Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH wants to buy PlayStation

166 replies

Playstationdilema · 25/09/2022 09:51

A bit of background....

We share our finances, both work full time, with each of us having an equal amount of spending money each month.

He's recently had a nice payrise, and was already annoyed that he didn't see any extra personal money out of it (bills). We're comfortable enough, and our personal spending money is an ok amount. What we choose to do with it is our own business.

He has some extra money in his account currently from overtime (wages still paid into his personal account, then transfers x amount into the joint account). He wants to buy a PlayStation, and I'm annoyed that he's viewing this money as his and not family money.

We're currently not communicating, which is making me doubt myself. He's usually quick to apologise when he thinks he's wrong, but he's holding out with this one.

It's not about the PlayStation. It's about how he views this money as his.

And in case it makes a difference (I know it will to some). I am, and always have been the higher earner. Any payrises etc I've had have not been treated as personal money, they are family money and decisions are made accordingly.
I'm not bitter about this...or at least I wasn't until he suddenly had extra money and acting like I'm being unreasonable.

There is actually a specific piece of furniture I've wanted to buy for 2 years (similar value to playstation) and his answer is always no, its not the right time, we don't have the money etc.

There's a lot we need to do in the house, and a playstation is certainly not a priority in my mind.

From his point of view 'he' doesnt have extra money very often and wont have this opportunity again.

So...AIBU?

OP posts:
Stag82 · 25/09/2022 10:57

Of course this is not about the play station (or furniture or anything else). It is about his approach to finances. Of course the extra money should be the same. If you have an all in approach to finances it should be exactly that. The only time this wud be ok is if it were birthday money or a gift of some kind.

roarfeckingroarr · 25/09/2022 10:55

I think you should have yours transferred into your account and then put a set amount in the joint account. See how he likes it.

You're completely right here, especially as you're the higher earner and always share the money you earn.

Bournetilly · 25/09/2022 10:55

I was going to say YABU until you said about him saying no to furniture which costs a similar amount. So YANBU, if there is no money as he says for you to get the furniture then there is no money for the PlayStation.

ForfuckssakeEXHstopbeingatwat · 25/09/2022 10:55

Ok the thing that needs to change is either both wages go directly into the joint and equal spends taken out, or neither do and a proportion of your salaries go in to cover bills with the remainder as spends and each of you can choose to prioritize whatever. Maybe a 3rd account for savings / project or something. It's completely unbalanced that yours all goes straight into joint and he chooses what to put in. The fact that you are enabling the overtime by managing the extra childcare makes it doubly irksome. What would actual childcare cost for those hours if you weren't available? If neither you nor the kids will see any benefit from the OT, why should you facilitate it?

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 25/09/2022 10:50

I think people are missing the point. Its not about the playstation.

It's that when you earn extra money, he is equally involved in decisions about how its spent. Its shared equally.

When he earns extra money, he keeps it all to himself, even though that means he would have more. So he is completely going against the grain of how the family finances work, but only when it suits him

People saying 'well if you dont agree to it then maybe he wont do overtime' are also missing the point - the OP doesn't want this. And the OP wouldnt have this attitude towards going for a promotion or something 'well what's the point if it's going on bills and I cant spend it on something just for me'...so why should he?

OP see if you can speak to him. Tell him if that's how he wants to view any extra money that's fine, but you need to agree together what that will mean when you get a promotion or bonus or one of you gets an inheritance. Will he be happy with you swanning off for posh meals or weekends away with mates because you suddenly have more spare cash than him? He surely cant come out and say 'what's yours is mine but what's mine is just mine' and if he does you have bigger issues than a playstation

user1471462115 · 25/09/2022 10:49

Do you see his wage slip, cos I am now wondering how much he keeps for himself.

this is all very suspicious and I would be demanding to see wage slips and corresponding bank transfers to the joint account.

he needs to get his wages paid in direct to the joint account, or you go 5050 on household expenses , and see how he likes that. I get a feeling he owes an awful lot of back contributions.

is he bothered you earn more, bless his little male ego

sofap · 25/09/2022 10:48

OP if you are the higher earner then of course you are expected to provide more for family. That is obvious.

You also said that you could save up but instead you choose to invest. That is what you choose to do with your personal finances. What DP would like to do is buy himself a playstation.

Presumably if he's recently got a promotion, then he's worked hard and deserves a reward?

I can't ever imagine being told that I can't treat myself with my own money.

RhiWrites · 25/09/2022 10:47

I’m with you, OP. You’re not being unreasonable.

ask him if he wants to change the arrangement about how you pay for things jointly. He can keep his money but then you will keep yours and stop paying it into the joint account. Instead you can both find the joint account with £x a month.

he probably doesn’t like that idea but it’s fairer than what’s yours is everyone’s and what’s his is his alone.

Talipesmum · 25/09/2022 10:44

Also I’m absolutely intrigued what you both spend near £500 per month on for yourselves? What comes out of this bucket for you and him?!

Talipesmum · 25/09/2022 10:42

So your current set up is that the personal spending money stays exactly the same each month, and any wage/bonus increases make the joint pot bigger.

He would like some of wage bonus / increases to reflect in his personal spending money. Probably so he feels like he is getting something back for them and so he feels “rewarded”.

If it were you, you’d feel “rewarded” by your extra money earnt going towards improved overall family pot - like you said, communal spending money on holidays, improving the house etc. You feel the benefit and reward for all when you do these things.

But he is saying he would like a different approach - he doesn’t feel as personally “rewarded” by home improvements. He may see them as necessary and appreciate them, but he isn’t perhaps motivated by them in the same way?

You earn more and are the main breadwinner. I think this is significant in your different approach. You always have the opportunity to have more money and have chosen that it goes towards family. But he probably thinks “if she really wanted x she could just get it with her bigger salary”. He earns less, is more reliant on you, and would like to feel independent every now and again, and would like some of the “extra” to go to him rather than joint. Maybe he wouldn’t mind if you did that too. The fact you aren’t personally interested in doing that isn’t particularly relevant. I think because he earns less, the occasional bonus of his creating should affect him more directly if he wants.

But, if it results in him wanting to do a lot more inconvenient overtime, that’s a different conversation, as it affects you directly.

Playstationdilema · 25/09/2022 10:42

gogohmm · 25/09/2022 10:38

The problem is that you have separate accounts, hence it is his money. I always had a joint account, we discussed major purchases and yes we had PlayStations but they would be a family Christmas present

We have a joint account AND personal accounts. My wages is paid into the joint account and x amount a month is transferred to personal.

He's reluctant to get his paint into joint, and I'm now realising it might be so he can keep any extra for himself.

OP posts:
Duolingolater · 25/09/2022 10:42

You need to relook at your finances, I don't have joint just because the thought horrifies me ( exh, abusive incl financially) but you need something that feels fair to you both, what you are currently doing doesn't appear to work for either of you

Shamoo · 25/09/2022 10:41

By the way, the thing you should say to him at this point is that it is fine if he keeps the money for himself and buys a PlayStation, as long as he is in agreement that all bonuses and additional money you ever get (including pay rises) are yours to keep as well (and do what you want with). I suspect if you are the higher earner that will play out much better for you than him in the long term.

somebody2lava · 25/09/2022 10:41

I really don't know why you are getting such a hard time over this op. I totally understand where you are coming from.

You earn more than him and so pay more of the bills, instead of having MINE and YOURS all money in a joint pot so you are equals with equal spare cash and you make joint decisions. But now he's saying that his unexpected bonus overtime (that you actually enabled him to do with childcare) is actually not part of this equation and he doesn't want to follow the normal rules despite him benefiting from them at your expense ( being the higher earner.

I would not be happy with this and I would suggest that any future pay rises of my own would follow the same pattern he wants. I would absolutely let it be known that if he wants to deviate from the way you have always done it, then he will lose out in the long term and YOU will have more cash spare than him. Tell him if he wants a PS5 , Christmas is soon?

Playstationdilema · 25/09/2022 10:40

DomesticShortHair · 25/09/2022 10:37

I’m sorry, I was being a little bit provocative. Of course, you both think you’re right, if you didn’t you wouldn’t be having this issue. For me, I can see merit to both sides of the argument.

To be honest, this sounds like a really good time to have a talk about finances and goals between you, and come up with a strategy that you can both get on board with and support going forward. It’s not really about the PlayStation, or furniture, or home improvements. It’s about a lack of agreement. Use the PlayStation issue as a catalyst to force the wider conversation, and accept that you’ll both have to (and should) compromise on what you think is right, so together you can both do what’s best.

Thank you. This is very sensible and does need to happen.

I struggle to get my point across to him and get upset when we argue...he shouts, and gets very stressed when we discuss money.

OP posts:
billy1966 · 25/09/2022 10:40

OP,

I think a man with children wanting a PS4 is a disaster waiting to happen.

It has the potential to be an area of huge conflict in the time it consumes.

I know, we have one that my son's use at night.

I think you need to rethink your division of finances and I think you need to have a look at him.

He does overtime for himself avoiding sharing the parenting role, and wants a ps4 which will likely be a big time distraction for him.

He sounds like a juvenile arse.

Shamoo · 25/09/2022 10:39

I totally get you OP, and I am not sure what other people are missing.

You both have £x per month spends, which is equal and can be spent on whatever you both want. But this isn’t the money he wants to use for the PS, he wants to use other money that he has from his wages. That money should be going into the shared pot, as is agreed, and then you decide together what that is spent on. Say its £1000 extra he got from the overtime, that could go in the pot and you both get £500 to spend on whatever you fancy because it isn’t needed for anything else. But he shouldn’t just get £1000 for himself.

I actually have the same issue at times with my DP. I am the much higher earner but everything is shared completely, and we are both left with a certain amount (the same) for spends each month. All bonuses I get go into the shared pool (and we always both get a treat from that of an equal sort of value of whatever we fancy). When my DP occasionally gets additional herself, she keeps it and buys herself treats - I see none of it. It irritates my and isn’t right, but I can never be bothered with the consequences of pointing it out. So I let it happen, as we have enough money that it doesn’t stop me doing what I want to do most of the time. She seems to think because she earns less its fair for her to keep it, even though that clearly makes no sense. My bonus may be £40k and hers will be £2k. If I kept mine to myself there would (rightly) be hell to pay, but she keeps all of hers. It is definitely unfair.

gogohmm · 25/09/2022 10:38

The problem is that you have separate accounts, hence it is his money. I always had a joint account, we discussed major purchases and yes we had PlayStations but they would be a family Christmas present

DomesticShortHair · 25/09/2022 10:37

Playstationdilema · 25/09/2022 10:32

Well obviously I think so!

But that's not really the point. I'm not also getting the extra £400 to spend on my priorities. Because he sees the money as his.

I’m sorry, I was being a little bit provocative. Of course, you both think you’re right, if you didn’t you wouldn’t be having this issue. For me, I can see merit to both sides of the argument.

To be honest, this sounds like a really good time to have a talk about finances and goals between you, and come up with a strategy that you can both get on board with and support going forward. It’s not really about the PlayStation, or furniture, or home improvements. It’s about a lack of agreement. Use the PlayStation issue as a catalyst to force the wider conversation, and accept that you’ll both have to (and should) compromise on what you think is right, so together you can both do what’s best.

romdowa · 25/09/2022 10:37

Sounds like you both need to revist the arrangement you have regarding finances. I can't help as everything is family money here. I couldn't be faffing about with house money , his money and my money.

Playstationdilema · 25/09/2022 10:37

Workyticket · 25/09/2022 10:30

I don't get it - if you have close to £500 each spending money he could buy a play station every month

You could buy the furniture you want every month?

Could he buy the PlayStation and the furnishings from his bonus?

He says he can't save up because he doesn't have enough money (cigarettes, nights out - rare but expensive etc).

I could also save up - I do, but also invest my personal money, spend on days out with the kids etc.

I'm not bothered about not getting the furniture particularly. It's not a specific piece, just something that would be useful. We can and do live without it.

OP posts:
LuaDipa · 25/09/2022 10:36

I think your dp is wrong.

I was a sahm for a while but during that time I received a not insubstantial inheritance. I didn’t buy myself anything, it went straight into the family pot. Dh paid for everything else so it would have felt wrong to prioritise treating myself when we needed things as a family.

If this is your dp’s attitude I would let him get the PlayStation but think very carefully about the amount that you are contributing to the family purse. You should be partners and ge us behaving like a spoiled brat.

EL8888 · 25/09/2022 10:34

BadgerLovesMash · 25/09/2022 10:25

If that is his attitude, that his money is his, and yours is for sharing then cut back what you put into the pot and any extra you have keep for yourself. He can't have it both ways, either you share finances or you don't.

This! He definitely wants of both ways and that’s not fair

lannistunut · 25/09/2022 10:32

There is actually a specific piece of furniture I've wanted to buy for 2 years (similar value to playstation) and his answer is always no, its not the right time, we don't have the money etc. This is the key bit of the OP, if he has historically said no, he can't expect the answer to be yes now?

But maybe you need a general chat to agree the basic principles.

Playstationdilema · 25/09/2022 10:32

DomesticShortHair · 25/09/2022 10:28

But yours are right?

Well obviously I think so!

But that's not really the point. I'm not also getting the extra £400 to spend on my priorities. Because he sees the money as his.

OP posts: