Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think inheritance tax should pay for social care

217 replies

Wouldloveanother · 24/09/2022 10:39

Just that really. Saw somebody else mention it on here and I think it’s a brilliant idea!

OP posts:
Figmentofmyimagination · 24/09/2022 17:42

I’ve always believed IHT should be hypothecated (ring-fenced) as a tax to fund social care - even if it doesn’t cover the full cost. It’s always seemed like a no brainer to me - then everyone who has assets pools the risk of long term ill-health such as dementia instead of it falling disproportionately on individual families - it’s not as if the individuals need their assets anymore because they are dead.

And it is ludicrous and pure political expediency to regard dementia care as somehow ‘social’ as opposed to medical care. This is just a funding device to avoid general taxation being used to fund care for this fatal disease because of the costs involved. Dementia is not simply a function of getting old. Fewer than one in five will need long term dementia care.

JassyRadlett · 24/09/2022 17:22

People want to give what they have to their own, and especially if they’ve made sacrifices to get it. It’s natural to want to help your own our first.

Though the exact same arguments apply to VAT, income tax, CGT... the only difference that IHT only directly affects people who haven't earned the money, and the other taxes affect people in a much more regressive way.

Why is IHT special? The only reason I can think of is 'I don't want to share my privilege.'

rockyg · 24/09/2022 16:34

Like I said upthread I think a fairer, more equal society would benefit my dc. My dc attend excellent schools, they have good prospects & most importantly a safety net. They don't actually need millions, they will be fine.

Quincythequince · 24/09/2022 16:23

I think the legacies left to younger people aren’t meant to help wider society.
Why would they?

People want to give what they have to their own, and especially if they’ve made sacrifices to get it. It’s natural to want to help your own our first.

JassyRadlett · 24/09/2022 16:10

I believe that all tax should (in theory) be avoidable and only paid 'knowingly'. Although, in practice, you will end up paying a lot of tax, it's because of life choices that you've made - often very good, worthy, wise choices (or realistically Hobson's choice), but still ones that you could have avoided if you'd wanted to.

IHT is a damn sight more avoidable than VAT or even income tax - you can choose not to own property, you can give sums from your savings that are above the threshold to charity, etc etc. A damn sight more feasible than never buying shoes.

Now, these choices don't add to your security and well-being, so most people do choose to own property, etc, even though it may be taxed after your death.

But arguing against IHT on the basis that it's less avoidable than income tax or VAT is frankly ludicrous. Avoiding IHT is a damn sight more comfortable and achievable than avoiding either of the other two.

rockyg · 24/09/2022 15:58

If a 10, 20, 30, 40-year-old person had the same needs, there would be no question that the NHS wouldn't pay for them, with nobody sniffing around to see what property could be taken from them or their parents to pay for it; but just because elderly people will often own their own home outright, and their death is likely not to be too far into the future, they're seen as ripe for the plucking.

But surely that ignores the fact we have an ageing population & most people haven't paid in anywhere near enough.

A 30 yr old today will face a much later pension age if they see it & it's unlikely the NHS will exist in its current form when they are old. Free prescriptions over 60 definitely won't.

We choose to leave legacies to the younger generations, often making great personal sacrifices whilst we are alive in order to do so

But how does it help wider society & don't you think it encourages more inequality?

AchatAVendre · 24/09/2022 15:44

CrystalCoco · 24/09/2022 15:06

You've massively misunderstood what I meant when I wrote "how/where you come into this world" - we can't choose our parents or our birth circumstances, I'm making reference to posters who seem to despise the privilege of others, it's a lottery at birth.
It'd be a pretty strange idea to suggest there's no freedom of movement which seems to be your interpretation of that statement.

Your argument founded on non-evidence assumptions.

I didn't state there was "no freedom of movement", I stated the opposite by pointing out that people may relocate. As they have always been able to do. In France, for instance, the minimum required monthly income for a VLS -TS (inactive) visa is 1330 euros per month. For a couple.

I haven't "massively misunderstood what [you] meant when you wrote "how/where you come into this world" - I disagreed with it and your dismissive comment about "crying over your cornflakes".

I disagreed with it because as I pointed out, the UK is extremely unusual in European terms in having extremely high house prices, relatively high taxation on middle earners and very low inheritance tax.

I made no reference at all to "the privilege of others" which you keep talking about. My interest is in making hard work more worthwhile for the majority rather than chance of birth for a smaller minority.

Are you deliberately misunderstanding what I said or do you really struggle with understanding basic discussion which diverts in opinion from your own?

Making up what you would like someone to have said so as to discredit them really isn't going to cause people to warm to you.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 24/09/2022 15:38

Do you believe in any tax? All of it comes from something somebody has ‘earned’.

I believe that all tax should (in theory) be avoidable and only paid 'knowingly'. Although, in practice, you will end up paying a lot of tax, it's because of life choices that you've made - often very good, worthy, wise choices (or realistically Hobson's choice), but still ones that you could have avoided if you'd wanted to.

Deliberately earn only within your personal allowance to avoid income tax; buy only very basic, spartan goods that aren't VAT-able (easier said than done, I know) - or even grow your own food/make your own clothes; don't run a car; don't buy any insurances etc.

These are all things that, if you were to do them, the taxman wouldn't have a say in, but if you own a house over the IHT threshold (difficult to end up doing if you've made some of the abovementioned choices, I realise), the taxman WILL force you (your estate) to pay tax by default, unless you deliberately retrospectively make arrangements to thwart them.

I think IHT is inherently a thoroughly ageist set-up. Many people in care homes are, at least partially, subject to medical health problems, rather than just general/personal care needs.

If a 10, 20, 30, 40-year-old person had the same needs, there would be no question that the NHS wouldn't pay for them, with nobody sniffing around to see what property could be taken from them or their parents to pay for it; but just because elderly people will often own their own home outright, and their death is likely not to be too far into the future, they're seen as ripe for the plucking.

Even if they are only general individual/dependence needs and non-medical - so we adjudge them out of the remit of the NHS - how is that different from the NHS covering all of the costs of a 'textbook' birth, where there are no active medical concerns other than what could potentially befall the mother and/or baby - just like numerous medical problems are considerably more likely to befall the elderly? Should the government be looking to put a charge on the expensive house of wealthy parents in order to pay for what are normal and anticipable 'beginning of life' costs? What if that same wealthy family go on to have 10 straightforward NHS births - why shouldn't they pay for what is mostly non-medical-need and very much predictable costs? Where are the people demanding to know 'why should I have to pay for other people to have more children than I could ever afford to look after?' and thus demanding they be personally taxed for their own families' needs in that respect? But flip it to the other end of life, and it's 'only' the old folk, so we don't want the burden of their needs.

I also think it's disingenuous to say that it's different because it's taking assets from a dead person who no longer needs them. Those of us with children - or those without who are also community/philanthropically-minded - don't make choices in a vacuum. We choose to leave legacies to the younger generations, often making great personal sacrifices whilst we are alive in order to do so. A deceased person's assets aren't just 'random' money that's dropped out of from nowhere - they are the proceeds of their life's work (and, yes, sometimes luck or being in the right place at the right time).

Meanwhile, lottery jackpot winners aren't taxed on their multi-millions, because they already paid 40p or whatever tax when they bought their ticket, so it's considered inherently unfair to tax them 'again'. But when you've paid lots of income tax (often off the back of hard work and sacrifice) and VAT in getting yourself comfortable and amassing a few valuable assets, it somehow is fair to tax you again on it.

For the record, I'm not wealthy and none of my family have ever been (or likely will be) anywhere near the IHT threshold, but I think the whole system is grossly unfair and discriminatory in a huge number of cases. Maybe somebody should campaign against it and take the case right up the top, to the King, as surely he will understand fairness....

rockyg · 24/09/2022 15:26

I was really surprised the gov didn't target VAT but I guess as that helps the poorer it was off the table.

rockyg · 24/09/2022 15:23

@JassyRadlett they worked harder for it? 🤔

rockyg · 24/09/2022 15:21

I'm making reference to posters who seem to despise the privilege of others

I don't think people who think inheritance should be changed & taxes more despise others. I think a fairer more equal society is better for me even though changes to IHT would impact me.

JassyRadlett · 24/09/2022 15:21

Honestly, can anyone explain why IHT is reprehensible/legalised theft/whatever because it's a tax on previously taxed income (despite us all knowing that a large part of most estates is a windfall from property price rises, and despite the person who paid the tax being dead and not affected in any way by the taxation, it's the recipients who haven't earned it who are affected) - but they don't see VAT, CGT on shares, stamp duty, whatever as the same principle?

(And in the case of VAT massively more regressive in terms of who pays.)

BorgQueen · 24/09/2022 15:20

With a private /Direct contribution pension, like an employers scheme with no special conditions or a SIPP, you can leave it to whoever you like, whether it’s in drawdown or not. Your Mum should have you down as beneficiaries within her pension account, if it’s been turned into an annuity however, it dies with her.
It’s only DB schemes, where there is no actual pot of money, just a promise to pay x amount per year, that normally have spouse only payments, usually at 50% - my DH gets a military pension at 60, if he dies then I would get half, for life.

JassyRadlett · 24/09/2022 15:17

Nobody should pay inheritance tax. It's legalised theft. Taxing something that has already been taxed?

You must fucking hate VAT. Far more VAT is levied on previously taxed income than IHT, a large proportion of which is on unearned above-inflation increases in property values.

And the people it impacts are those who are left behind.

Who haven't worked for this windfall, and will still inherit?

CrystalCoco · 24/09/2022 15:06

AchatAVendre · 24/09/2022 14:32

CrystalCoco Wasting your tears crying into your cornflakes because some people stand to inherit and you don't. Life is unfair in many respects and this is just one of them. And yes, it is a lottery as to how/where you come into this world, and guess what - there's f all you can do about it.

What an odd comment.

Surely even the most patriotic must be aware that Britain is an unusual position, due to high house prices and low inheritance tax? And it has relatively high income taxes on middle income earners.

Taxation is hardly static or unchangeable, so why on earth wouldn't people comment on it??

There is also plenty you can do about it. Moving or retiring abroad is just one of them. Still possible even after Brexit in many countries.

You've massively misunderstood what I meant when I wrote "how/where you come into this world" - we can't choose our parents or our birth circumstances, I'm making reference to posters who seem to despise the privilege of others, it's a lottery at birth.
It'd be a pretty strange idea to suggest there's no freedom of movement which seems to be your interpretation of that statement.

Wouldloveanother · 24/09/2022 14:54

dottiedodah · 24/09/2022 14:47

I find it incredible that older people who can afford it should be expected to give up their home (which they have likely lived in for most of their life) just because someone younger might need it!

If they need to do that to pay for their care, why not? If I was made redundant the bank would likely repossess my house, the fact I have small children would mean nothing to them. Why are houses only seen as emotional and sacred when it’s the elderly?

OP posts:
dottiedodah · 24/09/2022 14:47

I find it incredible that older people who can afford it should be expected to give up their home (which they have likely lived in for most of their life) just because someone younger might need it!

Icedlatteplease · 24/09/2022 14:42

Posted to soon...

If it will be used on for example my sons social care it will be used within a year, my DS's social care will still need funding so will our benefits.

It's a very very short sighted approach

Quincythequince · 24/09/2022 14:41

And I don’t actually disagree outright with your points, I am just questioning the relevance of some of what you say on this thread, that’s all.

Don’t get shirty about it.

Icedlatteplease · 24/09/2022 14:40

The amount my parents will leave me when they die means eventually I will be able to come off benefits and support myself and my kids.

If it was used to fund

Quincythequince · 24/09/2022 14:39

I mean, lottery wins since we’re moving on from individuals and IHT.

Those massive wins that you hear about?

How are they taxed? Can we do more to get a fair share of that too?

Quincythequince · 24/09/2022 14:37

rockyg · 24/09/2022 14:30

@Quincythequince sorry I didn't get the memo about what is allowed to be discussed & what isn't. Do you have a list?

We are speaking in this thread about individuals and tax avoidance.

Isn't it about paying for care & funding it from inheritance tax? I simply made the point that I find it interesting why some tax avoidance is criticised but others is a positive. It was a flippant comment but I'm not sure why that triggered you & it's gone on to a massive derail. Just agree to disagree! I'm bored of the back & forth, surely you are? I'm sure everyone else is! 😆

There is no memo, but many of your responses are whataboutery. To suddenly mention Amazon when individuals say they will minimise their IHT burden doesn’t make a lot of sense.

And Fine, clearly you can move on from the original topic. But nowhere has it been mentioned about corporates paying more tax to fund IHT, so you’ll get questioned on it, because it’s confusing.
It’s not derailed it. I am legitimately engaging with points you are making. What’s wrong with that?

FWIW I think corporations need to pay way more. Waaaaay more!

whumpthereitis · 24/09/2022 14:37

rockyg · 24/09/2022 13:48

Tax avoidance. They worked within the law. Many, if not most, people subject to higher taxes will minimize what they owe quite legally.

I know it's legal but people do criticise companies & wealthy individuals for doing this. Look at the abuse Rishi got!

Well yes, but in my experience no one utilizing financial advisors and minimizing their tax burden particularly cares about criticism*. It is what it is.

*with the exception of Rishi Sunak, and those similar to him, who depend on the good will of voters.

AchatAVendre · 24/09/2022 14:32

CrystalCoco Wasting your tears crying into your cornflakes because some people stand to inherit and you don't. Life is unfair in many respects and this is just one of them. And yes, it is a lottery as to how/where you come into this world, and guess what - there's f all you can do about it.

What an odd comment.

Surely even the most patriotic must be aware that Britain is an unusual position, due to high house prices and low inheritance tax? And it has relatively high income taxes on middle income earners.

Taxation is hardly static or unchangeable, so why on earth wouldn't people comment on it??

There is also plenty you can do about it. Moving or retiring abroad is just one of them. Still possible even after Brexit in many countries.

rockyg · 24/09/2022 14:30

@Quincythequince sorry I didn't get the memo about what is allowed to be discussed & what isn't. Do you have a list?

We are speaking in this thread about individuals and tax avoidance.

Isn't it about paying for care & funding it from inheritance tax? I simply made the point that I find it interesting why some tax avoidance is criticised but others is a positive. It was a flippant comment but I'm not sure why that triggered you & it's gone on to a massive derail. Just agree to disagree! I'm bored of the back & forth, surely you are? I'm sure everyone else is! 😆