Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think inheritance tax should pay for social care

217 replies

Wouldloveanother · 24/09/2022 10:39

Just that really. Saw somebody else mention it on here and I think it’s a brilliant idea!

OP posts:
Explaintome · 24/09/2022 12:54

Cognacsoft · 24/09/2022 12:52

IHT in France is different depending on family relationship.
A parent can give each child €100000 tax free once in 15 years. Any thing else is taxed at 30%.
Any other recipients have a tiny tax free allowance, I think €3000, may be different, and then pay tax at 60%.
However, crucially, dc are also legally responsible for paying towards their parents care in old age.
Therefore parents and dc always have familial responsibilities both ways, which seems much fairer to me.

It's also not possible for parents to disinherit children in France?

rockyg · 24/09/2022 12:54

The French system as well as their healthcare is much better than the U.K.

Quincythequince · 24/09/2022 12:53

PolarPolly27 · 24/09/2022 12:50

I can't comment on council homes as I have no idea about the terms of their tenancies.

What do you mean?
They don’t own their own council home!
That’s it.
It’s not theirs.

And unless I’ve misunderstood you (and I accept I may have) you think older homeowners, who don’t need their space, but own their homes, should have to move out?

Apologies if I’ve got this wrong.

Cognacsoft · 24/09/2022 12:52

AchatAVendre · 24/09/2022 12:37

Inheritance tax in France is 60%, starting from zero. I think thats a good level because it still lets people leave something but also benefits society. It also keeps house prices reasonable without massive inheritances fuelling giant deposits.

IHT in France is different depending on family relationship.
A parent can give each child €100000 tax free once in 15 years. Any thing else is taxed at 30%.
Any other recipients have a tiny tax free allowance, I think €3000, may be different, and then pay tax at 60%.
However, crucially, dc are also legally responsible for paying towards their parents care in old age.
Therefore parents and dc always have familial responsibilities both ways, which seems much fairer to me.

rockyg · 24/09/2022 12:52

If house prices were reasonable people wouldn't care so much about inheritance I don't think.

Agrudge · 24/09/2022 12:52

AchatAVendre · 24/09/2022 12:37

Inheritance tax in France is 60%, starting from zero. I think thats a good level because it still lets people leave something but also benefits society. It also keeps house prices reasonable without massive inheritances fuelling giant deposits.

It's not important what another country . This is the uk

Explaintome · 24/09/2022 12:51

BorgQueen · 24/09/2022 12:46

Why are people arguing over IHT when there is a far worse scenario that will hit a lot more people, especially in the future?
Say you have £500k in your pension (not an unreachable sum at all, even for average earners) and you need care at £2k a week, lets assume you took the tax free lump sum on retirement so all further money is taxable above personal allowance, which State pension almost covers.
So, you need £104k a year to fund your care - £10k is from SP then you are taxed at 20% on the first £50k, then you need another £44k to make up the difference, which is taxed at 40%.
To get that £104k - you actually need to get £160k out of your pension!!

It’s truly obscene and there should be some way of money going from a pension, to a care provider that involves minimal, if any, taxation.
I was staggered to learn this, my neighbour spent £600k on dementia care for his wife and the amount of tax he paid was staggering, he had several inexpensive properties that were meant to provide retirement income and now just has his home and State pension.
Before anyone mentions care annuities , you would need £millions to buy that level of cover.

"He" didn't have to pay anything. It would only be her share, unless he was paying for something above what was assessed as needed ( which would be perfectly reasonable if that's what he wanted)

Wouldloveanother · 24/09/2022 12:50

daisyjgrey · 24/09/2022 12:49

Nobody should pay inheritance tax. It's legalised theft. Taxing something that has already been taxed? And the people it impacts are those who are left behind.

It's another one of those 'solutions' that impacts people much further down the chain than it should.

If someone bought a house at 120k and it's now worth 600k because of increased property prices and (presumably) work they've done on it then it is what it is 🤷🏻‍♀️

So you think working families should fork out for the care of somebody who owns a £800k house outright?

OP posts:
PolarPolly27 · 24/09/2022 12:50

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 24/09/2022 12:47

@PolarPolly27 , so what do you think about single people remaining in 3 bed council homes? Is it fair to ask them to move to something smaller, so that a family on the waiting list in cramped accommodation can move in? Or does that principle apply only to owner-occupiers?

I can't comment on council homes as I have no idea about the terms of their tenancies.

Explaintome · 24/09/2022 12:49

Wouldloveanother · 24/09/2022 12:43

Does that mean euthanasia?

It doesn't need to be as black and white as that.

On the ambulance thread we have old and ill people being prioritised for care that will at best extend their life for a short period of poor quality. When DH was dying (and receiving an expensive care package), he asked for a review of pain meds. They wouldn't do it without him being assessed by an ambulance because he had chest pain.

The ambulance came, assessed that the pain was nothing more than the cancer that was killing him and he eventually got his pain relief reviewed, but if it had been something else it would at best have given him a few weeks of pain and extended the care costs.

I would never have wished him dead, but even at the time it seemed ridiculous to insist that so many resources should be used to "save" him for a few more weeks of pain. So no, not euthanasia, but maybe a review of who is/isn't treated?

daisyjgrey · 24/09/2022 12:49

Nobody should pay inheritance tax. It's legalised theft. Taxing something that has already been taxed? And the people it impacts are those who are left behind.

It's another one of those 'solutions' that impacts people much further down the chain than it should.

If someone bought a house at 120k and it's now worth 600k because of increased property prices and (presumably) work they've done on it then it is what it is 🤷🏻‍♀️

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 24/09/2022 12:47

@PolarPolly27 , so what do you think about single people remaining in 3 bed council homes? Is it fair to ask them to move to something smaller, so that a family on the waiting list in cramped accommodation can move in? Or does that principle apply only to owner-occupiers?

BorgQueen · 24/09/2022 12:46

Why are people arguing over IHT when there is a far worse scenario that will hit a lot more people, especially in the future?
Say you have £500k in your pension (not an unreachable sum at all, even for average earners) and you need care at £2k a week, lets assume you took the tax free lump sum on retirement so all further money is taxable above personal allowance, which State pension almost covers.
So, you need £104k a year to fund your care - £10k is from SP then you are taxed at 20% on the first £50k, then you need another £44k to make up the difference, which is taxed at 40%.
To get that £104k - you actually need to get £160k out of your pension!!

It’s truly obscene and there should be some way of money going from a pension, to a care provider that involves minimal, if any, taxation.
I was staggered to learn this, my neighbour spent £600k on dementia care for his wife and the amount of tax he paid was staggering, he had several inexpensive properties that were meant to provide retirement income and now just has his home and State pension.
Before anyone mentions care annuities , you would need £millions to buy that level of cover.

Wouldloveanother · 24/09/2022 12:43

KLFisgonnarockya · 24/09/2022 12:42

Need to start looking at quality of life. People needing hundred of thousands of pounds of care each year to prolong their bed bound misery is a disgrace

Does that mean euthanasia?

OP posts:
PolarPolly27 · 24/09/2022 12:43

girlfriend44 · 24/09/2022 11:47

Why should you pay IT though full stop. Your house, your business, your luck if it's gone up in value.

In reality though, many people who have amassed considerable wealth during their lifetime will have made sure that minimal IHT will need to be paid well before their death.

KLFisgonnarockya · 24/09/2022 12:42

Need to start looking at quality of life. People needing hundred of thousands of pounds of care each year to prolong their bed bound misery is a disgrace

Quincythequince · 24/09/2022 12:41

IHT is very easy to get out of.
Publicly saying this tax is to be used as a social care tax, will reduce the amount the treasury takes.

Explaintome · 24/09/2022 12:41

Quincythequince · 24/09/2022 12:40

But if you have enough money, you can plan for that anyway.

Not and give it all away to avoid the possibility of inheritance tax.

Quincythequince · 24/09/2022 12:40

Wouldloveanother · 24/09/2022 12:36

The incentive will be good quality care in your old age.

But if you have enough money, you can plan for that anyway.

AchatAVendre · 24/09/2022 12:37

Inheritance tax in France is 60%, starting from zero. I think thats a good level because it still lets people leave something but also benefits society. It also keeps house prices reasonable without massive inheritances fuelling giant deposits.

Wouldloveanother · 24/09/2022 12:36

Madamecastafiore · 24/09/2022 12:36

Well if it does come to that we'll start giving the kids even more money now, do equity release on our home and have a fantastic retirement because there's fuck all incentive to pass anything on when we die after working hard and saving for years.

The incentive will be good quality care in your old age.

OP posts:
Madamecastafiore · 24/09/2022 12:36

Well if it does come to that we'll start giving the kids even more money now, do equity release on our home and have a fantastic retirement because there's fuck all incentive to pass anything on when we die after working hard and saving for years.

Wouldloveanother · 24/09/2022 12:32

PolarPolly27 · 24/09/2022 12:32

So it would go in the category of a large house. Someone owns a large house that someone else thinks their entitled to. They're not. Very simple.

What on Earth are you talking about?

OP posts:
PolarPolly27 · 24/09/2022 12:32

Wouldloveanother · 24/09/2022 11:51

So? What’s the fact it has 5 bedrooms got to do with anything?

So it would go in the category of a large house. Someone owns a large house that someone else thinks their entitled to. They're not. Very simple.

JassyRadlett · 24/09/2022 12:24

^ive paid a massive amount of tax, worked since I was 12, and haven’t been able to help
my children as much as I’d have liked to. I want anything I’ve worked hard for to go to them and any grandchildren, not get put back into government coffers^

But I assume you're cool with any unearned element of your estate to be appropriately taxed as a windfall?

Are you equally up in arms about VAT?

Swipe left for the next trending thread