Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most Brexiteers must now regret their vote?

534 replies

hoovermanouvre · 24/09/2022 09:29

If you voted Brexit, do you feel like you have been able to "Take Back Control?" If so, where? Can anyone state one positive change since Brexit - I would genuinely like to hear at least something. Anything?

YANBU - I voted Brexit but now regret it
YABU - I voted Brexit and can see a benefit

OP posts:
WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 28/09/2022 00:10

I love it that the result is 61% YABU. (Out of almost 600 people at the moment!)

HOW the tide has turned! Grin

@hoovermanouvre YABU. No-one I know who voted to LEAVE the EU regrets it. I know you'd like to believe most people do, but that's just not the case.

Shame. Grin

scaredoff · 27/09/2022 23:49

Cillery · 27/09/2022 16:29

The problem with the NHS is that the system needs modernising. It is viewed almost as a religious shrine and every time somebody tries to bring it up to date there are howls that it is being ‘privatised’ or the like. I am all for the NHS but it’s no good keep pouring large amounts of money into it without actually modernising the structure. It is woefully inadequate

Nope. The main problem with the NHS is much simpler than that - it's underfunded.

What this line always neglects to mention is that the UK consistently spends a significantly lower proportion of GPD on healthcare than other comparable countries. You talk about "pouring large amounts of money into it" as if those amounts are large by comparison with other health systems. They aren't. We don't know whether "pouring" the kind of money that other countries "pour" into healthcare into the NHS would work, because it hasn't been tried yet.

Well, actually it was tried to an extent under the last Labour government. And miraculously, waiting times were slashed and service improved according to nearly all metrics.

The idea that the NHS has to keep being "modernised" within an inch of its life, and the use of that idea to justify chronic underfunding of fundamental valid workable structures that already exist within it, is a pernicious Tory lie. Actually, studies have shown that the NHS delivers some of the best efficiency in the world, comparing outcomes to the resources put into them. Having a single state run system like that actually has numerous huge advantages like the ability to obtain favourable prices through bulk purchasing.

Then there's the problem that the NHS is currently carrying the can for the chronic underfunding of social care as well, as patients are kept in hospitals due to having no suitable circumstances to be released to, for example.

TomPinch · 27/09/2022 23:43

BambinaJAS · 27/09/2022 18:24

Your replies remind me of a quote from Napoleon.

The British are indeed a "nation of shop-keepers" in the aggregate sense.

Mediocrity incarnate at this point in time.

I have yet to see even a modicum of higher intellectual ability among the masses over here.

What a sad state of affairs from a country with world class Universities like Oxford and Cambridge.

I met truly exceptional people at those institutions, but my lord, what a difference between them and the average Brit.

Gosh 🤭

TomPinch · 27/09/2022 23:32

BambinaJAS · 27/09/2022 18:25

Now we finally have the truth

Your "reasons" are basically Bullshit

hahahahaha

Its just self-interest. What a joke.

Eh??

I didn't vote for Brexit. I'm fact I didn't vote in the referendum at all and wouldn't consider myself a Brexiteer.

I'm someone who used to live in the UK, hasn't got some time, and has one foot in and one foot, not just outside the UK but outside Europe as a whole. That's the vantage point that I'm coming from.

UnCivil · 27/09/2022 21:46

Newrumpus · 25/09/2022 15:02

I’m not. Rental properties may be dreadful but the worst are better than they were in the 1970s. Nobody is allowed to rent out properties in the conditions of those in which I grew up these days.

Possibly because of some pesky regulations that the Tories will now try and do away with

Anon778833 · 27/09/2022 21:40

It’s also not insignificant that the vote was very evenly split. Nearly half of us didn’t bloody want this. Saying that British people are stupid is the same as saying Americans were stupid for voting for Donald Trump.

I still think David Cameron is to blame by allowing this nonsense in the first place. Most people don’t usually even bother to read manifestos, let alone understand the implications of leaving the EU. Political apathy is the problem.

Anon778833 · 27/09/2022 21:35

BambinaJAS · 27/09/2022 18:24

Your replies remind me of a quote from Napoleon.

The British are indeed a "nation of shop-keepers" in the aggregate sense.

Mediocrity incarnate at this point in time.

I have yet to see even a modicum of higher intellectual ability among the masses over here.

What a sad state of affairs from a country with world class Universities like Oxford and Cambridge.

I met truly exceptional people at those institutions, but my lord, what a difference between them and the average Brit.

I’m a remainer and always have been.

However, I don’t think your own attitude is any better than many Brexiteers tbh. Your posts are arrogant, scornful and actually a load of nonsense.

Not to mention your apparent toxic glee about some people who you say will be ‘impoverished’. That’s just nasty.

You clearly seem to have yourself down as a superior intellectual. When people act like this, it comes across as an inferiority complex. And also does nothing of any use.

MangyInseam · 27/09/2022 20:49

BambinaJAS · 27/09/2022 19:08

Incorrect.

Skin color or ethnicity is completely irrelevant.

The only question that matter is:

Can you add value at the job?

Thats it. It really is not that difficult.

Competition is what breeds excellence and productivity.

Nobody cares about your country or skin color.

Jobs are not based on charity.

You don't get paid just to show up. You get paid for adding value to your employer. If you cannot do this better than other people, then you will be replaced by someone who can.

If you cannot handle this, then thats on you.

Clearly you are not one of the people I referred to, you are one of those who is quite openly happy to bring in people from other countries to do crappy jobs to support citizens in having a nicer life. (Or that's the theory.)

It would be nice if people who go on about the moral superiority of the Remain position could take that on.

BambinaJAS · 27/09/2022 19:08

MangyInseam · 27/09/2022 18:56

It is deeply ironic that people on the progressive left argue for this and claim it is a sign of their greater internationalism and non-racism.

When really it is probably about the most clear example of exploitative global capitalism that favours westerners over people from "over-there" (who would be described as "black and brown" by many said progressives.)

Incorrect.

Skin color or ethnicity is completely irrelevant.

The only question that matter is:

Can you add value at the job?

Thats it. It really is not that difficult.

Competition is what breeds excellence and productivity.

Nobody cares about your country or skin color.

Jobs are not based on charity.

You don't get paid just to show up. You get paid for adding value to your employer. If you cannot do this better than other people, then you will be replaced by someone who can.

If you cannot handle this, then thats on you.

MangyInseam · 27/09/2022 19:07

TomPinch · 27/09/2022 18:23

As someone who lives in an English-speaking Commonwealth country whose economy has to live with hostile trade practices from the EU I say hooray to this. The opportunity to live and work in the UK was always an important opportunity (and a source of returning expertise) but until 2016 the door was being slowly but inexorably closed.

That's really interesting. I am also in a Commonwealth country, and feel similarly in terms of my own relative position.

Not that I think the UK should base their immigration policy on what is best for me. But it is weird to hear people complain about their basic rights to work in the EU being compromised when none seem to care at all about those of us in the Commonwealth who at one time had the right to come and live and work or study in the UK.

I've wondered if this is because they've just assumed that anyone from such a place must really hate the Empire and the monarchy and would rather give them a kick in the teeth than come to live there? Or maybe they just see us as provincial hicks and would rather hobnob with European sophisticates?

I have a teenage daughter who is desperate to study in the UK but as an international applicant it's going to take a lot of luck for her to manage to afford it.

MangyInseam · 27/09/2022 18:56

BambinaJAS · 27/09/2022 15:29

This is also incorrect.

What will happen is more natives will be pushed to do lower skilled work in the UK.

Also, we will lose some of our comparative advantages as it pertains to higher skilled work, which means those jobs will be exported abroad were they can be done cheaper.

End result is:

The natives replace the immigrants in the lower skilled jobs
Less high skilled jobs for the natives
More high skilled jobs exported abroad

Thats what happens when you curtail immigration for low skilled jobs. Every developed country in the world always has a pipeline for low skilled immigration, so that the natives can focus on higher-paying higher skill work. US, Canada, Norway, Switzerland etc. All do this.

It is deeply ironic that people on the progressive left argue for this and claim it is a sign of their greater internationalism and non-racism.

When really it is probably about the most clear example of exploitative global capitalism that favours westerners over people from "over-there" (who would be described as "black and brown" by many said progressives.)

BambinaJAS · 27/09/2022 18:25

TomPinch · 27/09/2022 18:23

As someone who lives in an English-speaking Commonwealth country whose economy has to live with hostile trade practices from the EU I say hooray to this. The opportunity to live and work in the UK was always an important opportunity (and a source of returning expertise) but until 2016 the door was being slowly but inexorably closed.

Now we finally have the truth

Your "reasons" are basically Bullshit

hahahahaha

Its just self-interest. What a joke.

BambinaJAS · 27/09/2022 18:24

TomPinch · 27/09/2022 18:16

As I explained yesterday there is an enormous difference between consulting the people on bridge construction and how they are governed.

Your replies remind me of a quote from Napoleon.

The British are indeed a "nation of shop-keepers" in the aggregate sense.

Mediocrity incarnate at this point in time.

I have yet to see even a modicum of higher intellectual ability among the masses over here.

What a sad state of affairs from a country with world class Universities like Oxford and Cambridge.

I met truly exceptional people at those institutions, but my lord, what a difference between them and the average Brit.

TomPinch · 27/09/2022 18:23

Thesinisterdiagram · 27/09/2022 16:52

We’re still going to import cheap labour though? The Tories have made immigration to the UK for non EU countries much easier than it used to be, and Liz Truss has recently announced plans to relax immigration rules further to help businesses recruit overseas workers. Only difference is where the cheap labour comes from.

As someone who lives in an English-speaking Commonwealth country whose economy has to live with hostile trade practices from the EU I say hooray to this. The opportunity to live and work in the UK was always an important opportunity (and a source of returning expertise) but until 2016 the door was being slowly but inexorably closed.

TomPinch · 27/09/2022 18:16

Alexandra2001 · 27/09/2022 17:04

You can add almost any modern organisation, political party, let alone Govt or Parliament/Civil Service.

We don't have referendums on NATO, TRident or even HS2 .. why? because most folk are not military experts, nuclear weapon designers or train experts... we delegate to MPs and Govt to make the decisions for us.... hopefully in our best interests lol!

EU membership should be done in the same way, Cameron put exiting the EU in his manifesto, with how he will do it, time scales etc... we vote for his party and he can exit the EU in an orderly way, with the mandate to do so with his MPs on board as they stood on that platform.

Or we don't...

As I explained yesterday there is an enormous difference between consulting the people on bridge construction and how they are governed.

ItsDarkAlready · 27/09/2022 17:08

I voted Brexit and don't regret it :) (I feel like I'm confessing a lot on Mumsnet tonight! Just admitted brushing my teeth over 10 times a day on another thread, so I really must name change right now before anyone knows who I am!!)

FWIW - I hate the conservative party (though i understand why people vote for them and appreciate their political.oponions, I just don't agree), I'm totally definitely not racist, I'm pro immigration and I'm not a bigot, or any of the other stereotypes people place on Brexit voters!! I had my reasons for voting Brexit and don't regret it!

The sad thing is that I could never admit in real life that I voted Brexit because everyone that knows me assumes I would have voted remain and I would likely lose friends over it. Which is really sad. I'm not the devil. I just have a different (and I believe valid) opinion.

Lunificent · 27/09/2022 17:07

Most will not regret it. The Brexiteer mindset isn’t about benefits or not, it’s about winning and losing. They won, you should get over it and that’s as far as it goes.

BambinaJAS · 27/09/2022 17:05

WatchoRulo · 27/09/2022 16:59

That is the thing about choosing to leave - we are stuck with the consequences good or bad. They didn't end when the voting did.

This is also 100% the case if we'd voted to remain.

Sure. But we would be wealthier.

SMEs that used to export to EU have either collapsed or moved.

The damage is immense.

We have destroyed a portion of our productive capacity.

That is serious but people seem oblivious to this.

This is why this nationalistic bent in the UK will only end in tears. There is no other way. It had to burn itself out via massive self-imposed suffering.

Alexandra2001 · 27/09/2022 17:04

TomPinch · 26/09/2022 22:09

That argument is a double-edged sword.

If it's too complicated to have a referendum on, it's also too complicated to be democratic.

You can add almost any modern organisation, political party, let alone Govt or Parliament/Civil Service.

We don't have referendums on NATO, TRident or even HS2 .. why? because most folk are not military experts, nuclear weapon designers or train experts... we delegate to MPs and Govt to make the decisions for us.... hopefully in our best interests lol!

EU membership should be done in the same way, Cameron put exiting the EU in his manifesto, with how he will do it, time scales etc... we vote for his party and he can exit the EU in an orderly way, with the mandate to do so with his MPs on board as they stood on that platform.

Or we don't...

BerriesOnTop · 27/09/2022 17:01

BambinaJAS · 27/09/2022 16:18

I am still laighing over that one.

My lord.

Example:

Getting cancer treatment using Medicaid vs NHS

Emergency care in the US hides the truth: that if you need care for a longer term condition you are toast in the US under Medicaid Vs NHS

Which is also precisely why lower income folks in the US are worse off.

I admit I only hear stories about the NHS but you really know nothing about the US system if you’d rather get cancer treatment elsewhere. Even a rural US hospital gives you a good treatment. That some hospitals refuse Medicare and Medicaid patients is no surprise to me; they can refuse you if you are on another insurance programme. It’s normal 🤷‍♀️plenty of others around

BambinaJAS · 27/09/2022 17:01

Alexandra2001 · 27/09/2022 16:57

Sort out staffing levels, morale and pay, then restructure.

Do it the other way round, when the nhs is in many cases, not functioning, would just make matters worse.

To help fund this, i d introduce some charging (most EU countries charge for things) exemptions for various groups of people.

The NHS can be modernised without privatisation, which in many cases have been a disaster... my DD's hospital have recently run out of wheelchairs, provided by a private company, thats led to un safe release of patients into the community, so they come back in again, as they can't live at home.

Anyway, isn't this off topic.

Only way that works is if you start charging the people that use it most.

Over 80% of NHS spending in the UK is on the over 55s

Until they start paying in, the funding model will not work.

Even in the US, the retired folks have to pay for Medicare coverage. This is a subsidised public option.

But because of the Grey Vote in the UK, the retired folks pay zero NI.

This is pure madness.

WatchoRulo · 27/09/2022 16:59

LiesDoNotBecomeUs · 27/09/2022 15:57

I get fed up with people saying in long-suffering tones: 'Brexit is over' and 'that all happened long ago'.

Brexit is now with us every single day.

That is the thing about choosing to leave - we are stuck with the consequences good or bad. They didn't end when the voting did.

Good/Bad? I've not noticed much happiness from the fishing industry here. (Many Brexiteers amongst them.)

That is the thing about choosing to leave - we are stuck with the consequences good or bad. They didn't end when the voting did.

This is also 100% the case if we'd voted to remain.

Alexandra2001 · 27/09/2022 16:57

Cillery · 27/09/2022 16:29

The problem with the NHS is that the system needs modernising. It is viewed almost as a religious shrine and every time somebody tries to bring it up to date there are howls that it is being ‘privatised’ or the like. I am all for the NHS but it’s no good keep pouring large amounts of money into it without actually modernising the structure. It is woefully inadequate

Sort out staffing levels, morale and pay, then restructure.

Do it the other way round, when the nhs is in many cases, not functioning, would just make matters worse.

To help fund this, i d introduce some charging (most EU countries charge for things) exemptions for various groups of people.

The NHS can be modernised without privatisation, which in many cases have been a disaster... my DD's hospital have recently run out of wheelchairs, provided by a private company, thats led to un safe release of patients into the community, so they come back in again, as they can't live at home.

Anyway, isn't this off topic.

BambinaJAS · 27/09/2022 16:56

Cillery · 27/09/2022 16:29

The problem with the NHS is that the system needs modernising. It is viewed almost as a religious shrine and every time somebody tries to bring it up to date there are howls that it is being ‘privatised’ or the like. I am all for the NHS but it’s no good keep pouring large amounts of money into it without actually modernising the structure. It is woefully inadequate

I fully agree it can be improved.

But Medicaid is still much worse.

Thesinisterdiagram · 27/09/2022 16:52

Vastlyunderrated · 27/09/2022 15:18

I think one positive of Brexit and I'll get shot in flames for even suggesting anything positive but here goes.

The fact we can no longer import cheap labour to work for us means that there should be more opportunities for careers for young people going forward. We can't just plug gaps with imports but may actually have to train people to do these jobs. I'd imagine that should have been happening anyway but employers took the easier and cheaper route.

Anyway I'll await my stoning.

We’re still going to import cheap labour though? The Tories have made immigration to the UK for non EU countries much easier than it used to be, and Liz Truss has recently announced plans to relax immigration rules further to help businesses recruit overseas workers. Only difference is where the cheap labour comes from.

Swipe left for the next trending thread