Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a lot of women are worse off than 50 years ago?

944 replies

Tsort · 24/09/2022 23:53

A certain type of person is nostalgic for the old days when ‘men were men, and women were women’. I am not. However, it must be noted that at the time when women were expected to be docile acquiescent homemakers, men were expected to foot the bill. They paid for dinner, sorted the mortgage and brought home the bacon. Not for me, but a fair division of labour.

Now, we have a generation of women who ‘pay their way’, go Dutch and refuse to let men pay for them as they don’t want to be indebted. Grand.

But, these same women also do the lion’s share of housework, because ‘men don’t see it’ and shoulder the emotional labour because ‘that’s just the way men are’.

So, women are now shouldering some of the traditionally male burdens while the traditional female burdens have remained firmly in place. How is this an improvement for women? And why do so many tolerate it? This is a profound misunderstanding of feminism and it hurts so many of us.

OP posts:
OP posts:
Discovereads · 25/09/2022 13:29

Wouldloveanother · 25/09/2022 13:21

So you don’t believe the menopause threads on here about major mood changes, loss of maternal feeling etc? They’re making it up?

Menopause is a transition phase during which for some women the hormones become unbalanced and this causes physical side effects like hot flashes and night what’s and also affects their mood- which lets be clear mood and feelings are not behaviours.

TinaPoopsy52 · 25/09/2022 13:29

Discovereads · 25/09/2022 13:13

@TinaPoopsy52

Oh yes, hormones influence behaviour, but only very slightly. I’m objecting to your exaggeration:
Hormones hugely influence behaviours.

No, they really don’t hugely influence behaviour. There’s no scientific basis for this. We are all compis mentis and able to choose our actions and behaviour (barring any hormonal disorder/medical condition).

@Discovereads

Nope they hugely influence behaviour, far more than “slightly”. You brought up all animals - do you realise suppose that the aggressive duelling for female partners male bucks (and others) do isn’t influenced by hormones. That they actually have free choice in the matter. That’s deluded.

Humans too are greatly influenced by hormones and the wider gap between them in sex the greater difference in behaviour overall. That’s why so many more men are in prison or violent or just risk takers (in a good or bad way) than women. Testosterone - ie a hormone. It’s the same for everything.

You like to think you or humans (or bizzarely other animals) can escape that but they can’t. Doesn’t mean we need to live like cavemen but we will always have gendered beahviour due to our hormones. That’s just the reality anyone who denies it lives in a fantasy land.

MsPincher · 25/09/2022 13:29

keepmywifesnameoutchagoddammouth · 25/09/2022 13:09

Well considering he actively does not want me to work because he wants me to do all the other things and do every school pick up I'd call him out on the inconsistency.

I choose what’s what for my family. It’s amazing and I recommend it. Exactly, it's what we do and what I want everyone to do.

yes, I've said our wider family on both sides are mostly this way. Some of the women also work full-time but the rest of the family provide the childcare so we don't need to employ anyone.

I see - a man who doesn’t want you to work because he wants you to be cleaning the house. Wow he sounds like a prince.

so a lot of your family have these strict gender roles - that’s understandable that you have been socialised this way. no one is saying it’s wrong not to work but it’s certainly an unequal relationship. If you think it’s a desirable way to run things, consider what you (and your family) would really (honestly) think of a man who deliberately married a woman who was a “provider” so he could never work again. If your attitude is different to him then you’re not really ok with that.

Octomingo · 25/09/2022 13:26

50 years is 72. Some people on here seem to be mixing it up with the 50s.

Is my life better than my mum's?
She didn't get into grammar school, so did secondary modern. Fought to stay on until 16. Got taught stereotypically female skills. Steered in to secretarial work.
Didn't have much life/ male experience. Married young.
Wasn't allowed mortgage in her name.
Gave up work to have us, then relied on husband's piss poor wage. No holidays, new clothes, nothing.
Eventually went to work again full time in my teens. Still did all housework.

My life
No graMmar schools when I went. Did a levels/ uni/ good job.
Did what I wanted, snagged who I pleased. Chose well.
Married at 25.
2 wages coming in. Didn't give up work when kids were born. Got to have the holidays, nice things and a bigger house. Share chores.

So in my case, I definitely have it better. Partly because I was driven by NOT wanting a life like my mum.

Tsort · 25/09/2022 13:26

Marvellousmadness · 25/09/2022 12:53

Yeah. Id really like to go back there

NOT

🤣

Please get a grip op

Your reading comprehension is such that you think I want to go back to a time for which I’ve explicitly stated I’m not nostalgic. I’m not the one who needs to get a grip.

OP posts:
Discovereads · 25/09/2022 13:26

@TinaPoopsy52
And all the tribes that were first contacted in colonial times that lives in a pre historical type way had strong gender roles

Well yes as westerners contacted other tribes and cultures, they did indeed have strong gender roles too. They just weren’t all the same gender roles that western culture had.

Ethiopia- female warriors
Dahomy- female warriors
Aka tribe- men do the child care while the women hunt
Narragansett- female farmers/hunters
Crow, Sioux,Iroquois, Cheyenne- female warriors
Nepal- women having many husbands
Mosuo- matriarchy- women ruling
BriBri- only women can lead religion and only women can own land
Most of China- cooking family meals is mens work

these are just off the top of my head. There are many more.

ImaDanishPastry · 25/09/2022 13:22

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

keepmywifesnameoutchagoddammouth · 25/09/2022 13:22

MsPincher · 25/09/2022 13:18

Yip and so you have to stay looking “fantastic” to keep your meal ticket? Do you know hall of all marriages end in divorce?

that’s not to say yours will of course but I would hate to be in an unequal relationship. To feel I had to keep looking pretty to keep my money and status. No thanks.

Yeah I know that, and no I don't have to but I will because stress is very ageing.

Wouldloveanother · 25/09/2022 13:21

Discovereads · 25/09/2022 13:13

@TinaPoopsy52

Oh yes, hormones influence behaviour, but only very slightly. I’m objecting to your exaggeration:
Hormones hugely influence behaviours.

No, they really don’t hugely influence behaviour. There’s no scientific basis for this. We are all compis mentis and able to choose our actions and behaviour (barring any hormonal disorder/medical condition).

So you don’t believe the menopause threads on here about major mood changes, loss of maternal feeling etc? They’re making it up?

Linning · 25/09/2022 13:20

bob78 · 25/09/2022 12:46

@Linning great post, I don't think anyone has mentioned other marginalised groups thus far.

If we understate the progress that's been made we risk taking it for granted, and just look how that has turned out in the US over abortion.

Exactly, what’s sad is that the great majority of women IN THE WORLD (including in the 70’s) are not white women living in Western Europe or the US. It’s women of color, most often from poor background, in still restrictive & oppressive countries in 2022, let alone then.

But every time someone makes a post about women being better off “back when” on Mumsnet, they seem to forget most of the female population!

TinaPoopsy52 · 25/09/2022 13:19

Discovereads · 25/09/2022 13:07

Oh yes there is plenty of evidence for female hunters and warriors in historic and prehistoric times. Especially now that we can do DNA analysis on skeletal remains. Thousands of graves that were recorded as “male warrior” or “male hunter” were discovered to actually be women. XX chromosomes cannot be faked. Past anthropologists and archaeologists spent a good 200yrs calling graves a man or woman’s grave based on sexist gendering of grave goods. All of this has been over-turned in the past twenty years as they’re going back and doing DNA analysis.

On a side note, the same is true for many “female priestess” or “female weaver” type graves…DNA analysis = XY. So it’s been cutting both ways.

@Discovereads

This is a load of bs. There’s virtually no evidence for female warriors. The closest is the supposed and sparse Viking maidens buried with weapons, but how does that prove they were warriors?

Yours is a modern feminist rewriting that simply isn’t reality. I don’t know why you would even pretend otherwise. How in the hell do you think female warriors were engaging with primitive weapons in warfare greatly based in physical strength with men who were far superior in physical strength? This goes double for pre history. Why does no written history ever record it ever happening?

Your ideas are all based in fantastical theories. Seriously how many women do you know that could seriously engage in physical fights and war with men successfully (meaning without guns).

Your idea of thousands of female warriors graves being found is laughable and complete fantasy.

MsPincher · 25/09/2022 13:18

keepmywifesnameoutchagoddammouth · 25/09/2022 12:53

No because see I look fantastic and I'm his best friend and mother of his children and loved by his family and it's all reciprocal.

Yip and so you have to stay looking “fantastic” to keep your meal ticket? Do you know hall of all marriages end in divorce?

that’s not to say yours will of course but I would hate to be in an unequal relationship. To feel I had to keep looking pretty to keep my money and status. No thanks.

Abaiia · 25/09/2022 13:17

The difference between now and 50 years ago is that we have more choices. People are also more understanding about divorce and single parents etc. I agree a lot of men need to up their game when it comes to housework and childcare though.

ImaDanishPastry · 25/09/2022 13:16

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Sisisisi · 25/09/2022 13:14

TinaPoopsy52 · 25/09/2022 13:00

@Sisisisi

Well your original post and follow up didn’t actually make it clear when they said they were furious that young women had more choices, just that they were ripping on women making their DH do chores - then you read into that them being upset you have more choices.

I think your projecting onto them.

Projecting what?

2 WOHP
Shared CC, work and domestic tasks.

Discovereads · 25/09/2022 13:13

TinaPoopsy52 · 25/09/2022 13:03

@Discovereads

Er yes they do. Testosterone, estrogen etc absolutely influence behaviour for both humans and other animals.

What in the hell do you think influences behaviour?

@TinaPoopsy52

Oh yes, hormones influence behaviour, but only very slightly. I’m objecting to your exaggeration:
Hormones hugely influence behaviours.

No, they really don’t hugely influence behaviour. There’s no scientific basis for this. We are all compis mentis and able to choose our actions and behaviour (barring any hormonal disorder/medical condition).

Wouldloveanother · 25/09/2022 13:11

Mumsnet is completely unlike real life in that posters truly, honestly believe that there is no difference between men and women bar their physical bodies. And that any behavioural or character differences can be put down to ‘societal conditioning’ or a trend that can be disproved with ‘well my son hates sport and loves housework, so that’s a load of rubbish.’

But then on another thread you have ‘my mood has totally changed since the menopause AIBU’ and posters are suddenly receptive to personalities being controlled by hormones after all.

keepmywifesnameoutchagoddammouth · 25/09/2022 13:09

MsPincher · 25/09/2022 13:07

you don’t “enable him completely” any more than my cleaner enables me. I used to have an au pair that cooked delicious meals. She was great but u wouldn’t like

but I think your comment on gay people reveals what you really think- you’re trapped in a role that you see is for women. Were your parents like that? How would you feel if your dh decided that he would now not work and you could financially support the family?

in terms of me, I have a busy job which of course not every man who works has. But it’s a lot easier with now wfh. Also dds are at primary school now. And I’m totally free- I choose what’s what for my family. It’s amazing and I recommend it.

Well considering he actively does not want me to work because he wants me to do all the other things and do every school pick up I'd call him out on the inconsistency.

I choose what’s what for my family. It’s amazing and I recommend it. Exactly, it's what we do and what I want everyone to do.

yes, I've said our wider family on both sides are mostly this way. Some of the women also work full-time but the rest of the family provide the childcare so we don't need to employ anyone.

Discovereads · 25/09/2022 13:07

TinaPoopsy52 · 25/09/2022 12:43

@Topgub

There is no “actual” evidence of female hunters in pre history your talking nonsense. And all the tribes that were first contacted in colonial times that lives in a pre historical type way had strong gender roles.

I mean what do you expect? It’s so dependent on physicality when you live that way.

Oh yes there is plenty of evidence for female hunters and warriors in historic and prehistoric times. Especially now that we can do DNA analysis on skeletal remains. Thousands of graves that were recorded as “male warrior” or “male hunter” were discovered to actually be women. XX chromosomes cannot be faked. Past anthropologists and archaeologists spent a good 200yrs calling graves a man or woman’s grave based on sexist gendering of grave goods. All of this has been over-turned in the past twenty years as they’re going back and doing DNA analysis.

On a side note, the same is true for many “female priestess” or “female weaver” type graves…DNA analysis = XY. So it’s been cutting both ways.

MsPincher · 25/09/2022 13:07

keepmywifesnameoutchagoddammouth · 25/09/2022 12:00

Lots to address there.

I enable him completely because there are things he never has to worry about which frees up time and energy to focus on work. You can't deny he's enabled to focus on work when he never has to clean anything or cook any meals.

He enables my freedom by taking all the financial burden.

I suppose you could say I'm limited, I'm tied to those school gates for sure, but my time is very free and personally I value my time.

When I worked full-time I felt very limited even before children, because I had to be at my job for 10 hours every weekday, including commute.

Those days, that's five days a week, were for work and nothing else. The weekends were for recuperation.

I don't know how I would have fitted in childcare and nurturing around that but if you can I applaud you. I don't see how it's possible but I believe you when you say it is, I'd need to see it in action to understand.

Being homosexual would eradicate the sex roles is what I meant, because you'd both be the same sex.

I feel very free not having a job. Does your job not take up every weekday?

you don’t “enable him completely” any more than my cleaner enables me. I used to have an au pair that cooked delicious meals. She was great but u wouldn’t like

but I think your comment on gay people reveals what you really think- you’re trapped in a role that you see is for women. Were your parents like that? How would you feel if your dh decided that he would now not work and you could financially support the family?

in terms of me, I have a busy job which of course not every man who works has. But it’s a lot easier with now wfh. Also dds are at primary school now. And I’m totally free- I choose what’s what for my family. It’s amazing and I recommend it.

ImaDanishPastry · 25/09/2022 13:06

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

keepmywifesnameoutchagoddammouth · 25/09/2022 13:04

bob78 · 25/09/2022 13:02

I wouldn't expect you to be either though since you've said you choose to work when you don't have to

Oh look your insecurity is showing again Wink

Well we all have insecurities.

keepmywifesnameoutchagoddammouth · 25/09/2022 13:04

Topgub · 25/09/2022 13:01

@keepmywifesnameoutchagoddammouth

I still can't get away with you thinking that's equal or as important as paying for it all and being husband and father

I guess you need to though eh.

Okay well lucky me then getting away with it.

TinaPoopsy52 · 25/09/2022 13:03

Discovereads · 25/09/2022 12:56

They really don’t. Not even for animals. Basic biology babes.

@Discovereads

Er yes they do. Testosterone, estrogen etc absolutely influence behaviour for both humans and other animals.

What in the hell do you think influences behaviour?