Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this a crazy price for DofE Silver Award

161 replies

Fgsvirgin · 24/09/2022 16:44

School have just sent the letter. (Not a fee paying school.)

It is £420 (plus a £50 deposit).

That seems like an awful lot to me for a trip where you have to provide the transport there and back yourself, provide the food and some of the kit.

The price is set by the third party company organising it and does include training sessions (not an overnight session just a couple of classroom based sessions and one 7 hr walk), the registration fee and loan/hire of the tent, cooking stove thing and coat/waterproof bottoms and sleeping bag if you want. This is what the deposit is for.

Does that not seem a really expensive hike to you?

I suppose I’m comparing it to other school trips where they get a couple of nights away with food and transport for less than £300.

I should have seen it coming when Bronze was £300 but I paid that blindly thinking that is how much these things cost!

If your child did D/E Silver, how much was it?

(I realise the key here is that there is a third party company arranging it so I suppose I’m looking for responses from those who also have experience with third party D/E companies.)

OP posts:
Puffalicious · 25/09/2022 13:00

Totally agree with Bluegingerbread - it doesn't matter if the kids don't continue, it's the skills/ experience/ perspective they get whilst volunteering.

Puffalicious · 25/09/2022 12:58

I am hysterically laughing at teacher's overtime at weekends! 🤣🤣🤣. Did you not read my post about willingly giving up Saturdays/ overnights. I know NO teachers who are paid for any extra time (including the theatre/ dance/sports trips that are late nights). What on Earth do you think goes on in schools? We barely have money for books!

lechatnoir · 25/09/2022 12:50

Wow that sounds steep - it was £100 for bronze and £120 for silver & I £550 for gold but DS has just finished silver and decided not to do gold (thank goodness as we couldn't afford it!)

zingally · 25/09/2022 11:48

Bloody hell. I could take my entire family of 4 hiking for that amount. I don't have that amount of spare cash lying around, so it would be a no from me!

I hope my kids don't get a whiff of that when they're older. My DH did Bronze at secondary school, but it wasn't something ever mentioned at mine. I don't think I even ever heard of it until I was in my early 20s.

Bluegingerbread · 25/09/2022 11:33

Needmorelego · 25/09/2022 11:16

@Bluegingerbread valid points but I do wonder what the % of the teen volunteers carry on helping/being involved once they have got their award.
To be honest I don't know much about DofE. Never heard of it in my school days (80s/90s) even though I know now that it did exist then.

I don't know what %. In the case of my kids' Scout group a lot remain volunteers through uni and quit when they get to the stage of their first full time job taking too much time. My school didn't do D of E but did insist that sixth formers spent one afternoon a week doing some kind of volunteer work and I've volunteered with various things once my kids got to school age so maybe the idea stuck for me or maybe not. I think a lot of people don't necessarily volunteer all their life but come in and out as work and family commitments change. And that's fine, it shouldn't need to be that the same people do it forever, new blood can be useful.

Either way, in my area the supply of D of E teens definitely benefits the community and keeps activities going and cheaper than they'd be otherwise so I'm grateful for it. In an affluent area it might not be as obviously beneficial I guess.

bettbburg · 25/09/2022 11:29

We didn't pay anything, they do it with the teachers

Needmorelego · 25/09/2022 11:16

@Bluegingerbread valid points but I do wonder what the % of the teen volunteers carry on helping/being involved once they have got their award.
To be honest I don't know much about DofE. Never heard of it in my school days (80s/90s) even though I know now that it did exist then.

Mamansparkles · 25/09/2022 11:11

DrinkingAllTheGin · 25/09/2022 08:35

The school will be paying the external company for the expert advice of a mountain leader to assess them as well as providing first aid cover. (DH is one).
Fir a large school there will be up to 6 of these per cohort. Plus the teachers overtime etc for weekends.

With Scouts etc (I'm one) there is no adult costs but don't forget you are paying subs which will cover some of the expenses.

Sorry, I'm laughing at the idea that teachers get paid overtime for weekend/holiday residential trips. We don't. Teachers are volunteers on trips.

The reasons private schools can do it more cheaply is they can recruit teachers who have the skills and qualifications to run these things and extra curricular activities are part of their contract (and no, usually no extra pay, most private schools pay the same roughly as state, some less, some - like Eton - more).

Some state schools will happen to have teachers who have the skills and qualifications and volunteer to give up their time which makes it cheaper. Many won't and will have to pay third party companies.

Someone else up thread said 'where have all the volunteers gone?'
Emotionally - they ran out of goodwill after all the complaints they got that little Seraphine 'mustn't be told off' at Brownies after hitting another child with a stick.
Practically, childcare for their own children - people are having children later and grandparents are older on average and can't help as much as 20 years ago.
Financially - fewer people can afford to volunteer. They need that time to work more hours, or struggle with the hidden costs of volunteering (eg bus fares, parking charges, that all add up).
Physically - I just don't have the energy anymore so I gave up. With a 6 day a week job to make ends meet, DH also working and us juggling the children and housework, I just can't do it. Even 20 years ago families could manage on one income or one and a half, which gave a bit more space. Now they can't.

Bluegingerbread · 25/09/2022 11:10

Needmorelego · 25/09/2022 10:38

@Bluegingerbread but I wonder how many of the teens you see are volunteering so it ticks a box on their form or just volunteering because they really want to help out.

I don't understand why that matters? I watch them while I'm watching my youngest play and the D of E teens are doing a good job, they're helpful, polite and look enthusiastic, they're out there every Sunday at 9am including in Jan and Feb when it's freezing and tipping it down. Whether they enjoy or do it just to get that bit of D of E ticked off they are still learning about commitment and reliability, they're learning skills and patience in helping people younger/less skilled than themselves and they're giving something to their community. They can be relied upon to turn out for the whole season (season runs Sept to April and it's very rare for the Bronze kids to leave when they've done their 3 months). I think instilling the idea of volunteering in young people is a good idea, rather than just hoping it will occur to them organically. Teens do lots of things they might not like eg GSCEs or having braces, I don't see that wanting it or not changes the worth of the outcome?

Arguably, the kid who is less keen to do it might actually gain more benefit in terms of learning things, stretching themselves, people skills..

I really appreciate our teen helpers and I always send DD with a Christmas card and box of Maltesers for the ones that help her team. They always look really pleased to be thanked.

Puffalicious · 25/09/2022 11:03

I'd agree with this re the skills training and the level of independence reached too.
Am horrified by some of the reports I read about on hear, and occasionally hear from families who have done the award through some schools (not all, I hasten to add).

Thankfully you said not all schools. I'm part of my DiofE team in school. It costs our pupils nothing to do Bronze or Silver- we've not planned a Gold as of yet, but it's coming. Our City Council invested a lot in training all of us (we're assessors too) in hiking/ biking/ kayaking and the lead teacher (Geography) works his backside off to get funding from everywhere and anywhere for our supply tests/ equip/ waterproofs/ boots. The kids have DodE one afternoon the entire year, so it's done properly. We give up lots of time on Saturdays/ overnights.

The area I work in has huge deprivation, so pupils can't pay. I willingly give up my time for these kids as they get huge amounts out of it: it is certainly not about a thing on a CV for them at all.

Wish the teacher bashing MNers would think of this kind of work at times.

MedievalNun · 25/09/2022 11:02

Hubs is currently training as a DoE co-ordinator with a uniformed cadet org. He has to do his Mountain and Low-Land Leader courses (not cheap!) which involve a lot of hiking weekends. He has a minibus licence, a DBS, and is also doing an FAW (first aid) course. So before he can even set foot outside the classroom, there's 5 costs that have to be met. Oh, 6 - I forgot about the DoE reg.

The organisation the school is using will need all of these for every member of staff. If we were having to pay for all of these outselves, we'd be lucky to get change out of a grand.

However- by paying for it, the cadet organisations can keep the costs down for parents - and some units will help with registration fees for parents that are struggling. Our unit does.

The volunteer teachers, cadet, Scouting, Guiding and St Johns staff that make it possible for children and young adults to do DoE and other activities are amazing.

Noviembre · 25/09/2022 10:58

Moveonswiftlyplease · 24/09/2022 16:47

I wouldn't pay that. Hiking is free apart from the equipment. That's part of the appeal. Could you not just take your DC hiking yourself?

They wouldn't get the DoE though. I assume the costs are for the judging if they qualify for the desired award? It's not just a medal they chuck at you for completing a hike.

fUNNYfACE36 · 25/09/2022 10:56

Quincythequince · 25/09/2022 08:18

To be fair, they are interested. It really depends on what you did to achieve it though.

What D of E doesn’t give you however is UCAS points.

If you do a Gold, that’s an awful lot of activities over a long time to talk about. It may cost a lot of money to do use (using some organisers) but you still have to have done your skills, physical, volunteering, weeks residential and then the expedition.

They don’t just ignore that because it is a lot of effort.

Dof E is of no interest to universities at all

fUNNYfACE36 · 25/09/2022 10:53

My eldest did it through school 10 years or,so ago and it was only £30.When youngest got to that stage it was £300+

MrMrsJones · 25/09/2022 10:49

Fgsvirgin · 24/09/2022 16:44

School have just sent the letter. (Not a fee paying school.)

It is £420 (plus a £50 deposit).

That seems like an awful lot to me for a trip where you have to provide the transport there and back yourself, provide the food and some of the kit.

The price is set by the third party company organising it and does include training sessions (not an overnight session just a couple of classroom based sessions and one 7 hr walk), the registration fee and loan/hire of the tent, cooking stove thing and coat/waterproof bottoms and sleeping bag if you want. This is what the deposit is for.

Does that not seem a really expensive hike to you?

I suppose I’m comparing it to other school trips where they get a couple of nights away with food and transport for less than £300.

I should have seen it coming when Bronze was £300 but I paid that blindly thinking that is how much these things cost!

If your child did D/E Silver, how much was it?

(I realise the key here is that there is a third party company arranging it so I suppose I’m looking for responses from those who also have experience with third party D/E companies.)

Join Army Cadets the fee is £26.00/£30.00 all in, you will need to provide food.

Schools are a rip off

Buzzinwithbez · 25/09/2022 10:48

Yes it does. We just paid 70 for bronze - we only have to supply food, cutlery and plates. Hat, gloves, hiking socks and midlayers.
All waterproofs, boots etc are supplied.

You could kit your son out with some very decent hiking and camping equipment for that.

  • however, good point that our scheme is provided by unpaid volunteers.
AntlerRose · 25/09/2022 10:44

It does seem a lot but i suppose the cost is the people. Normal school trips, even overnighters, the people are free. My sons school dont use a company and the teachers give up their weekends and bank holidays for it. Im very grateful.

Quincythequince · 25/09/2022 10:41

*understood the charge

Quincythequince · 25/09/2022 10:41

PotatoHammock · 25/09/2022 10:14

It's not just the Scouts that's run by volunteers. At my school the kids do DofE through the school, and it is run purely by volunteer teachers (like myself!) We put in hours of extra time doing assessor training, we run lunchtime and weekend training sessions, we have to take the minibus test (surprisingly admin heavy), and we get no kit allowance or anything- we're expected to provide our own tents, backpacks, stoves etc.

We also oversee all the other aspects of DofE, making sure the kids have picked valid activities, and chasing up getting those various sections signed off by the assessors.

This makes me wonder whether the parents at my school realise that we're not getting paid for any part of what we do. The money we charge goes purely towards paying the campsite, and equipment hire, which is expensive because the kids are always breaking stuff (despite all those hours of training!)

It is so much work.
My boys’ school has a coordinator only, and even he does a lot.

I bet your parents have absolutely no clue of what it would cost of all volunteer time and resources were accounted for.

People should pay for other people’s time where they can. Which is why, whilst expensive to get external people in for the Expedition, I undertone charge and paid without complaint.

Needmorelego · 25/09/2022 10:38

@Bluegingerbread but I wonder how many of the teens you see are volunteering so it ticks a box on their form or just volunteering because they really want to help out.

Quincythequince · 25/09/2022 10:38

Kite22 · 25/09/2022 10:03

Not really, NCS is done in a week's residential (Outdoor stuff), another week's residential (other skills) and a few days volunteering.
Achieving DofE requires months of volunteering, physical and skill learning, wher ea young person has to stick with hit, show commitment, usually work with different people of different ages.
Mine have all done both, and the NCS is a good scheme, but DofE needed a LOT more commitment.

Yep all of this.
My son has done both too. D of E Gold is way more work and those familiar with the workings of each, wouldn’t even compare them.

Needmorelego · 25/09/2022 10:35

@Kite22 yes the DofE requires a lot of commitment but that could be why so many teens don't get the opportunity to do it. Family responsibilities, part time jobs, not being able to get to places because there's no/unreliable public transport simply means they don't have the time to take part even if they wanted to.
It's very much a middle class thing in my opinion. To expensive for many whose families are both money poor and time poor.

TooMuchToDoTooLittleInclination · 25/09/2022 10:25

Cognacsoft · 25/09/2022 08:40

When dd did D of E 15 years ago it was all done through rangers at minimal cost.
These costs are not really in the spirit of the award scheme are they?
Whats happened to all the adult volunteers?

They got fed up to the back teeth of moaning parents & disinterested kids!!

PotatoHammock · 25/09/2022 10:14

It's not just the Scouts that's run by volunteers. At my school the kids do DofE through the school, and it is run purely by volunteer teachers (like myself!) We put in hours of extra time doing assessor training, we run lunchtime and weekend training sessions, we have to take the minibus test (surprisingly admin heavy), and we get no kit allowance or anything- we're expected to provide our own tents, backpacks, stoves etc.

We also oversee all the other aspects of DofE, making sure the kids have picked valid activities, and chasing up getting those various sections signed off by the assessors.

This makes me wonder whether the parents at my school realise that we're not getting paid for any part of what we do. The money we charge goes purely towards paying the campsite, and equipment hire, which is expensive because the kids are always breaking stuff (despite all those hours of training!)

VoiceOfCommonSense · 25/09/2022 10:12

That’s pricey. Phillip must be turning in his grave!!