Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Questions asked at hospital

88 replies

Anxiousmummy1187 · 24/09/2022 13:25

I took my daughter into hospital today for infected earring.

mynson was being a menace and I kept having to tell him off, I was very stressed as I’m anxious and hate hospital, we’re going on holiday next week and my card just got blocked so I’m trying to sort it all out in one go so I didn’t have much patience with him so kept telling him to stop doing things like fighting with sister on chair and running around.

when we saw the nurse she asked if she had any allergies etc and then asked what school she was at, who she lived with and first names. Then if social was involved,

I’ve left feeling like they’re going to be reporting me for maybe me telling my son off.. I’m an over thinker 😂 has anyone else had these questions asked I’m proper panicking they’re gonna take my kids from me.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
blebbleb · 19/11/2022 18:51

Yes standard. I've been asked every time. Was also offended the first time Grin

PUGMEISTER21 · 19/11/2022 18:01

Normal questions, however parents/adults who abuse their kids tend to take them to different A+E's each time,as to avoid the repeated visits I front of the same doctors

Legofigure · 24/09/2022 21:57

Home schooling is not the same thing as tuition provided by the LA under s.19 of the Education Act 1996.

Home schooling absolutely is another legitimate name for EHE. Here is a government page confirming so.

wrenniejen · 24/09/2022 21:49

Probably best @pineappleapplepine

pineappleapplepine · 24/09/2022 21:43

I'm out at the ignorant comment.
I'm far from that and work hard every day to try and minimise risk and harm to children and maximise their opportunities. But not sharing 'research' on a Saturday night to people unwillingly to entertain critical thinking and with a pre conceived narrative makes me ignorant haha!

I could share every scr over decades, every piece of research about what puts children at risk of serious harm and death and this poster will still bang on about a tiny part of my first post that has been twisted to suit their 'cause'.

Just for the record not all home schooled/home Ed/deregisterd/ free schooled etc etc are abused but SOME are and the ones who are never seen outside of the home by anyone need looking out for.

Off to name change and block this thread because the lack of critical thinking and willingness to think outside the box is tiresome.

Good night

wrenniejen · 24/09/2022 21:21

It's Saturday night. I'm mumsnetting while watching strictly. I am not going to log on to my work laptop and find peer reviewed research that you likely can't access without the right account and log ins and will dismiss anyway so I'm not going to waste my time.

I'm neutral about home education, but your post sounded ignorant to me. I knew you wouldn't be able to back it up with facts or stats, esp. after you quoted the kyra case incorrectly. You can't drop something like that into your post and not expect to be challenged.

pineappleapplepine · 24/09/2022 21:02

Killed a week I should add

pineappleapplepine · 24/09/2022 21:01

wrenniejen · 24/09/2022 19:51

Well you clearly haven't read the full serious case review in her utterly tragic case but it's not the ultimate point of the OP's post.

But what they're saying is correct.

I asked for stats and links after making such a bold statement, and derailing the thread. I'm not surprised you weren't able to provide any.

It's Saturday night. I'm mumsnetting while watching strictly. I am not going to log on to my work laptop and find peer reviewed research that you likely can't access without the right account and log ins and will dismiss anyway so I'm not going to waste my time.

Most of my knowledge is gained from coal face practice supported by the findings of SCR's across the country and backed up by academic study. Not all reports are published to the public. Not all research is available to the public.

I'm not anti home Ed. But it's fascinating how out of everything I've said that's the only thing to make people froth at the mouth.

When 1-2 children are killed by their parent or main carer in a multitude of circumstances but with many common denominator factors that is worthy of froth.

Many many more are left permanently disabled, emotionally traumatised and with a myriad of complex support needs as a result of their experiences but hey let's pile on about home Ed and throw a dead cat into the thread

Hesma · 24/09/2022 20:29

That’s perfectly normal, don’t worry

Twospaniels · 24/09/2022 19:59

Standard questions - don’t worry about it.

ChocolateSpreadOnToast · 24/09/2022 19:57

We have to ask the questions because it’s quite literally on the paperwork. Which if we don’t answer we get in trouble as it’s all audited.

wrenniejen · 24/09/2022 19:51

Well you clearly haven't read the full serious case review in her utterly tragic case but it's not the ultimate point of the OP's post.

But what they're saying is correct.

I asked for stats and links after making such a bold statement, and derailing the thread. I'm not surprised you weren't able to provide any.

pineappleapplepine · 24/09/2022 19:48

Well you clearly haven't read the full serious case review in her utterly tragic case but it's not the ultimate point of the OP's post.

Dismissive and prejudiced? Nope! Just an experienced professional not frightened to challenge or question anything that may make a child vulnerable to abuse or neglect.

If you had read everything I have written fully I was very clear I don't view a presentation of a child with social care input as automatically 'dodgy'. Just like I didn't think a child not in school is automatically worrying. Just as a nicely presented, polite child with Boden wearing parents is not automatically nothing to worry about.

I look through the lens of the child and their lived experience not purely the parents perspective. When we listen to children and create opportunities for their voices to sing it's amazing what you can learn about how they view the world.

And it's often an eye opener to the parent.

ElephantsintheCupboard · 24/09/2022 19:31

pineappleapplepine · 24/09/2022 19:11

With reference to the 'home schooling' matter. Home schooled, home educated, unschooled what ever people choose to call it has been linked to SOME child protection cases where withdrawing the child from school was part of the efforts by the adults to hide their actions. Many of the cases I have been involved with I can't discuss for confidentially reasons but the case of Khyra Ishaq is an example of a child withdrawn from education who suffered abuse.

Not in school PLUS not being seen by anyone else outside of the home would concern any safeguarding professional.

I'll wait for the Mumsnet pile on despite me being clear that it is some and is a feature in a proportion of safeguarding practice reviews but by no means all.

Lovely thread derail!

You seem quite dismissive and prejudiced. People don't "choose to call it" home education, that is what it's actually called.

Khyra Ishaq was at school. Her school raised concerns with social services many times but no action was taken to protect her. When she died she had been de-registered from school. She was abused (at home) while she was at school. The abuse didn't start when she was home educated and home education didn't cause it.
Many children are abused at school so does the fact that parents choose to send their children to school also "pique your interest"?

Sorry about the de-rail OP. I am just tired of people being suspicious of parents who choose to fulfill the requirements of the Education Act to make sure their child are "educated according to their age, ability and aptitude".

Ineedsleepandcoffee · 24/09/2022 19:27

Standard although some of them I've only been asked at admission to a ward rather than at a and e

Darkstar4855 · 24/09/2022 19:24

Standard questions! I work in A&E and had to take my son in when he broke his arm and even though they knew me, I still had to be asked.

pineappleapplepine · 24/09/2022 19:15

ElephantsintheCupboard · 24/09/2022 18:59

Home schooling alone is not a safeguarding issue. However, SOME children are 'home schooled' to keep them out of sight of professionals as they are being abused or neglected so home schooling plus other concerns may pique the interest of a safeguarding professional

Just to be clear. In the UK home schooling is when a child is registered at school but can't attend. The LA provides home tutoring.

Children who are not registered at school are (electively) home educated. This is the legal default according to the Education Act . It should not "pique the interest" of a safeguarding professional as it is parents acting lawfully. It is not a safe guarding concern.

It's abuse and neglect you should be looking out for, regardless of who delivers a child's education.

Cherry picking the bits that suit your narrative is not helpful.

I have never said not being in school alone is a safeguarding issue.

I considered home ed for one of my children at one point as I felt their needs weren't being met in school.

But children not in school and never being seen by anyone outside of the home is a risk factor shown through SOME not all safeguarding practice reviews (formally called serious case reviews)

pineappleapplepine · 24/09/2022 19:11

With reference to the 'home schooling' matter. Home schooled, home educated, unschooled what ever people choose to call it has been linked to SOME child protection cases where withdrawing the child from school was part of the efforts by the adults to hide their actions. Many of the cases I have been involved with I can't discuss for confidentially reasons but the case of Khyra Ishaq is an example of a child withdrawn from education who suffered abuse.

Not in school PLUS not being seen by anyone else outside of the home would concern any safeguarding professional.

I'll wait for the Mumsnet pile on despite me being clear that it is some and is a feature in a proportion of safeguarding practice reviews but by no means all.

Lovely thread derail!

ElephantsintheCupboard · 24/09/2022 18:59

Home schooling alone is not a safeguarding issue. However, SOME children are 'home schooled' to keep them out of sight of professionals as they are being abused or neglected so home schooling plus other concerns may pique the interest of a safeguarding professional

Just to be clear. In the UK home schooling is when a child is registered at school but can't attend. The LA provides home tutoring.

Children who are not registered at school are (electively) home educated. This is the legal default according to the Education Act . It should not "pique the interest" of a safeguarding professional as it is parents acting lawfully. It is not a safe guarding concern.

It's abuse and neglect you should be looking out for, regardless of who delivers a child's education.

wrenniejen · 24/09/2022 18:36

starfishmummy
Probably because it was a GP referral.

Nope, I’ve had a GP referral too. Still been asked.

I've never visited A & E before so don't know what's usual. They seemed to be expecting us, though we had a lengthy (couple of hours?) wait. The blood test was clear and we were able to leave immediately.

They asked which school attended, possibly checked my name, address, then general questions about health.

blebbleb · 24/09/2022 18:26

They asked me a few weeks ago when I took my son to a&e. I was taken aback at first but glad to know it's standard procedure!

Glitteratitar · 24/09/2022 18:25

starfishmummy · 24/09/2022 17:22

Probably because it was a GP referral.

Nope, I’ve had a GP referral too. Still been asked.

starfishmummy · 24/09/2022 17:22

girlmom21 · 24/09/2022 16:00

I wonder if it's because it wasn't an injury

Probably because it was a GP referral.

Glitteratitar · 24/09/2022 16:13

girlmom21 · 24/09/2022 16:10

@Glitteratitar in that case maybe the other posters was just a trust not following procedure. We've only been once and got asked all the questions but it was for an injury

Most probably, as we use two different trusts and they have always asked. The very first time I was somewhat offended but then started to realise it’s a routine question.

viques · 24/09/2022 16:11

Anxiousmummy1187 · 24/09/2022 13:37

It’s because they wrote it all down so worried me.

No point asking questions in a busy place like a hospital unless you record the answers!