Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this a crazy price for DofE Silver Award

161 replies

Fgsvirgin · 24/09/2022 16:44

School have just sent the letter. (Not a fee paying school.)

It is £420 (plus a £50 deposit).

That seems like an awful lot to me for a trip where you have to provide the transport there and back yourself, provide the food and some of the kit.

The price is set by the third party company organising it and does include training sessions (not an overnight session just a couple of classroom based sessions and one 7 hr walk), the registration fee and loan/hire of the tent, cooking stove thing and coat/waterproof bottoms and sleeping bag if you want. This is what the deposit is for.

Does that not seem a really expensive hike to you?

I suppose I’m comparing it to other school trips where they get a couple of nights away with food and transport for less than £300.

I should have seen it coming when Bronze was £300 but I paid that blindly thinking that is how much these things cost!

If your child did D/E Silver, how much was it?

(I realise the key here is that there is a third party company arranging it so I suppose I’m looking for responses from those who also have experience with third party D/E companies.)

OP posts:
Needmorelego · 25/09/2022 21:13

Sorry ignore that @KittyKatBlue . I meant to press @Kite22 .
Thanks @Kite22 . I don't think DofE is for her.
I like the look of NCS but think it's a shame she can't do that now (age 14) rather than waiting until post GCSEs.

Needmorelego · 25/09/2022 21:11

Thanks @KittyKatBlue

Kite22 · 25/09/2022 20:59

Needmorelego · 25/09/2022 19:26

Another question - is there a simplified version for children with disabilities/health conditions who couldn't do the expedition part?
(I'm just curious - my daughter is autistic and she just simply wouldn't be able to do that part)

There are reasonable adjustments throughout the scheme, although obviously you can't get the award if you don't do what is needed for the award.
One of the folk one of my dc did his Gold Training, practice and expedition with has Autism, and another had some physical disabilities. It took a lot of extra planning to make the expedition work but all the Young People achieved it.

Needmorelego · 25/09/2022 19:53

Thanks @Puffalicious . I had briefly looked at the scheme to see if it would suit my girl.
She is autistic, was out of school for over 2 years and desperately needs to catch up her confidence etc.
But the expedition/outdoors stuff would be just no good for her.
She simply would not want to do it or would be able to cope with it.

Puffalicious · 25/09/2022 19:45

Needmorelego · 25/09/2022 19:26

Another question - is there a simplified version for children with disabilities/health conditions who couldn't do the expedition part?
(I'm just curious - my daughter is autistic and she just simply wouldn't be able to do that part)

Yes, there are adjustments made for all disabilities at Bronze Level, and for some at Silver. I'm not sure about Gold, as we've not offered Gold yet.

e.g locally there was a mixed Bronze group (disabled/ abled/ ND/ NT) who kayaked (there are many alternatives to hiking), some with carers, camped and kayaked the next day.

Needmorelego · 25/09/2022 19:31

@Quincythequince I mean compared to the volunteering side of it - which I personally would find more rewarding (if I was of the age to be doing it).

Needmorelego · 25/09/2022 19:29

@Quincythequince I am genuinely curious about it. Yes it's challenging, yes it's an experience but it seems such a massive part of the whole scheme (and the expensive part).

Needmorelego · 25/09/2022 19:26

Another question - is there a simplified version for children with disabilities/health conditions who couldn't do the expedition part?
(I'm just curious - my daughter is autistic and she just simply wouldn't be able to do that part)

Quincythequince · 25/09/2022 19:26

Needmorelego · 25/09/2022 19:23

I am still curious about why the expedition part is such a big deal? Why? I assume it's good for learning how to do organising/planning/team work etc but surely the equipment part of it is what makes the whole scheme expensive and really it's not an everyday normal life experience !

4 days Wild camping in Windermere then 4 days in Snowdonia.

You can’t imagine why this might be challenging and a special experience?

Cognacsoft · 25/09/2022 19:23

TooMuchToDoTooLittleInclination · 25/09/2022 10:25

They got fed up to the back teeth of moaning parents & disinterested kids!!

Surely teens doing silver or gold want to be there.
If they’re disinterested they shouldn’t be doing it.
My dd and her friends loved it. They worked incredibly hard and the volunteers were amazing.
Sad to think parents complain when their dc are so privileged.

Needmorelego · 25/09/2022 19:23

I am still curious about why the expedition part is such a big deal? Why? I assume it's good for learning how to do organising/planning/team work etc but surely the equipment part of it is what makes the whole scheme expensive and really it's not an everyday normal life experience !

Puffalicious · 25/09/2022 19:15

Noodledoodledoo · 25/09/2022 19:02

I'm just home from my schools bronze assessed expedition. 90 students. 12 members of staff over the weekend, 11 unpaid using own vehicles and fuel plus losing (for most - needed 10 at all times) both days of the weekend, straight back to work tomorrow, worked till Friday.

We did a practice one earlier in the year, same commitment, same staff.

To train as a Leader, my course was a total of 10 days over 3 sessions, again at my expense re fuel etc.

We don't lend out tents/bags anymore as the norm, they get trashed very quickly as teens don't care if its not theirs.

4 of the teachers are off to silver assessed in the next month as well.

Replace this with a paid company and you can see why the costs mount up.

Volunteers are getting rarer in all walks of life, expectations are much higher constantly, thanks are rarer.

Well done you. Those kids will be hugely enriched by your commitment. Been there - the training seems like it goes on and on...

Quincythequince · 25/09/2022 19:11

Garysmum · 25/09/2022 17:22

I agree with you - but picking students based on DofE is biased towards middle class families where it is the done thing.

Yep! It is awfu to do that.
Once you get to know them, you learn about it after the fact, marks will always trump ex-curric stuff.

We do interviews though, so actually get to speak to them and get to know about more about them that way.

Noodledoodledoo · 25/09/2022 19:02

I'm just home from my schools bronze assessed expedition. 90 students. 12 members of staff over the weekend, 11 unpaid using own vehicles and fuel plus losing (for most - needed 10 at all times) both days of the weekend, straight back to work tomorrow, worked till Friday.

We did a practice one earlier in the year, same commitment, same staff.

To train as a Leader, my course was a total of 10 days over 3 sessions, again at my expense re fuel etc.

We don't lend out tents/bags anymore as the norm, they get trashed very quickly as teens don't care if its not theirs.

4 of the teachers are off to silver assessed in the next month as well.

Replace this with a paid company and you can see why the costs mount up.

Volunteers are getting rarer in all walks of life, expectations are much higher constantly, thanks are rarer.

Puffalicious · 25/09/2022 18:44

Circleoffifths · 25/09/2022 18:34

It really depends. As I mentioned upthread, we didn’t have to pay a penny for ours (bronze and silver) run in school - state school, deprived area. And DD’s experience absolutely did not match those PP who suggested that a school-run DofE not involving a private company is somehow not the real thing, or a bit rubbish.

She had a great experience, her group did all the planning themselves supported by the teachers. She did volunteering once a week which was a real commitment but she stuck with it.

Her school is about as far from a leafy, middle class secondary as you can get. Grateful to the staff who go above and beyond so that any student who wanted to could take part.

Thank you. This is exactly the experience of pupils in my school. Those hinting it might be a bit crap should be ashamed of themselves.

Circleoffifths · 25/09/2022 18:34

FannyAintMeAunt · 25/09/2022 18:05

You have to pay?
bloody hell I hope my DD doesn’t remember I was egging her on into doing the DofE

It really depends. As I mentioned upthread, we didn’t have to pay a penny for ours (bronze and silver) run in school - state school, deprived area. And DD’s experience absolutely did not match those PP who suggested that a school-run DofE not involving a private company is somehow not the real thing, or a bit rubbish.

She had a great experience, her group did all the planning themselves supported by the teachers. She did volunteering once a week which was a real commitment but she stuck with it.

Her school is about as far from a leafy, middle class secondary as you can get. Grateful to the staff who go above and beyond so that any student who wanted to could take part.

FannyAintMeAunt · 25/09/2022 18:05

You have to pay?
bloody hell I hope my DD doesn’t remember I was egging her on into doing the DofE

DrinkingAllTheGin · 25/09/2022 17:57

I'm sorry if I offended any of you out there by suggesting teachers might (should) get paid.

TheRubyRedshoes · 25/09/2022 17:34

I can't help thinking it's become evolved away from it's original intention.

Garysmum · 25/09/2022 17:22

Quincythequince · 25/09/2022 17:02

I disagree, and as an academic with multiple undergrad students, the ones who complete Gold, are generally more able (for many reasons).

Again, for contexts my husband was an admissions tutor (amongst other things) for many years. I routinely sift through and help with applications on one I teach on.

Both courses were oversubscribed and required good STEM A levels
so as you may have gathered, we work in STEM.

The applicant obviously need to get the grades, no question at all.

But all things things being equal between applicants, and you’d be surprised how often this happens, D of E does make a difference.

Not least because in looking for well rounded people to undertake a course which requires a versatile range of skills, you’d rather Jenny with her D of E gold, than Sarah who played netball.

You can say it doesn’t make a difference because you told your kids not to bother or you personally don’t read personal statements for applicants (not sure which it is) - that doesn’t make what you say right.

They don’t award UCAS points for it no, but if you were doing Geography or field biology work for example, it’s extremely helpful.

I agree with you - but picking students based on DofE is biased towards middle class families where it is the done thing.

Garysmum · 25/09/2022 17:20

I'm afraid DofE is not an accessible thing to do. It's a nice to have on a CV but way out of my budget for my DC.

Quincythequince · 25/09/2022 17:02

fUNNYfACE36 · 25/09/2022 10:56

Dof E is of no interest to universities at all

I disagree, and as an academic with multiple undergrad students, the ones who complete Gold, are generally more able (for many reasons).

Again, for contexts my husband was an admissions tutor (amongst other things) for many years. I routinely sift through and help with applications on one I teach on.

Both courses were oversubscribed and required good STEM A levels
so as you may have gathered, we work in STEM.

The applicant obviously need to get the grades, no question at all.

But all things things being equal between applicants, and you’d be surprised how often this happens, D of E does make a difference.

Not least because in looking for well rounded people to undertake a course which requires a versatile range of skills, you’d rather Jenny with her D of E gold, than Sarah who played netball.

You can say it doesn’t make a difference because you told your kids not to bother or you personally don’t read personal statements for applicants (not sure which it is) - that doesn’t make what you say right.

They don’t award UCAS points for it no, but if you were doing Geography or field biology work for example, it’s extremely helpful.

Needmorelego · 25/09/2022 16:23

@Kite22 like I said - I don't know much about it really.
Was never mentioned in my school days so hadn't really heard of it until a few years back.

Kite22 · 25/09/2022 16:18

Needmorelego · 25/09/2022 10:35

@Kite22 yes the DofE requires a lot of commitment but that could be why so many teens don't get the opportunity to do it. Family responsibilities, part time jobs, not being able to get to places because there's no/unreliable public transport simply means they don't have the time to take part even if they wanted to.
It's very much a middle class thing in my opinion. To expensive for many whose families are both money poor and time poor.

Mine all worked alongside completing theirs.
The lack of transport seems more of a rural vs City thing rather than a "class" or financial thing to me.
Yes, when going to a Gold presentation, I'll not disagree that there more youngsters there from a middle class background BUT, it isn't cost that is a barrier, if that were what the youngsters / their families really wanted them to do, as has been shown by this thread. Scouts, Guides, BB, GB offer DofE for minimal costs, and cadets are even able to subsidise it. You won't find anything better vfm to take your dc to than any of those organisations.
I know a Team that organise many DofE opportunities year after year, to many dc from deprived backgrounds and money isn't a barrier for any of them.

I am very much aware there will still be some families where the children work in the family business straight from school until well into the evening every day of the week, and other families who are homeless and in other dire straits, but for most, there is no reason that DofE shouldn't be open to them possibly unless the family lives very remotely.

Kite22 · 25/09/2022 16:08

Totally agree with @Bluegingerbread too.

Anecdotally, I know a LOT of youngsters who start volunteering through DofE, continue long after the 3 or 6 months they "need" to, for the award.

@DrinkingAllTheGin That's hilarious, the idea that the teachers that give up their time are even offered any time off in lieu, let alone overtime Grin