Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hope that we welcome men fleeing Russia

354 replies

MindYourBeeswax · 24/09/2022 17:07

Many are fleeing Putin's Press Gangs.
The EU Council President has recommended that the EU offer them asylum.

It must be bloody terrifying and, although we're not in the EU longer, I hope that this government follow his example and offer sanctuary as we have done for fleeing Ukrainians.

I know that they will be young men and not need to live with families in the same way that Ukrainian women and children did so although that would be ideal, it's not essential and hostels/hotels could be used.

Will you offer a home if asked? I can't but I would like to help in some way.
AIBU to hope that we will help these fleeing Russians?

OP posts:
Quincythequince · 25/09/2022 08:43

LOL. Let’s just bring hoards of non-English men, with no jobs, little money, no family, from what anybody with any sense can see is to be perceived as an Enemy state (for most Countries that is)
whose leader regularly threaten to blow us up, vet them, and pay for them including resettlement.

Hoards of young, displaced Russian men.

No thank you!

Georgia has said ‘no way’, so has Lithuania. That list is going to increase rapidly.

Hoppinggreen · 25/09/2022 08:40

DH used to do business in Russia and has quite a few contacts there.
He is in regular contact with them, they are well educated, intelligent middle class business people and most are Pro Putin. Some are neutral but the younger ones (20s - 30s) are particularly strong in their support for his actions.
I also know people from an ethnic group in Russia who are not treated especially well by The Regime and quite a few of them were effectively conscripted last year. Even THEY think that Putin has been forced to act due to threats from NATO.
The majority of men trying to flee Russia now are anti having to fight rather than anti Putin

Quincythequince · 25/09/2022 08:40

Porcupineintherough · 25/09/2022 08:33

@Quincythequince I would have thought that would give us more reason to want to thwart the Russians, not less.

That’s not about not wanting to beat them, of course anyone does, but that’s a NATO decision as you well know. And what an overly simplistic view if you think us letting in a bunch of Russians fleeing only now, will help this.

No sane government, under the current circumstances and timings, would reasonably take a bunch of Russian defectors who are doing so, because the going has finally gotten tough…for them personally.

Porcupineintherough · 25/09/2022 08:33

@Quincythequince I would have thought that would give us more reason to want to thwart the Russians, not less.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 25/09/2022 08:31

@MindYourBeeswax
We have a dire shortage of reasonable, affordable housing, though. Especially in areas with jobs, where people want to live.

Whammyyammy · 25/09/2022 08:30

Can't belive it's taken 214 days for all these young men to now disagree with the invasion of Ukraine and the murdering of its citizens.... and coincidentally all at the same time.....

Quincythequince · 25/09/2022 08:28

Porcupineintherough · 25/09/2022 08:24

Thia is not the Vietnam war and we are not Canada

Can you spell out the differences because the situations seem superficially similar to me.

I quite like the sound of a world where men could just refuse to fight.

Vietnam didn’t threaten to blow Ottawa off the map regularly, and send spies Over there to poison people for a start.

It also didn’t infiltrate Canada’s government with dirty money blatantly try to swing elections (including, in part Brexit).

That’s just for starters.

Porcupineintherough · 25/09/2022 08:24

Thia is not the Vietnam war and we are not Canada

Can you spell out the differences because the situations seem superficially similar to me.

I quite like the sound of a world where men could just refuse to fight.

Quincythequince · 25/09/2022 08:24

Raddix · 25/09/2022 08:15

They are not fleeing racial or religious persecution. They are not taking their families to safety from these things, or to avoid starvation. They don't want to be called up.
You don’t think being forced to fight and die in an unjust war is a form of persecution? These people are literally being sent to their deaths, and if they say no they get imprisoned in camps for years on end.

But they were happy to stay there whilst their country was bombing the shit out of their neighbours, and just go about their lives.

And if you can’t protest (which I believe) doesn’t that show you how Totalitarian this regime actually is anyway, and shouldn’t you be aiming to flee for that reason alone,
if it’s that’s bad?

But no, stay and live your life until you are required to fight, but not issue before then!

Yeah, I don’t think so.

Russians are overwhelmingly in support of this war (my DH new employee who left Russia has broadly confirmed this to be true and he was a voice on the ground alrhough decided to move months ago).

Many aren’t of course, why haven’t they already left.

Whammyyammy · 25/09/2022 08:23

These extra 300k untrained civilians drafted to the front line won't do well against battle hardened ukraine with Western weapons, training and their love of their country.

Maybe the russia popularity might not think its such a great thing anymore and change their attitude and do something...

Raddix · 25/09/2022 08:15

They are not fleeing racial or religious persecution. They are not taking their families to safety from these things, or to avoid starvation. They don't want to be called up.
You don’t think being forced to fight and die in an unjust war is a form of persecution? These people are literally being sent to their deaths, and if they say no they get imprisoned in camps for years on end.

Losinghope9 · 25/09/2022 08:10

Posted too soon, however I felt the same way with Ukraine. Our country is struggling, there are people in desperate need of housi

Losinghope9 · 25/09/2022 08:09

Absolutely not, and it's nothing to do with them being Russian, there are many Russians who are against the war, they are not all evil.

However I felt the same

Raddix · 25/09/2022 08:08

Givenuptotally · 25/09/2022 00:28

Theres not a shortage of worker ,there a shortage of people who want to work

are you sure about that? I mean, those on benefits long term could absolutely manage the healthcare and teacher recruitment crisis’ we are currently experiencing? That’s aside from social care, cleaning, general dogsbody vacancies that need filling in their thousands?

I agree that unskilled people could do the latter. But do you really think long term unemployed people would be suitable to be teachers or nurses?!

Anyway, the teacher recruitment crisis isn’t due to lack of people. There are loads of qualified teachers, including myself - we just don’t want to work as teachers because the pay and conditions are so poor.

zoeFromCity · 25/09/2022 03:04

The only men who are able to flee Russia now are the wealthy now. Ticket prices skyrocketed, if they are on conscription lists, a massive bribe is needed for flighing away.
Many of them are people who support the war, just feel entitled to not fight it. The others are still from wealthy families. This isn't a kind of men which would happily take low prestige jobs.

I am in a country which took many Ukrainian immigrants and I support our government's position to not open up for Russian men. I can't imagine what would happen if large number of Ukrainian refugee women has to compete for jobs and cheaper rent with large number of Russian men while their own men are fighting against the invasion, it just seems very wrong.

Givenuptotally · 25/09/2022 00:28

Theres not a shortage of worker ,there a shortage of people who want to work

are you sure about that? I mean, those on benefits long term could absolutely manage the healthcare and teacher recruitment crisis’ we are currently experiencing? That’s aside from social care, cleaning, general dogsbody vacancies that need filling in their thousands?

Goatling · 24/09/2022 23:30

No way, thousands of Ukraine men have had no choice about fighting for their country so why should we take in Russians who are running away.

GetRichOrDieTrying · 24/09/2022 23:16

MrsFezziwig · 24/09/2022 22:10

Patronising people certainly won’t win them over to your point of view.

The OP doesn’t want to win anyone over, she just wants to sneer at people who aren’t virtue signaling as hard.

MrsFezziwig · 24/09/2022 22:45

Everyone I know in Russia is against this war

Then they need to stand up and be counted. We can’t do it for them.

Quincythequince · 24/09/2022 22:28

CPL593H · 24/09/2022 22:12

I don't actually care very much if the war bothered them before the last few days (and I rather doubt it did, most of them) They are not fleeing racial or religious persecution. They are not taking their families to safety from these things, or to avoid starvation. They don't want to be called up.

Russia is their country and Putin is their leader. I suggest that if sufficient numbers of these young people make their feelings known, or mutiny when they get to the front, there might be significant change. It's happened before, after all. It is on them, it has to be. we can't do it for them and they can't do it from a B and B in Cleethorpes (or where ever)

I'll reserve my sympathy for (eg) the Afghan people who oppose the Taliban and are still holed up in the Panjshir valley and of course the invaded people of Ukraine.

Agree.

And the PP details some of the atrocities of war and its horrid.

But only now leaving despite being so against this regime? And only when the personal risk to him is too great?

And people are saying the British are to screen, vet, resettle and support all these fleeing men?

It’s easy to make a decision with a quick cost-benefit analysis of the situation, and the risk is too high to allow large numbers of Russian males to mass migrate on someone else’s tab.

It’s shit, terrible in fact but why is this now everyone else’s problem.

I’d have had more sympathy if they left at the start saying genuinely I object and won’t stay here to watch this.

But no, leaving now because it directly impacts them… now they want sympathy.

I’ll take 10000 ex Ukrainian fighters when the war is over before one of these.

And what about all these other countries where there has been mass civil war/ infighting over the years.

Don’t see people making a desperate case to ship over loads of Palestinians or soldiers from various African countries do you.

MrsFezziwig · 24/09/2022 22:28

Kendodd · 24/09/2022 19:38

I'm torn on this. I think they should stay and overthrow Putin. Everyone against this war leaving Russia just makes life easier for Putin, plus, if they actually are conscripted and deployed, I don't thing they would be the most ruthless fighters and we might have mutiny in Russia ranks.

As for staying in my house, I have some Ukrainians already so yes, would take a Russia.

What would the Ukrainians think of this?

MrsFezziwig · 24/09/2022 22:27

I’ve read that there are 300,000 reservists in Russia (although some say this number is exaggerated). Maybe if they all started dissenting at home instead of fleeing the country there might be a chance of Putin being overthrown.

MrsFezziwig · 24/09/2022 22:16

MindYourBeeswax · 24/09/2022 20:21

Yes, it is generally the case that when nearly a third agree then two thirds don't.!

Did they not teach you that when you " were working with the Commission?"

Maybe they thought it was so obvious they didn't need to point it out to you.

Hilarious that you’re accusing people of insulting you when you’re coming out with patronising claptrap like this.

CPL593H · 24/09/2022 22:12

Raddix · 24/09/2022 22:00

Putin has started calling up civilians. Other civilians have gone “shit I’m next” and scarpered while they still can.

How can you know if the war bothered them before now? You can’t judge based on whether they protested - they aren’t allowed to protest otherwise they get locked up or killed. There are things in the UK which I object to but I don’t protest about them because the consequences would be too severe.

I don't actually care very much if the war bothered them before the last few days (and I rather doubt it did, most of them) They are not fleeing racial or religious persecution. They are not taking their families to safety from these things, or to avoid starvation. They don't want to be called up.

Russia is their country and Putin is their leader. I suggest that if sufficient numbers of these young people make their feelings known, or mutiny when they get to the front, there might be significant change. It's happened before, after all. It is on them, it has to be. we can't do it for them and they can't do it from a B and B in Cleethorpes (or where ever)

I'll reserve my sympathy for (eg) the Afghan people who oppose the Taliban and are still holed up in the Panjshir valley and of course the invaded people of Ukraine.

MrsFezziwig · 24/09/2022 22:10

MindYourBeeswax · 24/09/2022 20:05

It's a hard subject isn't it,! Don't worry.

Patronising people certainly won’t win them over to your point of view.