Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think inheritance tax should pay for social care

217 replies

Wouldloveanother · 24/09/2022 10:39

Just that really. Saw somebody else mention it on here and I think it’s a brilliant idea!

OP posts:
CrystalCoco · 24/09/2022 14:26

Wasting your tears crying into your cornflakes because some people stand to inherit and you don't. Life is unfair in many respects and this is just one of them. And yes, it is a lottery as to how/where you come into this world, and guess what - there's f all you can do about it.

I doubt very much that the bank of Mum & Dad want to use their money (however it was earned) to pay for social care of those who probably / possibly have not contributed anywhere near what they have already contributed over their lifetimes. Of course they want it to benefit their own families.

These same super rich already pay for private care throughout their lives, taking some of the burden from the system, and when it comes to elderly care, again paying for themselves. Lots of posters on this thread would like to bleed the rich dry in a race to the bottom. Which is hard luck really, as PPs have said, wealth advisors will show the wealthiest how to avoid paying ridiculous amounts of inheritance tax.

And for what it's worth, no I'm not likely to inherit big, I don't need to, but what will be left behind when DH & I go is sizeable and we'll do everything we can to make sure it's as tax-free as possible. I don't have socialist values and I'm sorry to break it to you but the UK is not a socialist country.

GoldenPineapple88 · 24/09/2022 14:18

Absolutely not. I think inheritance tax is abhorrent and I would abolish it completely. I will be doing everything I legally can to ensure my children don't pay a single penny of IT and my parents are doing the same for their estate.

However, I would happily pay additional tax/national insurance to fund social care. But be taxed on property that's already been taxed? Jog on 😂

Quincythequince · 24/09/2022 14:17

rockyg · 24/09/2022 14:14

I don’t think most people that get tax avoidance, have a problem with it.

So you think people who criticise Amazon etc are stupid or don't understand?

Using Rishi Sunak, the ‘billionaire chancellor’ by way of marriage to his non-dom wife, is not a good example of this.

I disagree & also think it was sexist & racist, but that's a different point.

No, because Amazon is a corporation, not an individual. We are speaking in this thread about individuals and tax avoidance. You want to discuss why corporations should fund care, by all means do so, but that’s not what this thread is about.

There is non direct comparison to be made here at all.

What was sexist and racist?

Quincythequince · 24/09/2022 14:15

rockyg · 24/09/2022 14:11

It’s a completely false equivalence and conflating it with the term ‘evasion’ is a bit of a strawman too.

I didn't conflate it, I used the wrong term & then followed it with the right one & said I forgot which one is the correct term...

Ok, but to then bring a chancellor (who himself didn’t avoid anything that we know of) and his wife’s perfectly legal activities into this by way of mention of the daily mailesque style headline is not necessary.

Rishi did nothing wrong. Neither did his wife.

Was he a palatable choice as chancellor - yes (in my view) are those affairs surrounding him and his family in any way relevant to the average person on the street - no!

rockyg · 24/09/2022 14:14

I don’t think most people that get tax avoidance, have a problem with it.

So you think people who criticise Amazon etc are stupid or don't understand?

Using Rishi Sunak, the ‘billionaire chancellor’ by way of marriage to his non-dom wife, is not a good example of this.

I disagree & also think it was sexist & racist, but that's a different point.

rockyg · 24/09/2022 14:11

It’s a completely false equivalence and conflating it with the term ‘evasion’ is a bit of a strawman too.

I didn't conflate it, I used the wrong term & then followed it with the right one & said I forgot which one is the correct term...

EmmaH2022 · 24/09/2022 14:09

BorgQueen · 24/09/2022 13:31

My point is, that you can gamble by paying an absolute fortune for a care annuity that isn’t taxed (you need approx. £500k for every £75k a year and if you only live a year, all that money is gone) from your pension or you can pay a horrific amount of tax on withdrawing the necessary cash. Money for care fees should NOT be taxed.
People with little pension provision but who own a property that is signed over for care ‘win’ in this situation, if that property is jointly owned then it’s not even taken into consideration, even if worth millions.
Do people not realise that with married couples, the last to die can leave £1million before ANY IHT is due? I don’t think it’s an unfair tax at all, it’s unfair that rich people can get around it.
If neither of us need care and we die with plenty of cash in our pensions, DD will get our house tax free and only pay her nominal rate of tax on our pensions ( if we die after 75 - before that it’s tax free) She could potentially have half a million tax free.

IHT revenue wouldn’t touch the sides of the social care budget, which is growing with the aging population.

Oh I see
yes, I can see money for care shouldn't be taxed, esp as you paid tax to earn it.

re your DD and the pension - does this mean we inherit mum's private pension? It's very small but I just thought it went with her. I thought only spouses inherited pensions.

Quincythequince · 24/09/2022 14:07

rockyg · 24/09/2022 14:02

@Quincythequince what's your point? I made the point that people are fine with some tax avoidance eg IHT but not other types. Do you disagree?

I don’t think most people that get tax avoidance, have a problem with it.

Using Rishi Sunak, the ‘billionaire chancellor’ by way of marriage to his non-dom wife, is not a good example of this.

This is a man who was going to take £20 per week from the poorest and say he was going to run the country for the good of all.

Not Joe and Sarah round the corner who make sure that they can pass on their money to their kids.

It’s a completely false equivalence and conflating it with the term ‘evasion’ is a bit of a strawman too.

rockyg · 24/09/2022 14:07

@2bazookas I literally typed avoidance straight after & said I couldn't remember what the correct term was. I know IHT tax planning is legal, I said upthread I know a few people who have circumnavigated it, including family.

My point was that I find it interesting how not all tax avoidance is criticised in the same way. As I said see the example of Rishis wife bowing to pressure despite doing nothing illegal. You can disagree though.

rockyg · 24/09/2022 14:02

@Quincythequince what's your point? I made the point that people are fine with some tax avoidance eg IHT but not other types. Do you disagree?

Quincythequince · 24/09/2022 13:57

rockyg · 24/09/2022 13:48

Tax avoidance. They worked within the law. Many, if not most, people subject to higher taxes will minimize what they owe quite legally.

I know it's legal but people do criticise companies & wealthy individuals for doing this. Look at the abuse Rishi got!

So should individuals use their ISA allowance each year then? Or not?

Is that immoral even though you are advised to do this to be more tax efficient.

Winter2020 · 24/09/2022 13:55

@girlfriend44

Quote re house prices
"Is their business their luck, their gain. Its nothing to do with anyone else.
Your already taxed on your earnings why should you be taxed on your house too.

Never ever will I agree with IT never ever.
None of the governments or the tax man's business."
End quote

Following on from your logic is dementia and other ill health in old age just their bad luck and their loss and nothing to do with anyone else?

Is it none of anyone elses business?

Or would you like ill old people/those with dementia to be helped by the public purse?

If you believe in publicly funded support in old age that's a bit what's mine is mine and what's yours is mine too.

No man (or woman) is an island.

Quincythequince · 24/09/2022 13:55

2bazookas · 24/09/2022 13:51

Rocky, you're too under-informed to comment on matters you know nothing of. IHT tax avoidance is not tax evasion.

Tax AVOIDANCE is totally legal and above board. People earning very modest incomes employ it when they claim their Personal Allowance against basic PAYE taxation. The Govt ENCOURAGES legal tax exemptions/ avoidance.

Tax evasion is illegal, and has nothing to do with Govt permitted tax reductions.

Yep, this.

Through totally legal means, I will reduce how much IHT I have to pay. Anyone is well within their rights to do this.

Quincythequince · 24/09/2022 13:54

Should nobody ever be tax efficient where they legally can be?

Quincythequince · 24/09/2022 13:53

rockyg · 24/09/2022 13:27

One is legal and the result of clever planning, one is illegal.

Nonetheless plenty criticise big companies & the global elite for legal tax avoidance

I agree. I’m just pointing out the legalities of it. I mean an ISA is tax avoidance (or tax efficient, whichever way you look at it).

2bazookas · 24/09/2022 13:51

rockyg · 24/09/2022 13:17

IHT tax isn’t particularly difficult to minimize or avoid entirely. I know my parents sorted things out 10/11 years ago in regards to putting their assets into trust funds and signing some over to my brother and I.

It's interesting how people don't mind IHT tax evasion but other ones are frowned upon.

Rocky, you're too under-informed to comment on matters you know nothing of. IHT tax avoidance is not tax evasion.

Tax AVOIDANCE is totally legal and above board. People earning very modest incomes employ it when they claim their Personal Allowance against basic PAYE taxation. The Govt ENCOURAGES legal tax exemptions/ avoidance.

Tax evasion is illegal, and has nothing to do with Govt permitted tax reductions.

rockyg · 24/09/2022 13:48

Tax avoidance. They worked within the law. Many, if not most, people subject to higher taxes will minimize what they owe quite legally.

I know it's legal but people do criticise companies & wealthy individuals for doing this. Look at the abuse Rishi got!

Bollocks989 · 24/09/2022 13:48

Wouldloveanother · 24/09/2022 13:35

So a poorer demographic has to pay for a wealthier one?

I didn't suggest that. How would that even happen? The government just keeps paying more and more out with their printing press.

BorgQueen · 24/09/2022 13:42

One more thing.
Anyone with life insurance to cover a large mortgage or to protect their family - PLEASE get it written in trust, it then takes the payout outside your estate so no IHT is due, plus it’s paid out quicker.
It must be devastating to lose a partner and then find out the life insurance that you thought would pay off the mortgage or help your family, is taxable.

2bazookas · 24/09/2022 13:42

Anybody in a position to care about IHT can afford to make their own advance financial arrangements to minimise it.

Wouldloveanother · 24/09/2022 13:35

Quincythequince · 24/09/2022 13:18

The taxpayer has to pay.

So a poorer demographic has to pay for a wealthier one?

OP posts:
FitAt50 · 24/09/2022 13:34

Iht is a horrible thing. If it was paid on all inheritances, regardless of the amount, people would be up in arms.

BorgQueen · 24/09/2022 13:31

My point is, that you can gamble by paying an absolute fortune for a care annuity that isn’t taxed (you need approx. £500k for every £75k a year and if you only live a year, all that money is gone) from your pension or you can pay a horrific amount of tax on withdrawing the necessary cash. Money for care fees should NOT be taxed.
People with little pension provision but who own a property that is signed over for care ‘win’ in this situation, if that property is jointly owned then it’s not even taken into consideration, even if worth millions.
Do people not realise that with married couples, the last to die can leave £1million before ANY IHT is due? I don’t think it’s an unfair tax at all, it’s unfair that rich people can get around it.
If neither of us need care and we die with plenty of cash in our pensions, DD will get our house tax free and only pay her nominal rate of tax on our pensions ( if we die after 75 - before that it’s tax free) She could potentially have half a million tax free.

IHT revenue wouldn’t touch the sides of the social care budget, which is growing with the aging population.

Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 24/09/2022 13:30

TippledPink · 24/09/2022 11:36

I work in social care and we have many packages of care that cost £260,000 a year, just to care for one person. We need more than inheritance tax to pay for adult social care. The costs are incredible.

This. I don’t think people realise how much local councils and local health boards/trusts are paying!

Bollocks989 · 24/09/2022 13:29

WeegieGranny · 24/09/2022 13:18

Atm, self-funders' care fees are higher in order to cover the shortfall from those funded by their local authority.

Is this not enough MN? ^^

Swipe left for the next trending thread