Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think inheritance tax should pay for social care

217 replies

Wouldloveanother · 24/09/2022 10:39

Just that really. Saw somebody else mention it on here and I think it’s a brilliant idea!

OP posts:
JassyRadlett · 24/09/2022 12:23

Ifailed · 24/09/2022 12:18

It would help shift the narrative from 'taxing what someone has worked hard for (or not)' to 'taxing a windfall that someone has done nothing to earn.'

It already is, hence the name Inheritance Tax!

But because the estate as a whole is taxed, not the recipient, it enables the idea that something that has already had tax paid on it (even if it hasn't) is being taxed. And it does not take into account the personal financial situations of the recipient/s.

Shifting to taxing the recipient/s, taking their existing tax situation into account, would rightly put the tax emphasis on the person/people who benefit.

(I'd also bring in graduated rates of capital gains tax.)

HidingFromDD · 24/09/2022 12:21

I think the biggest issue is sorting out the housing. We don’t have enough houses for the people here, which leads to house price inflation and ultimately people benefitting if their parents have property. This is really only an issue because the value of the property has increased out of line with other costs. Affordable housing should be a right for everyone and if there wasn’t such a shortage property values would fall.

ive paid a massive amount of tax, worked since I was 12, and haven’t been able to help
my children as much as I’d have liked to. I want anything I’ve worked hard for to go to them and any grandchildren, not get put back into government coffers

Ifailed · 24/09/2022 12:18

It would help shift the narrative from 'taxing what someone has worked hard for (or not)' to 'taxing a windfall that someone has done nothing to earn.'

It already is, hence the name Inheritance Tax!

Wouldloveanother · 24/09/2022 12:18

You’re on fire @Explaintome i think that’s a really good idea as well! Frankly I would be open to anything which doesn’t further penalise working families to subsidise people who outright own a £800k house.

OP posts:
Explaintome · 24/09/2022 12:16

fiftytontheresa · 24/09/2022 12:13

I don't quite understand how this would work though? For residential care, it wouldn't be unusual for the time in residential care to completely wipe out the proceeds of the house sale. So IT would mean mess money not more. Or do you mean that IT all goes into a central pot and that's where the government funds social care from?
Sorry if I'm being dim!

I don't know what OP is thinking but in my plan, people who have money/properly pay for their own care. Where that's care in their own home, that could be by way of a loan that's cleared when they die/the house is sold.

People who are fortunate enough not to need care and therfore die with their estate still in tact, pay more inheritiance tax to contribute to the overall all social care bill.

JassyRadlett · 24/09/2022 12:15

In some ways it would be better to stop taxing the estates and shift the tax to the recipients, who would then pay tax on it as either a capital gain or income. Capital gains, for choice.

It would help shift the narrative from 'taxing what someone has worked hard for (or not)' to 'taxing a windfall that someone has done nothing to earn.'

Wouldloveanother · 24/09/2022 12:14

fiftytontheresa · 24/09/2022 12:13

I don't quite understand how this would work though? For residential care, it wouldn't be unusual for the time in residential care to completely wipe out the proceeds of the house sale. So IT would mean mess money not more. Or do you mean that IT all goes into a central pot and that's where the government funds social care from?
Sorry if I'm being dim!

Central pot, the way I see it.

OP posts:
EvilRingahBitch · 24/09/2022 12:13

At the moment, if your homeowner parent lives to the age of 80 in decent health and then dies rapidly from cancer over the next 6 months you inherit a fortune tax free (up to a million quid free from IHT).
If their next door neighbour contracts Alzheimer's aged seventy and requires full time care then their children might inherit virtually nothing. Inheritance is a total lottery.

IMO it's better for both families to pay a sizeable lump sum on death and in return gain the certainty of maintaining the bulk of their inheritance.

fiftytontheresa · 24/09/2022 12:13

Wouldloveanother · 24/09/2022 10:39

Just that really. Saw somebody else mention it on here and I think it’s a brilliant idea!

I don't quite understand how this would work though? For residential care, it wouldn't be unusual for the time in residential care to completely wipe out the proceeds of the house sale. So IT would mean mess money not more. Or do you mean that IT all goes into a central pot and that's where the government funds social care from?
Sorry if I'm being dim!

FreddyHG · 24/09/2022 12:11

Ifailed · 24/09/2022 12:11

Why should you pay IT though full stop. Your house, your business, your luck if it's gone up in value.

At the time of death, you cease to exist - you have no belongings and no rights in law. IT is a tax on the unearned benefits that the deceased benefactors inherit.

This exactly.

Ifailed · 24/09/2022 12:11

Why should you pay IT though full stop. Your house, your business, your luck if it's gone up in value.

At the time of death, you cease to exist - you have no belongings and no rights in law. IT is a tax on the unearned benefits that the deceased benefactors inherit.

FreddyHG · 24/09/2022 12:10

I believe the limit for inheritance tax should be 0 with no primary residence exemption and taxed at up to 100%. If you want to give your children money before you die to avoid this or care costs then you are literally left on your own. I believe in meritocracy unearned income via inheritance or House prices increases should be taxed very heavily.

rockyg · 24/09/2022 12:08

True dat!

JassyRadlett · 24/09/2022 12:07

Are all the folk who are so firmly opposed to a tax on 'income people have already paid tax on' also campaigning to abolish VAT?

Same principle (albeit with a much more regressive impact.)

People who are anti-IHT but pro-VAT often strike me as being quite transparently pro-inherited privilege and economic stratification.

rockyg · 24/09/2022 12:05

I think it should be, perhaps a charge is put on the house

fiftytontheresa · 24/09/2022 12:04

rockyg · 24/09/2022 11:52

@fiftytontheresa but is house value included in the means testing? I thought it was for out of the home but not in home?

No it's not, only savings and liquid assets.

rockyg · 24/09/2022 12:03

We also need to tax wealth in the same way as income otherwise we will have more & more inequality

rockyg · 24/09/2022 12:02

my parents house was about 40k in the 80s, 1.8m now. Holiday home abroad was 20k in the 90s, maybe 250k now. They worked hard but that was nothing to do with the house price gains.

TheSmallestOneWasMadeline · 24/09/2022 12:01

I agree, and DH and I stand to inherit a share of 6 different properties when our parents pass away.

I dont understand why people are so against IT. The double tax argument doesnt hold any weight as it isnt the original owner being taxed again, it's the recipient. Both mine and DHs parents paid peanuts for their houses in the 80s and their value has increased 10x. Why should we get handed hundreds of thousands tax free while the younger generation get saddled with the social care debt? Its ridiculous. The threshold is extremely generous IMO.

JassyRadlett · 24/09/2022 12:01

girlfriend44 · 24/09/2022 11:47

Why should you pay IT though full stop. Your house, your business, your luck if it's gone up in value.

Do you feel the same about dividends tax?

rockyg · 24/09/2022 12:00

s their business their luck, their gain. Its nothing to do with anyone else.

this view lacks critical thinking. Ever increasing house prices have contributed to wage stagnation, shrinking public services, rising pension ages so it is to do with everyone if you care about the society you live in.

JassyRadlett · 24/09/2022 12:00

(And for the 'you're just jealous/you wouldn't talk that way if you stood to inherit a lot' brigade - barring a major global catastrophe, and even if my parents require extensive care for many many years, I'll still be extraordinarily comfortable after they die. It's not money I've earned and though they've worked hard and invested shrewdly, a lot of it isn't money they've earned either, because so much of it is property.)

JassyRadlett · 24/09/2022 11:57

WoooahNelly · 24/09/2022 11:54

I know that my parents views are that they have paid tax on everything all their lives...including stamp duty to buy the house, and worked all their lives and will be paying IHT why should they pay even more to subsidise those, that they have already been subsidising all through life, rather than being able to pass on their hard earned efforts to their children? My take is that I hope my parents use their assets to pay for the care they need.

How much has the value of their house appreciated above inflation since they paid their stamp duty? How much of that appreciation was the result of home improvements?

I'm not being goady but there is a huge hole in the 'I/they worked for all this' argument.

Wouldloveanother · 24/09/2022 11:55

girlfriend44 · 24/09/2022 11:53

Is their business their luck, their gain. Its nothing to do with anyone else.
Your already taxed on your earnings why should you be taxed on your house too.

Never ever will I agree with IT never ever.
None of the governments or the tax man's business.

Because earnings tax doesn’t go far enough. That simple. Unless you want income tax to skyrocket?

OP posts:
JassyRadlett · 24/09/2022 11:55

PolarPolly27 · 24/09/2022 11:15

We really need people to get out of large houses in catchment areas and this might help.
This kind of attitude disgusts me. Why should people be expected to give up their homes because it suits someone else? If they want to live in a large house and can afford it, it's no one else's business. Children can go to an alternative school.

I think you could argue that it was no one else's business if we were building adequate new homes and decent educational provision in sufficient volumes.

But we aren't, and one demographic who vote disproportionately for parties who prevent mass housebuilding and have made it incredibly difficult to build or expand schools where they're needed (on a national level) and stymie planning (locally) is the demographic who tend to be older homeowners.

So it turns out that it is the business of others, because none of these things exist in a vacuum.

I don't think empty nesters should be forced to sell but equally it's not 'disgusting' to point out that the choice to stay in a large home for one's entire life has broader impacts in the current context, and there's nothing wrong with discussing ways to incentivise or encourage downsizing (which often comes with the benefit of being able to stay in one's home for longer.)