Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think inheritance tax should pay for social care

217 replies

Wouldloveanother · 24/09/2022 10:39

Just that really. Saw somebody else mention it on here and I think it’s a brilliant idea!

OP posts:
whumpthereitis · 24/09/2022 13:28

rockyg · 24/09/2022 13:17

IHT tax isn’t particularly difficult to minimize or avoid entirely. I know my parents sorted things out 10/11 years ago in regards to putting their assets into trust funds and signing some over to my brother and I.

It's interesting how people don't mind IHT tax evasion but other ones are frowned upon.

Tax avoidance. They worked within the law. Many, if not most, people subject to higher taxes will minimize what they owe quite legally.

Bollocks989 · 24/09/2022 13:28

Quincythequince · 24/09/2022 13:18

The taxpayer has to pay.

Exactly.

rockyg · 24/09/2022 13:27

One is legal and the result of clever planning, one is illegal.

Nonetheless plenty criticise big companies & the global elite for legal tax avoidance

Explaintome · 24/09/2022 13:22

fiftytontheresa · 24/09/2022 13:12

@Explaintome ok so you need to look at how much revenue is raised through inheritance tax, and how much is spent on social care. I imagine there is a huge discrepancy.
And as I said earlier, on many cases someone's IT bill will not cover the cost of their care. As the system is right now, they'd have to sell and use the proceeds from the property sale which of course is going to be a higher amount.
Many people who receive funded home care right now probably won't end up paying a huge amount of IT due to the thresholds, despite the significant increase in house prices.

Yes and as I've said, people who can pay would continue to pay and the scheme could only work by substantially increasing the amount of inheritance tax collected by reducing the threshold and increasing the rate. And yes, people would become better at avoiding it, so those loopholes need to be closed too.

It might not be enough to fully solve the issue, but it could definitely be a start. It won't replace the money currently funding care, but add to it.

Quincythequince · 24/09/2022 13:19

rockyg · 24/09/2022 13:17

IHT tax isn’t particularly difficult to minimize or avoid entirely. I know my parents sorted things out 10/11 years ago in regards to putting their assets into trust funds and signing some over to my brother and I.

It's interesting how people don't mind IHT tax evasion but other ones are frowned upon.

It’s not tax evasion.

It’s tax avoidance.

One is legal and the result of clever planning, one is illegal.

Quincythequince · 24/09/2022 13:18

Bollocks989 · 24/09/2022 13:12

But how will the people without homes pay for their care?

The taxpayer has to pay.

WeegieGranny · 24/09/2022 13:18

Bollocks989 · 24/09/2022 13:12

But how will the people without homes pay for their care?

Atm, self-funders' care fees are higher in order to cover the shortfall from those funded by their local authority.

rockyg · 24/09/2022 13:17

or avoidance, not sure what the right term is

rockyg · 24/09/2022 13:17

IHT tax isn’t particularly difficult to minimize or avoid entirely. I know my parents sorted things out 10/11 years ago in regards to putting their assets into trust funds and signing some over to my brother and I.

It's interesting how people don't mind IHT tax evasion but other ones are frowned upon.

rockyg · 24/09/2022 13:15

I cannot agree that taxing someone for their work via income tax is not "legalised theft" whereas not taxing them for income they haven't worked for which has come to them through chance of birth from another person, isn't.

this

Bollocks989 · 24/09/2022 13:12

But how will the people without homes pay for their care?

fiftytontheresa · 24/09/2022 13:12

@Explaintome ok so you need to look at how much revenue is raised through inheritance tax, and how much is spent on social care. I imagine there is a huge discrepancy.
And as I said earlier, on many cases someone's IT bill will not cover the cost of their care. As the system is right now, they'd have to sell and use the proceeds from the property sale which of course is going to be a higher amount.
Many people who receive funded home care right now probably won't end up paying a huge amount of IT due to the thresholds, despite the significant increase in house prices.

EmmaH2022 · 24/09/2022 13:07

BorgQueen · 24/09/2022 12:46

Why are people arguing over IHT when there is a far worse scenario that will hit a lot more people, especially in the future?
Say you have £500k in your pension (not an unreachable sum at all, even for average earners) and you need care at £2k a week, lets assume you took the tax free lump sum on retirement so all further money is taxable above personal allowance, which State pension almost covers.
So, you need £104k a year to fund your care - £10k is from SP then you are taxed at 20% on the first £50k, then you need another £44k to make up the difference, which is taxed at 40%.
To get that £104k - you actually need to get £160k out of your pension!!

It’s truly obscene and there should be some way of money going from a pension, to a care provider that involves minimal, if any, taxation.
I was staggered to learn this, my neighbour spent £600k on dementia care for his wife and the amount of tax he paid was staggering, he had several inexpensive properties that were meant to provide retirement income and now just has his home and State pension.
Before anyone mentions care annuities , you would need £millions to buy that level of cover.

The amount of tax paid - on what? - has nothing to do with how much his wife's care cost. Do you think they should be offset? Sadly the reality is that care costs a fortune.

Explaintome · 24/09/2022 13:06

fiftytontheresa · 24/09/2022 13:05

@Explaintome so people who find their own care do not pay IT?
Or just those who've needed a charge on their house to pay for care (which already happens for those going into residential but not for care provided at home.
Only those who didnt need to pay for care pay IT?
Or everyone eligible pays IT but those that didn't need to pay for care pay more??

There must be data available that shows what the current IT revenue is and the total amount spent on social care.

They'd still pay tax on what's left (to whatever the threshold is).

fiftytontheresa · 24/09/2022 13:05

@Explaintome so people who find their own care do not pay IT?
Or just those who've needed a charge on their house to pay for care (which already happens for those going into residential but not for care provided at home.
Only those who didnt need to pay for care pay IT?
Or everyone eligible pays IT but those that didn't need to pay for care pay more??

There must be data available that shows what the current IT revenue is and the total amount spent on social care.

Quincythequince · 24/09/2022 13:04

whumpthereitis · 24/09/2022 13:01

IHT tax isn’t particularly difficult to minimize or avoid entirely. I know my parents sorted things out 10/11 years ago in regards to putting their assets into trust funds and signing some over to my brother and I.

I don’t believe that I know anyone liable to pay large amounts of IHT that hasn’t employed a wealth advisor, actually.

Exactly this.
And if people are clear that that’s
what it will be used for, there will be increased efforts to ensure the tax burden is removed or at least minimised, resulting in less IHT overall.

AchatAVendre · 24/09/2022 13:02

daisyjgrey · 24/09/2022 12:49

Nobody should pay inheritance tax. It's legalised theft. Taxing something that has already been taxed? And the people it impacts are those who are left behind.

It's another one of those 'solutions' that impacts people much further down the chain than it should.

If someone bought a house at 120k and it's now worth 600k because of increased property prices and (presumably) work they've done on it then it is what it is 🤷🏻‍♀️

I cannot agree that taxing someone for their work via income tax is not "legalised theft" whereas not taxing them for income they haven't worked for which has come to them through chance of birth from another person, isn't.

As for taxing something that has already been taxed, what are your views on using taxed income to pay ££££ to commute to work in order to a have a job which is taxed?

EmmaH2022 · 24/09/2022 13:02

Wouldloveanother · 24/09/2022 12:14

Central pot, the way I see it.

But this is what happens already.

do you think inheritance tax is being wasted on something else in particular?

Cognacsoft · 24/09/2022 13:02

Explaintome · 24/09/2022 12:54

It's also not possible for parents to disinherit children in France?

Exactly.
And this is causing huge problems regarding second marriages and step children.
If a dp has no contact with their adult dc for 30 years, has remarried and both partners have contributed financially to the estate it is very galling for the remaining partner to find themselves liable to pay out a quarter of the estate to strangers, and if the adult children don't take from the estate they may still be liable for 30% tax.

whumpthereitis · 24/09/2022 13:01

IHT tax isn’t particularly difficult to minimize or avoid entirely. I know my parents sorted things out 10/11 years ago in regards to putting their assets into trust funds and signing some over to my brother and I.

I don’t believe that I know anyone liable to pay large amounts of IHT that hasn’t employed a wealth advisor, actually.

Quincythequince · 24/09/2022 13:00

PolarPolly27 · 24/09/2022 12:58

No, I think the opposite - if a single older person wishes to stay in their large home, they should. My comment was solely in relation to the PP who made the comments bout 'getting people out of large houses in catchment areas', not in relation to IHT or ability to pay for social care.

Ah, ok. Makes sense.

AchatAVendre · 24/09/2022 13:00

Agrudge · 24/09/2022 12:52

It's not important what another country . This is the uk

Of course it is. Comparison is vital to economics, its how the markets work and currency value is calculated.

FGS. Do you really have no curiosity outwith your place of birth?

And before you start off on one, I'm not French.

Theres no road tax either in France...its all an up front registration fee when you buy a new car.

Explaintome · 24/09/2022 12:58

Makes me laugh how MN wants to talk about all the ways other countries do things better but doesn't want to talk about how they raise the money to pay for it.

PolarPolly27 · 24/09/2022 12:58

Quincythequince · 24/09/2022 12:53

What do you mean?
They don’t own their own council home!
That’s it.
It’s not theirs.

And unless I’ve misunderstood you (and I accept I may have) you think older homeowners, who don’t need their space, but own their homes, should have to move out?

Apologies if I’ve got this wrong.

No, I think the opposite - if a single older person wishes to stay in their large home, they should. My comment was solely in relation to the PP who made the comments bout 'getting people out of large houses in catchment areas', not in relation to IHT or ability to pay for social care.

Cognacsoft · 24/09/2022 12:57

Agrudge · 24/09/2022 12:52

It's not important what another country . This is the uk

Surely it's informative to see how social care and IHT work in other countries if you are discussing a change to the system.