Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think inheritance tax should pay for social care

217 replies

Wouldloveanother · 24/09/2022 10:39

Just that really. Saw somebody else mention it on here and I think it’s a brilliant idea!

OP posts:
rockyg · 25/09/2022 11:33

I know loads of people who did it this way including my inlaws but obvs it's a gamble

rockyg · 25/09/2022 11:31

Also to a pp who says they know someone who inherited a £1.5m property tax free, this is either not true or there’s another factor (trusts etc.).

Or the 7 yr rule

FudgeSundae · 25/09/2022 11:29

Heartbreaktuna · 25/09/2022 10:11

If you were married and leave your estate to a direct descendant IT relief is over £1m (2x 325k relief plus 2x residential nil rate bands). So I'm not sure how much that would raise.

This is incorrect - you get the 325k nil rate band OR the 500k residence band, not both. The maximum anyone can get (if second surviving spouse) is £1m nil rate band.

Also to a pp who says they know someone who inherited a £1.5m property tax free, this is either not true or there’s another factor (trusts etc.).

and to the pp who said “what if you bought a property in London for 800k and now worth 3.75m… well you’d pay £1.3m in IHT, that’s what if. Seems quite a lot to me.

FWIW I cheerfully paid over £250k of tax when my mum died, and it meant we had to sell her house. I’m not quite sure how people on this thread want to increase it but it’s a toss up between collecting a lot and incentivising undesirable behaviour (people giving away/spending assets). 40% seems a good balance to me.

rockyg · 25/09/2022 11:21

We have worked hard non of the family has ever lived in a rented property we rarely use public transport other than children at times going to their HQ's in central London . We gifted between our kids recently around 500k they did not want it all work all have a property to live in and or BTL

What has working hard got to do with renting a property?

FreddyHG · 25/09/2022 11:10

Indeed set the limit at 0 and it will soon raise enough.

Wouldloveanother · 25/09/2022 11:08

Apparently fewer than 1 in 25 estates pay inheritance tax.

IHT only raises about £3 billion a year,

Probably related

OP posts:
rocketfromthecrypt · 25/09/2022 10:23

IHT only raises about £3 billion a year, I believe. Nowhere near enough to pay for social care. I'd support higher IHT rather than higher income tax. Why should some people get a windfall which they haven't earned and others not?

Getoff · 25/09/2022 10:12

Wouldloveanother · 24/09/2022 10:39

Just that really. Saw somebody else mention it on here and I think it’s a brilliant idea!

Apparently fewer than 1 in 25 estates pay inheritance tax.

If the proposal is that those people pay for their own care, that's OK, but hardly going to solve the societal issue.

If the proposal is that those people pay for themselves as well as 24 other people's aggregate costs, then yes, I can see how a measure that means nearly everyone would benefit from someone else's money would be popular.

(I've ignored whether there is actually enough money, which is a separate but valid issue.)

Heartbreaktuna · 25/09/2022 10:11

If you were married and leave your estate to a direct descendant IT relief is over £1m (2x 325k relief plus 2x residential nil rate bands). So I'm not sure how much that would raise.

Sally573 · 25/09/2022 10:09

@JamesBondOO7 how have they paid taxes on taxes? Sorry I'm not very knowledgeable about these things..

JamesBondOO7 · 25/09/2022 10:02

Sally573 · 25/09/2022 09:56

I have a question relating to something one of the pp said.. that her and her dp stand to inherit a portion of 6 properties that their parents own. Is it part of the problem in this country that comfortable/wealthy people buy up properties to rent or air bnb out, meaning less availability for younger people to get a foot on the housing ladder? Sorry I know that isn't about inheritance tax and I don't mean to derail or be goady but it's something that really concerns me and has done for a long time.

Good luck to that person - their parent have paid taxes on taxes - why penalise someone for hard work and prudence?

Trust me, if taxes keep on rising and IHT is raised we'd buy new cars, fly first class and 8 international hols a year and millions of others would do this and as a result IHT receipts would dive

JamesBondOO7 · 25/09/2022 10:00

CrystalCoco · 24/09/2022 14:26

Wasting your tears crying into your cornflakes because some people stand to inherit and you don't. Life is unfair in many respects and this is just one of them. And yes, it is a lottery as to how/where you come into this world, and guess what - there's f all you can do about it.

I doubt very much that the bank of Mum & Dad want to use their money (however it was earned) to pay for social care of those who probably / possibly have not contributed anywhere near what they have already contributed over their lifetimes. Of course they want it to benefit their own families.

These same super rich already pay for private care throughout their lives, taking some of the burden from the system, and when it comes to elderly care, again paying for themselves. Lots of posters on this thread would like to bleed the rich dry in a race to the bottom. Which is hard luck really, as PPs have said, wealth advisors will show the wealthiest how to avoid paying ridiculous amounts of inheritance tax.

And for what it's worth, no I'm not likely to inherit big, I don't need to, but what will be left behind when DH & I go is sizeable and we'll do everything we can to make sure it's as tax-free as possible. I don't have socialist values and I'm sorry to break it to you but the UK is not a socialist country.

@CrystalCoco

Excellent post and one I could have almost written
As I've said my parents, dad was worth around the million but as he remairred when I was 21 when mum died, just before he died years ago he wanted to leave me something I said thanks but no dad as you have a new family.

My wifes family worth a mill or so because of our culture most old timers leave everything for their son/s. We were happy with that as we have always stood on our own two feet

We have worked hard non of the family has ever lived in a rented property we rarely use public transport other than children at times going to their HQ's in central London . We gifted between our kids recently around 500k they did not want it all work all have a property to live in and or BTL

We still have money and property and like most pay taxes on it again and again CGT etc etc on top of PAYE, taxes, NI etc etc

Why should our prudent spending working hard always support those that are or had the capacity to work but could never be bothered to be prudent with their money EG not live hand to mouth and live off credit cards?

I'm not referring to those that worked and lost job/income via ill health but the millions who by presnets, go on hols, buy phones, sky cars etc on credit - why buy a car for 40k and repay 60k when you could save up and not pay interest

Having said that, I have always found that those with hardly anything in their names will always support taxing not just the rich but ordinary people who have worked hard and spent and saved wisely as they want to jsut support their kids, grandkids and ensure they are not a burden on the state when they retire so thos that really need help can get it.

Sally573 · 25/09/2022 09:56

I have a question relating to something one of the pp said.. that her and her dp stand to inherit a portion of 6 properties that their parents own. Is it part of the problem in this country that comfortable/wealthy people buy up properties to rent or air bnb out, meaning less availability for younger people to get a foot on the housing ladder? Sorry I know that isn't about inheritance tax and I don't mean to derail or be goady but it's something that really concerns me and has done for a long time.

InsertPunHere · 25/09/2022 09:48

IHT is the fairest tax there is.

"Hi, taxpayer. Having a civilised society with health care and social care and education is insanely expensive. We know you can't afford to pay for it all through taxation while you're working and raising a family, and won't have a big enough income in retirement to do so. Instead, we'll keep taxes moderate and take the rest off when you've died and don't need money anymore."

Those who - through luck, good timing, hard work or inherited privilege - amassed greater wealth will send more back to the public coffers than those who didn't.

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 25/09/2022 09:46

We really need people to get out of large houses in catchment areas and this might help.

This makes no sense... if all the large houses around a school are taken up with couples with no kids, the catchment area just gets wider 🤷‍♀️

You do realise there's no such thing as a catchment area? The school just casts its net as wide as it needs to each year to fill the school.

fiftytontheresa · 25/09/2022 09:39

Nat6999 · 25/09/2022 06:23

No, the majority of old people don't need social care so why should they pay for something they don't use. Better for something to run alongside workplace pensions to provide a fund for each person's social care & if they don't use it then it is passed to their estate after they die. My aunt is in a care home due to dementia, my uncle has recently died & my cousin can't sell their house due to red tape about the care home getting their money, my aunt & uncle were tenants in common. In the meantime my cousin is having to pay council tax as it is over 6 months since the house became empty & the energy bills as they can't be finalised until the day the house is sold, I don't know how she is affording to pay them. Why should dementia be any different to someone who has cancer & qualifies for continuing health care & gets all their care paid for?

Continuing health care is based on nursing needs not diagnosis, so someone with dementia could get CHC funding if assessed as eligible.

JassyRadlett · 25/09/2022 09:37

That's not the fault of the person who bought it though... so why penalise them or their family.

You're not penalising them, they're dead. This is a much fairer way to handle the untaxed windfall than other measures that hit while they're alive such as property or wealth tax.

Their family still gets an unearned windfall, just less of one than if it hadn't been taxed. They're not 'penalised', they're being part of society in the same way as people paying CGT, income tax, VAT...

Nat6999 · 25/09/2022 06:23

No, the majority of old people don't need social care so why should they pay for something they don't use. Better for something to run alongside workplace pensions to provide a fund for each person's social care & if they don't use it then it is passed to their estate after they die. My aunt is in a care home due to dementia, my uncle has recently died & my cousin can't sell their house due to red tape about the care home getting their money, my aunt & uncle were tenants in common. In the meantime my cousin is having to pay council tax as it is over 6 months since the house became empty & the energy bills as they can't be finalised until the day the house is sold, I don't know how she is affording to pay them. Why should dementia be any different to someone who has cancer & qualifies for continuing health care & gets all their care paid for?

Devilishpyjamas · 25/09/2022 05:15

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll

This isn’t true If a 10, 20, 30, 40-year-old person had the same needs, there would be no question that the NHS wouldn't pay for them, with nobody sniffing around to see what property could be taken from them or their parents to pay for it; but just because elderly people will often own their own home outright, and their death is likely not to be too far into the future, they're seen as ripe for the plucking.

younger people with social care needs do pay for their care. The assessment deciding whether NHS or they pay/contribute to their care is exactly the same as the one used for elderly people.

Travellingwomble · 25/09/2022 05:09

A relative had all of the money she had saved in her life used up on her healthcare in her last years. She wanted to leave something for her children and worked accordingly. She invested in her home over the years and it accumulated in value but was sold to pay for her care. She was in a nursing homeand the people in the room adjacent to her never worked a day in their lives and not because they couldnt either. I'm all for a caring society but this seems very unfair. Btw I wasnt one of ber children.

The 'good' news is that the way things are going few of us will be able to afford to buy a house never mind run it, so another generation or so and the inheritance thing will be redundant.

Still wondering where all the money for healthcare from Brexit has gone and interested to know if anything was ever done about taxing the Amazons Costas Starbucks of this world proportionately , or is it the minions who are just liable to tax ?

Flyingwithoutwing · 25/09/2022 04:53

Dazedandconfused10 · 25/09/2022 04:43

That's not the fault of the person who bought it though... so why penalise them or their family.

I didn't realise we were purchasing homes now hoping they decreased in value.

i know someone who bought a house for £20k, lived in it for 50 years and sold it for £1.5m. This money is totally and utterly tax free. Have they earned that money? No.

this country needs to raise taxes. Is it fairer to up income tax, or to find some means of taxing Mr £1.5m? Yes, a capital gains tax on property while scrapping stamp duty would be fairer, but if that £1.5m is caught by inheritance tax that’s also fair. House prices increases are not earned money, and so are not taxed.

High house prices are so bad for this country:

takes up so much salary people don’t want to pay income taxes (our basic rate tax is low compared to other European counties, but our average house price is much higher)

People are put off having families until later on in life due to saving for a house / have smaller families due to not being able to afford as big a house as they’d like.

Those with bank of mum and dad are much more likely to get on the housing ladder, ingraining inequalities.

Breeds inter generational resentment.

Dazedandconfused10 · 25/09/2022 04:43

Flyingwithoutwing · 25/09/2022 04:18

Because the value of that house has been inflated massively due to house price rises and that’s unearned, untaxed income.

That's not the fault of the person who bought it though... so why penalise them or their family.

I didn't realise we were purchasing homes now hoping they decreased in value.

Flyingwithoutwing · 25/09/2022 04:18

girlfriend44 · 24/09/2022 11:39

No because I don't believe in IT.
Why should you be taxed on a house you bought it's yours.

Because the value of that house has been inflated massively due to house price rises and that’s unearned, untaxed income.

Binkybix · 25/09/2022 04:10

Tax AVOIDANCE is totally legal and above board. People earning very modest incomes employ it when they claim their Personal Allowance against basic PAYE taxation. The Govt ENCOURAGES legal tax exemptions/ avoidance

I think you have this wrong. Evasion = illegal. Avoidance = co-opting a mechanism intended for a different purpose to reduce tax. Planning = taking advantage of schemes in the way they were designed to be used eg ISA

Binkybix · 25/09/2022 04:07

In some ways it would be better to stop taxing the estates and shift the tax to the recipients, who would then pay tax on it as either a capital gain or income. Capital gains, for choice

Agree with this 100%. A think tank headed by David willets suggested just this - a lifetime allowance , then taxed as if income. Which it is really, it’s just that the recipient has done nothing to earn it.