Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a lot of women are worse off than 50 years ago?

944 replies

Tsort · 24/09/2022 23:53

A certain type of person is nostalgic for the old days when ‘men were men, and women were women’. I am not. However, it must be noted that at the time when women were expected to be docile acquiescent homemakers, men were expected to foot the bill. They paid for dinner, sorted the mortgage and brought home the bacon. Not for me, but a fair division of labour.

Now, we have a generation of women who ‘pay their way’, go Dutch and refuse to let men pay for them as they don’t want to be indebted. Grand.

But, these same women also do the lion’s share of housework, because ‘men don’t see it’ and shoulder the emotional labour because ‘that’s just the way men are’.

So, women are now shouldering some of the traditionally male burdens while the traditional female burdens have remained firmly in place. How is this an improvement for women? And why do so many tolerate it? This is a profound misunderstanding of feminism and it hurts so many of us.

OP posts:
Topgub · 25/09/2022 13:50

@TinaPoopsy52

Wrong about your sexist beliefs about evolution

Honestly, even a cursory Google would enlighten you.

TinaPoopsy52 · 25/09/2022 13:50

Discovereads · 25/09/2022 13:43

No it’s really not. I’m just shocked that someone that believes 1822 pseudoscience and historical errors actually exists in 2022.

@Discovereads

So let me get this straight. We know that all other mammal species with the sex with higher testosterone (ie males) will be more aggressive on average across the board, we know that this has also been true for the entirety of history of humans males.
And yet you are saying testosterone doesn’t make men more likely to be violent or takes risks? And it’s all just a patriarchal construct. Just like all those other damn patriarchal constructs in every other mammal species ever!

Higher Testosterone in males affecting their more prevalent aggressive and risky behaviour is a fact.
Your living in a feminist fantasy land to think otherwise.

Anyone who believes hormones like testosterone don’t hugely influence behaviour is the one who believes in pseudoscience

Discovereads · 25/09/2022 13:50

TinaPoopsy52 · 25/09/2022 13:44

@Discovereads

Its the reality. Women weren’t manning the lines of historical armies and it’s deluded to say otherwise. You may get the occasional figure head like Boudicca or Joan of Arc but that’s about it

No it’s really not. You do not know your history or archaeology at all. You’re stuck in 1822.

I just finished a book on the Vikings alone and the author went through over a dozen cases of warrior burials..some even were high status military commander burials that have been DNA analysed and found to be women not men.

Yes female warriors among the Vikings were not 50/50, they were a minority but as he says they were there and some even led and commanded military campaigns.

And as with the other historic cultures I mentioned, these were not royal women or figurehead/mascots. These were rank and file soldiers and warriors.

Wouldloveanother · 25/09/2022 13:47

MsPincher · 25/09/2022 13:45

It’s total crap that hormones “lead to gendered behavior”. Women behave in all sorts of different ways despite having the same hormones. Same with men. Hormones may have “some influence” on behavior but we are complex sophisticated animals not slaves to our hormones.

women and men behave hugely differently and have different roles in different cultures and societies. Yet hormone levels are the same.

the idea that women should be chained to the sink because of biology is crap.

Yeah because that’s exactly what we said isn’t it 🙄

And no, it isn’t crap, no matter how uncomfortable that is for feminism. Men have higher testosterone, are more aggressive by nature and more target-driven.
Women tend to be less aggressive and more emotionally intelligent.

keepmywifesnameoutchagoddammouth · 25/09/2022 13:46

I still want to know who @MsPincher thinks is losing out in my family.

Me because he's prohibiting me from working to have a live-in cleaner
or him because I'm relying on his money.

MsPincher · 25/09/2022 13:45

TinaPoopsy52 · 25/09/2022 13:29

@Discovereads

Nope they hugely influence behaviour, far more than “slightly”. You brought up all animals - do you realise suppose that the aggressive duelling for female partners male bucks (and others) do isn’t influenced by hormones. That they actually have free choice in the matter. That’s deluded.

Humans too are greatly influenced by hormones and the wider gap between them in sex the greater difference in behaviour overall. That’s why so many more men are in prison or violent or just risk takers (in a good or bad way) than women. Testosterone - ie a hormone. It’s the same for everything.

You like to think you or humans (or bizzarely other animals) can escape that but they can’t. Doesn’t mean we need to live like cavemen but we will always have gendered beahviour due to our hormones. That’s just the reality anyone who denies it lives in a fantasy land.

It’s total crap that hormones “lead to gendered behavior”. Women behave in all sorts of different ways despite having the same hormones. Same with men. Hormones may have “some influence” on behavior but we are complex sophisticated animals not slaves to our hormones.

women and men behave hugely differently and have different roles in different cultures and societies. Yet hormone levels are the same.

the idea that women should be chained to the sink because of biology is crap.

Discovereads · 25/09/2022 13:45

TinaPoopsy52 · 25/09/2022 13:42

@Topgub

Wrong about what? About hormones influencing behaviour? Because nothing remotely scientific would ever say otherwise.

Ah, you’ve back pedalled from “hugely influencing behaviour” to the innocuous “influencing behaviour” which is vague but not wrong. See we’ve convinced you to drop the “hugely” fallacy.

TinaPoopsy52 · 25/09/2022 13:44

Discovereads · 25/09/2022 13:41

@TinaPoopsy52
There have been virtually no female warriors in pre history and none proven in history.

This is fucking bullshit to the max. No female warriors in all of history?!?
Where were you educated? In some patriarchal cult?

@Discovereads

Its the reality. Women weren’t manning the lines of historical armies and it’s deluded to say otherwise. You may get the occasional figure head like Boudicca or Joan of Arc but that’s about it

keepmywifesnameoutchagoddammouth · 25/09/2022 13:43

runwalk · 25/09/2022 13:38

"consider what you (and your family) would really (honestly) think of a man who deliberately married a woman who was a “provider” so he could never work again. If your attitude is different to him then you’re not really ok with that."

That question was not to me but it shows you miss the point MsPincher. You may not like the point but anyway..., If a couple have a dynamic where they naturally gravitate to certain roles and he is driven more towards the providing role and her a more nurturing role, then your scenario above wouldn't work no, because it is asking those particular human beings to go against their natures and self-identities., People only do what they want to do and there's not a lot you can do about that, I'm afraid..

Also, to make it relevant he would have to be marrying a woman who specifically wanted a stay at home man as well, in which case no, there wouldn't be an issue would there since both are willing participants in those roles.

For some reason though, (patriarchal societal conditioning/sex influences natural roles) that doesn't happen and it's the woman with the mammary glands and womb who does the childcare and non-financial stuff usually.

Discovereads · 25/09/2022 13:43

TinaPoopsy52 · 25/09/2022 13:40

@Discovereads

“That’s why so many more men are in prison or violent or just risk takers (in a good or bad way) than women.

Testosterone doesn’t make men rape and murder. It’s not as big of an influence as you say.“

It does though. Individual men may have choice, but it’s the reason why they are so much more likely to do those things and always have been. Why bother denying it? It is the cause of that.

No it’s really not. I’m just shocked that someone that believes 1822 pseudoscience and historical errors actually exists in 2022.

TinaPoopsy52 · 25/09/2022 13:42

Topgub · 25/09/2022 13:37

@TinaPoopsy52

A quick Google proves you wrong.

Its not admirable to be that uneducated.

Its all a bit flat earther

@Topgub

Wrong about what? About hormones influencing behaviour? Because nothing remotely scientific would ever say otherwise.

Discovereads · 25/09/2022 13:41

@TinaPoopsy52
There have been virtually no female warriors in pre history and none proven in history.

This is fucking bullshit to the max. No female warriors in all of history?!?
Where were you educated? In some patriarchal cult?

bob78 · 25/09/2022 13:41

People only do what they want to do

That's an interesting observation, because I feel a lot of people don't (in this context), and they do what they think they should do or feel pressured to do, and I think women are most guilty of that. (I'm not one of those, but my mother is a prime example of that, as were my grandmothers). The expectation of sacrifice seems to fall more on women, but I do also think the comments around standards are true too.

TinaPoopsy52 · 25/09/2022 13:40

@Discovereads

“That’s why so many more men are in prison or violent or just risk takers (in a good or bad way) than women.

Testosterone doesn’t make men rape and murder. It’s not as big of an influence as you say.“

It does though. Individual men may have choice, but it’s the reason why they are so much more likely to do those things and always have been. Why bother denying it? It is the cause of that.

keepmywifesnameoutchagoddammouth · 25/09/2022 13:40

Topgub · 25/09/2022 13:36

@keepmywifesnameoutchagoddammouth

I genuinely hope you've got the resilience to cope with any stressful events that come your way.

Its not possible to live a life entirely free of stress.

Bereavement, financial worries, children not coping/being bullied/mh issues. I could go on.

Looking great won't help you cope

I've been through most of those and more so yes. Thank you, you're right.
Maybe I do lack the capacity for all of them and that's why I sought this situation out.

Certainly found work took up all my capacity although I did do my post-graduate degree during a full-time job. I just wouldn't want to do that again you see, I'm late thirties now and it's all behind me. I left a lot of skills and qualifications dormant for this life. I burned the candle at both ends at one time but now I live a much simpler life it's true. It's also on purpose.

Discovereads · 25/09/2022 13:39

Wouldloveanother · 25/09/2022 13:30

Mood definitely affects behaviour. Hence why we act different when happy, sad, angry.

But would you say that your female menstrual or menopause hormones hugely influence your behaviour? As in, huge meaning the primary factor behind why you behave the way you do? Would you accept normal levels of “estrogen” as the huge influence as to why you chose to be a mother, and if so, what does that say about women who choose not to be mothers? Not enough estrogen or stronger willed than you?

runwalk · 25/09/2022 13:38

"consider what you (and your family) would really (honestly) think of a man who deliberately married a woman who was a “provider” so he could never work again. If your attitude is different to him then you’re not really ok with that."

That question was not to me but it shows you miss the point MsPincher. You may not like the point but anyway..., If a couple have a dynamic where they naturally gravitate to certain roles and he is driven more towards the providing role and her a more nurturing role, then your scenario above wouldn't work no, because it is asking those particular human beings to go against their natures and self-identities., People only do what they want to do and there's not a lot you can do about that, I'm afraid..

TinaPoopsy52 · 25/09/2022 13:37

Discovereads · 25/09/2022 13:26

@TinaPoopsy52
And all the tribes that were first contacted in colonial times that lives in a pre historical type way had strong gender roles

Well yes as westerners contacted other tribes and cultures, they did indeed have strong gender roles too. They just weren’t all the same gender roles that western culture had.

Ethiopia- female warriors
Dahomy- female warriors
Aka tribe- men do the child care while the women hunt
Narragansett- female farmers/hunters
Crow, Sioux,Iroquois, Cheyenne- female warriors
Nepal- women having many husbands
Mosuo- matriarchy- women ruling
BriBri- only women can lead religion and only women can own land
Most of China- cooking family meals is mens work

these are just off the top of my head. There are many more.

@Discovereads

Exaggeration. You know full well that the vast vast vast majority of tribes had fairly stock standard gender roles of male warriors, chiefs, female nurturers, sometime medicine women.

Some of the tribes you have mentioned either had female warriors very sparingly (or without any real evidence) and a few of them are literally groups of dozens of people. One is a tiny tribe of four foot pgymies.
There have been virtually no female warriors in pre history and none proven in history.

you have to go far far out of your way to find a tribe that deviates from standard gender roles in any way and then you have to exaggerate most of the way it deviates - and even then it’s a drop in the ocean to all those with traditional gender roles. It’s just what works, especially then.

Topgub · 25/09/2022 13:37

@TinaPoopsy52

A quick Google proves you wrong.

Its not admirable to be that uneducated.

Its all a bit flat earther

Topgub · 25/09/2022 13:36

@keepmywifesnameoutchagoddammouth

I genuinely hope you've got the resilience to cope with any stressful events that come your way.

Its not possible to live a life entirely free of stress.

Bereavement, financial worries, children not coping/being bullied/mh issues. I could go on.

Looking great won't help you cope

Tsort · 25/09/2022 13:34

Linning · 25/09/2022 13:20

Exactly, what’s sad is that the great majority of women IN THE WORLD (including in the 70’s) are not white women living in Western Europe or the US. It’s women of color, most often from poor background, in still restrictive & oppressive countries in 2022, let alone then.

But every time someone makes a post about women being better off “back when” on Mumsnet, they seem to forget most of the female population!

I’m a Black African immigrant. As is fairly clear from my posting history. So, no, my focus isn’t white women living in Western Europe. The fact that you assumed it was says considerably more about your default assumptions than it does about mine.

OP posts:
Discovereads · 25/09/2022 13:34

TinaPoopsy52 · 25/09/2022 13:29

@Discovereads

Nope they hugely influence behaviour, far more than “slightly”. You brought up all animals - do you realise suppose that the aggressive duelling for female partners male bucks (and others) do isn’t influenced by hormones. That they actually have free choice in the matter. That’s deluded.

Humans too are greatly influenced by hormones and the wider gap between them in sex the greater difference in behaviour overall. That’s why so many more men are in prison or violent or just risk takers (in a good or bad way) than women. Testosterone - ie a hormone. It’s the same for everything.

You like to think you or humans (or bizzarely other animals) can escape that but they can’t. Doesn’t mean we need to live like cavemen but we will always have gendered beahviour due to our hormones. That’s just the reality anyone who denies it lives in a fantasy land.

the aggressive duelling for female partners male bucks (and others) do isn’t influenced by hormones. That they actually have free choice in the matter.

Ah, I see now you are confusing hormones with instincts. Setting aside the fact that no choice is ever free, yes many animals do exercise choice. For every two males butting heads…there will be other males off to one side chewing grass and staring at the clouds.

That’s why so many more men are in prison or violent or just risk takers (in a good or bad way) than women.

Testosterone doesn’t make men rape and murder. It’s not as big of an influence as you say.

keepmywifesnameoutchagoddammouth · 25/09/2022 13:32

MsPincher · 25/09/2022 13:29

I see - a man who doesn’t want you to work because he wants you to be cleaning the house. Wow he sounds like a prince.

so a lot of your family have these strict gender roles - that’s understandable that you have been socialised this way. no one is saying it’s wrong not to work but it’s certainly an unequal relationship. If you think it’s a desirable way to run things, consider what you (and your family) would really (honestly) think of a man who deliberately married a woman who was a “provider” so he could never work again. If your attitude is different to him then you’re not really ok with that.

Wait a minute, so he's out of order, or I am? Or both?

Is he exploiting me or am I exploiting him? In your opinion.

keepmywifesnameoutchagoddammouth · 25/09/2022 13:32

Okay you could be right that it's not equal, perhaps he's saying that to make me feel better.
Still preferable to working full-time.
Maybe I'm selfishly taking advantage.
But it's what we both want so I guess I'm just very fortunate. I am grateful, every single day, and so happy about it all.

But your points are valid.

Wouldloveanother · 25/09/2022 13:30

Discovereads · 25/09/2022 13:29

Menopause is a transition phase during which for some women the hormones become unbalanced and this causes physical side effects like hot flashes and night what’s and also affects their mood- which lets be clear mood and feelings are not behaviours.

Mood definitely affects behaviour. Hence why we act different when happy, sad, angry.