Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH wants to buy PlayStation

166 replies

Playstationdilema · 25/09/2022 09:51

A bit of background....

We share our finances, both work full time, with each of us having an equal amount of spending money each month.

He's recently had a nice payrise, and was already annoyed that he didn't see any extra personal money out of it (bills). We're comfortable enough, and our personal spending money is an ok amount. What we choose to do with it is our own business.

He has some extra money in his account currently from overtime (wages still paid into his personal account, then transfers x amount into the joint account). He wants to buy a PlayStation, and I'm annoyed that he's viewing this money as his and not family money.

We're currently not communicating, which is making me doubt myself. He's usually quick to apologise when he thinks he's wrong, but he's holding out with this one.

It's not about the PlayStation. It's about how he views this money as his.

And in case it makes a difference (I know it will to some). I am, and always have been the higher earner. Any payrises etc I've had have not been treated as personal money, they are family money and decisions are made accordingly.
I'm not bitter about this...or at least I wasn't until he suddenly had extra money and acting like I'm being unreasonable.

There is actually a specific piece of furniture I've wanted to buy for 2 years (similar value to playstation) and his answer is always no, its not the right time, we don't have the money etc.

There's a lot we need to do in the house, and a playstation is certainly not a priority in my mind.

From his point of view 'he' doesnt have extra money very often and wont have this opportunity again.

So...AIBU?

OP posts:
Playstationdilema · 25/09/2022 11:45

OK, so I think I need to say to him...

We need to discuss how we manage our finances. Do you want to
-each cover 50% of bills, and anything else is our personal money
-each pay in a percentage of the bills based on our incomes and everything else is our personal money
-each pay our wages into the joint account and transfer x amount each every money into our personal accounts (and if there's extra it's split equally).

Difficult conversations. I'm a planner, I know to the penny how much each bill is and how much we have left over. He has access to the same info but gets stressed as soon as money is brought up.

OP posts:
Shamoo · 25/09/2022 11:44

Playstationdilema · 25/09/2022 11:34

I'm not sure how I would instigate this?

Get my wages paid into personal account and only transfer 50% of the bills to joint? If he transferred 50% of the bills he'd be left with no personal spending money but I'd have loads.

If we did it on percentage...I'd have more personal spending than he does, but he'd still have some...less than he does now.
Is that OK? Won't be OK with him.

The problem I have with this second option, apart from the inevitable arguments. We've spent 8 years with me being the higher earner and him benefitting from that, and now I'm tied to a job with little chance of promotion or pay increases (largely because I'm default parent and need to keep flexibility - a whole different argument) while he is free to pursue any promotion or overtime offered without thinking about how it impacts childcare. Eventually his income will be higher than mine, so he's benefitted from me having a higher salary while his is lower, but I wouldn't see the same benefit.

OP, the more you share the more it becomes clear that you have bigger issues in your marriage than the fact he wants to buy a PS from his overtime payment.

Why are you telling yourself it would be unfair for you to leave him with less spends than you have when that is what he is clearly happy to do to you?

And why are you accepting a position where you have to be default carer for your children while he takes any overtime he fancies?

You need to be having a very serious conversation with him about respect and fairness and if he won’t have it, you really need to be considering how to move forward (and making sure you are saving as much money as you can now before he becomes the higher earner and really fucks you over).

shreddednips · 25/09/2022 11:41

Tricky one. It depends on your overall financial situation I think. I would be annoyed if DH got a pay rise and wanted to buy a PlayStation because I've financially supported him for a long time while he retrained and also do the lion's share of the childcare as his course is demanding. I have little money to spend on myself and would expect him to add any extra money to the family pot to finally take some pressure off me.

We get the same amount of personal spending money though so any increase in his pay would increase both our available money by an equal amount- so I'd be perfectly happy for him to do exactly what I would have to do if I wanted a big, non-essential item and save for it. Everything is equal regardless of who earns what in our household so I would be unreasonable to feel I had any say over his personal money.

If you're financially comfortable then I would be happy for him to buy the PlayStation on the proviso that you had the same freedom to buy something you want (the furniture.) If he isn't happy for you to veto his spending, he shouldn't feel he has the right to veto yours.

Shamoo · 25/09/2022 11:40

mountainsunsets · 25/09/2022 11:32

Honestly OP, the way you do your finances is perfectly common, I know plenty of people who do it like this (it is often, in fact, recommended on MN by people).

Really? I've never seen anyone recommend that one person's salary goes into the joint account and the other persons' goes into their own personal account.

Presumably you know exactly what I mean, which is the concept that all money is shared other than a certain agreed amount which is kept by each person as spends is a perfectly legitimate approach to money.

If that is the agreed approach to finances and both people can be trusted, it doesn’t matter which account the money is initially paid into, because it should all just be sorted through bank transfers so that the money all ends up in the right place.

Presumably you also read the rest of my post, which said that the issue is that he isn’t actually applying that set of rules because he won’t pay it into the joint account and is keeping more than the agreed amount of money for himself.

mountainsunsets · 25/09/2022 11:37

Playstationdilema · 25/09/2022 11:34

I'm not sure how I would instigate this?

Get my wages paid into personal account and only transfer 50% of the bills to joint? If he transferred 50% of the bills he'd be left with no personal spending money but I'd have loads.

If we did it on percentage...I'd have more personal spending than he does, but he'd still have some...less than he does now.
Is that OK? Won't be OK with him.

The problem I have with this second option, apart from the inevitable arguments. We've spent 8 years with me being the higher earner and him benefitting from that, and now I'm tied to a job with little chance of promotion or pay increases (largely because I'm default parent and need to keep flexibility - a whole different argument) while he is free to pursue any promotion or overtime offered without thinking about how it impacts childcare. Eventually his income will be higher than mine, so he's benefitted from me having a higher salary while his is lower, but I wouldn't see the same benefit.

Your entire financial set-up is wrong - that's why you're arguing.

Either put ALL money into one account and transfer equal amounts into your personal accounts for spends/fun money, or put both your salaries into individual accounts and transfer set percentages/amounts each month to leave you with a set amount for spends/fun money.

I wouldn't ask his permission or anything - just do it. If it's okay for him to have his salary in a personal account, it's okay for you to do the same.

LifeIsaRollerCoaster1 · 25/09/2022 11:37

So you have your money paid directly into a joint account and take your "pocket money" out and put it into another account. He pays his money into his own account and then pays money into the joint account to cover bills. You need to both either take a set amount out for yourself or pay a set amount into the joint account. You are doing y different things and you are resenting him for ending up with more money. I'd find all this just too much like hard work. Why don't you just have your wages paid into your account and pay into the main account, then you can't be petty as you'll have more money too.

misskatamari · 25/09/2022 11:37

You're not being unreasonable. I was going to say you were at first, but reading all your responses - he's taking the piss!

He needs to get his wages paid into the joint account. Like YOU do! And then get his spends sent to his personal account. It's the only fair way to deal with this.

Playstationdilema · 25/09/2022 11:34

Heyahun · 25/09/2022 11:27

So stop making all your extra money family money then and keep some for yourself

I'm not sure how I would instigate this?

Get my wages paid into personal account and only transfer 50% of the bills to joint? If he transferred 50% of the bills he'd be left with no personal spending money but I'd have loads.

If we did it on percentage...I'd have more personal spending than he does, but he'd still have some...less than he does now.
Is that OK? Won't be OK with him.

The problem I have with this second option, apart from the inevitable arguments. We've spent 8 years with me being the higher earner and him benefitting from that, and now I'm tied to a job with little chance of promotion or pay increases (largely because I'm default parent and need to keep flexibility - a whole different argument) while he is free to pursue any promotion or overtime offered without thinking about how it impacts childcare. Eventually his income will be higher than mine, so he's benefitted from me having a higher salary while his is lower, but I wouldn't see the same benefit.

OP posts:
mountainsunsets · 25/09/2022 11:32

Honestly OP, the way you do your finances is perfectly common, I know plenty of people who do it like this (it is often, in fact, recommended on MN by people).

Really? I've never seen anyone recommend that one person's salary goes into the joint account and the other persons' goes into their own personal account.

mountainsunsets · 25/09/2022 11:31

Playstationdilema · 25/09/2022 11:22

The majority of people voting that I'm unreasonable...are you doing this understanding that it's not his personal spending money that I'm contesting.

It's what is considered family money - or is considered family money when it's my wages.

Are you voting that way because you don't agree with the way we split finances (x amount of personal money each month, the rest is family money)? Or because you think it's fair that my extra money is family money but his extra money is his??

I think you're being unreasonable and silly to put all your wages into a joint account when he doesn't do the same thing. It's like you're deliberately making life harder for yourself.

Just get your salary paid into your account, transfer a set amount for bills and family spends, and spend the rest on whatever you like. He can do the same and buy the Playstation from his leftovers, and you can buy new furniture with yours if that's what you want to do.

Shamoo · 25/09/2022 11:30

Honestly OP, the way you do your finances is perfectly common, I know plenty of people who do it like this (it is often, in fact, recommended on MN by people).

You expecting his additional money to be shared when your is, is also perfectly reasonable.

There is nothing in your set up or position that is inherently unreasonable.

The issue is that he doesn’t actually want to play by the rules you have set as a family. He doesn’t pay his money into the joint account and you now know he is keeping additional for himself (I suspect this wont be the first time), while expecting you to put yours in the joint account and share any additional.

So take the discussion away from the PS and turn it into one about what the family approach to finances should be. If he wants it the way he is currently operating that is also fine and a legitimate way of managing money, but the consequence is that you move your money to your own account and only put in a set amount each month and keep the rest for you. He will lose out this way, and you will benefit, but it is also a perfectly legitimate approach.

BUT if you do this, then the amount that you both put in has to cover ALL family expenses, including reasonable amounts for holidays, school uniform etc. Otherwise you will just end up paying for that out of your money.

Jake1248 · 25/09/2022 11:29

We all need our own time. We don't share our money. I pay for food shopping, my way of paying for something. Once that is done, DH pays for it after.

If I want something, I save up for it, I have an excel spreadsheet of my money so I can keep track.

I pay for holidays, spending money also.

Heyahun · 25/09/2022 11:27

So stop making all your extra money family money then and keep some for yourself

Playstationdilema · 25/09/2022 11:26

LifeIsaRollerCoaster1 · 25/09/2022 11:21

You sound controlling to be honest. Either just share all your money or pay a set amount into a shared account. You are basically paying a set amount into an account but now he has a bit extra you want everything to be shared. You can't have it both ways and stomping your feet that you want to buy something else with the money he has sounds quite childish. He's paid his money to cover bill so the rest is his, he wants a PlayStation so he can buy a PlayStation, he's an adult.

We share all our money, our PlayStation broke so my husband replaced it, he didn't even mention it. We use it for the TV to hook it up to the Internet (TV is a few years old) I really didn't care he'd replaced it. He doesn't splash out on things generally, nor do I so if one of us buys something big there's no fallouts it just means we really wanted whatever it was. There's complete trust on both sides so money can be shared. I earn slightly more than my husband, it isn't even a thing, the money is our money, we've never fallen out over money in the 18 years we've been together. I'd be pretty pissed off if my husband was dictating to me what I can and can't have like I was a child besides.

My money is shared, his is his and if I contest this I'm controlling?

I didn't say I want to buy something else. I don't want to buy the furniture...it was an example of a similar situation where we have decided together what joint money is/isn't spent on.

OP posts:
rwalker · 25/09/2022 11:24

All sounds very hard work life’s to short
get the ps
as for the furniture my guess is he doesn’t like and he’s using the money as an excuse
rather than stand up to you

Playstationdilema · 25/09/2022 11:22

The majority of people voting that I'm unreasonable...are you doing this understanding that it's not his personal spending money that I'm contesting.

It's what is considered family money - or is considered family money when it's my wages.

Are you voting that way because you don't agree with the way we split finances (x amount of personal money each month, the rest is family money)? Or because you think it's fair that my extra money is family money but his extra money is his??

OP posts:
LifeIsaRollerCoaster1 · 25/09/2022 11:21

You sound controlling to be honest. Either just share all your money or pay a set amount into a shared account. You are basically paying a set amount into an account but now he has a bit extra you want everything to be shared. You can't have it both ways and stomping your feet that you want to buy something else with the money he has sounds quite childish. He's paid his money to cover bill so the rest is his, he wants a PlayStation so he can buy a PlayStation, he's an adult.

We share all our money, our PlayStation broke so my husband replaced it, he didn't even mention it. We use it for the TV to hook it up to the Internet (TV is a few years old) I really didn't care he'd replaced it. He doesn't splash out on things generally, nor do I so if one of us buys something big there's no fallouts it just means we really wanted whatever it was. There's complete trust on both sides so money can be shared. I earn slightly more than my husband, it isn't even a thing, the money is our money, we've never fallen out over money in the 18 years we've been together. I'd be pretty pissed off if my husband was dictating to me what I can and can't have like I was a child besides.

Crunchymum · 25/09/2022 11:20

I'd be more concerned about where the PS is going to fit into family life?

#bitterexperience

billy1966 · 25/09/2022 11:20

I think his refusing to pay his salary into the joint account is a red flag.

Start paying yours into your own account and only match what he pays in.

He clearly wants two sets of rules.

He shouts you down when you try to discuss it?

This is to shut you down.

You are being very very naive and need to protect yourself.

Stage one is moving your salary into your own account, reduce what you pay in and build a contingency fund for you and your children.

I bet you are going to need it.

RoachTheHorse · 25/09/2022 11:16

gamerchick · 25/09/2022 11:15

There is actually a specific piece of furniture I've wanted to buy for 2 years (similar value to playstation) and his answer is always no, its not the right time, we don't have the money etc

The answer to your problem lies right in there. Sorted.

I was just going to say this. Yeah he gets the PlayStation. You get the furniture. Everyone wins!

gamerchick · 25/09/2022 11:15

There is actually a specific piece of furniture I've wanted to buy for 2 years (similar value to playstation) and his answer is always no, its not the right time, we don't have the money etc

The answer to your problem lies right in there. Sorted.

mountainsunsets · 25/09/2022 11:12

It's your financial set-up that's the problem here. You have one salary going into the joint account, one into a personal account so of course there's confusion.

Either both salaries get paid into the joint account and personal spends/savings are transferred out, or both salaries are paid into personal accounts, and a set amount/percentage is transferred to the joint account for bills.

In your shoes, I would get my salary paid into my own account and just transfer a set amount over each month to cover your share of the bills and savings. Whatever is left, spend on what you want - furniture in your case, and the Playstation in his case.

Topgub · 25/09/2022 11:10

You obvneed to adjust how you split the finances

At the moment whats yours is his but what's his is his.

He can't have it both ways

Heyahun · 25/09/2022 11:04

We just get paid into our own accounts and then we both transfer our half of the bills / mortgage into the joint account (he pays more in than me as he earns more)

then we have a savings account and I put 200 in that a month and he puts 300! That’s for holidays/house stuff etc

then we both have money left to do whatever we want with it.

couldn’t be dealing with this having to ask can I get something it’s ridiculous - you are both adults

Playstationdilema · 25/09/2022 11:02

sofap · 25/09/2022 10:48

OP if you are the higher earner then of course you are expected to provide more for family. That is obvious.

You also said that you could save up but instead you choose to invest. That is what you choose to do with your personal finances. What DP would like to do is buy himself a playstation.

Presumably if he's recently got a promotion, then he's worked hard and deserves a reward?

I can't ever imagine being told that I can't treat myself with my own money.

I'm repeating myself...but it's not his personal money we're talking about.

It's what would usually be seen as joint money (if it was part of my wages), in addition to his personal spending.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread