Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most Brexiteers must now regret their vote?

534 replies

hoovermanouvre · 24/09/2022 09:29

If you voted Brexit, do you feel like you have been able to "Take Back Control?" If so, where? Can anyone state one positive change since Brexit - I would genuinely like to hear at least something. Anything?

YANBU - I voted Brexit but now regret it
YABU - I voted Brexit and can see a benefit

OP posts:
jgw1 · 27/09/2022 10:17

DdraigGoch · 27/09/2022 08:32

Before we left, how did your vote influence the selection of the European Commission?

It didn't, and my vote doesn't influence who is our Head of State or Head of Government either.

Kendodd · 27/09/2022 10:15

RudsyFarmer · 27/09/2022 10:04

Were we ever asked if we wanted to join the EU? I don’t think we were.

No, likewise other international organisations. We voted for people/parties with manifestos to take expert advice and make those decisions for us. Personally, this was how I approached the EU referendum. The vast majority of experts, on every aspect, supported remain. That and the impact Brexit would have on the peace in NI made my decision for me.

RudsyFarmer · 27/09/2022 10:04

Were we ever asked if we wanted to join the EU? I don’t think we were.

Kendodd · 27/09/2022 10:02

Remainers could have persuaded me but chose to call me a racist idiot for considering to vote Leave.

Most people I know personally who voted Leave are racist. Proper 'they should all fuck off home' racist. Look at the people and groups who supported Leave, EDL, Britain First etc, every racist group in the UK supported Leave, no exceptions. The racism attached to the leave voter didn't come from nowhere, it wasn't just made up. Now I know that not every Leave voter was motivated by racism, but I lot were.

The other point I don't really understand is why name calling might influence you on such an important issue. I've heard this argument a lot. Basically 'people called me stupid so I'll vote just to spite them' that seems the very definition of stupid in my book thereby proving the name callers right.

OneTC · 27/09/2022 09:48

Whether people think that there's benefit or not to Brexit and as I said earlier I don't think Brexit had to be a negative for Britain (but it was always going to be with such a chaotic, haphazard delivery) I don't think they will outstrip the negatives of the societal level division that a basically 50:50 result has so clearly shown.

Deciding an issue like this, in this way, is also pretty contrary to the style of democracy we have in this country. We elect people to make complex decisions in our favour. If Britain wanted out they needed to vote in a party with a plan and a promise to withdraw. What we got was the decision put back on us and then the results of that decision was put back to a government woefully under prepared to enact it.

If the normal process had been followed, and a popular government had been voted in, who had campaigned on these issues, with some kind of specific plan for what it might look like, then yeah it would have taken longer (if it ever proved a popular enough movement to get that far) but the result would have been more legitimate and the withdrawal could have proceeded to a plan, rather than happen simply through necessity

Kendodd · 27/09/2022 09:46

DdraigGoch · 27/09/2022 08:32

Before we left, how did your vote influence the selection of the European Commission?

@DdraigGoch
Are you willing to concede that voters in Europe do have an influence on the make up of the EU commission? As a voter in the UK I have NEVER "won" . I'm in my 50s, vote in every election, never has what I voted for won. Ironically with the exception of the EU parliament because they didn't have a winner-take-all system so at least my view had some voice there.

Dotjones · 27/09/2022 09:45

bellabasset · 27/09/2022 09:03

The Referendum allowed 37% of the electorate to vote the UK out of the EU when the terms of leaving were speculation.

True, but then the referendum also showed that only 36% of the electorate wanted to remain in the EU. That means 64% either wanted to leave or were indifferent to the point they couldn't be arsed to vote.

Maybe if Remainers had engaged a few of the "can't be arsed" brigade, they'd have got the result they wanted.

I voted Leave, not through any certainty that things would be better - I expected them to be worse - but because remaining in the EU would also have led to us being in a worse position than we were in 2016. I was about 52% sure that leave was right, and 48% convinced we should remain. Remainers could have persuaded me but chose to call me a racist idiot for considering to vote Leave.

If David Cameron had said in advance that he would quit it the result was Leave, I'd have voted remain. It was clear at the time he was the best PM we'd had during my lifetime (admittedly a shit selection, the second best at that point was probably Thatcher, and the third best fucking Blair).

I any case I don't particularly regret it. I always felt it would take at least a decade for us to see any real benefit of Brexit, that of course was not factoring in them taking so long to actually arrange it and then being thrown into the midst of a once in a century pandemic.

The choice wasn't remain in the 2016 situation or leave - it was ever-closer integration and continual erosion of our rights or leave.

Cillery · 27/09/2022 09:43

Kendodd · 27/09/2022 09:04

I actually don't have too much of a problem with an appointed second chamber. I think the problem with the HoL is its badly weighted. Appointments for life etc. One suggestion I've heard for reform, which I think is a good one, is political appointees in the HoL, after each election, to reflect actual vote share each party got rather than winner-take-all in the HoC. Might go some way to better representation of the voter.

The house of lords is not a policy-making chamber but what if he is to check that the laws are made are good laws and workable laws. I think what you suggest would make it a political chamber rather than what it is supposed to be a chamber for checking that the laws are good and workable

Cillery · 27/09/2022 09:40

lannistunut · 27/09/2022 09:19

No, Truss was selected by the Tory party members who were definitely not elected by the Britsih people - the vast majority of her own MPs did not want Truss.

You are completely wrong in how our parliamentary democracy works. MPs voted for Sunak by 137-113 which is hardly a ‘vast majority’. However the majority of the members voted for Truss. This is the way the system worked. In Britain the party with the majority of MPs from the government and the leader becomes prime minister. That is how the British system works.

VapeVamp12 · 27/09/2022 09:30

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 26/09/2022 10:23

@VapeVamp12 I am interested in your realisation the leave campagn was a lie. How come you didn't realise earlier? It was clear as day to me it was rubbish, and SO much expertise telling anyone who cared to look into that, and I often wonder why people found it so compelling. Didn't you question it at t the time?

@Icanstillrecallourlastsummer I can't really remember now but my sister is a hardcore remainer and she has enlightened me on more than one occasion!

OneTC · 27/09/2022 09:26

Tiani4 · 27/09/2022 00:56

This could be a useful discussion of what is working Brexit and what isn't working... and then you get ignorant posters who can't even listen to any one else's posts !!! Why do a select population of MNers do this? Why do PPs not try to engage? but instead hey get jingoistic and controlling about their fixed views?

The UK was part of that slip to the right

lannistunut · 27/09/2022 09:19

Cillery · 27/09/2022 09:16

Truss is elected by the British Parliament which is elected by the British people by democratic mandate.

No, Truss was selected by the Tory party members who were definitely not elected by the Britsih people - the vast majority of her own MPs did not want Truss.

Cillery · 27/09/2022 09:16

jgw1 · 27/09/2022 07:22

@Cillery on the subject of democracy are you happy to have new unelected Heads of State and Government, with the latter paying no attention to any democratic mandate?

Truss is elected by the British Parliament which is elected by the British people by democratic mandate.

Kendodd · 27/09/2022 09:04

TomPinch · 27/09/2022 08:54

The House of Lords is mostly appointed, isn't it? Does that make it demonstratic after all?

I actually don't have too much of a problem with an appointed second chamber. I think the problem with the HoL is its badly weighted. Appointments for life etc. One suggestion I've heard for reform, which I think is a good one, is political appointees in the HoL, after each election, to reflect actual vote share each party got rather than winner-take-all in the HoC. Might go some way to better representation of the voter.

bellabasset · 27/09/2022 09:03

The Referendum allowed 37% of the electorate to vote the UK out of the EU when the terms of leaving were speculation.

TomPinch · 27/09/2022 08:55

Demonstratic??? I mean democratic!!!

TomPinch · 27/09/2022 08:54

Kendodd · 27/09/2022 08:48

I believe it did. Aren't the EU commissioners, one for each country, appointed by the elected governments of that country? I might be wrong but I believe that's how it worked. Happy to be corrected.

The House of Lords is mostly appointed, isn't it? Does that make it demonstratic after all?

TomPinch · 27/09/2022 08:53

I do think that the parliamentary leader should be a matter for the parliamentary party alone. Having a selectorate of party members outside Parliament undermines the principle of Parliamentary supremacy and also results in the election of oddballs like Truss and Corbyn.

Unfortunately that genie is well out of the bottle.

Kendodd · 27/09/2022 08:48

DdraigGoch · 27/09/2022 08:32

Before we left, how did your vote influence the selection of the European Commission?

I believe it did. Aren't the EU commissioners, one for each country, appointed by the elected governments of that country? I might be wrong but I believe that's how it worked. Happy to be corrected.

DdraigGoch · 27/09/2022 08:32

jgw1 · 27/09/2022 08:23

Apparently they do think that is democratic and the EU is not.

I'd love to be able to live in such a world, it must be a very happy place.

Before we left, how did your vote influence the selection of the European Commission?

DdraigGoch · 27/09/2022 08:31

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 27/09/2022 07:48

Members of Parliament are elected by the people. Someone who can find the backing of a majority of those elected MPs will be invited to form a government. Therefore it is democratic.

But @DdraigGoch, Liz Truss didn't have the backing of the majority of elected MPs. They backed Rishi Sunak, and I believe their second choice was Penny Mordant.

Liz Truss had the backing of the unelected Tory membership, some of whom were non-British citizens who had never even been to the UK.

Do you think that's democratic?

Liz Truss can command a majority in the House. Trust me, Conservative MPs are a rebellious lot so wouldn't put up with a leader they really didn't want.

Kendodd · 27/09/2022 08:29

TomPinch · 27/09/2022 00:30

Hah! I see what you did there 😉

I accept that we have to rely on experts to, for example, design and build our bridges, maintain them, and decide what safety standards they should be built and maintained under.

How we're governed and how our laws are made is very clearly a different matter. For better or for worse, this is absolutely the business of the public. Would you have denied the Scots a referendum in 2014? Membership of the EU meant a huge and increasing outsourcing of making the UK's laws. If you say this is only a matter for experts you undermine the whole basis for democracy, which is that the public get to choose who gets to make the laws and who administers them.

Also regarding 'experts' I reckon it's been forgotten just how badly the UK was affected by the GFC. It hasn't really recovered. So it's not surprising that the experts, ie, the economists, bankers and regulators have been on probation since, because they let it all happen. Because they got it horrendously wrong and didn't face up to this, their advice got ignored in 2016.

I wouldn't have denied the Scottish a vote but I certainly wouldn't have run the referendum the way they did, it was absolute maddness. For a start people need access to proper weighted information such as - 90% of economists think it will be terrible 10% think it will be good. It should be illegal to lie or mislead the public on such an important issue. Plus, they need a supermajority in order to make a change of such magnitude. If they have another referendum in Scotland and its won on a wafer thin majority, its a recipe for disaster. Unfortuatly, the precedent has been set and the madness of a simple majority has been set. Basically the EU referendum, like the outcome or not, was extremely poorly done (copying Scotland) and split the country into thirds. About one third voted Leave, one third Remain and one third didn't vote . So we had such a massive decision that most people didn't even vote for, its very likely to be the same in Scotland. I would even add a further safeguard of a veto in the Scottish Parliament. It make such a massive change, you need to take the people with you and they should have high hurdels, we are now paying the price in the UK for not doing that. I remember i was chair of a preschool, we had a higher voting bar to get over, to close the preschool, than we did to take the uk out of the eu. Whichever side you are on, anyone sensible must agree that to make such massive, long reaching and possibly irreversible changes to a country, should be harder than it was.

jgw1 · 27/09/2022 08:23

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 27/09/2022 07:48

Members of Parliament are elected by the people. Someone who can find the backing of a majority of those elected MPs will be invited to form a government. Therefore it is democratic.

But @DdraigGoch, Liz Truss didn't have the backing of the majority of elected MPs. They backed Rishi Sunak, and I believe their second choice was Penny Mordant.

Liz Truss had the backing of the unelected Tory membership, some of whom were non-British citizens who had never even been to the UK.

Do you think that's democratic?

Apparently they do think that is democratic and the EU is not.

I'd love to be able to live in such a world, it must be a very happy place.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 27/09/2022 07:48

Members of Parliament are elected by the people. Someone who can find the backing of a majority of those elected MPs will be invited to form a government. Therefore it is democratic.

But @DdraigGoch, Liz Truss didn't have the backing of the majority of elected MPs. They backed Rishi Sunak, and I believe their second choice was Penny Mordant.

Liz Truss had the backing of the unelected Tory membership, some of whom were non-British citizens who had never even been to the UK.

Do you think that's democratic?

DdraigGoch · 27/09/2022 07:40

jgw1 · 27/09/2022 07:22

@Cillery on the subject of democracy are you happy to have new unelected Heads of State and Government, with the latter paying no attention to any democratic mandate?

Members of Parliament are elected by the people. Someone who can find the backing of a majority of those elected MPs will be invited to form a government. Therefore it is democratic.

Since the restoration and the Glorious Revolution, the monarch has reigned only with the consent of Parliament. If Parliament (who are elected, remember) were to decide that they no longer want a monarchy, then they would remove it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread