place which was Ellen’s stardust and frankly I don’t recommend it. Other then that we ate at diners and little cafe places and they were fabulous. I didn’t buy much clothes wise so I think I spent £700. Completely depends on what you have planned to do. If you plan to do the whole city experience you need a lot.

MadameOvary81 · 25/09/2022 15:25

If you're anything like me....Two Gazillion dollars!

We lived in NYC for 6 months, tried to be as frugal as possible and you will still haemorrhage money at the rate of knots.

One way to save money is to avoid eating out (you will be a fortune in tips) and eat at places like Subway and Burger King. And speaking of tips, most people in service wants one. The porters in hotels, door staff if they hail you a cab, taxi drivers, waitresses....and on and on. Don't let anyone do anything for you, it's not kindness, they want your $$$.

Optimist2020 · 25/09/2022 15:20

I have done New York on a budget in 2017 & 2019 and spent around $120 a day pp.

TalkSomeSense1 · 25/09/2022 15:19

We walked EVERYWHERE - easy to do and a great way to see it all. But the island of Manhattan is bigger than you think. And it's expensive! Just coffee and really simple sandwich lunches from a deli were easily $30. You could do it on a budget but wear very comfortable shoes, don't expect to be able to do the really touristy things like the Empire State - but that doesn't matter as there is so much to see anyway. You can still have an amazing time as it's all about the atmosphere.
NY Public Library
Upper East Side
Central Park
Brooklyn Bridge
DumBo
Hudson Yards
Greenwich Village
Meatpacking District
Staten Island Ferry
Harlem
Times Square but that's heavy on a drug dealers!!
China Town

dlb30 · 25/09/2022 15:18

We are going for 5 nights next yr (2 of us) and currently saving a bit each month to take approx £2k (and maybe a little more if we can, can always convert back if we don't spend it). We're also going to buy the NY passes before we go.

Have been told it's extremely expensive so I would up your budget to be comfortable, would rather have too much than not enough imo.

Greybutterfly · 25/09/2022 15:18

That’s £50 a day … surely you must realise that this would not even cover your dinner. A 3 day New York day pass is over $200. I think you need to times that amount by 4/5

PanicAtTheBigTesco · 25/09/2022 15:11

For the subway you can just tap your debit card now like you do for the tube in London.

PanicAtTheBigTesco · 25/09/2022 15:10

I went in April and was prepared for it to be expensive but it really is on another level.

We spent £1500 on 5 days and that didn't include attractions which we had a separate pass for, only ate at two restaurants (talking $78 for two burgers + chips and a coke each) and had street food/takeaway the rest of our trip.

functionoverform · 25/09/2022 15:03

Not enough for NYC. We went last Apr and it was pricey then. We booked somewhere with a basic breakfast, would pick up a baguette/ falafel wrap / burrito for lunch, or go to one of the cheap pizza slice places (2 dollars a massive slice). Train station food hall is great for freshly made food. We would also go to wholefoods for a salad bar / hot food bar and sit in the dining area, good value for money.

We spent most of our budget on doing things and the odd tour, so cut back on dining out. We have been before when the exchange rate was higher and enjoyed really nice restaurants, so wasn't too fussed.

You'll need to plan your days so you can budget / end up with food options.

Definitely get a subway pass 33 dollars or something similar for a weeks usage. That wil cover all transport.