Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how to teach my female daughter to be more assertive?

30 replies

noliquidassets · 24/09/2022 16:57

Okay, so I may be getting ahead of myself, but I have a toddler DD. I've noticed that with her big cousins (same age) she will be very passive/let them hit or push her/just hand over her toys. She isn't upset by their behaviour but doesn't react.
Before I get flamed, I'm not wanting her to batter them but it would be nice for her to push back a bit.
I do challenge and say things like:

No, you've both got one so you can keep yours
It's okay, you can move his hands etc

It's hard as I don't want to teach her to hit them though!

I am not a passive person with DH, and mine/DHs relationship is relatively equal. We are respectful to each other.

I'm just worried I'm doing something wrong

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
noliquidassets · 25/09/2022 10:18

@justdontkno1 sorry if that came across as shade to SAHPs or anything but I meant in the sense of instilling the need to make use of the education we get in the U.K., get qualifications so that she has a chance to work and if shit ever hits the fan she will know she can support herself. Each to their own but I personally don't like to feel fully reliant on another person financially.
Also yes re attachment, definitely get the importance.

OP posts:
justdontkno1 · 25/09/2022 08:50

@noliquidassets same with my boys. There generally pretty easy going and I’ve noticed particularly with a girl in our estate bossing them and taking stuff off them. I try to increase their confidence and tell them it’s ok to say no and ask for things back so they do and are able to say no and when to tell someone to back off.
With my youngest ds I found it so irritating recently at a party where a girl kept at him and jumping on him and he said several times to stop, “stop touching me” etc but she wouldn’t so I had to help him out as he’s young , the mums though it was hilarious, funny enough I can imagine the other way around not so much…
Regardless of whether you work or are a sahp you can instill confidence in children, not sure what the relevance was to working there..In fact I think resilience is built on from the start , like many child psychologists echo re attachment leading (breastfeeding, good healthy attachment to main caregiver in the early two years) to a more confident, resilient, emotional healthy adult. So the first 2/3 years are paramount imho.

oddoneoutalways · 25/09/2022 08:39

I think OP, what you're trying to teach your daughter is so important. I am a mum of two girls (preschool and young primary age) and it astounds me sometimes when I read on here of grown women who get in a terrible flap around just saying 'no' to someone, or asserting themselves.

I am neurodivergent and I think - for me - one of the benefits that is I have far less self consciousness around being direct than my neurotypical friends do. It doesn't register with me often to be bothered if people think I'm a bit bolshy because I'm happy to assert myself. I don't care.

It displeases some people sometimes, but I am never rude (really I'm not, I might be ND but I'm nearly 40, I know what rude is), always polite but firm. One of my children is also ND (she's a mini me) and so it's really important to me that she's clear on her own boundaries especially regarding physical safety and space. She won't pick this up as easily as her NT friends so I teach her as and when things crop up.

For me, modelling is important. I don't allow people to speak to me rudely or disrespectfully anyway but especially not in front of my children and particularly if it's men. I will calmly challenge it if it happens. It doesn't often. No passive aggressive digs in response, no apologetics in the face of someone else's rudeness. I will calmly and cheerily tell someone what they've just said was rude or disrespectful and say that I don't expect them to speak to me like that again. It takes people by surprise and men (it's nearly always men!) bluff and bluster at their rudeness being remarked upon so directly.

I teach my children that whilst sharing their belongings/toys is nice and I encourage them to do it, that it's fine to have boundaries around it and if something is particularly precious to them then they can put it up and decide not share it. I don't like to share my belongings much either but no one expects me too. It's no different for children unless they are shared group items like in school or playgroup and then they don't get to be precious about them. If it has their name label on at school it means it comes from home and they can choose if they share it or not.

I've taught my eldest (hasn't come up with the youngest yet but no doubt it will) that if someone invades her personal space at school or elsewhere then she can put her hand up in front of her chest in a 'stop' signal (not to hit, very very clear on that) and say 'Stop, I don't like you being so close to me. Move back please' Equally important if people are touching/hugging her like kids can do and she doesn't want them to 'Stop touching me please' which escalates to 'Take your hands off of me now'.

Same rules apply if people say rude things. Call it out, but politely and calmly. 'That was a very rude thing to say to me, it hurt my feelings. I'm going to go and play with someone else now'.

All these sorts of little things will build our daughters confidence as they go. They don't need to be aggressive, or shouty or rude, it's important that they're not actually - but they do need to learn that they are valuable people and that it is perfectly ok to look after their own interests and feelings as well as being nice people. 'Be Kind' sure, but not to your own detriment!

Kokapetl · 24/09/2022 22:18

My oldest child was like that too but grew out of it. They are now, if anything, way too cheeky and borderline aggressive.

I agree with the previous poster who said it was a first child reaction. They go through a stage during toddlerhood, once they start interacting with other children, of being a bit baffled by this behaviour and just accepting it. The second and subsequent get it earlier and more frequently and so learn to deal with it before they become toddlers. Probably the personality of the child, and whether they are in nursery from a young age, has an impact too.

noliquidassets · 24/09/2022 21:56

@Worriedpanda50 I don't have a male daughter 😬

OP posts:
noliquidassets · 24/09/2022 21:55

Oh no, my thread is going to be derailed by this typo. It did not mean anything. I have a daughter. She is a female. In my (admittedly, very tired and fuzzy) mind my OP title made sense lol.

Thanks to all who have posted advice.
I try to lead by example as did my mum. She is in a fairly senior position, and I have a profession and I am also retraining so DD sees me go out to work daily as well as once per week evenings out to learn.

I am a silent and assertive person, I don't like confrontation but I won't be pushed about by people.

OP posts:
noliquidassets · 24/09/2022 21:50

Apologies all, been v tired today just realised I've typed female daughter 😂 I meant to put female child or just daughter.

OP posts:
Aprilx · 24/09/2022 21:31

Stayathomenamechange · 24/09/2022 20:41

OP probably edited her title halfway through and didn't realise she'd put "female daughter", let's not get hung up on a typo

Well what did she mean to say then? “My female offspring”? It is really quite weird and no wonder people are distracted by it.

Watapalava · 24/09/2022 21:25

By being assertive and opinionated yourself

owning your actions

my dd is hard as nails and kind with it

she takes no shit but also is the one who’s most empathetic

that’s because I wasn’t her best mate and because I pushed her from day 1 to not be a sheep. It didn’t always make her popular but she stands out in a group for maturity beyond her years

Hopeandlove · 24/09/2022 21:23

jetadore · 24/09/2022 17:03

Best way is to model assertiveness yourself. Both in your dealings with others and with her. She’ll learn from your example. Still, sounds like she’s already better behaved than her grabby cousins.

This teaching boundaries.
play and share nicely yes
put up with verbal insults no

this comes from love, talking, compassion and strong boundaries

user29 · 24/09/2022 20:59

i think its more to do with being a first or only child,second and subsequent children are used to standing up for themeselves

girlmom21 · 24/09/2022 20:57

Repetition is the answer.

Keep doing what you're doing and reminding her it's ok to stand up for herself.

Worriedpanda50 · 24/09/2022 20:57

How did you teach your male daughter?

Underwater11 · 24/09/2022 20:56

Mine was similar at that age, would have just moved on to something else. Different story now at 4, more then able to stand up for herself!

RedHelenB · 24/09/2022 20:52

TheLette · 24/09/2022 20:31

I wouldn't worry. She might just be quite chilled. My daughter was pretty chilled age 2 if other kids grabbed stuff off her, she generally accepted it and moved on. Different story now she is nearly 5!

My dd1 was the same. It was as though she worked out other kids took toys off her for a reaction, and when she didn't give one they'd leave the toy quickly and she'd toddle off to get it. DS always reacted though

Stayathomenamechange · 24/09/2022 20:41

OP probably edited her title halfway through and didn't realise she'd put "female daughter", let's not get hung up on a typo

Stickmansmum · 24/09/2022 20:37

Just wait and watch. It’s too early for it to mean anything. A woman’s balance of assertiveness and strength is hard to see till much much later.

TriedAndBested · 24/09/2022 20:35

A few things that I try to do (though no idea if they are helping):

  1. Build confidence and self esteem
  2. Teach her it's ok to say no, not just to other kids but also to adults . We role play this a lot. She loves role playing so it's easy.
  3. Teach her that her voice matters and that what she wants matters to.
  4. At her age definitely intervene if she's getting hit or pushed. You can give it a moment to see if she'll help herself but if she doesn't then you make it clear that this isn't behaviour she should tolerate.
MassiveSalad22 · 24/09/2022 20:34

Female daughter 😁

Teach her the same way you’d teach a boy. ‘I don’t play with people who are mean to me/don’t share/etc’ is a good one. And I use it sometimes with my own kids if they’re being brats 😄 shows that you are not a doormat.

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 24/09/2022 20:34

@noliquidassets

To add to what a few others have said, WTF does 'female daughter' mean? ALL daughters are 'female!' Confused

Sarahcoggles · 24/09/2022 20:32

ChagSameachDoreen · 24/09/2022 20:02

Female daughter?

That confused me too

Melassa · 24/09/2022 20:31

My daughter was a bit like this when she was tiny and first started nursery and I had the same concerns, but then once she found her feet she did push back if she wasn’t happy with the outcome. She was always the smallest in the class and some did try it on but she wasn’t fazed and had no time for queen bee groups at school and just quietly and firmly got on with what she wanted to do.

she’s more introverted than I am but does have a silent, strong streak and quietly takes no shit. I didn’t adopt a specific policy (apart from telling her she could do what she wanted and was capable of and not to let her sex hold her back), but she’s surrounded by strong women in senior jobs, so I suppose she’s used to non passive women who are used to being respected. I expect the best thing is to lead by example 🤷🏻‍♀️

TheLette · 24/09/2022 20:31

I wouldn't worry. She might just be quite chilled. My daughter was pretty chilled age 2 if other kids grabbed stuff off her, she generally accepted it and moved on. Different story now she is nearly 5!

Hoppinggreen · 24/09/2022 20:27

jetadore · 24/09/2022 17:03

Best way is to model assertiveness yourself. Both in your dealings with others and with her. She’ll learn from your example. Still, sounds like she’s already better behaved than her grabby cousins.

Doesn’t always work.
I am known for being “assertive” but unfortunately DD is a bit of a doormat, always has been. When anyone did something to her she just looked sad.
She is 17 now and I think she is actually getting a bit better but I still fear for her

ParentallyUnprepared · 24/09/2022 20:24

My male son is the same.