Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask you to think twice about eating chicken regularly

640 replies

Tigofigo · 25/09/2022 09:03

...it's just not sustainable for us to consume as much as we do.

Intensive chicken farming is polluting and destroying our rivers and also potentially causing breathing difficulties and lung issues in those who live near farms spraying chicken / other animal manure as fertilizer.

Really worrying too, at a time when govt are ripping up EU regs on environmental laws that will further destroy our rivers and the animals, plants and people that rely on them (along with the shit already pumped into them...).

www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/sep/25/chicken-farm-giant-linked-to-river-wye-decline-was-sued-over-water-blight-in-us

www.google.com/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/environment/2019/jan/14/muck-spreading-could-be-banned-to-reduce-air-pollution

inews.co.uk/news/brexit-bonfire-environment-regulations-otters-dolphins-birds-conservationists-1875799

OP posts:
user29 · 25/09/2022 14:01

Tigofigo · 25/09/2022 11:17

Ideally, perhaps. But it's going to be hard to get most people to stop eating meat altogether. Getting everyone to eat less and better feels more realistic.

I can buy a whole, locally organically farmed small chicken from a small traceable farm I have researched from a brilliant butcher near me. They're about £18. The same size chicken in Sainsbury's or Waitrose is about £3/4.

As a result, chicken is a treat for my kids once every six weeks or so. They'll then have chicken for 2/3 meals.

£18 for a chicken! Everyone reading this is going to think you are a gullible fool. Which doesn't exactly help your cause!

Dreamwhisper · 25/09/2022 13:59

Our intelligence allowed us to escape the usual barriers nature imposes on populations and grow far beyond what is naturally sustainable or desirable. As such, we should have been using our intelligence to find ways to feed the population sustainably and in balance with nature. Instead we have exploited and decimated the planet to indulge a small portion of the global population's taste preferences, to the detriment of both the planet and developing countries

Literally this. I'm so sick of people not being able to see how abnormal everything we do is, and realise if we're smart enough to do what we've done already, we're smart enough to fix it.

YellowTreeHouse · 25/09/2022 13:59

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 25/09/2022 13:28

Why do you think that?

What is it specifically that makes you think a human life is more valuable to nature than an animal life?

We've put ourselves up on a pedestal because we are self-aware and intelligent. Yet rather than use that intelligence to ensure the planet (the only place that we can physically exist) and all of its inhabitants are protected and cared for we use it to destroy and justify abuse.

The majority of humans are an absolute cancer on the Earth and the sooner we face natural correction the better. It's just a shame that those of us who actually care will be impacted as much as those who don't give a fuck.

Oh don’t be so ridiculous.

Humans > animals. It’s really that simple and if you can’t see that I think something’s gone really wrong somewhere in your education.

Dreamwhisper · 25/09/2022 13:57

I do really hate how people are so callous towards these billions of poor animals. It's very transparent that your faux ease and your derisiveness of vegan alternatives are a defence mechanism because you know it's shit.

I'm not even a vegan but I know I should be. I'm not going to pretend to justify why I'm not vegan though and pretend it's all okay. It's laziness/convenience/affordability/enjoyment of meat products that stop me being vegan, but endeavour to go plant based wherever I can and plan to gradually increase this.

There are so so many ways to get protein in a human diet that do not require meat, and plenty of them require no animal products at all.

As with so many things, the problem is that most people are safely sheltered away from the carnage that is the animal farming industry. If we had to go to the abattoirs' to buy our meat and see the way the animals suffer in life and in death, I am sure 90% of people would swear off meat. And that would be enough.

I don't even have a problem with eating meat in principle. But as usual humans have found a way to make a natural practice a fucking carnival of horror and induce suffering on a massive scale. It's appalling. It's hard to pay £18 a chicken the same way it's hard to pay £15 a t shirt you could get from primark for £3 as long as there's a bit of child labour involved to cut costs..

We need to wake up and realise that the rate at which we consume things is simply, unsustainable in the most basic definition of the word.

bellac11 · 25/09/2022 13:57

Musti · 25/09/2022 13:53

Much cheaper to eat a vegan diet.

Can you set out a weekly shop?

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 25/09/2022 13:57

bellac11 · 25/09/2022 13:25

I wasnt referring to the UK, it was a theoretical point about wild animals

And yes of course it is ok for humans to eat animals, we are part of the food chain and have been since humans and humanoids evolved

Not sure where mistreatment of children come into it.

You tried to justify the mistreatment of animals by humans based on the fact some animals die in gruesome ways in the wild.

As you alluded to humans are part of the natural world so I was asking if, based on that logic, you find it justifiable to harm humans because they also die in gruesome ways in the "wild".

I suspect your answer is "no" and that you are similar to so many other people who consider humans to be a special case, that exists both outside and inside of nature depending on the point you want to make.

Your comment about humans evolving as part of the food chain and eat meat is a perfect illustration if this.

You claim it is OK to eat meat because we evolved to be part of the food chain, fine. But we didn't evolve to have meat at every meal or have a choice of pork, chicken, fish, beef, lamb, venison, etc available to us 365 days a year.

Our intelligence allowed us to escape the usual barriers nature imposes on populations and grow far beyond what is naturally sustainable or desirable. As such, we should have been using our intelligence to find ways to feed the population sustainably and in balance with nature. Instead we have exploited and decimated the planet to indulge a small portion of the global population's taste preferences, to the detriment of both the planet and developing countries.

If you were advocating for a return to more natural ways of raising and consuming meat I'd agree with people eating meat, if you want to hunt, kill and clean your meat fine by me (so long as it didn’t result in the decline of the species you wanted to eat). But justifying industrial scale animal agriculture on the basis that "humans evolved to eat meat" is just wrong.

Bacibaci · 25/09/2022 13:56

I still eat meat but I have cut way down. I eat too much dairy though.

Musti · 25/09/2022 13:55

BerriesOnTop · 25/09/2022 13:52

What is it specifically that makes you think a human life is more valuable to nature than an animal life?

Well yeah nature doesn’t give a fuck but I can’t understand people who don’t value themselves over animals. Or understand there is a hierarchy of life that we place value on accordingly. Like, a dog obviously has more value to humans than cockroaches and we act accordingly.

Yet rather than use that intelligence to ensure the planet (the only place that we can physically exist) and all of its inhabitants are protected and cared for we use it to destroy and justify abuse

Better now than literally any point in human history so don’t know what you are on about. As for animals, we have concepts like animal welfare that are very new but there. I dare say animals don’t have this concept at all 😆

The majority of humans are an absolute cancer on the Earth and the sooner we face natural correction the better

Would you say that about all living things on this planet? That all living things are cancer on the planet? Maybe you would 🤔

It's just a shame that those of us who actually care will be impacted as much as those who don't give a fuck

You won’t be impacted quite as much as you think.

Have a look at the latest IPCC report and get scared.

Scientists all over the world agree. And you only have to look at the extreme weather events caused by man that are happening due to climate change of which animal production is a big part. But the biggest is fossil fuels.

Bacibaci · 25/09/2022 13:54

That’s just a typically lazy position that ‘progressives’ take because they are not smart enough to invent their way out of a problem.

Condescending and sneery.

user29 · 25/09/2022 13:54

Tigofigo · 25/09/2022 11:17

Ideally, perhaps. But it's going to be hard to get most people to stop eating meat altogether. Getting everyone to eat less and better feels more realistic.

I can buy a whole, locally organically farmed small chicken from a small traceable farm I have researched from a brilliant butcher near me. They're about £18. The same size chicken in Sainsbury's or Waitrose is about £3/4.

As a result, chicken is a treat for my kids once every six weeks or so. They'll then have chicken for 2/3 meals.

You do you.stop preaching and respect o t her people's rights to make their own decisions

Musti · 25/09/2022 13:53

MessyBunPersonified · 25/09/2022 13:45

Morals are great if you can afford to have them.

Unfortunately I can't.

Much cheaper to eat a vegan diet.

BerriesOnTop · 25/09/2022 13:52

What is it specifically that makes you think a human life is more valuable to nature than an animal life?

Well yeah nature doesn’t give a fuck but I can’t understand people who don’t value themselves over animals. Or understand there is a hierarchy of life that we place value on accordingly. Like, a dog obviously has more value to humans than cockroaches and we act accordingly.

Yet rather than use that intelligence to ensure the planet (the only place that we can physically exist) and all of its inhabitants are protected and cared for we use it to destroy and justify abuse

Better now than literally any point in human history so don’t know what you are on about. As for animals, we have concepts like animal welfare that are very new but there. I dare say animals don’t have this concept at all 😆

The majority of humans are an absolute cancer on the Earth and the sooner we face natural correction the better

Would you say that about all living things on this planet? That all living things are cancer on the planet? Maybe you would 🤔

It's just a shame that those of us who actually care will be impacted as much as those who don't give a fuck

You won’t be impacted quite as much as you think.

user7845209 · 25/09/2022 13:49

It not just not eating meat though it's that you have to have the vegan version of everything and they are always more expensive so if you are out and buying ice creams for the family the vegan version if you can get it are more expensive and stuff like that, it's a bit like when people have to eat gluten free but that unfortunately isn't a choice like being vegan is.

fyn · 25/09/2022 13:48

YABU. Chicken is the most efficient form of animal protein for food/resources input to output. It’s 1.6kg of feed to 1kg chicken deadweight.

Dunnoburt · 25/09/2022 13:48

As a keen angler you've only got to look at the state of the river Wye......YANBU

MessyBunPersonified · 25/09/2022 13:45

Morals are great if you can afford to have them.

Unfortunately I can't.

tedgran · 25/09/2022 13:43

I do eat chicken, but only buy free range. If we have a takeaway I only have lamb.

lemons44 · 25/09/2022 13:41

@Pinkpeony2 😂😂

Pinkpeony2 · 25/09/2022 13:39

Sounds like you have a slave locked up in the cellar.

Pinkpeony2 · 25/09/2022 13:39

scrufffy · 25/09/2022 11:49

My person can't have soya. We can't have nuts in the house. Can't have dairy (and the fake cheese makes them vomit). Can't have anything with gluten. Shellfish is off the table and they aren't keen on fish.

I'm sticking with chicken.

Your ‘person’ wtf is that?

user7845209 · 25/09/2022 13:35

Yes lamb is really expensive and very small portions, we eat it quite a bit as there are only two of us but to feed a family it would cost loads. I don't really like any of the other meat but love lamb

Stopsnowing · 25/09/2022 13:35

Please send along links to protein rich veggie cheap easy to prepare meals that kids will eat

bellac11 · 25/09/2022 13:35

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 25/09/2022 13:28

Why do you think that?

What is it specifically that makes you think a human life is more valuable to nature than an animal life?

We've put ourselves up on a pedestal because we are self-aware and intelligent. Yet rather than use that intelligence to ensure the planet (the only place that we can physically exist) and all of its inhabitants are protected and cared for we use it to destroy and justify abuse.

The majority of humans are an absolute cancer on the Earth and the sooner we face natural correction the better. It's just a shame that those of us who actually care will be impacted as much as those who don't give a fuck.

We are top of the food chain, its just the way it is. Humans may well die out, we may not, we're just another animal but we're top of the food chain.

If we werent here it would probably be other carnivores, probably different ones in different regions.

RainingRubies · 25/09/2022 13:33

Lots of people have b12 deficiency. I know several who have to have injections of it. I dont think theyre even vegetarians! Probably a lot of people should take supplements. Its quite handy now, as lots of people have inadequate diets.

For some people that is about diet, but most people who have B12 injections have them because of pernicious anaemia which is caused by the body being able to process B12 from food, so diet makes no difference to it.

bellac11 · 25/09/2022 13:33

I dont know why lamb is so expensive. Its my favourite meat. I dont eat pork (generally speaking), I dont like chicken that much and out of beef and lamb I love lamb more, but it doesn thalf cost a lot!