Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a lot of women are worse off than 50 years ago?

944 replies

Tsort · 24/09/2022 23:53

A certain type of person is nostalgic for the old days when ‘men were men, and women were women’. I am not. However, it must be noted that at the time when women were expected to be docile acquiescent homemakers, men were expected to foot the bill. They paid for dinner, sorted the mortgage and brought home the bacon. Not for me, but a fair division of labour.

Now, we have a generation of women who ‘pay their way’, go Dutch and refuse to let men pay for them as they don’t want to be indebted. Grand.

But, these same women also do the lion’s share of housework, because ‘men don’t see it’ and shoulder the emotional labour because ‘that’s just the way men are’.

So, women are now shouldering some of the traditionally male burdens while the traditional female burdens have remained firmly in place. How is this an improvement for women? And why do so many tolerate it? This is a profound misunderstanding of feminism and it hurts so many of us.

OP posts:
MsPincher · 25/09/2022 18:53

Sisisisi · 25/09/2022 18:51

So men who parent their own children are gender neutral?
WTAF have I just read ?!

What?????

Sisisisi · 25/09/2022 18:51

So men who parent their own children are gender neutral?
WTAF have I just read ?!

Thepeopleversuswork · 25/09/2022 18:51

@Discovereads

I've quite a lot of literature around the question of whether having two working parents is a risk factor for delinquency and there just isn't any conclusive evidence for it. In fact I've just looked at a 2001 study published by the Oxford University Press (admittedly fairly old but well within the timeframe during which mothers have routinely worked), based on longitudinal data and its conclusion was:

Our findings contradict the view that maternal employment causes child behavioral problems.

There's a very good reason why people who argue that working mothers are bad for children rarely cite evidence for this and that's because there isn't any decent evidence for it.

MsPincher · 25/09/2022 18:51

Discovereads · 25/09/2022 18:43

That’s fantastic. We need more men working in schools and childcare settings. That’s part of the later feminist step….that such work is of value to society and worthy of respect and therefore men can do these jobs too. My DH got all kinds of shit for being a SAHP twenty years ago. Cocklodger, deadbeat, sponger, etc

That’s terrible. My ex used to look after dds one day a week to make the nanny more affordable. Daddy daycare- he was called in the local community! Funny but of course because he was the exception as a man.

Ameadowwalk · 25/09/2022 18:49

to discoverreads I don’t really follow the logic of your argument. Yes, there were class differences in the suffrage movement, but working-class women were active in the campaigns, firstly, and moving away from suffrage, if you consider groups like the Women’s Co-operative Guild, women in the middle and working classes were actively involved in trying to improve women’s lives and campaigning for this. Yes, that needed a voice in political discussion (although whether women even really had power when most of the dominant political and public roles were held by men is another matter), and those arguments were couched in terms of what was considered feminine at the time (and still, women were decried for being manly daring to even encroach on male privilege), but how the heck do we know that women thought something other than what they wrote or argued? At the end of the day, we need to evaluate motives based on the evidence we have, which is what was written and published, not some speculation.

MsPincher · 25/09/2022 18:48

TinaPoopsy52 · 25/09/2022 18:44

@Discovereads

They want to go home to their family, house, pets and toys and relax. They’ve already had the “village” all day long at school. That’s more than enough time.

Mine don’t. They get to play, read, bake do whatever with their friends. There’s a corner to relax in if they want. My oldest likes to chat with the workers and reports back on things going on in the community.

It’s boring at home and they come home at 5:30 anyway.

Discovereads · 25/09/2022 18:47

TinaPoopsy52 · 25/09/2022 18:42

@Discovereads

I think most kids prefer to go home after school than spend more hours there. Seriously what kid wants a 9 hour school day, which is what your essentially creating by leaving them in after school hours care often.

That’s choices we all make as parents and kids are not all the same. As I’ve said my DH was a SAHD for years and so my DC weren’t ever in after school care. But then we had two DC with ASD and the other two had other LDs. So for our kids, they literally couldn’t be in after school or wrap around care. But if you have extroverted NT DCs, from what I understand many DCs are quite happy with it- especially DCs with no siblings. They get all their homework done with help on tap. They get to hang out with friends. Quite often there are activities and crafts…games they can play.

Topgub · 25/09/2022 18:44

@TinaPoopsy52

I didnt say I wasn't replaceable. That's not the question I'm answering

You asked what difference would it make if a man did my role

It would make a difference in lots of ways.

MsPincher · 25/09/2022 18:44

Yes I agree. I felt awful when I got the nanny and went back to work but it was great really as young kids are so full on. I would have gone crazy doing it all day every day. That way they had an engaged caregiver all the time.

TinaPoopsy52 · 25/09/2022 18:44

@Discovereads

They want to go home to their family, house, pets and toys and relax. They’ve already had the “village” all day long at school. That’s more than enough time.

Discovereads · 25/09/2022 18:43

MsPincher · 25/09/2022 18:28

Actually in dds after school club they try to have a balance of male and female staff - best for the children. They are also trying to generally encourage more men into nursery and primary teaching which is a good thing imo. I don’t think children going to childcare is anti feminist in itself.

That’s fantastic. We need more men working in schools and childcare settings. That’s part of the later feminist step….that such work is of value to society and worthy of respect and therefore men can do these jobs too. My DH got all kinds of shit for being a SAHP twenty years ago. Cocklodger, deadbeat, sponger, etc

Diverseopinions · 25/09/2022 18:43

I've had conversations about this topic with some men who grew up in other countries where, for many, the expectation is that men must bring in the money - or else. One was a carer to my son who comes from Romania. He said that men are expected to provide, to be able to pay for hospital care for relatives, to get the biggest and best, and the pressure is hard. The wives are often on their case insinuating that they are a failure if they can't pull in the pounds like other husbands. I don't like that dynamic.

It's fairer to share the load, even if one of you is part time working. Share the childcare duties too.

For me there are so many variations that this is not a big issue. If women want to present themselves as people who see men as a walking wallet, then they might find that the men view them as hard and emotionally unfeeling about them. These men might feel that, when an affair is offered on a plate, that they don't see why they should refuse, as their partner doesn't care about their feelings and health - only whether they are bringing in the money.

There are variations in partnerships and variations in children. Regardless of working, when or if at all, if you are in poor health, things will be hard. If you parent a disabled child who wakes up four times a night, life will be hard. I think pulling together as a team is most important to success, and not forgetting, if the man falls sick or incapacitated, the woman will need to work.

TinaPoopsy52 · 25/09/2022 18:42

@Discovereads

I think most kids prefer to go home after school than spend more hours there. Seriously what kid wants a 9 hour school day, which is what your essentially creating by leaving them in after school hours care often.

Tsort · 25/09/2022 18:40

Discovereads · 25/09/2022 17:57

@Tsort
Women, statistically, do considerably more housework, across all demographics, regardless of employment or earnings. These are the stats and they are readily available.

And men statistically work considerably more hours, across all demographics, regardless of employment or earnings.

I think it is the individual set ups that matter because the statistics don’t tell the whole story.

Yes, and? That quote was a direct response to another poster talking about housework. In what way is ‘men work more hours’ is relevant to either that or the OP?

If you’re having a parallel conversation, that’s got sweet FA to do with me.

OP posts:
Discovereads · 25/09/2022 18:39

MsPincher · 25/09/2022 18:33

Also @Discovereads (while it’s not all about me) after school club seems like quite a fun job for kids of that age. There are a mix of older ladies and younger men and women who do it and several from the community have told me they do it because they enjoy it. Also given that many of the leaders are community elders I don’t think it’s a bad thing for the kids either. Takes a village and all that.

Oh I agree, they’re not bad things. But I know many working mothers who feel the guilt for using them…guilt I think is mostly caused by socialisation stressing outdated views about what a good mother should do and feel.

MsPincher · 25/09/2022 18:37

TinaPoopsy52 · 25/09/2022 18:34

@Topgub

Unless you are the only one who can do your profession, are some esteemed world leader or athlete - or are the creator and ceo of a massive company, you are replaceable at work. That’s just the truth for anyone. It’s not an insult but it’s the truth. A parent isn’t replaceable by a nanny to their child, that it also the truth.

A parent is replaceable by a nanny for childcare not AS A PARENT. I’m a parent and I always was. Yet I have had a nanny. She didn’t replace me just liked after my children for a while (and now they don’t remember her at all).

MsPincher · 25/09/2022 18:35

Thepeopleversuswork · 25/09/2022 18:00

This in spades.

If a higher cost of living and more women having to work is the price we pay for being treated as legal adults, having the right not to be raped by our own husbands and being able to walk away from an abusive or unsatisfactory marriage then I'll take that thanks very much.

Yes I think this is it. Being an adult is not always easy but I wouldn’t have it any other way.

TinaPoopsy52 · 25/09/2022 18:34

@Topgub

Unless you are the only one who can do your profession, are some esteemed world leader or athlete - or are the creator and ceo of a massive company, you are replaceable at work. That’s just the truth for anyone. It’s not an insult but it’s the truth. A parent isn’t replaceable by a nanny to their child, that it also the truth.

MsPincher · 25/09/2022 18:33

Also @Discovereads (while it’s not all about me) after school club seems like quite a fun job for kids of that age. There are a mix of older ladies and younger men and women who do it and several from the community have told me they do it because they enjoy it. Also given that many of the leaders are community elders I don’t think it’s a bad thing for the kids either. Takes a village and all that.

Topgub · 25/09/2022 18:32

@TinaPoopsy52

Youve no idea what role I do. None.

Do you have a link for your claim children are happier with a sahm?

@Discovereads

What's your claim based on?

TinaPoopsy52 · 25/09/2022 18:31

MsPincher · 25/09/2022 18:24

I think it probably depends on the age of the children re financial equivalent of sahp. I had to have a nanny plus cleaner when they were little but now just after school club plus cleaner so less than £1k a month. I would probably have the cleaner anyway though as I hate to clean.

@MsPincher

A nanny isn’t capable of being a replacement for an actual parent. Someone else doing the same job as you is capable of being your replacement at work.

MsPincher · 25/09/2022 18:28

Discovereads · 25/09/2022 18:22

Yes they did write those things. But when I read them, I saw very clever middle class and upper class women trying to reassure these men in power that they were what were considered sane and reasonable, natural women for the times. I think they wrote their arguments in such a way because if they hadn’t said it was “for their children” and supporting good “motherhood” they’d quite literally be branded as lunatics. But the reality is most of the campaigners were not working class, and so they already had nursemaid, nannies, cooks, housemaids and so on. They weren’t doing these female roles. It was about entire lives of non working class women wasted on frivolities like fashion and crushing boredom. They wanted access to the professions and societies of men, to political power.

They weren’t really fighting to not do what their female servants did…that work was still viewed as beneath them and very much as work of little value, the lot of the working class woman.

You still see it a bit, with posters arguing that the “feminist” choice means hiring another woman to clean, childmind…

Actually in dds after school club they try to have a balance of male and female staff - best for the children. They are also trying to generally encourage more men into nursery and primary teaching which is a good thing imo. I don’t think children going to childcare is anti feminist in itself.

Discovereads · 25/09/2022 18:25

MsPincher · 25/09/2022 18:20

I find that unlikely or if it is it’s just correlation not causation. There’s a lot of negative data on single parents but once you control for relationship breakdown and poverty there is no difference in outcomes between single parent families and two parent families.

Yes, that’s true for single parent families vs two parent families after the divorce aftershock period. But not the case for two parent families where both parents work FT vs one parent being a SAHP. The studies have shown it as a risk factor. So that means one of many potential causes.

MsPincher · 25/09/2022 18:24

bob78 · 25/09/2022 18:05

@TinaPoopsy52 nor do I but I'm still valued at work. Ok I'm not saying it's the same as my value as a mother obviously, I could resign tomorrow and the job would get done, but I think I bring something special to my role that others don't, one of those MN niche skills lol, and yes I would be missed. I go to work feeling the value in what I do knowing I make a difference as many working people do. I don't agree what someone has said to you that you don't have value to society, that's not fair and I don't agree with that, didn't they say years ago the financial equivalent of a SAHM is £35k, not that it's about money. But I don't think it's fair to belittle what working people do either.

I think it probably depends on the age of the children re financial equivalent of sahp. I had to have a nanny plus cleaner when they were little but now just after school club plus cleaner so less than £1k a month. I would probably have the cleaner anyway though as I hate to clean.

Discovereads · 25/09/2022 18:22

Ameadowwalk · 25/09/2022 18:13

to discoverreads - how did first wave feminism devalue the status of traditionally female roles? i thought one of the key arguments in the campaign for suffrage was that women’s role as nurturers and their (perceived at the time) moral superiority would improve politics. In other words, the campaign for the vote - while on the surface about gaining equality - was grounded in difference between men and women, in what ‘traditional feminine values’ would bring to the political and public sphere. Campaigners also argued that women needed the vote, education and access to the professions to protect their children and promote welfare. One article supporting the extension of the franchise noted that ‘questions relating to morality, education, the care of children […] may be regarded as the surroundings of the home […] men can do some kinds of work better than women, who are in other respects superior’. This type of argument (written by a man) was based entirely on the idea of difference between the sexes.

Emmeline Pankhurst was herself a single parent to four children after the death of her husband.

Plus, in the aftermath of the First World War, women outnumbered men by 1 200 000. There was no way for all these women to take on traditional female roles within marriage. But even if you go back to the 1860s, the 1861 census showed that there were 500 000 odd more women than men. What were those women to do but seek education and employment? Why should they - and indeed married women - not be interested in the concerns of life beyond their own domestic sphere? But they had to make their arguments to gain access to the public sphere precisely around ideas of feminine virtues, not the absence of them.

Yes they did write those things. But when I read them, I saw very clever middle class and upper class women trying to reassure these men in power that they were what were considered sane and reasonable, natural women for the times. I think they wrote their arguments in such a way because if they hadn’t said it was “for their children” and supporting good “motherhood” they’d quite literally be branded as lunatics. But the reality is most of the campaigners were not working class, and so they already had nursemaid, nannies, cooks, housemaids and so on. They weren’t doing these female roles. It was about entire lives of non working class women wasted on frivolities like fashion and crushing boredom. They wanted access to the professions and societies of men, to political power.

They weren’t really fighting to not do what their female servants did…that work was still viewed as beneath them and very much as work of little value, the lot of the working class woman.

You still see it a bit, with posters arguing that the “feminist” choice means hiring another woman to clean, childmind…

Swipe left for the next trending thread