Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask you to think twice about eating chicken regularly

640 replies

Tigofigo · 25/09/2022 09:03

...it's just not sustainable for us to consume as much as we do.

Intensive chicken farming is polluting and destroying our rivers and also potentially causing breathing difficulties and lung issues in those who live near farms spraying chicken / other animal manure as fertilizer.

Really worrying too, at a time when govt are ripping up EU regs on environmental laws that will further destroy our rivers and the animals, plants and people that rely on them (along with the shit already pumped into them...).

www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/sep/25/chicken-farm-giant-linked-to-river-wye-decline-was-sued-over-water-blight-in-us

www.google.com/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/environment/2019/jan/14/muck-spreading-could-be-banned-to-reduce-air-pollution

inews.co.uk/news/brexit-bonfire-environment-regulations-otters-dolphins-birds-conservationists-1875799

OP posts:
AclowncalledAlice · 25/09/2022 15:32

Well you can ask but chicken is the only meat I eat so I shall be neither cutting down, nor giving it up. Sorry OP.

PreferAnimals · 25/09/2022 15:30

Hubby and I became veggie 5 years ago. Next step will be vegan. The planet just can't sustain the amount of meat humans eat. Just my opinion, but I thunk a lot of people just prefer to bury their heads in the sand and don't care. Sad really.

user6363 · 25/09/2022 15:28

OP, if you bring up anything to do with people’s meat intake being an issue so many people will just shut down and get defensive. There’s always a reason why they absolutely can’t make any change at all.

I recognise that food is a sensitive topic for people and I’ve never bothered trying to change anyone’s mind, personally. I would say people don’t understand that vegan substitutes can be eaten sparingly, if at all… I eat vegan chicken substitutes maybe twice a month. I appreciate people don’t necessarily like a diet of pulses, tofu, falafels etc (I really do get that), but being vegan doesn’t mean eating processed substitutes all the time.

I’m coeliac so being vegan too is hard but doable. But anyway, reducing your meat intake is super easy for most people, it really doesn’t have to be all or nothing.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 25/09/2022 15:25

bellac11 · 25/09/2022 14:01

I didnt justify mistreatment, I compared your comment of a sheep having an early death (in your view) to a sheep having an early death at the hands/paws of its main predator.

I dont view the short lives of animals that we eat as mistreatment in and of itself

And yes we have evolved to eat meat when we want because we have farmed it, evolution hasnt ended, we are still evolving, farming was part of that.

Personally I dont eat huge quantities of meat, unfortunately my nemesis is cheese which of course is also part of animal husbandry, but industrial scale animal agriculture isnt 'wrong' any more than industrial scale agriculture of anything is wrong. They are neither right nor wrong.

But the animals that are raised as part of an industrial farming system ARE mistreated. You cannot slaughter animals on an industrial scale humanely.

Take pigs for example, 90% of pigs sent to slaughter in the UK are put into gas chambers and gassed unconscious. When the Nazis did that to humans it was considered one of the worst atrocities in history, but its a "humane" way to kill pigs. It is not, it is fucking sick and despicable.

You can Google "pigs being gassed" and find hundreds of recordings of them screaming and thrasing in absolutely terror during this process but I guarantee most won't because they want to pretend it's ok.

Isaidnoalready · 25/09/2022 15:24

Don't quote American statistics and then bang on about brexit we are not all in America and we don't all have the same welfare standards as America

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 25/09/2022 15:12

@BerriesOnTop

Well yeah nature doesn’t give a fuck but I can’t understand people who don’t value themselves over animals. Or understand there is a hierarchy of life that we place value on accordingly. Like, a dog obviously has more value to humans than cockroaches and we act accordingly.

Because a human is not intrinsically more valuable to the planet than an animal, except in the minds of many humans. You may consider yourself special but you are not. I do not believe that just because I am human I should have the right to abuse or support the abuse of other animals for my pleasure.

You claim go understand their is a hierarchy of life based on value but I'm not sure that you do, as if you did you would understand the point I am making.

Out of interest why do you think a dog is more valuable to humans than a cockroach? Surely this would depend on the situation. For companionship sure a dog is more valuable but, cockroaches help pollinate plants in the wild and breakdown decaying matter into nutrient rich soil. Scientists have also taken inspiration from the mechanics of cockroach legs when developing prosthetics and are looking at how their naturally produced antibodies could be used to fight against antibiotic resistant viruses.

Better now than literally any point in human history so don’t know what you are on about. As for animals, we have concepts like animal welfare that are very new but there. I dare say animals don’t have this concept at all 😆

It's not better now than at any point in human history at all. Up until the industrial revolution human population was relatively stable with a population growth rate around 0.02%. That jumped to 0.3% on the back of the revolution and continued to rise to a peak of 2% in the 1970s (we're now around 1.1%). That explosion in population has meant we have had to massively increase our exploitation of the Earth and there is no plausible way you can consider this to be "best" the relationship between humans and the Earth has ever been.

Would you say that about all living things on this planet? That all living things are cancer on the planet? Maybe you would 🤔

No, because most other living things live in balance with the Earth and aren't actively exploiting the planet to the detriment of everything else that lives here. Current extinction rates are between 1,000-10,000 times higher than the background extintion rates we would expect to see naturally, with human activity being the primary (and pretty much only) driver.

You won’t be impacted quite as much as you think.

I should be dead before the impacts are acutely felt at a UK level but unfortunately they're already happening in many places around the world. The increase in extreme weather events we are seeing including drought, flooding, storms, fires, intense rain, temperature extremes, etc are all happening with a 1.1 degree rise in GMST and were currently on course for a 2.9 degree rise by 2050. You think brexit or covid has caused issues with supply chains? Wait until billions if people are displaced and billions of acres of food producing land suffer crop failures.

blackheartsgirl · 25/09/2022 15:08

I thought eating red meat contributes to the risk of bowel cancer and all that. Or is that processed meat, sausages, bacon etc?

bellac11 · 25/09/2022 15:07

Musti · 25/09/2022 14:36

Bibimbap, fabada asturiana- just Google vegan versions and the gousto one is vegetable noodles with silky cashew nut sauce.

So without knowing the names or exact recipes, I seem to be cooking things like this, a version of them and this is what Ive become bored with

Veggie stews for want of a better name. I tend to throw things together rather than follow recipes so you find your way to putting thigs like this together with various condiments and ingredients and various veg. Turns out they've all got a name!!

I dont find them hugely satisifying after a while to be honest. Bean stews Im sick to death of and I dont really enjoy rice all that well.

I like thai flavours and like putting nuts in things.

midsomermurderess · 25/09/2022 15:07

I find this utterly presumptuous, posters like you jumping in your soap boxes. People will make their own choices, whether you approve or not.

vodkaredbullgirl · 25/09/2022 15:02

user29 · 25/09/2022 14:01

£18 for a chicken! Everyone reading this is going to think you are a gullible fool. Which doesn't exactly help your cause!

I've just been to the local farm shop, medium chicken cost me £8.99, couldn't see any chickens costing £18.

LadyMaid · 25/09/2022 14:52

Chicken parmesan with thick cut chips and a green salad. Yum.

kateandme · 25/09/2022 14:46

Sillysop92 · 25/09/2022 11:38

My roast chicken is about to be cooked! It will be delicious and far better than any over-processed vegan substitutes. Served with lovely veggies, stuffing and gravy and maybe some sausages that need using up. Chicken fajitas for tea tomorrow!

Sounds perfect
i might have to include some demon white bread chicken sandwiches there too!

Meili04 · 25/09/2022 14:45

I'm on a really restricted diet (medical issues ) a vegan diet would leave me more malnourished. I eat small amounts so I need protein and fat rich foods.

sunshineandsuddenshowers · 25/09/2022 14:38

@Eeksteek is right:

”Chicken was historically a middle income food, precisely because it’s expensive. Historically, the poor are very little meat at all. I don’t say we should go back to that, or that it’s right, but meat is affordable at all for many people (and certainly at the frequency it’s consumed now) only because the barbaric unsustainable factory farming has artificially depressed the price. Just as travel is only accessible to many people because of the low and unsustainable price and practice of burning oil. There’s no values attached to those statements. It’s nothing to do with class. It just can’t last forever. “

It can’t last. That’s the point. And it is only possible now because environmental destruction is free…

Musti · 25/09/2022 14:36

bellac11 · 25/09/2022 14:27

Thanks the top one is something I have cooked before, didnt know it was an actual recipe!! Or had a name

Your others come up with page not found

Bibimbap, fabada asturiana- just Google vegan versions and the gousto one is vegetable noodles with silky cashew nut sauce.

Pengwinn · 25/09/2022 14:35

Fluffyfluffflufffluff · 25/09/2022 14:32

Oh aye, rice, beans and veg. Famously extortionate.

Yes not sure where the myth that eating a veggie or vegan diet is more expensive. Bizarre. Sure its good to be more aware perhaps of nutrition and ensuring you get x, y and z in your diet, but it's not like all omnivores have balanced diets containing everything our body needs just because they eat meat.

Orangesare · 25/09/2022 14:34

Eat lamb. Order it direct from a small producer preferably someone who keeps rare breeds. If they say I haven’t got any now but I’m taking orders for x date all the better as they are not using grain feed only grass.
You should be able to choose how uou want the cuts too.
If you like chicken try partridge when it’s in season, it’s had a much nicer life than a chicken and has made a major contribution to the rural economy.

BotterMon · 25/09/2022 14:34

I only buy local farm meat directly including chicken. And I have my own chickens for eggs.
Far better to eat less meat but buy better quality. I rarely eat meat at restaurants unless source is known.
Just ordered 1/2 a lamb and some beef for the freezer. By doing this we use all the meat rather than just the common cuts and anything we don't like, the dogs devour.
Living rurally and knowing local farmers we're not ripped off. £18 for a chicken?!

Pengwinn · 25/09/2022 14:33

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 25/09/2022 14:26

You haven't really answered why though.

Laws are designed by and for humans so it's not a great metric for value. In fact laws are more often designed by and for a paricular society so it's an even worse metric than first thought.

For example, 100 years ago in the west the life of a straight white man would have been considered more valuable than that of a women, homosexual or black man (and you could argue that this is still the case in many societies across the world) using that metric. But I'd hope must of us would argue that that was/is wrong.

So no, laws aren't a good indicator of the value of a life.

Neither is using the position of a species on the food chain to value their lives. Phytoplankton and plants are near the bottom of the marine and terrestrial food chains but without them everything dies.

To me value is all about contribution. The human species, as a whole, takes far more from the planet than it contributes to it, but at the same time has the potential to innovate and create beyond anything else. Plants and animals may not be able to invent like us but they ensure the world remains a habitable and pleasant place for us to live.

Our greater intelligence means we have a greater responsibility and until we use that for the benefit of the planet instead of ourselves I will always disagree with the notion that a human life is more valuable than an animal life, at least at a species level.

This is a brilliant post. Again if people choose to eat meat that's their choice, but the bending and breaking to try and justify or dismiss the truth is quite something.

user7845209 · 25/09/2022 14:33

Blix · 25/09/2022 14:26

I've never seen a chicken that cost £18?
I have always bought free range eggs and chickens and pay about £8 for a FR chicken from Aldi.
It's obviously more expensive but we eat less.
The problem is that many people cannot afford the luxury of putting animal welfare above their budget. Not all families want to be vegetarian.
Cheap meat feeds people.

A lot of supermarkets only have the smaller free range chicken mainly, we have had them from Waitrose and they are about £10-£12 which are similar size to the £4 ones, the larger ones are mainly in stock at Christmas, I think the posters were probably talking about larger ones from the butcher rather than supermarkets that cost £18 or maybe it was just before Christmas

Musti · 25/09/2022 14:32

This is really tasty www.lazycatkitchen.com/vegan-bao-buns-pulled-jackfruit/

Vegan pavlova - cookveggielicious.com/vegan-aquafaba-pavlova-coconut-cream-berries

i make vegan tempura all the time - peppers, onions, cauliflower, butternut squash, mushrooms, sweet potato, aubergines - dipped in broth made from seaweed instead of fish stock

vegan sushi too - shiitake mushrooms cooked in soy and sugar. Spinach with tahini and maple syrup, avocado, cucumber, pepper, carrots. Okra.

all very kid friendly even if they don’t eat all the elements

Fluffyfluffflufffluff · 25/09/2022 14:32

Oh aye, rice, beans and veg. Famously extortionate.

bellac11 · 25/09/2022 14:27

Musti · 25/09/2022 14:22

I cook different stuff all the time so I don’t have a standard weekly shop. But meat and fish are more expensive than plants.

but last week for example:
1.west African peanut stew thehappyfoodie.co.uk/recipes/african-vegan-peanut-stew/

  1. vegan bibimbap my own version but here is an idea biancazapatka.com/en/vegan-bibimbap/
  2. My own version of Fabada Asturiana www.anediblemosaic.com/giveaway-winner-recipe-for-fabada-asturiana-asturian-bean-stew/
  3. www.gousto.co.uk/cookbook/vegan-recipes/vegetable-noodles-silky-cashew-nut-sauce
each meal enough to do a few meals/dinners/lunches.

Tasty and nutritious food. No meat alternatives. Not particularly cheap ingredients but still cheaper than buying animal products.

Thanks the top one is something I have cooked before, didnt know it was an actual recipe!! Or had a name

Your others come up with page not found

Blix · 25/09/2022 14:26

I've never seen a chicken that cost £18?
I have always bought free range eggs and chickens and pay about £8 for a FR chicken from Aldi.
It's obviously more expensive but we eat less.
The problem is that many people cannot afford the luxury of putting animal welfare above their budget. Not all families want to be vegetarian.
Cheap meat feeds people.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 25/09/2022 14:26

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 25/09/2022 13:32

Why do you think that?

Because a human life is more valuable, that's why it's illegal to take a human life but legal to eat animals. Like it or not, animals are lower down on the food chain.

You haven't really answered why though.

Laws are designed by and for humans so it's not a great metric for value. In fact laws are more often designed by and for a paricular society so it's an even worse metric than first thought.

For example, 100 years ago in the west the life of a straight white man would have been considered more valuable than that of a women, homosexual or black man (and you could argue that this is still the case in many societies across the world) using that metric. But I'd hope must of us would argue that that was/is wrong.

So no, laws aren't a good indicator of the value of a life.

Neither is using the position of a species on the food chain to value their lives. Phytoplankton and plants are near the bottom of the marine and terrestrial food chains but without them everything dies.

To me value is all about contribution. The human species, as a whole, takes far more from the planet than it contributes to it, but at the same time has the potential to innovate and create beyond anything else. Plants and animals may not be able to invent like us but they ensure the world remains a habitable and pleasant place for us to live.

Our greater intelligence means we have a greater responsibility and until we use that for the benefit of the planet instead of ourselves I will always disagree with the notion that a human life is more valuable than an animal life, at least at a species level.