Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a lot of women are worse off than 50 years ago?

944 replies

Tsort · 24/09/2022 23:53

A certain type of person is nostalgic for the old days when ‘men were men, and women were women’. I am not. However, it must be noted that at the time when women were expected to be docile acquiescent homemakers, men were expected to foot the bill. They paid for dinner, sorted the mortgage and brought home the bacon. Not for me, but a fair division of labour.

Now, we have a generation of women who ‘pay their way’, go Dutch and refuse to let men pay for them as they don’t want to be indebted. Grand.

But, these same women also do the lion’s share of housework, because ‘men don’t see it’ and shoulder the emotional labour because ‘that’s just the way men are’.

So, women are now shouldering some of the traditionally male burdens while the traditional female burdens have remained firmly in place. How is this an improvement for women? And why do so many tolerate it? This is a profound misunderstanding of feminism and it hurts so many of us.

OP posts:
bob78 · 25/09/2022 14:26

@keepmywifesnameoutchagoddammouth that's one reason yes, but for many, career minded people especially, it's about what the work is, the enjoyment of it, the purpose it can bring, those people and careers exist too. Do you think doctors and nurses do that job purely for the salary? If so they made a peculiar choice of vocation! As I say I haven't always needed to work but have always chosen to, to progress my career.

Discovereads · 25/09/2022 14:25

TinaPoopsy52 · 25/09/2022 14:03

@Discovereads

Im guessing you usually read books with a feminist bent on history and look to confirm your own beliefs. What the hell is a Viking “commander”? That is totally made up. How did this guy get the information that this woman was a commander? From the few etched Viking runes (none of which mention female “commanders”).

I really think your living in a fantasy. Seriously weapons and fighting back then were largely strength and physical ability based. Think about it realistically - there is little use or reason to have women in an army which does it’s fighting by bashing into each other with shields, axes and long spears (all of which take strength and constant exertion of force to use). Think of it this way - if all the men on a busy street and all the women on a busy street were given dark ages weapons what do you think would happen? Obviously the women would badly lose quite quickly. Why on earth do you think dark ages or ancient armies were looking to enlist women? This doesn’t make sense, it’s pure modern fantasy

No. It’s not a “feminist book”, it is a history book.
Children of Ash and Elm: A History of the Vikings by Neil Price (c)2020
For your information Dr Neil Price is a well known and respected archaeologist who has studied the Vikings for almost forty years.
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neil_Price_(archaeologist)

What the hell is a Viking “commander”? That is totally made up.
A Viking commander would usually be captain of a ship (and lead the warriors on board on land-based campaigns) or higher- ie could command entire fleets.

If you want to know how archaeologists can tell who was important, read the book. I highly recommend it.

Seriously weapons and fighting back then were largely strength and physical ability based.. So no skill involved then….🙄

Think of it this way - if all the men on a busy street and all the women on a busy street were given dark ages weapons what do you think would happen? Obviously the women would badly lose quite quickly..

But this wouldn’t happen. You’d never have men vs women. It would be groups of men + women fighting groups of men + women. That’s not unrealistic.

keepmywifesnameoutchagoddammouth · 25/09/2022 14:23

bob78 · 25/09/2022 14:21

@keepmywifesnameoutchagoddammouth riiight so you're natural, you're the way women are supposed to be, but we're the wrong'uns eh? How do you account for the career women who are happy and choosing to work and not feeling pressured to do so? I know, I know you think they don't exist, but I assure they do, how do you account for them?

Well why does anyone want to work? It's so they feel secure and able to have financial security.

bob78 · 25/09/2022 14:21

@keepmywifesnameoutchagoddammouth riiight so you're natural, you're the way women are supposed to be, but we're the wrong'uns eh? How do you account for the career women who are happy and choosing to work and not feeling pressured to do so? I know, I know you think they don't exist, but I assure they do, how do you account for them?

Thelnebriati · 25/09/2022 14:20

at the time when women were expected to be docile acquiescent homemakers, men were expected to foot the bill. They paid for dinner, sorted the mortgage and brought home the bacon. Not for me, but a fair division of labour.

men were ''expected to foot the bill'' because married women were barred from working without their husbands permission. Its really irritating to see this framed as an imposition on men.

Gender roles are nothing to do with fairness. Women often worked outside of the home, in lesser, less well paid, menial job. And they did that on top of the housework.

Women did war work during WW2 (only slightly more than 50 years ago), they did hard labour on farms and they worked in munitions factories. They were dropped behind enemy lines as spies. No one complained they were taking men's masculinity away - until the men returned and wanted their wives back in the home.

Topgub · 25/09/2022 14:20

@TinaPoopsy52

I think maybe you need to ask yourself why you're so wedded to this belief that women have to be a certain way?

So much so you'll deny all the available evidence?

The limitations of sex (smaller, weaker, childbearing) may have led to sexist gender stereotypes being largely enforced in the past but they weren't exclusively limiting and certainly aren't now.

Are you worried if its not true that women have to act a certain way it invalidates your choices?

keepmywifesnameoutchagoddammouth · 25/09/2022 14:19

bob78 · 25/09/2022 14:12

@TinaPoopsy52 how do you account for more women wanting to go out and get careers (be "providers") in the last few decades if you think it's against our nature?

Societal conditioning.

Sharpapplejuice · 25/09/2022 14:16

I wanted to come on and add my twopence to this one. I am in the position of working most days in the business I run with my husband but also being the person who does all of the housework, the majority of the childcare and emotional support for the kids etc. Our business is based on my husband's profession, say for outing purposes, as a specialist lawyer so there are large chunks of the work I can't do as not trained. I do all of the house / childcare etc because my husband works from 7am until 10pm nearly 7 days a week to keep the business running well enough for us to have no money worries. I have my evenings free ish after 8 say but am at home looking after the kids. We have no major money worries so can afford takeaways or meals out sometimes.

I wanted to say that this lifestyle gives me personally many advantages - time with my kids being the main one,I drop into school and collect at normal times, we can treat ourselves to stuff, we can go away. But I do feel uncomfortable with the perceived gender roles and how my children will be learning these from us. I could go and get a full time job but that won't earn us more than we earn through me building up the business and my kids would have to go to wraparound care and we'd have to farm out a lot to help. I would feel under even more pressure as less time with the kids. So yep women have it tough but I think we always have.

bob78 · 25/09/2022 14:12

@TinaPoopsy52 how do you account for more women wanting to go out and get careers (be "providers") in the last few decades if you think it's against our nature?

TinaPoopsy52 · 25/09/2022 14:10

Discovereads · 25/09/2022 14:02

We know that all other mammal species with the sex with higher testosterone (ie males) will be more aggressive on average across the board,

No we don’t. In fact in many mammal species the female is more aggressive than the male despite having lower testosterone: lemurs, antelopes, hyenas, lions. Interestingly, it’s the lactating female hyenas that are the most aggressive….do you think that breastfeeding mothers are hugely aggressive?

we know that this has also been true for the entirety of history of humans males

Correlation doesn’t equal causation. As in yes, human men are more aggressive on average and have more testosterone on average but this doesn’t mean that the testosterone caused the aggression. In fact there is more evidence for socialisation causing aggression than hormones as an abused boy is at high risk to become an abusive and aggressive man.

Higher Testosterone in males affecting their more prevalent aggressive and risky behaviour is a fact.

Its not a fact, but 200yr old hypothesis that is losing plausibility by the day.

@Discovereads

Your living in a fantasy land. It’s impossible to get reason out of someone who thinks that all human gender differences are “socialisation” (why did it even happen in the first place if we were all once the same, it’s nonsense).

Testosterone has been well studied in all animals including humans and is very much proven to be responsible for higher aggression.

I understand you have to believe this nonsense otherwise ideas about gender differences being “all socialisation” would fall apart but really, the only place testosterone being responsible for aggression is “losing plausibility” is in some feminist based social science perhaps and only the most extreme of them.

And male Lions are more aggressive actually, females actually have to show submission to (thankfully we’re not lions) and they get majorly pissy if it’s not done right, they also fight each other for dominance and patrol territory.

Discovereads · 25/09/2022 14:06

MsPincher · 25/09/2022 14:00

our biology is no different from 50 years ago, yet our behavior and expectations are massively different. That indicates that any influence biology has is very small indeed.

So true!

keepmywifesnameoutchagoddammouth · 25/09/2022 14:06

MsPincher · 25/09/2022 14:02

You said in your quote that I quoted above that he “prohibited you from working”. That’s toxic sexist behavior.

you do not have equal roles and you know it. He makes the money and you make the tea.

Make the tea, funny.

Was it you who said the long list of duties I fulfil was practically nothing?

You're tying yourself up in knots.

keepmywifesnameoutchagoddammouth · 25/09/2022 14:05

MsPincher · 25/09/2022 14:02

You said in your quote that I quoted above that he “prohibited you from working”. That’s toxic sexist behavior.

you do not have equal roles and you know it. He makes the money and you make the tea.

I was basically paraphrasing you, no of course he doesn't and yes that would be. Maybe that was my mistake.

Okay so then how am I being exploited if that's true?

keepmywifesnameoutchagoddammouth · 25/09/2022 14:04

bob78 · 25/09/2022 14:00

but I do anyway

Didn't you make a dig at me for choosing to work...?

No.

HamiltonFan1 · 25/09/2022 14:03

YABU

Life is far better for women these days than 50 years ago, the stats you quote about women killed by their families etc. were just as bad, if not worse 50 years ago.

But back then women couldn't get divorced as easily, couldn't have access to their own money.

50 years ago women weren't seen or treated equally

Now on the most part they are, and it's getting better with each generation.

I am 32 and I have never been harassed at work, passed over for a promotion due to my genitalia, treated with disrespect due to my sex, and that's the same for every single one of my friends and work colleagues around the same age or younger.

I also don't know anyone married whose husbands don't contribute 50/50 to the running of their homes unless they're SAHPs. I also know a fair few SAHDs.

Just because some women put up with shit these days (eg husbands that don't pull their weight) doesn't mean women as a group aren't better off now than 50 years ago

TinaPoopsy52 · 25/09/2022 14:03

Discovereads · 25/09/2022 13:50

No it’s really not. You do not know your history or archaeology at all. You’re stuck in 1822.

I just finished a book on the Vikings alone and the author went through over a dozen cases of warrior burials..some even were high status military commander burials that have been DNA analysed and found to be women not men.

Yes female warriors among the Vikings were not 50/50, they were a minority but as he says they were there and some even led and commanded military campaigns.

And as with the other historic cultures I mentioned, these were not royal women or figurehead/mascots. These were rank and file soldiers and warriors.

@Discovereads

Im guessing you usually read books with a feminist bent on history and look to confirm your own beliefs. What the hell is a Viking “commander”? That is totally made up. How did this guy get the information that this woman was a commander? From the few etched Viking runes (none of which mention female “commanders”).

I really think your living in a fantasy. Seriously weapons and fighting back then were largely strength and physical ability based. Think about it realistically - there is little use or reason to have women in an army which does it’s fighting by bashing into each other with shields, axes and long spears (all of which take strength and constant exertion of force to use). Think of it this way - if all the men on a busy street and all the women on a busy street were given dark ages weapons what do you think would happen? Obviously the women would badly lose quite quickly. Why on earth do you think dark ages or ancient armies were looking to enlist women? This doesn’t make sense, it’s pure modern fantasy

MsPincher · 25/09/2022 14:02

keepmywifesnameoutchagoddammouth · 25/09/2022 13:59

Okay well firstly I never said he prohibited me, you did. He told me I don't need to and not to bother, but I do anyway.

Secondly, what toxic sexist behaviour exactly?

Thirdly, what is the difference between us exploiting from one another and from us benefiting from one another's roles?

And if we're both equally exploiting one another what's unequal about our set up?

You said in your quote that I quoted above that he “prohibited you from working”. That’s toxic sexist behavior.

you do not have equal roles and you know it. He makes the money and you make the tea.

Discovereads · 25/09/2022 14:02

TinaPoopsy52 · 25/09/2022 13:50

@Discovereads

So let me get this straight. We know that all other mammal species with the sex with higher testosterone (ie males) will be more aggressive on average across the board, we know that this has also been true for the entirety of history of humans males.
And yet you are saying testosterone doesn’t make men more likely to be violent or takes risks? And it’s all just a patriarchal construct. Just like all those other damn patriarchal constructs in every other mammal species ever!

Higher Testosterone in males affecting their more prevalent aggressive and risky behaviour is a fact.
Your living in a feminist fantasy land to think otherwise.

Anyone who believes hormones like testosterone don’t hugely influence behaviour is the one who believes in pseudoscience

We know that all other mammal species with the sex with higher testosterone (ie males) will be more aggressive on average across the board,

No we don’t. In fact in many mammal species the female is more aggressive than the male despite having lower testosterone: lemurs, antelopes, hyenas, lions. Interestingly, it’s the lactating female hyenas that are the most aggressive….do you think that breastfeeding mothers are hugely aggressive?

we know that this has also been true for the entirety of history of humans males

Correlation doesn’t equal causation. As in yes, human men are more aggressive on average and have more testosterone on average but this doesn’t mean that the testosterone caused the aggression. In fact there is more evidence for socialisation causing aggression than hormones as an abused boy is at high risk to become an abusive and aggressive man.

Higher Testosterone in males affecting their more prevalent aggressive and risky behaviour is a fact.

Its not a fact, but 200yr old hypothesis that is losing plausibility by the day.

bob78 · 25/09/2022 14:00

but I do anyway

Didn't you make a dig at me for choosing to work...?

MsPincher · 25/09/2022 14:00

TinaPoopsy52 · 25/09/2022 13:56

@MsPincher

And this is it. The fear that acknowledging that biology and hormones lead to gendered behaviour would lead to women being “chained to the sink”.

Hormones absolutely influence gendered behaviour- you admit it yourself in this post but try to down play it as “some influence” - well your right, they have some influence. A lot of influence.

Most cultures have had fairly standard gender roles in society taken at a distance, but given these usually are a response to the technology available (being practical in their own time) there is no reason to think that in todays technologically advanced world that acknowledging natural gender differences means putting women or men in a rigid box. We live in a world of plenty were there can be more choice.

our biology is no different from 50 years ago, yet our behavior and expectations are massively different. That indicates that any influence biology has is very small indeed.

keepmywifesnameoutchagoddammouth · 25/09/2022 13:59

MsPincher · 25/09/2022 13:57

both of you because you clearly live in a starkly unequal relationship. And your children who are seeing toxic sexist behavior. Anyone who has a spouse who “prohibits them from working” so they can run around after them but thinks it’s ok needs help.

Okay well firstly I never said he prohibited me, you did. He told me I don't need to and not to bother, but I do anyway.

Secondly, what toxic sexist behaviour exactly?

Thirdly, what is the difference between us exploiting from one another and from us benefiting from one another's roles?

And if we're both equally exploiting one another what's unequal about our set up?

MsPincher · 25/09/2022 13:57

keepmywifesnameoutchagoddammouth · 25/09/2022 13:46

I still want to know who @MsPincher thinks is losing out in my family.

Me because he's prohibiting me from working to have a live-in cleaner
or him because I'm relying on his money.

both of you because you clearly live in a starkly unequal relationship. And your children who are seeing toxic sexist behavior. Anyone who has a spouse who “prohibits them from working” so they can run around after them but thinks it’s ok needs help.

TinaPoopsy52 · 25/09/2022 13:56

MsPincher · 25/09/2022 13:45

It’s total crap that hormones “lead to gendered behavior”. Women behave in all sorts of different ways despite having the same hormones. Same with men. Hormones may have “some influence” on behavior but we are complex sophisticated animals not slaves to our hormones.

women and men behave hugely differently and have different roles in different cultures and societies. Yet hormone levels are the same.

the idea that women should be chained to the sink because of biology is crap.

@MsPincher

And this is it. The fear that acknowledging that biology and hormones lead to gendered behaviour would lead to women being “chained to the sink”.

Hormones absolutely influence gendered behaviour- you admit it yourself in this post but try to down play it as “some influence” - well your right, they have some influence. A lot of influence.

Most cultures have had fairly standard gender roles in society taken at a distance, but given these usually are a response to the technology available (being practical in their own time) there is no reason to think that in todays technologically advanced world that acknowledging natural gender differences means putting women or men in a rigid box. We live in a world of plenty were there can be more choice.

Seymour5 · 25/09/2022 13:53

Helgadaley · 25/09/2022 10:46

It has a lot to do with the price of property today. Fifty years ago, a household could get by one salary, which in most cases came from the husband. Now it realistically takes two incomes, so many more women have careers. From all I read, men are doing more domestic work than they used to. But equally, more households now have help - cleaners, nannies, nursery, whereas in the past, all that was down to the woman.
I read a lot of posts where women are urged to 'get their partner to step up,' so from that I guess that daily life has become more stressful for both partners.

We could have got by on one income in the 1970s/80s if we’d been prepared to stay in the decrepit private rental, in a run down area with poor schools. We made the decision that we wanted better for our children, that meant two incomes.

bob78 · 25/09/2022 13:51

Been following the hormone chat with interest. I am a total slave to my hormones, I suffer quite bad PMT and it can make me miserable, I was ready to side with hormones influencing behaviours as it makes me eat chocolate and chin off a run. But then I considered it doesn't inherently change who I am or what I do, I have female hormones (lots of them Sad) and yet I am not the so called traditional maternal figure with instincts to nurture as has been stated, I'm a nurturer sure, but I'm also competitive, a provider, and my DH actually has better parental instincts that me most of the time. So yeah I'm not sure I believe our hormones are what cause gendered behaviours.

Swipe left for the next trending thread