Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Spending money for a week in New York?

184 replies

Feofjwonxoaks · 25/09/2022 12:54

Well 6 days. My partner and I, no children. We'd like to book onto some tours etc. As well. Would need some sort of subway pass.
Want to try new places to eat but i don't think we'll be eating in restaurants for every meal, probably some quick takeaway stuff too.
Wondering if £300 each (obviously converted) would be enough?

OP posts:
hellesbells · 25/09/2022 21:19

Not sure the OP is coming back which is a shame as I feel people are trying to be helpful, the bottom line is that even if you go a strict budget holiday £300 is not going to touch the sides, there is every chance over the next week the £ will reach parity with the dollar so £300 will buy you even less, when are you actually going OP? You will need a minimum of 1k each to cover 6 days

2MinuteRice · 25/09/2022 21:19

TheOnlyBeeInYourBonnet · 25/09/2022 20:23

Those additional tips like for drinks at a bar, hotel cleaning, bathroom attendant - what's a reasonable amount for each?

I'm planning a trip too and so stressed about this part. Don't want to spend more than I need to buy don't want to offend or cause a scene either!

We went in August and after reading up on it (Facebook NYC groups are amazing).

Based on reading we thought 15-20% appeared the norm. We found if you pay by card, in restaurants, then the machine gives you choice. It was usually the 10%, 15%, 20% or 25%.

To be honest we never chose 25%! It took a while to get used to but we started basing it on our experience. Go to Five Guys, you get up to order and then get up to collect. They got less as there wasn't table service

We went to a mall and had lunch, it was like Bluewater etc. Choose what you want and take your tray, no tip.

Kids wanted a bubble tea, was sooo much money but their choice. There was an option tip jar. The servers were great so I put a couple of dollars in.

I think it gets easier as you go along. If you want your room cleaned in a hotel. Changer the sign and leave 5-10 dollars. I forgot the first time and they took all the soap and toilet roll! Got more from reception but learnt a lesson. We then turn the sign to do not disturb and gave £10 on the last day.

Tipping is difficult and I think we found as British people it's sometimes embarrassing and then we are uncomfortable. Some of our tips were bigger, some people really make your experience better!

We mostly paid by card, Chase but apparently Revolut is good too. We needed more cash than I expected. Thinks like tips for the maid, also my car didn't work buying the week long metro card. Luckily I had enough cash for 5 of us at $30ish each!

Have a lovely trip, it's a great city. We go to London a lot and thought it would be similar, it's nothing like it!

PanicAtTheBigTesco · 25/09/2022 21:11

For anyone stressed about tipping this is the guide I followed when we went back in April, don't let it stress you out! Also if you have a meal/tab for drinks then on the receipt it will calculate the tip at 3 rates e.g. 15/20/25% and you just choose one and leave the amount stated.

Spending money for a week in New York?
VroomVrooom · 25/09/2022 21:03

This thread is hilarious - with everyone pumping up the spend amount more and more to outdo each other Grin

Bottom line - no, £300 for a week will not be enough.

2MinuteRice · 25/09/2022 20:58

kavalkada · 25/09/2022 18:36

For somebody who always travels with strict budget in mind, this is very interesting thread. If I waited to have some of the sums mentiones here, I would never go anywhere.

I have never been in New York but I plan to go, mabye next year. I have already planned that trip and in my world it is possible to visit New York on the budget.
I can't wait to visit Roosevelt Island (free with metrocard 33 dolars for a week) and have lunch on a bench looking at Manhattan with cherry blossoms above my head, have coffe and snack in a small park at Tudor City after I visit Grand Central Station, take a Staten Island Ferry and see Statue of Liberty, take a NYC Ferry around harbour (2,75 dolars), walk across the Brooklyn Bridge from DUMBO to Manhattan at sunset, take a free tour of New York City Library and see Winnie the Pooh, after that have picnic on the grass in Bryant Park, walk the High Line.

Yes, I would like to have enough money. In my fantasy world I would stay at Plaza, go to see Rockettes at Radio City Music Hall, go to a club after seeing Broadway play, have diiner in One if by Land, Two if by Sea (that place is stunning). But I can't. If that means taking my blanket out in Central Park and watch people passing while I have lunch with my husband after we have been walking and exploring every little street...

OP, I hope you'll have a wonderful time.

Also Bryant Park have free music nights and activities. Depends on when you go to how many are free. We went to an open air concert with loads of eclectic music. It was amazing!

We got a cheap blanket and took a picnic that we made in the hotel room after going to target! It was random but lots of fun!

clowerina · 25/09/2022 20:51

one more tip - get a Starling bank account as there are no fees for debit card usage or cash withdrawals. highly recommend

clowerina · 25/09/2022 20:50

for statue of liberty you can just pay about a few dollars for the staten island ferry return. it's from a distance but you won't regret not paying so much!

clowerina · 25/09/2022 20:48

oh and beware that the airport on the way back is criminally expensive. they were charging about £6.50 for a large bottle of water. They have water fountains though if you can find them!

clowerina · 25/09/2022 20:47

me and my DD (2 people) £1000 in one week. we did empire state etc and bars, but not a lot of eating out. it is super expensive!

for metro ticket you can just use your debit card as a kind of tap on tap off thing. it works out cheaper than getting a weekly subway card generally as the max it will charge you over a week is the weekly rate. Look into it. We bought metro tickets for the week but it wasn't worth it!

remember tipping is crazy expensive. Also remember you might want to get an uber from the airport (about £55 including a tip) and so on.

everything is madness.

Even in supermarkets things are really crazy expensive (£6 loaf of bread, £5 bag of apples). Yes some stuff can be bought a little more modestly but it all adds up.

A beer is about $10.Try for happy hours in bars. A bit more reasonable. Find a jazz bar with live jazz and a happy hour.

you will spend a lot.

alltoomuchrightnow · 25/09/2022 20:44

Also I didn't go to any fancy restaurants or any shows!

Sally573 · 25/09/2022 20:42

I'm planning a trip too and so stressed about this part. Don't want to spend more than I need to buy don't want to offend or cause a scene either!**
No need to stress about it. You could write it down beforehand so you don't panic when it comes to payment. IE drinks bill $x amount = $x amount tip. Dinner bill same.
You literally have to factor in the cost of tipping for hospitality into your daily budget.

urgen · 25/09/2022 20:42

I have been many times over the last 15 years. Came back a few weeks ago. I have never seen it as expensive as it is now. Having dollar slices, eating Burger King. Tbh - I would rather stay at home and go the following year to save more.

20% tip expected and one place on the bill suggested if the service was excellent 30% plus sales tax.

alltoomuchrightnow · 25/09/2022 20:42

I spent about 2k in five days and that was late 90s!
and no designer goods shopping.. NY was extortionate and that wasnt a bad exchange rate then! I never spent that sort of dosh in California where I went yearly...

FlounderingFruitcake · 25/09/2022 20:32

TheOnlyBeeInYourBonnet · 25/09/2022 20:23

Those additional tips like for drinks at a bar, hotel cleaning, bathroom attendant - what's a reasonable amount for each?

I'm planning a trip too and so stressed about this part. Don't want to spend more than I need to buy don't want to offend or cause a scene either!

I always do $5 per day for hotel cleaning, $1 per drink at the bar for a wine/beer and $2 if it’s fancy cocktail but if it’s table service then usual 15-20% applies. I don’t know that I’ve ever encountered a bathroom attendant, I don’t usually carry cash out with me so if I did then they’d be shit out of luck and I’d have to dry my hands on my tights!

TheOnlyBeeInYourBonnet · 25/09/2022 20:23

Those additional tips like for drinks at a bar, hotel cleaning, bathroom attendant - what's a reasonable amount for each?

I'm planning a trip too and so stressed about this part. Don't want to spend more than I need to buy don't want to offend or cause a scene either!

Solmum1964 · 25/09/2022 20:12

LadyAethelfled · 25/09/2022 13:02

I think I took about 800 for just me for one week! We did an activity each day like a museum or shopping, plus 3 meals out a day & cocktails in the evening. We also went to a show one evening. Don't forgot you need to tip everywhere too!

I was going to mention tipping too. It's not just for meals, it's anywhere you receive a service - drinks at a bar; the lady keeping the washroom tidy; chambermaids (daily if staying in a hotel. Also, not just the 10 per cent you might typically tip in the UK but more probably 20 per cent!
It's a few years since we went but there were plenty of places where you could get a takeaway lunch for not a great deal of money and depending on where you are staying a lot of things to do within walking distance and for free. We only used the subway a couple of times, I think to get to the Staten Island Ferry (free) and also for the Statue of Liberty.
We walked miles but planned what we wanted to see: Grand Central Terminus; 9/11 Memorial; Times Square; Brooklyn Bridge; The High Line; China Town; The Flatiron Building; The Chrysler Building; Central Park; Washington Square Park... Yes, you can pay to go into a lot of buildings but you don't have to. The architecture is very interesting anyway.
If getting a taxi from JFK, ensure you use an official yellow cab - they have a set fee.

PigsInBlanketyBlankets · 25/09/2022 20:05

Go to the museums when they are free. It just requires some planning

PigsInBlanketyBlankets · 25/09/2022 20:02

You don't need the pass. There's enough to keep you occupied for free in NYC.

One dollar slices are still a thing. Breakfast takeaway and eat on the go from places like Dunkin Donuts or bacon, egg and cheese from a street vendor.

Find places with lunch deals before you go and make that your main meal. Dollar slice in the evening and a sharing bag of crisps Grin. You can take snacks with you and coffee cups/coffee to make before you head out.

Get a 7 day subway pass each.

You don't need to do tours, just guide yourself. £300 is tight but it's doable if it's all you've got.

How are you getting to and from the airport because a taxi will cost you but the subway is easy.

Commonhealthgames · 25/09/2022 19:56

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Butterflyfluff · 25/09/2022 19:54

Sorry - wrong thread

Butterflyfluff · 25/09/2022 19:53

It’s easier to work out what’s expected against menu prices - even if it is annoying that it’s expected no matter how bad the service

What really baffles me is the expectation of tips in the toilet, or for housekeeping, or the hotel receptionist or in an AI hotel each time you get a drink

2MinuteRice · 25/09/2022 19:20

We paid for a city pass before we left, it's around $130 but it is cheaper to access some attractions. We used ours for Empire State, Liberty Island, 911 museum and a few more.

It's about $30 for a metro pass for the week each. Much cheaper than paying for individual journeys.

There were 5 of us, 3 adults 2 children. We went to Target & Walmart to buy drinks & snacks for breakfast and to take out with us.

Everything is really expensive. We went to a few restaurants, not fancy ones but paid over $150 plus tip. There was a $1dollar per slice pizza place next to the hotel which was useful!

We saved for the last year or so and asked for $ for birthdays etc. The children had $300 each, they came back with about $40 each. Most of it in souvenirs, presents and treats. We agreed to pay for meals, they had to pay for the random ice cream, Slushy etc.

One adult spent $600 ( again we paid for meals) they got trainers etc that you can't get in the UK.

The two of us spent £2500+ between us. To be honest we were having a once in a lifetime holiday so it wasn't an issue.

We took Chase cards as then you don't pay fees on transactions. You also get 1% cash back.

Remember if you are staying in a hotel they expect you to use a credit card to hold some money in case of damages. We got a 0% credit card just for this purpose. Ours was a hold of £50 per night. We went for 8 nights.

PatientlyWaiting21 · 25/09/2022 19:12

It really depends on what you want to do. You can eat $1 pizza slices or splurge $300 on one meal for two.

we went (2 adults) 4 years ago and took £2k, we shopped, ate at some amazing places, shit load of sight seeing. We walked everywhere or took the subway occasionally. We purchased our tickets in advance.

there’s a great Facebook group called NYC the place to be, check it out.

have a great time, I can’t wait to go back!!

grayhairdontcare · 25/09/2022 18:54

You need 2k I reckon or you will struggle

QuizzlyBears · 25/09/2022 18:48

SavingsThreads · 25/09/2022 17:17

I think your DH is exaggerating! I was there this week and got pizza for $5, and a full meal out for $30 in Times Square!

I don’t know. I bought lunch in NYC in a museum restaurant 3 weeks ago - a water, a coffee, Caesar salad and an Alfredo pasta dish and with tax and tip it was $42.