Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hope that we welcome men fleeing Russia

354 replies

MindYourBeeswax · 24/09/2022 17:07

Many are fleeing Putin's Press Gangs.
The EU Council President has recommended that the EU offer them asylum.

It must be bloody terrifying and, although we're not in the EU longer, I hope that this government follow his example and offer sanctuary as we have done for fleeing Ukrainians.

I know that they will be young men and not need to live with families in the same way that Ukrainian women and children did so although that would be ideal, it's not essential and hostels/hotels could be used.

Will you offer a home if asked? I can't but I would like to help in some way.
AIBU to hope that we will help these fleeing Russians?

OP posts:
Suetwo · 25/09/2022 14:12

I admire anyone who opposes the invasion on moral grounds and chooses to leave Russia rather than fight. Unfortunately, having an open door policy will lead to problems. Why? Because people will take advantage. They always do. It’s the same with the benefits system. I’m not saying we shouldn’t have a benefits system (we should), and I’m not saying we shouldn’t help Russian men fleeing Russia (we should), all I AM saying is be realistic and sensible. Real life isn’t like a sickly Hollywood movie. Lots of the Russians who move to Germany or the U.K. will just be rootless young men who see an opportunity to start a new life in a rich country. It’s the same with the channel migrants. We keep being told they are “frightened refugees, fleeing war and persecution.” Then you look at the footage of people arriving and see nothing but fit young men (where are the women and children and old people? Presumably left behind to face the “war and persecution”).

LaBellina · 25/09/2022 13:56

We can’t provide asylum for the whole world. Besides, many of them have supported the war before, my sympathy is with the Ukrainians.

Whammyyammy · 25/09/2022 13:47

whumpthereitis · 25/09/2022 13:35

No, a lot of them haven’t. There’s been a LOT of anti war activism happening within Russia, and not just in regards to the protests.

and there are Russians fighting for Ukraine, with support coming for them from within Russia as well. There’s not a lot of information out there about them because there can’t be.

amp.theguardian.com/world/2022/jun/14/russians-fighting-for-ukraine

Well I'm only going by what's been reported and fact checked, I don't have access to russian resistance movements. What I do know is:

Russia invaded Ukraine ✔️
Residential areas deliberately bombed✔️
Mass graves of civilians ✔️
Mass looting in Ukraine ✔️
Women and children raped ✔️

Threats of nuclear weapons by Russian leader regularly added to the mix.

The Russian people can either

  1. Support thier leader
  2. Flee Russia
3 .Mass protests

I've only seen 1 and now 2, the odd minor protest has been reported, but considering the size of their population, its very small %..so can only conclude that its a minority against the above atrocities

whumpthereitis · 25/09/2022 13:39

www.express.co.uk/news/world/1648470/russia-news-legion-freedom-battalions-ukraine-war-putin-latest/amp

“Igor Sushko, director of the Wind of Change Research Group, a think tank based in Washington, DC, told Express.co.uk: "[The group] started some time ago, since the beginning of the invasion. Some Russian soldiers decided to surrender [to Ukraine] and were allowed to, over time and after some training, fight for Ukraine.

"There's active recruitment going on inside Russia for volunteers to come fight. So these are Russians, it is all completely comprised of Russians fighting against Putin’s regime."

However, Mr Suskho says they are now recruiting civilians inside of Russia who are opposed to the war to carry out various anti-Kremlin activities.“

Maireas · 25/09/2022 13:39

I'm watching those brave women in Iran. They can be imprisoned and killed for breaking the "morality" laws, eg wearing a headscarf loosely.
They're on the streets, taking off headscarves, cutting their hair.
I wish we could give asylum to every girl and woman there, but we can't.
So many world problems. How do we select?

whumpthereitis · 25/09/2022 13:35

Whammyyammy · 25/09/2022 13:28

But they have supported since the invasion, only now do they flee or act.
Maybe they cross the border to help repel the invaders or rebuild ukraine?

No, a lot of them haven’t. There’s been a LOT of anti war activism happening within Russia, and not just in regards to the protests.

and there are Russians fighting for Ukraine, with support coming for them from within Russia as well. There’s not a lot of information out there about them because there can’t be.

amp.theguardian.com/world/2022/jun/14/russians-fighting-for-ukraine

whumpthereitis · 25/09/2022 13:30

CPL593H · 25/09/2022 12:53

@whumpthereitis I'm sorry you've been made to feel like that. As I say, neither are words I would ever use to describe any race or nationality (although I'd use far worse to personally describe Putin and his henchmen)

Of course no nationality is intrinsically "bad". The Russian people have been through more than many over the centuries, including within living memory and it is easy to say that Putin should have been stopped before we got to this point but harder to do. However, we are where we are. He is Russia's leader, he is making threats against the safety of the UK (and the entire planet) and there are in reality plenty of people who do support him or who will always be too frightened to take action. What are we in the West meant to do? Invade Russia? Effectively it is the problem of the Russian people to deal with and it won't be easy. We can't do it for them, though.

I’m sorry, I’m being clumsy with my words. I’m not hurt, but I am wary. I grew up in Yugoslavia, I’ve seen first hand the consequences of ‘othering’ people based on their ethnicity. That didn’t just happen overnight, it started with language.

I do fully agree with your points. It’s not as simple as just taking people. And yes, ultimately change has to happen from within Russia. Unfortunately, that won’t happen overnight either.

Whammyyammy · 25/09/2022 13:28

whumpthereitis · 25/09/2022 13:22

‘Draft dodgers’, as if it’s shameful to want to ‘dodge’ fighting in an aggressive war.

Plenty of them will have been protesting from the beginning, for what good it’s done them or Ukraine.

So you think people should be conscripted to fight a war they don’t support, in order for them to be killed easily?

But they have supported since the invasion, only now do they flee or act.
Maybe they cross the border to help repel the invaders or rebuild ukraine?

Jedsnewstar · 25/09/2022 13:26

Nope nope nope. They made their bed.

whumpthereitis · 25/09/2022 13:25

Whammyyammy · 25/09/2022 13:21

If they only wish to leave now, and have thought it OK to stay for the past 200+ days, the only difference now is the fact they will be called up to fight. Is that not dodging the draft?

And my sympathies lie with the Ukrainians, the ones that have been invaded, the ones that have had residential areas repeatedly bombed, the ones buried in mass graves, the ones that have been raped.
Sorry, but Putin has dragged Russia back behind the iron curtain, he was elected in and is supported by his people.

Ah yes, the free and fair Russian elections, because Russia is of course a country notable for its democratic freedoms.

Many want to leave now because it’s got to the point where it’s leave or be forced to fight. Plenty will have stayed because, like many here are saying they should, they actually wanted to try and force change by being present and protesting in their own country.

My sympathies lie with the Ukrainians too. They also lie with Russians.

whumpthereitis · 25/09/2022 13:22

Whammyyammy · 25/09/2022 13:02

The western world shouldn't accept these draft dodgers as only now it affects then do they act (run away)and shloud keep its borders closed to Russians, increase sanctions and concentrate on keeping ukraune armed.

Ukraine are repelling the trained army, conscripts won't last long, and hopefully the Russians withdraw from their invasion/mass murders/raping/looting

‘Draft dodgers’, as if it’s shameful to want to ‘dodge’ fighting in an aggressive war.

Plenty of them will have been protesting from the beginning, for what good it’s done them or Ukraine.

So you think people should be conscripted to fight a war they don’t support, in order for them to be killed easily?

Whammyyammy · 25/09/2022 13:21

gnilliwdog · 25/09/2022 13:15

Draft Dodgers? I think that's ridiculous language. Not everyone is up for killing fellow humans. Not everyone can leave their country when they want. Protest makes no difference if your country goes to war, as we saw with Iraq. I am all for putting our own first and don't want to take anyone in unless it's to our own advantage, but I can own that without demonising people.

If they only wish to leave now, and have thought it OK to stay for the past 200+ days, the only difference now is the fact they will be called up to fight. Is that not dodging the draft?

And my sympathies lie with the Ukrainians, the ones that have been invaded, the ones that have had residential areas repeatedly bombed, the ones buried in mass graves, the ones that have been raped.
Sorry, but Putin has dragged Russia back behind the iron curtain, he was elected in and is supported by his people.

gnilliwdog · 25/09/2022 13:15

Draft Dodgers? I think that's ridiculous language. Not everyone is up for killing fellow humans. Not everyone can leave their country when they want. Protest makes no difference if your country goes to war, as we saw with Iraq. I am all for putting our own first and don't want to take anyone in unless it's to our own advantage, but I can own that without demonising people.

Whammyyammy · 25/09/2022 13:02

The western world shouldn't accept these draft dodgers as only now it affects then do they act (run away)and shloud keep its borders closed to Russians, increase sanctions and concentrate on keeping ukraune armed.

Ukraine are repelling the trained army, conscripts won't last long, and hopefully the Russians withdraw from their invasion/mass murders/raping/looting

CPL593H · 25/09/2022 12:53

@whumpthereitis I'm sorry you've been made to feel like that. As I say, neither are words I would ever use to describe any race or nationality (although I'd use far worse to personally describe Putin and his henchmen)

Of course no nationality is intrinsically "bad". The Russian people have been through more than many over the centuries, including within living memory and it is easy to say that Putin should have been stopped before we got to this point but harder to do. However, we are where we are. He is Russia's leader, he is making threats against the safety of the UK (and the entire planet) and there are in reality plenty of people who do support him or who will always be too frightened to take action. What are we in the West meant to do? Invade Russia? Effectively it is the problem of the Russian people to deal with and it won't be easy. We can't do it for them, though.

whumpthereitis · 25/09/2022 12:34

CPL593H · 25/09/2022 12:23

I have no problem in accepting that some of the men attempting to leave Russia in the last few days will be genuine activists against the regime (ones that haven't been arrested, obviously) but can guarantee that ALL of them without exception will be vehemently anti Putin when being interviewed at their destinations. There is no way of sorting out the wheat from the chaff, the people who genuinely oppose the regime, from the ones quite happy about the invasion of Ukraine as long as they don't have to do any actual fighting, from the security services plants. Quite a lot did leave soon after 24/2 and they are understandably viewed and treated differently.

I certainly do not consider Russians "subhuman" (I haven't actually seen that vile and loaded word used on this thread, but could have missed it) or "orcs". All of us are aware there are protesters against the thug regime they have in charge and know how brave those people are. It doesn't mean that we are obliged to take in tens of thousands of Russians who have decided to leave their country to avoid being called up, to the potential detriment of our own security.

i’m not saying that the UK should take them in. I don’t actually think the UK is in the best position to.

My point is that it’s very easy to say ‘well, they need to change it then’, especially when you’ve never been in that position, having to ask yourself whether you can even make a difference, whether it’s worth being arrested and tortured, or whether you want to risk having your children taken to detention camps. Even in spite of all that, it’s not like people haven’t been trying. They have.

Calling an entire population ‘the orcs’ is calling them subhuman, by definition. I’m half Russian, does that make me 50% orc? What degree of blood denotes me as a write off? Am I considered to have a redeeming 50%, or is it akin to a rotten apple where you throw the whole thing away?

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 25/09/2022 12:29

Fill the country full of young fit men who also happen to be our enemy. Yeah sounds like a great plan. What could possibly go wrong?

This. Absolutely no way, OP.

Hard as it sounds, Russian men haven’t been bother about Putin until they were affected personally. They need to stay and do something about him.

CPL593H · 25/09/2022 12:23

I have no problem in accepting that some of the men attempting to leave Russia in the last few days will be genuine activists against the regime (ones that haven't been arrested, obviously) but can guarantee that ALL of them without exception will be vehemently anti Putin when being interviewed at their destinations. There is no way of sorting out the wheat from the chaff, the people who genuinely oppose the regime, from the ones quite happy about the invasion of Ukraine as long as they don't have to do any actual fighting, from the security services plants. Quite a lot did leave soon after 24/2 and they are understandably viewed and treated differently.

I certainly do not consider Russians "subhuman" (I haven't actually seen that vile and loaded word used on this thread, but could have missed it) or "orcs". All of us are aware there are protesters against the thug regime they have in charge and know how brave those people are. It doesn't mean that we are obliged to take in tens of thousands of Russians who have decided to leave their country to avoid being called up, to the potential detriment of our own security.

walkingonsunshinekat · 25/09/2022 12:17

SpangledShambles · 25/09/2022 10:51

This is the issue many Russians are facing – they are being conscripted. However I agree with other posters in that there are many people who need our help and they’re already here, people who have been driven from their homes by wars our country was quite happy to get involved with. However, I disagree with posters saying Russians are the enemy – they are not. Putin and his government may be the enemy, but normal Russians are just human beings like us. Hating people for their nationality - there’s a name for that.

Believing Russians are the enemy of the West, isn't hating or xenophobic.

As i said earlier, if Iranian women can stand up against machine guns, then so can ordinary Russians and there are some exceptionally brave Russians opposing Putin.

Western former soldiers have gone and died, been beaten & captured fighting for Ukraine - if they can do this, then fit young ex soldiers can fight for their own country.

But if you genuinely do believe Russians are not our enemy, then let them in, we have nothing fear do we?

Pengwinn · 25/09/2022 12:15

I just think if propaganda is being used as a justification for inaction then surely those people who believed it wouldn't be so against fighting.

Pengwinn · 25/09/2022 12:15

whumpthereitis · 25/09/2022 12:09

You’re assuming that those protesting and fleeing are the same ones believing the government line. Of course there will be overlap, but that does not reflect the entirety of the situation.

As a rule, it is those living in cities are more able to access information as to what is actually going on. A lot of, if not most of, these people are the ones that have been opposed to the war from the beginning.

As I said earlier in the thread hopefully those who were protesting and are now against this find safety, but those who believed the propaganda then should surely feel strongly enough to want to fight now. Unless- many were apathetic as long as it was someone else in the firing line, in which case no thanks.

whumpthereitis · 25/09/2022 12:13

It’s very easy to sit back from a position of safety, judge these people, and say they should have been doing more. No one here has to seriously consider the repercussions in their own lives.

whumpthereitis · 25/09/2022 12:09

Pengwinn · 25/09/2022 11:59

For those that are so brainwashed though surely they would welcome taking up arms for their country, no? If they believe the narrative being spun and were happy to accept that then its only as they are now at risk that they're concerned.

You’re assuming that those protesting and fleeing are the same ones believing the government line. Of course there will be overlap, but that does not reflect the entirety of the situation.

As a rule, it is those living in cities are more able to access information as to what is actually going on. A lot of, if not most of, these people are the ones that have been opposed to the war from the beginning.

whumpthereitis · 25/09/2022 12:05

www.compas.ox.ac.uk/2022/on-the-anti-war-movement-in-russia-from-street-protests-to-guerrilla-activism/

and here’s some information the recent history of Russian activism, and what is actually happening within Russia in regards to the anti-war movement:

www.compas.ox.ac.uk/2022/on-the-anti-war-movement-in-russia-from-street-protests-to-guerrilla-activism/

Feel free to take a read, or don’t. Just continue to write of an entire ethnicity as ‘orcs’ and subhuman.

Pengwinn · 25/09/2022 11:59

whumpthereitis · 25/09/2022 11:41

To those saying Russians support the war - you know the vast majority don’t have access to the same information we do, as to what is actually happening? They believe what is being reported to them. Shit, it’s not like there aren’t propaganda channels in the west, where people do have significantly more freedom when it comes to accessing alternatives, that have their viewers unquestioningly believing them.

That said, a lot of these men fleeing were the ones opposed to the war. They were the ones protesting. A lot of them didn’t flee then because they did want to stay and try and force change within their own country (as if it’s that fucking easy). They’re fleeing now because they don’t want to be forced into fighting a war they don’t believe in, they don’t want to be sent to kill and/or die.

For those that are so brainwashed though surely they would welcome taking up arms for their country, no? If they believe the narrative being spun and were happy to accept that then its only as they are now at risk that they're concerned.