Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a lot of women are worse off than 50 years ago?

944 replies

Tsort · 24/09/2022 23:53

A certain type of person is nostalgic for the old days when ‘men were men, and women were women’. I am not. However, it must be noted that at the time when women were expected to be docile acquiescent homemakers, men were expected to foot the bill. They paid for dinner, sorted the mortgage and brought home the bacon. Not for me, but a fair division of labour.

Now, we have a generation of women who ‘pay their way’, go Dutch and refuse to let men pay for them as they don’t want to be indebted. Grand.

But, these same women also do the lion’s share of housework, because ‘men don’t see it’ and shoulder the emotional labour because ‘that’s just the way men are’.

So, women are now shouldering some of the traditionally male burdens while the traditional female burdens have remained firmly in place. How is this an improvement for women? And why do so many tolerate it? This is a profound misunderstanding of feminism and it hurts so many of us.

OP posts:
TinaPoopsy52 · 25/09/2022 17:54

@bob78

She is the one who brought this all up by making snide comments like “at least your family values you - someone has too”. So I’m pointing out that in reality whatever anyone outside her family thinks of her really amounts to very little in the grand scheme of things. It’s fine if she’s happy in her work - but nobody but her really values her for it.
I wouldn’t say it if she had not tried to get snippy with me only having value to my family (and friends) as though that isn’t true of the vast majority of people.

bob78 · 25/09/2022 17:54

@TinaPoopsy52 and there is also evidence that daughters born to working mothers earn more and sons are more independent. It's much more nuanced than purely work = success/no success. If only parenting was that inevitable and easy!

keepmywifesnameoutchagoddammouth · 25/09/2022 17:53

Discovereads · 25/09/2022 17:46

No stay at home parent is a risk factor though along with divorce, poverty and abuse per the studies done on juvenile delinquency. It’s not ‘blaming women’ by stating a known risk factor.

What you've written makes no sense. No SAHP is a risk factor, what does that mean?

Discovereads · 25/09/2022 17:53

Diverseopinions · 25/09/2022 17:42

Pre the advent of the contraceptive pill (1969?) women used to face the likelihood of falling pregnant. It's hardly surprising that they predicted that their role would be childrearing and keeping the home environment safe and clean. Because of that vital change, I don't think you can compare the two eras. Factor in the lack of labour saving devices in 1950 and the picture, then, looks less rosy.

It upsets me somewhat when men are critisized on MN for putting all their energies into work. I don't think it is considered enough that they might be scared about losing work and want to try very hard to keep their job - in these uncertain times.

I think experiences vary from couple to couple. If you both work with good salaries, you can pay a cleaner and a gardener to do the bulk of the work at home. The early years are difficult because of the cost of childcare, but get easier if you have one child, or maximum two.

People are living longer, healthily, so, today, the option of grandparents helping is more of a reality. Some grandparents will and some won't , but at least they are living healthily into their old age. I think childcare costs are the worst thing about the modern age.

Yes I agree. If I’d been a man, I’d probably have been roundly criticised on MN for the amount of time I was working and my DH left with everything else as a SAHD. It’s a lot of pressure to be sole breadwinner and at the same time you are free from guilt in the sense you know your DC are not with a child minder or stuck in an after school club/wrap around care or being passed between relatives homes because they’re at home with a parent. I remember the 2008/9 crash well as it was a time where we were oh shit don’t lose your job Discover.

I don’t think that future generations will have healthy grandparents to depend on. For one, people are having to move away from their families to find secure employment. For two, people are having babies in their 40s quite regularly noe and when those children grow up and have kids when they are 40, their parents will be 80+ and outside the window of realistically being full time childminders to grandchildren.

Topgub · 25/09/2022 17:53

@TinaPoopsy52

Yeah given your inability to accept evidence of scientific research I'm calling bullshit on anything you say is a fact.

Tsort · 25/09/2022 17:53

Diverseopinions · 25/09/2022 17:42

Pre the advent of the contraceptive pill (1969?) women used to face the likelihood of falling pregnant. It's hardly surprising that they predicted that their role would be childrearing and keeping the home environment safe and clean. Because of that vital change, I don't think you can compare the two eras. Factor in the lack of labour saving devices in 1950 and the picture, then, looks less rosy.

It upsets me somewhat when men are critisized on MN for putting all their energies into work. I don't think it is considered enough that they might be scared about losing work and want to try very hard to keep their job - in these uncertain times.

I think experiences vary from couple to couple. If you both work with good salaries, you can pay a cleaner and a gardener to do the bulk of the work at home. The early years are difficult because of the cost of childcare, but get easier if you have one child, or maximum two.

People are living longer, healthily, so, today, the option of grandparents helping is more of a reality. Some grandparents will and some won't , but at least they are living healthily into their old age. I think childcare costs are the worst thing about the modern age.

Pre the advent of the contraceptive pill (1969?) women used to face the likelihood of falling pregnant. It's hardly surprising that they predicted that their role would be childrearing and keeping the home environment safe and clean. Because of that vital change, I don't think you can compare the two eras. Factor in the lack of labour saving devices in 1950 and the picture, then, looks less rosy.

The OP says ‘50 years ago’. Not the sixties, and certainly not the 50’s.

It upsets me somewhat when men are critisized on MN for putting all their energies into work. I don't think it is considered enough that they might be scared about losing work and want to try very hard to keep their job - in these uncertain times.

This post isn’t about men. Some women’s inability to have a conversation about anything without centring men is rather depressing. And don’t you think that women ‘might be scared about losing work and want to try very hard to keep their job - in these uncertain times’? No? Just men, then?

I think experiences vary from couple to couple. If you both work with good salaries, you can pay a cleaner and a gardener to do the bulk of the work at home. The early years are difficult because of the cost of childcare, but get easier if you have one child, or maximum two.

Women, statistically, do considerably more housework, across all demographics, regardless of employment or earnings. These are the stats and they are readily available.

People are living longer, healthily, so, today, the option of grandparents helping is more of a reality. Some grandparents will and some won't , but at least they are living healthily into their old age. I think childcare costs are the worst thing about the modern age.

Nothing to do with this post.

OP posts:
Topgub · 25/09/2022 17:52

@TinaPoopsy52

The world would absolutely be worse if only men worked.

Its horrific to think that some women are so mysoginist they literally see women as worthless outside of their scope to be mothers

TinaPoopsy52 · 25/09/2022 17:52

@Topgub

Its actually a fact that children with SAHM have better outcomes and happiness (on average) than those from equivalently earning families from equivalent areas with two working parents or single parent families. It can’t be much clearer than that. SAHM are good for children. Doesn’t mean a child can’t succeed without a SAHM but it just means it’s a little less likely.

bob78 · 25/09/2022 17:50

But seriously - how much do you think your clients or employees really give a shit about you? They’re not your friends, they won’t care if your not in their lives, they’ll replace you with someone similar.

Why are you comparing her clients and colleagues view of her value to your family's value of you, that's not the same thing, it's not comparable. Do you tell your husband is value is less because he's not at home doing the child rearing and house work because he's irreplaceable at work?

Topgub · 25/09/2022 17:49

@Discovereads

Its not a risk factor or a positive factor either.

It has no baring. Except obviously increasing the liklihood of poverty

What risk factor do you think was being stated as a fact?

Working?

TinaPoopsy52 · 25/09/2022 17:47

Topgub · 25/09/2022 17:46

@TinaPoopsy52

And in reality it would make little difference if no women did roles like yours (whatever it is) and that’s what you can’t stand.

You don't think women can make any difference via their employment?

Jeeze.

@Topgub

If you were replaced by a man in your job tomorrow - how would the world be worse for it?
Would anyone other than you even care?

TinaPoopsy52 · 25/09/2022 17:46

Diverseopinions · 25/09/2022 17:42

Pre the advent of the contraceptive pill (1969?) women used to face the likelihood of falling pregnant. It's hardly surprising that they predicted that their role would be childrearing and keeping the home environment safe and clean. Because of that vital change, I don't think you can compare the two eras. Factor in the lack of labour saving devices in 1950 and the picture, then, looks less rosy.

It upsets me somewhat when men are critisized on MN for putting all their energies into work. I don't think it is considered enough that they might be scared about losing work and want to try very hard to keep their job - in these uncertain times.

I think experiences vary from couple to couple. If you both work with good salaries, you can pay a cleaner and a gardener to do the bulk of the work at home. The early years are difficult because of the cost of childcare, but get easier if you have one child, or maximum two.

People are living longer, healthily, so, today, the option of grandparents helping is more of a reality. Some grandparents will and some won't , but at least they are living healthily into their old age. I think childcare costs are the worst thing about the modern age.

@Diverseopinions

People are having kids later though and grandparents may still be working. Through old age or work commitments it’s actually far less likely grandparents will help more.

50 years ago often you would have a 50 something non working grandmother able and wanting to help with kids. It was commonplace. It’s not now.

Discovereads · 25/09/2022 17:46

Topgub · 25/09/2022 17:43

@keepmywifesnameoutchagoddammouth

Yeah.

Your denial isn't helping.

The majority of kids who are 'off the rails' have suffered abuse or poverty or both.

I know you feel you need to justify your role but blaming women for kids being off the rails while moaning about put downs is too much irony.

No stay at home parent is a risk factor though along with divorce, poverty and abuse per the studies done on juvenile delinquency. It’s not ‘blaming women’ by stating a known risk factor.

Topgub · 25/09/2022 17:46

@TinaPoopsy52

And in reality it would make little difference if no women did roles like yours (whatever it is) and that’s what you can’t stand.

You don't think women can make any difference via their employment?

Jeeze.

bob78 · 25/09/2022 17:45

@TinaPoopsy52 but you do realise you have come across as entirely triggered by your choice as well in the way you have responded, are you perhaps insecure about your choices? It works both ways. Let's face it, we've all mostly been at this for hours, it's clearly something we are all interested in, we've all heard the negative comments made to both sides, some on this post, we are all defensive and all sick of this discussion. But here I am still...

keepmywifesnameoutchagoddammouth · 25/09/2022 17:44

bob78 · 25/09/2022 17:40

Right but what's your point there? Our family has financial security but I just don't need to earn it specifically, just take the pressure off the one who does. What point are you trying to make ?

My point is exactly what is written which in response to another poster not you, the poster said workers are replaceable at work and I'm merely stating certain elements of housework are also entirely replaceable, and that my family value what my job brings into the home. Just as I'm sure your family values what you do. It's not a case of one has value and one doesn't. It's all getting done.

Right well I agree with you and agreed with you before.

Topgub · 25/09/2022 17:43

@keepmywifesnameoutchagoddammouth

Yeah.

Your denial isn't helping.

The majority of kids who are 'off the rails' have suffered abuse or poverty or both.

I know you feel you need to justify your role but blaming women for kids being off the rails while moaning about put downs is too much irony.

TinaPoopsy52 · 25/09/2022 17:42

Topgub · 25/09/2022 17:32

@TinaPoopsy52

Lots of people value my roles. My family certainly does. Employers yes. Employees. Client group. Wider society too.

Without roles like mine society would definitely be worse off.

Without women doing roles like mine society would be worse off.

@Topgub

And as I’ve said - you were the one who snidely said “good your family value you - I guess someone has to”. Don’t act like that was anything other than a catty insult.

Anyway I guess it’s good your family values you and you can split that value with your employer.

But seriously - how much do you think your clients or employees really give a shit about you? They’re not your friends, they won’t care if your not in their lives, they’ll replace you with someone similar.

And in reality it would make little difference if no women did roles like yours (whatever it is) and that’s what you can’t stand.

Diverseopinions · 25/09/2022 17:42

Pre the advent of the contraceptive pill (1969?) women used to face the likelihood of falling pregnant. It's hardly surprising that they predicted that their role would be childrearing and keeping the home environment safe and clean. Because of that vital change, I don't think you can compare the two eras. Factor in the lack of labour saving devices in 1950 and the picture, then, looks less rosy.

It upsets me somewhat when men are critisized on MN for putting all their energies into work. I don't think it is considered enough that they might be scared about losing work and want to try very hard to keep their job - in these uncertain times.

I think experiences vary from couple to couple. If you both work with good salaries, you can pay a cleaner and a gardener to do the bulk of the work at home. The early years are difficult because of the cost of childcare, but get easier if you have one child, or maximum two.

People are living longer, healthily, so, today, the option of grandparents helping is more of a reality. Some grandparents will and some won't , but at least they are living healthily into their old age. I think childcare costs are the worst thing about the modern age.

Discovereads · 25/09/2022 17:42

keepmywifesnameoutchagoddammouth · 25/09/2022 17:40

How can you misquote when it's right there?

Deny it all you want but the kids who are off the rails did not have parents who were as hands on as a SAHM can be

You conveniently missed that part. You need to comprehend what I'm saying better. One does not negate the other. A SAHM mum is able to be a hands on parent, so is a working mum, it's just a little more tricky when you work 9 - 5 and school finishes at 3 isn't it unless you have two bodies.

It's a little more tricky when you've been working all day in a demanding job, physically and mentally, to spend 3-7pm focused on your children. Surely you have housework and prep and maybe even work to take home?

And why deny it? I thought it was something wonderful to be proud of that you all have such a stressful demanding job that benefits society.

You should really be writing SAHP instead of SAHM. This is a valuable role that can be done equally well by a mum or a dad.

bob78 · 25/09/2022 17:40

Right but what's your point there? Our family has financial security but I just don't need to earn it specifically, just take the pressure off the one who does. What point are you trying to make ?

My point is exactly what is written which in response to another poster not you, the poster said workers are replaceable at work and I'm merely stating certain elements of housework are also entirely replaceable, and that my family value what my job brings into the home. Just as I'm sure your family values what you do. It's not a case of one has value and one doesn't. It's all getting done.

keepmywifesnameoutchagoddammouth · 25/09/2022 17:40

Topgub · 25/09/2022 17:37

@keepmywifesnameoutchagoddammouth

Yes you did

*Being hands on with parenting will benefit society.

Deny it all you want but the kids who are off the rails did not have parents who were as hands on as a SAHM can be. All the people in our family are functional members of society producing children who are caring and making society better, and it's because of our family values that these types of people come from us.*

The kids who were off the rails did not have parents like sahms. Our family is better because of our values (traditional)

Come on!

Own it

How can you misquote when it's right there?

Deny it all you want but the kids who are off the rails did not have parents who were as hands on as a SAHM can be

You conveniently missed that part. You need to comprehend what I'm saying better. One does not negate the other. A SAHM mum is able to be a hands on parent, so is a working mum, it's just a little more tricky when you work 9 - 5 and school finishes at 3 isn't it unless you have two bodies.

It's a little more tricky when you've been working all day in a demanding job, physically and mentally, to spend 3-7pm focused on your children. Surely you have housework and prep and maybe even work to take home?

And why deny it? I thought it was something wonderful to be proud of that you all have such a stressful demanding job that benefits society.

Topgub · 25/09/2022 17:40

@TinaPoopsy52

Oh dear.

Talk about lacking self awareness.

You can apply all that to yourself.

TinaPoopsy52 · 25/09/2022 17:38

You know I’ve concluded from this thread that though most people (women or men) aren’t pressed by the existence of SAHM, there will always be a subsection of unselfaware career women who are deeply triggered by SAHM on an obvious and emotional level.

Perhaps it comes from them feeling like someone somewhere looked down on them for working a lot and not being a SAHM or home focused mum, or perhaps it’s borne from insecurity from when they leave their kids in daycare and perhaps some relative or so on comments on it - but anyway it’s a product of their own insecurity that they have to scream and cry about their own big important career value and try to devalue SAHM.

I mean if they’re so happy working full time then why do they get so emotionally shaken when SAHM talk about their good experiences and what their kids valued about it? Perhaps they’re just the kinds of fundamentally insecure people who take anyone not living the same lifestyle as them as an insult to their life.

Discovereads · 25/09/2022 17:38

Wouldloveanother · 25/09/2022 16:22

Ah, so in your eyes SAHMs ‘aren’t contributing’.

Now we’ve got down to the crux of your opinions. You think housework and looking after children is a doss job which isn’t deserving of support.

So what this boils down to is jealousy (I say this as a working mum with a ‘traditionally male’ career).

@Wouldloveanother
I agree with you. One of the mistakes old feminism made in the fight for women to have the choice to take on traditionally male roles is they further devalued the status of traditionally female roles. Patriarchy initially devalued them, but first wave feminism continued that. Later feminist thought, which I agree with, is saying hang on traditionally female roles are just as important to society and just as worthy of respect. That’s why it’s really about choice and equality isn’t about making all of us do traditionally male roles, but making all roles equal and making it a free society where women and men can choose how they want to live and contribute.

Swipe left for the next trending thread