Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most Brexiteers must now regret their vote?

534 replies

hoovermanouvre · 24/09/2022 09:29

If you voted Brexit, do you feel like you have been able to "Take Back Control?" If so, where? Can anyone state one positive change since Brexit - I would genuinely like to hear at least something. Anything?

YANBU - I voted Brexit but now regret it
YABU - I voted Brexit and can see a benefit

OP posts:
jgw1 · 27/09/2022 07:22

Cillery · 27/09/2022 06:58

Let’s face it the idiocy of the Lisbon Treaty where people voted it down in countries where referendums were held (including France) but then it crept in by the backdoor by the machinations of European bureaucrats was a typical example of how these people want to get rid of democracy and put themselves at the centre of an unelected Europe. What is going on in Italy is a kickback against these people

@Cillery on the subject of democracy are you happy to have new unelected Heads of State and Government, with the latter paying no attention to any democratic mandate?

Cillery · 27/09/2022 06:58

Let’s face it the idiocy of the Lisbon Treaty where people voted it down in countries where referendums were held (including France) but then it crept in by the backdoor by the machinations of European bureaucrats was a typical example of how these people want to get rid of democracy and put themselves at the centre of an unelected Europe. What is going on in Italy is a kickback against these people

jgw1 · 27/09/2022 06:15

Tiani4 · 27/09/2022 01:06

My worry all along is that a number of European countries were becoming more far right. And I don't think U.K. wants to be pulled into that . Not do I think we want to get pulled into centralisation without accountabilities in those making those policies

It's not where a democracy wants to go

Have you paid any attention to the current UK government?

Tiani4 · 27/09/2022 01:06

My worry all along is that a number of European countries were becoming more far right. And I don't think U.K. wants to be pulled into that . Not do I think we want to get pulled into centralisation without accountabilities in those making those policies

It's not where a democracy wants to go

Tiani4 · 27/09/2022 00:56

This could be a useful discussion of what is working Brexit and what isn't working... and then you get ignorant posters who can't even listen to any one else's posts !!! Why do a select population of MNers do this? Why do PPs not try to engage? but instead hey get jingoistic and controlling about their fixed views?

Tiani4 · 27/09/2022 00:53

And first sentence too. The IIRONY of @BambinaJAS calling other people ignorant is not lost on the intelligent posters!!!

What an absolute joke a/he is

Tiani4 · 27/09/2022 00:52

Sorry the 2nd third and fourth paragraphs are a quote from an ignorant poster @BambinaJAS

Tiani4 · 27/09/2022 00:50

@BambinaJAS
So, another delusional leaver.

Why do we even let you people vote?

Letting people vote on things they have zero knowledge on is sheer folly.

Thats also precisely why civilised countries banned referendums.

Yet another ignorant person who doesn't get the complexities of how people voted or why they did not even ca. talk about the concerns about how EU politics are going.

It's really worrying when this level of ignorance and black and white thinking without eve. Understanding who criticised others & ignore those wgo have tried to talk about why we might have been and still are concerned (with EVIDENCE as Italy is going far right PM too!) --- and it doesn't fit your usual jingoistic rhetorical thick belief, , that a huge number of voters like you @BambinaJAS ate the worst!!! Ignorant as anything!!!
Well done for pointing yourself as covered in ignorance.

There are complexities involved and I really worry about the low level of intelligence in trying to talk about those. Most intelligent people can at least try to make at least a coherent argument- it's all an unknown area which is what I believe and that we all tried to find a way forward.

TomPinch · 27/09/2022 00:39

MsJinks,

It was a terrible thing to just say leave or stay without any parameters or guidance- even leaving out the misinformation debacles.

Perhaps, but I doubt that the EU would have agreed an alternative for Cameron to put to the voters. Even if they hadn't been completely intransigent I don't see how it would have been workable. Potentially years of negotiations before a vote was even held.

What I found less excusable was that there weren't any plans in the event of a Leave vote. That really was his job. But (in my opinion anyway) his was a pretty rubbish government.

TomPinch · 27/09/2022 00:30

Kendodd · 26/09/2022 22:18

But some things obviously are too complex for the public to decide on, that's why we have experts. That's not some sort of insult to the public, we're not experts and shouldn't be expected to be. Brexit is an obvious example.

Hah! I see what you did there 😉

I accept that we have to rely on experts to, for example, design and build our bridges, maintain them, and decide what safety standards they should be built and maintained under.

How we're governed and how our laws are made is very clearly a different matter. For better or for worse, this is absolutely the business of the public. Would you have denied the Scots a referendum in 2014? Membership of the EU meant a huge and increasing outsourcing of making the UK's laws. If you say this is only a matter for experts you undermine the whole basis for democracy, which is that the public get to choose who gets to make the laws and who administers them.

Also regarding 'experts' I reckon it's been forgotten just how badly the UK was affected by the GFC. It hasn't really recovered. So it's not surprising that the experts, ie, the economists, bankers and regulators have been on probation since, because they let it all happen. Because they got it horrendously wrong and didn't face up to this, their advice got ignored in 2016.

DdraigGoch · 27/09/2022 00:11

Alexandra2001 · 26/09/2022 21:23

Its fairly obvious obvious most people, leave or remain, hadn't a clue what they were voting for.
Hand on heart did you know ALL about Horizon, state aid rules, erasmus, med and banking agencies, wto tariffs, SM CU, europol, nuclear medicine, CAP/CFP/pilar 1 pilar 2?

I suspect you do know the Swiss have many safe guards in place for referendums, the brexit vote had none, including on who was funding it or the influence of unelected thinktanks on Cameron and May, fgs it wasn't even an election held under EC rules....

I'm sure that plenty of people vote on plenty of issues without being fully aware of the implications. That doesn't mean that they should be deprived of their right to vote. That would lead us down a very dark path.

MangyInseam · 26/09/2022 23:49

I would think that people's views now would depend on why they voted as they voted as they did, and also on what they see happening in, say, the next 50 years.

Six years, and really less than that, isn't a reasonable timescale to judge something like leaving (or entering) the EU.

I tend to think the EU is screwed anyway, and it may turn out to be better to be out of it's death throes. But that's a projection obviously, no one can know.

MsJinks · 26/09/2022 23:08

TomPinch · 26/09/2022 22:14

I did think, however, that having the Tory government we had then was the worst possible party to implement leaving and would take advantage of it for themselves and rich folk.

Except that Cameron's government was Remain. That's what he himself wanted. The EU has been very good at making Tories very rich. He took a gamble to shut the Brexiteers up, and he lost.

Actually I think (from the outside looking in) that the Tories are in chaos due to Brexit. The party has been taken over by the right-wing version of Momentum. They're motivated by ideologues at least as much as by greed.

You’re right and I debated with myself over putting that, as I was actually looking back at Cameron’s government thinking how awesome it must have been then, compared with today, and wasn’t sure I’d have thought that as much, despite not being particularly enamoured of policy. However, I do know I said it, so maybe in the moment it wasn’t as good as it might now seem in comparison!
Interesting to consider whether brexit has caused this current and recent showers’ performances. Maybe as it’s taken over so much for a few years now - bottom line we knew what staying in EU meant and the work it wouldn’t be causing - we had no idea what leaving was going to look like with the huge range of options and no idea how much work there would be to untangle 50 years of integration. It was a terrible thing to just say leave or stay without any parameters or guidance- even leaving out the misinformation debacles.

Kendodd · 26/09/2022 22:18

TomPinch · 26/09/2022 22:09

That argument is a double-edged sword.

If it's too complicated to have a referendum on, it's also too complicated to be democratic.

But some things obviously are too complex for the public to decide on, that's why we have experts. That's not some sort of insult to the public, we're not experts and shouldn't be expected to be. Brexit is an obvious example.

TomPinch · 26/09/2022 22:14

I did think, however, that having the Tory government we had then was the worst possible party to implement leaving and would take advantage of it for themselves and rich folk.

Except that Cameron's government was Remain. That's what he himself wanted. The EU has been very good at making Tories very rich. He took a gamble to shut the Brexiteers up, and he lost.

Actually I think (from the outside looking in) that the Tories are in chaos due to Brexit. The party has been taken over by the right-wing version of Momentum. They're motivated by ideologues at least as much as by greed.

TomPinch · 26/09/2022 22:09

Alexandra2001 · 26/09/2022 21:23

Its fairly obvious obvious most people, leave or remain, hadn't a clue what they were voting for.
Hand on heart did you know ALL about Horizon, state aid rules, erasmus, med and banking agencies, wto tariffs, SM CU, europol, nuclear medicine, CAP/CFP/pilar 1 pilar 2?

I suspect you do know the Swiss have many safe guards in place for referendums, the brexit vote had none, including on who was funding it or the influence of unelected thinktanks on Cameron and May, fgs it wasn't even an election held under EC rules....

That argument is a double-edged sword.

If it's too complicated to have a referendum on, it's also too complicated to be democratic.

MarshaBradyo · 26/09/2022 21:49

Well we were all in the same boat then and ‘Why do we even let you people vote?’ doesn’t reflect well on them

MsJinks · 26/09/2022 21:48

I am very much a remainer, for a raft of reasons mostly discussed on this thread already. I did think, however, that having the Tory government we had then was the worst possible party to implement leaving and would take advantage of it for themselves and rich folk. I told my parents who were glad to leave that even if I accepted/ agreed we should leave just we shouldn’t do it under the government of the time, who didn’t even have an outline of what would happen let alone a plan. Mainly I just didn’t trust them to maintain rights, standards, share any cash with deserving causes or regions. Maybe it could have been better - unlikely to be seen how it could have been beneficial for decades probably, but at least not scary.
I remain sorry to have left but we have done and next hope is for it to be managed pragmatically going forwards - a hope that gets dashed more each day. Anyway, as seems to happen under this consistently gobsmacking government my worries change and currently are on survival of people and environment in this country. I do think that obviously these are linked to brexit, but they didn’t need to be the result of Brexit, it’s compounded by the worst possible people utilising ‘freedom’ from the EU stuff not to improve anything for the whole, but to play games and gamble with the future of a whole country due to some fantasy ideology.

Kendodd · 26/09/2022 21:45

Alexandra2001 · 26/09/2022 21:23

Its fairly obvious obvious most people, leave or remain, hadn't a clue what they were voting for.
Hand on heart did you know ALL about Horizon, state aid rules, erasmus, med and banking agencies, wto tariffs, SM CU, europol, nuclear medicine, CAP/CFP/pilar 1 pilar 2?

I suspect you do know the Swiss have many safe guards in place for referendums, the brexit vote had none, including on who was funding it or the influence of unelected thinktanks on Cameron and May, fgs it wasn't even an election held under EC rules....

I agree.
I think the biggest give away of someone who didn't have a clue what they were voting for is when a person says they 'understood what they voted for' because anyone who says that hasn't even grasped the complexity of the question. It became clear pretty quickly that even the MPs championing this didn't have a clue what it entailed, Dominic Cummings himself said as much.

Alexandra2001 · 26/09/2022 21:23

DdraigGoch · 26/09/2022 20:54

Aren't you a peach. I have to congratulate you, every time I think that you can sink no further, you prove me wrong. You should join the Submarine Service.

Pray tell, which "civilised countries" banned referendums? The Swiss have held hundreds at Federal level since 1848, plus thousands more at Cantonal level.

Its fairly obvious obvious most people, leave or remain, hadn't a clue what they were voting for.
Hand on heart did you know ALL about Horizon, state aid rules, erasmus, med and banking agencies, wto tariffs, SM CU, europol, nuclear medicine, CAP/CFP/pilar 1 pilar 2?

I suspect you do know the Swiss have many safe guards in place for referendums, the brexit vote had none, including on who was funding it or the influence of unelected thinktanks on Cameron and May, fgs it wasn't even an election held under EC rules....

TomPinch · 26/09/2022 21:08

BambinaJAS · 26/09/2022 19:52

So, another delusional leaver.

Why do we even let you people vote?

Letting people vote on things they have zero knowledge on is sheer folly.

Thats also precisely why civilised countries banned referendums.

You're actually making a pro-Brexit argument, just inadvertantly. If a system of government is too complicated for the average person to understand, democracy is put in danger.

For all its good points (and they're many) the EU is a bit of a Heath Robinson contraption, and it does make lawmaking very remote.

DdraigGoch · 26/09/2022 21:06

OneTC · 26/09/2022 20:28

That kind of total democracy where everything went to a referendum would be fucking ugly, fucking quickly

It works in Switzerland. Though constitutional changes require a double majority - that is not only do you need an overall majority of the population, there must also be a majority in every single canton.

Kendodd · 26/09/2022 21:02

GyozaGuiting · 26/09/2022 20:50

I voted Brexit and I Regret it. It could have been handled so much better by us and the EU, but the opportunities haven’t been taken and it’s part of the reason the economy is going to shit.
I think it’s very important for us to admit when we’re wrong, and I also think it’s fine to change your mind of political things.

So yep I was definitely wrong! I also thought Boris would do a good job as PM as I really rated him as London Major. Wrong on that too (I am occasionally right on things! Just not those 2)

I agree, it is really, really important to admit you have taken the wrong road and change track, not just in politics, in life as well. Unfortunately, Brexit was very much about feelings, it is an identity (as is remain) I think this is one reason and Brexit damage is irrelevant and will never change minds. The most obvious example of this is the DUP stance. Their biggest fear in life is a united Ireland, it is completely obvious to everyone that Brexit has done more than anything ever to bring this possibility closer. They DUP are still absolutely 100% lovers of Brexit though, best thing ever for them.

Cillery · 26/09/2022 21:00

BambinaJAS · 26/09/2022 20:05

The point stands.

These people have shown that they had absolutely no clue as to what they were voting for.

Thats not Democracy. Democracy only works when people have a basic education about what they are voting for.

What we have now is MOB RULE.

A bunch of folks easily manipulated by a very thin slice of the population.

Again, why do we allow this?

Its downright insane. And what is happening now is what happens when the extremism that generates reaches the end of the road.

Great! So what do we do? Ban the national franchise? I believe it was Churchill who said that democracy is the worst form of government apart from everything else that has been tried.

DdraigGoch · 26/09/2022 20:54

BambinaJAS · 26/09/2022 19:52

So, another delusional leaver.

Why do we even let you people vote?

Letting people vote on things they have zero knowledge on is sheer folly.

Thats also precisely why civilised countries banned referendums.

Aren't you a peach. I have to congratulate you, every time I think that you can sink no further, you prove me wrong. You should join the Submarine Service.

Pray tell, which "civilised countries" banned referendums? The Swiss have held hundreds at Federal level since 1848, plus thousands more at Cantonal level.