For somebody who always travels with strict budget in mind, this is very interesting thread. If I waited to have some of the sums mentiones here, I would never go anywhere.
I have never been in New York but I plan to go, mabye next year. I have already planned that trip and in my world it is possible to visit New York on the budget.
I can't wait to visit Roosevelt Island (free with metrocard 33 dolars for a week) and have lunch on a bench looking at Manhattan with cherry blossoms above my head, have coffe and snack in a small park at Tudor City after I visit Grand Central Station, take a Staten Island Ferry and see Statue of Liberty, take a NYC Ferry around harbour (2,75 dolars), walk across the Brooklyn Bridge from DUMBO to Manhattan at sunset, take a free tour of New York City Library and see Winnie the Pooh, after that have picnic on the grass in Bryant Park, walk the High Line.
Yes, I would like to have enough money. In my fantasy world I would stay at Plaza, go to see Rockettes at Radio City Music Hall, go to a club after seeing Broadway play, have diiner in One if by Land, Two if by Sea (that place is stunning). But I can't. If that means taking my blanket out in Central Park and watch people passing while I have lunch with my husband after we have been walking and exploring every little street...
OP, I hope you'll have a wonderful time.