Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a lot of women are worse off than 50 years ago?

944 replies

Tsort · 24/09/2022 23:53

A certain type of person is nostalgic for the old days when ‘men were men, and women were women’. I am not. However, it must be noted that at the time when women were expected to be docile acquiescent homemakers, men were expected to foot the bill. They paid for dinner, sorted the mortgage and brought home the bacon. Not for me, but a fair division of labour.

Now, we have a generation of women who ‘pay their way’, go Dutch and refuse to let men pay for them as they don’t want to be indebted. Grand.

But, these same women also do the lion’s share of housework, because ‘men don’t see it’ and shoulder the emotional labour because ‘that’s just the way men are’.

So, women are now shouldering some of the traditionally male burdens while the traditional female burdens have remained firmly in place. How is this an improvement for women? And why do so many tolerate it? This is a profound misunderstanding of feminism and it hurts so many of us.

OP posts:
TinaPoopsy52 · 25/09/2022 09:21

Strugglingtodomybest · 25/09/2022 09:00

And with the rape laws it’s very good they changed, but you have to realise that even today that crime of marital rape would be virtually impossible to convict without evidence - so what’s the real difference? It’s lip service to an unsolvable problem.

I'm glad that you acknowledge that it's good the rape laws have changed. The real difference that I see is that because it wasn't illegal, no-one thought of it as wrong, it was just "conjugal rights". Nowadays a woman is is raped by her husband knows that it is wrong and that may give her the strength to leave him.

@Strugglingtodomybest

Most Everyone thought of it as wrong. Even in earlier times a hundred years ago stuff like that would often fall under the umbrella of “spousal cruelty”

balalake · 25/09/2022 09:19

There is one area where I think women are in general on average a lot worse off, and that is the expectations regarding sex that men have of them.

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 25/09/2022 09:15

100% agree @Tsort And people saying 'oh but women can just LEAVE easier these days' are being ridiculous. Yes it's more socially acceptable to leave, but it's MUCH harder financially for the women if they do. Especially seeing as how most of them are NOT on the £100,000 a year salary SOME claim on here.

Being alone on a basic salary - the sort MOST people have is really hard. Being alone forever is hard. That is why there are so many people on dating sites. No-one wants to be alone forever.. No matter how much they try to convince themselves - and everyone else. (Not talking about people who have been divorced/in relationships/widowed... I mean people who have NEVER been in a relationship...)

But yeah, life is - and always has been - fucking SHIT for women!

Idontgiveagriffindamn · 25/09/2022 09:12

No thank you. 50 years ago my mums income wasn’t counted towards the mortgage she was a teacher so a professional and a steady income. They only counted my dad’s salary which was less.
She didn’t want to give up job to be a satm but did as it was the social norm.
I on the other hand have a career, carried on with this after having 2 children which was my choice. I also share all the house work with my husband.

Topgub · 25/09/2022 09:12

I think some things have obviously improved for some women.

We have the illusion of equality.

But the reality is we still live in a hugely sexist, mysoginist, patriarchal society.

Where our rights (looking at you America) can easily be removed to suit the made up fairy stories men believe.

And women for the most part are worse than men for reinforcing it. For judging women who don't conform to the sexist rules. For enabling men.

Discovereads · 25/09/2022 09:08

No, sorry you are wrong. It was worse for women 50yrs ago. The bored housewife only applied to middle class on up. Most women still had to work and raise families. Only they couldn’t have their own bank accounts- well they could open one with their name on it but their husband could literally walk into the bank and clear out all the funds to have a big day at the races if he felt like it. He could them come home and rape his wife, perfectly legal back then as forcing your wife to have sex even if you had to smack her around a bit first and hold her down wasn’t considered to be rape back then. Because he owns his wife see.

And even though the equal pay act was passed in 1970, they weren’t enforcing it. Women were being paid far less than men for the same jobs. They also had no protection against being sacked for pregnancy or marriage. The pay gap we have now is a fraction of what it was then.

MindPalace · 25/09/2022 09:02

I agree with you, OP. Living ‘the dream’ for many women means working outside the home at least as much as their partner and doing 99% of the work at home and childcare etc. You see it on here a lot.

As ever, the beneficiaries are often the men.

Strugglingtodomybest · 25/09/2022 09:01
  • that is raped
Party0fpigeons · 25/09/2022 09:01

50 years ago
My mother had a twin tub washing machine (not a case of press a button & walk away) to do the main weekly wash once a week.
Hand washing was done daily
Cloth nappies
Most food was homemade from scratch like pastry pies, stews & dumplings, suet puddings & sponge puddings for dessert
Food shopping was done once a week. Shops were always closed on a Sunday & some on Wednesday afternoons.
Coal fire, no central heating
Husband worked & only person to have ever drive

My grandparents had a mangle in their kitchen

The generation before that had huge families due to no contraception & not all the children survived to adulthood.

Do I think people have it better today ? YES

I live a totally different life to my previous generations, much more freedom & choices !

Strugglingtodomybest · 25/09/2022 09:00

And with the rape laws it’s very good they changed, but you have to realise that even today that crime of marital rape would be virtually impossible to convict without evidence - so what’s the real difference? It’s lip service to an unsolvable problem.

I'm glad that you acknowledge that it's good the rape laws have changed. The real difference that I see is that because it wasn't illegal, no-one thought of it as wrong, it was just "conjugal rights". Nowadays a woman is is raped by her husband knows that it is wrong and that may give her the strength to leave him.

Strugglingtodomybest · 25/09/2022 08:57

TinaPoopsy52 yes, my blood ran cold. That's the way I feel about it. I'm glad you had a better experience of life back then.

mrsparsnip · 25/09/2022 08:51

I grew up in the sixties and seventies. To some extent, it was a very different world, especially in the small, rural community where my family lived.

A chalk line was drawn down the playground, separating boys from girls. Boys ran around and played with balls; girls had skipping ropes and engaged in singing and dancing games (I stood in a corner, because I was too shy to join in).

At secondary school, boys played football, rugby and cricket; girls played hockey, tennis and netball. Boys did woodwork and metalwork; girls did needlework and 'Domestic Science' (there was a token swap around in the middle of the secondary years). When the first computer came to school (just one!), the boys crowded round it, however, it would be the girls who would be more likely to use it, and this was recognised towards the end of my school career, when one option for exams was 'Computer Science' and this was open to all pupils.

In the workplace, I was told that I had to wear a skirt or dress and flesh-coloured tights, and almost all the supermarket shop assistants (that was my job) were female. It was still generally expected that women would not work when their children were very young, and there was little in the way of formal childcare for young children.

Attitudes seemed to change during the eighties and into the nineties, and certainly we have come a long way as a nation in terms of equality of opportunity. Yet, according to The Gender Trust, Britain has the fifth largest gender-based pay gap in Europe, and there is a difference of about 9% v=between the average pay for men and the average pay for women in the UK.

This gap is bolstered by the fact that there are still proportionally more males in higher paying senior positions than women, and the fact that our current PM is only the third female PM in Britain perhaps indicates that it is still a lot harder for women to get into positions of power, than for men to do so.

So, I would say things have improved for women over the past six decades, but, perhaps sadly, the change has been slow and has still not resulted in true equality.

WhatNoRaisins · 25/09/2022 08:47

Parenting seems a lot more hands on. Kids not allowed to play out without adults, I've even heard of 12 year olds that still go to childminders! Parents expected to be involved with schoolwork in a way previous generations weren't are two examples I can think of.

It's going to be either extra time or money for the parents.

Wouldloveanother · 25/09/2022 08:44

I think some elements of life were better back then, some are better now. It would be nice if we could combine the two rather than assuming SAM = abused unfulfilled drudge and working mums = stressed out guilty absent parent

DdraigGoch · 25/09/2022 08:41

Just how demanding is the housework these days? I stick clothes in my washing machine and turn it on. When it finishes I hang them up to dry. Some people have tumble dryers so can just fold everything and put it away as soon as it finishes. Hardly any time out of my day at all. 50 years ago, washing machines were new and revolutionary, often they were twin tubs. There would still have been plenty of housewives washing clothes by hand.

Central heating is pretty ubiquitous these days. 50 years ago you'd have had fires to maintain and clean up after.

Before everyone had freezers, shopping had to be done several times a week because the meat would go off otherwise. Without a second car in the family you had to carry your bags home, either on foot or on the bus.

You've never had it so good OP.

Wouldloveanother · 25/09/2022 08:38

Anyoneleft · 25/09/2022 00:02

I am amazed by friends that have given up their jobs/ financial independence for their families. My job is a lot more demanding and higher paid than my husbands so we share the household tasks/parenting around our work schedule. My DD is only 10 but not a hells chance she will grow up thinking her worth/independence is less than her partners

But that relies on your daughter thinking SAHMs aren’t doing anything valuable and aren’t as worthy as their husband, which you clearly do but she might not. And I don’t.

MumCanIDoThat · 25/09/2022 08:37

But, these same women also do the lion’s share of housework, because ‘men don’t see it’ and shoulder the emotional labour because ‘that’s just the way men are’.

Nah that's a poor excuse for making a bad choice in man. A woman like that is just enabling a useless man. She doesn't have to put up with it but she does. Look at the countless threads here, useless pathetic man but oh he's a great dad.

Women are now more empowered with choices than ever was. It's your responsibility to make those choices.

Elfrazzle · 25/09/2022 08:37

@TinaPoopsy52 I agree, society has changed, we live further from our extended families, we are having children later, people are working later. So we now have both parents often working FT, with little support from family and extortionate childcare costs. Working patterns are completely at odds with 6 hour primary school day and 12 weeks of school holiday.

Not to mention support for elderly relatives too. No wonder we are stressed as a society.

TinaPoopsy52 · 25/09/2022 08:37

bozzabollix · 25/09/2022 08:28

This is bang on.

“But its a cold hard shock when after being treated as an equal you have your first child to find out that actually most women can't have it all.

Essentially we have been given an extra 10-15 years of illusionary equality than we used to have and we are expected to be fucking grateful for it.”

Usually early child rearing falls more to women, because of physiology (men need to grow working boobs), this teamed with paternity traditionally being two weeks firmly sticks children as predominantly a female role. Then childcare costs are huge, or non existent (at present there is no wrap around childcare that could facilitate me working full time in this town, child minders are full, after school clubs full).

So career choices are really stymied, with some women able to carry on as before, but many taking lower paid and part time jobs so children can be looked after, then the career hugely suffers and then doesn’t recover.

I think the key is that the workplace becomes more family friendly for all, with less of a marked division between the jobs where you’re expected to live and breathe them, and jobs got simply because they fit around family. Only then will you have men and women seeing the domestic arena as being a shared thing.

My husband is a high earner and his job is ridiculously demanding. My career is currently shit, simply because I couldn’t do literally 90% of all home and child stuff as well as a demanding job. I would’ve drowned. Totally aware that it leaves me vulnerable and impressed by women who can multitask and do both roles with ease.

So yes, I get what you’re saying OP. I have one friend who is the main earner, does the vast majority of home stuff too whilst her husband tries to find himself. I think she is the embodiment of all you’re saying. I’m not sure men have caught up in terms of their attitude, the worst scenario is that women literally carry it all like my friend.

Its very hard to get the balance right as well as earn the right amount to get through in these straitened times.

@bozzabollix

But your post assumes that couples will both want to balance work and family duties to the same extent. There will still be men like those who do your husbands job who want to work excessively and these people will achieve the best results (so why should that be stopped), then there will be women who don’t want that and they may end up with these men sometimes.

A system that forced both to work (but not too much) would be holding people like that back and on the work from sounds sure to produce mediocrity.

bob78 · 25/09/2022 08:35

Absolutely not for me. One grandmother was trapped in a marriage she hated but societal pressures made divorce very difficult, she'd have loved a career but was pushed out of working when she had kids, her husband "allowed" her to have a part time shop job when youngest turned 5. On the other end of the spectrum my other grandmother had my dad illegitimately with no support, lived in poverty with huge amounts of judgement.

We have a long way to go yet, but I am so grateful to live my life, not theirs, (some through time, some through my own personal background) to have actively chosen the life I wanted, and to be aspirational, something my grandmothers were never empowered with.

A580Hojas · 25/09/2022 08:35

Has this only just occurred to you? Are you living under a rock?

Nachobutt · 25/09/2022 08:34

I don't think your summary of the "deal" or division of labour in the 50s is accurate. The price that women had to pay for men who were sole earners was complete and total acquiescence, whatever their behaviour. The balance of power in the marriage was totally in the man's favour.

We have a choice now - we can choose to put up with shit behaviour from our partners or we can walk away and - heaven forfend - live on our own. The fact that many women are still choosing to put up with shit behaviour is what makes me sad.

TinaPoopsy52 · 25/09/2022 08:33

@Strugglingtodomybest

Your “blood ran cold” at the thought of being back in 1972? Really?

I was a young mother and wife in 1972 and was actually very happy and excited to start that life. In spite of all you hear now most men back then weren’t beating their wives black and blue and it wasn’t though of as a good thing to do so either.

And with the rape laws it’s very good they changed, but you have to realise that even today that crime of marital rape would be virtually impossible to convict without evidence - so what’s the real difference? It’s lip service to an unsolvable problem.

TinaPoopsy52 · 25/09/2022 08:28

@Elfrazzle

But the “village” after childbirth used to be other non working women, older non working grandparents (but not as old as today because women gave birth earlier) and relatives and maybe some retired men.

The simple truth is if all those people are working the “village” is impossible. It sure can’t be replaced by a childcare facility which has no vested interest in you or your children other than the money they can take from you.

bozzabollix · 25/09/2022 08:28

This is bang on.

“But its a cold hard shock when after being treated as an equal you have your first child to find out that actually most women can't have it all.

Essentially we have been given an extra 10-15 years of illusionary equality than we used to have and we are expected to be fucking grateful for it.”

Usually early child rearing falls more to women, because of physiology (men need to grow working boobs), this teamed with paternity traditionally being two weeks firmly sticks children as predominantly a female role. Then childcare costs are huge, or non existent (at present there is no wrap around childcare that could facilitate me working full time in this town, child minders are full, after school clubs full).

So career choices are really stymied, with some women able to carry on as before, but many taking lower paid and part time jobs so children can be looked after, then the career hugely suffers and then doesn’t recover.

I think the key is that the workplace becomes more family friendly for all, with less of a marked division between the jobs where you’re expected to live and breathe them, and jobs got simply because they fit around family. Only then will you have men and women seeing the domestic arena as being a shared thing.

My husband is a high earner and his job is ridiculously demanding. My career is currently shit, simply because I couldn’t do literally 90% of all home and child stuff as well as a demanding job. I would’ve drowned. Totally aware that it leaves me vulnerable and impressed by women who can multitask and do both roles with ease.

So yes, I get what you’re saying OP. I have one friend who is the main earner, does the vast majority of home stuff too whilst her husband tries to find himself. I think she is the embodiment of all you’re saying. I’m not sure men have caught up in terms of their attitude, the worst scenario is that women literally carry it all like my friend.

Its very hard to get the balance right as well as earn the right amount to get through in these straitened times.