Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most Brexiteers must now regret their vote?

534 replies

hoovermanouvre · 24/09/2022 09:29

If you voted Brexit, do you feel like you have been able to "Take Back Control?" If so, where? Can anyone state one positive change since Brexit - I would genuinely like to hear at least something. Anything?

YANBU - I voted Brexit but now regret it
YABU - I voted Brexit and can see a benefit

OP posts:
red4321 · 28/09/2022 13:05

Bambina so do you think the elderly as well as the stupid shouldn’t be allowed to vote?*

Add them to the list. We'll forget that they've worked and paid into the economy for longer than most of us, and dismiss their life experience as irrelevant.

Actually, let's just go the whole hog and ban everyone except Bambina from voting as they're the only one suitably qualified apparently.

I gather that empirical research shows that dictatorships can actually be an efficient way of governing, so it's a double win....

MrsHarrisgoestoTimbuctoo · 28/09/2022 12:52

@BambinaJAS Instead, the Grey Vote in the UK is intent on suffocating the younger folks to maintain their standars of living.

I'm not sure what this means?

I live in an area where there are a lot of retired people. From what I've seen these are the ones that are having extensions built, fitting double-glazing and a myriad of other home improvements.
So they are certainly putting more into the economy than they are taking out.

Andante57 · 28/09/2022 12:50

Instead, the Grey Vote in the UK is intent on suffocating the younger folks to maintain their standars of living.

Bambina so do you think the elderly as well as the stupid shouldn’t be allowed to vote?

BambinaJAS · 28/09/2022 12:45

GasPanic · 28/09/2022 11:06

@Alexandra2001

Not quite sure how you think "help shore up the currency" equates to "having the financial muscle to bail out the EZ".

Less shouting, more reading and thinking is in order.

I don't really follow current affairs very much no, because the interpretation tends to be noisy and full of hyperbole and desperate people trying to make political capital rather than focused on the fundamentals, which to me are the key things in assessing the long term future. I'm more of a long term analyst than a trader. Things like demographic parameters and debt to GBP are more important to me than what some politician mouthed off about last week.

In that case, you should know full well how spectecularly screwed the UK is because of demographics.

I do long-term complex actuarial calculations for a living.

With an aging population (with rising costs for pensions and healthcare), and limited immigration (young people paying in and not utilising), the only variable that can stop the stagnation is productivity.

You would need to increase productivity by a factor of 200% in order to make the math work.

Instead, the Grey Vote in the UK is intent on suffocating the younger folks to maintain their standars of living.

This is why the pound is collapsing.

Investors see this negative long-term trend as well.

You have way too many unproductive older people in the UK vs productive working people, with the ratio getting worse.

So they mark down UK assets via FX as the UK economy will contract.

And yes, this will get worse in the next few nonths as the BOE stalls on raising rates, as they are terrified of collpasing the property market.

That means large spending cuts coming in November.

This is all fairly predictable if you understand complex financial modelling. Why do you think hedge funds are making out like bandits now?

Alexandra2001 · 28/09/2022 11:41

@GasPanic Its exactly the same thing and you know it.

Actions matter and whats happening with the BoE interventions today, based on that idiot Kwartengs actions, is very much relevant to your post.

The UK, in or out of the EU, has too many problems to bail out or shore up any currency.

We'll soon be a Greece, with the IMF running the show.

Thankyou very much Brexitiers, this all on you.

jgw1 · 28/09/2022 11:34

WhoDatDen · 28/09/2022 07:24

I asked earlier what the benefits are for someone like me if we had remained in the EU and only got one reply which was debunked. I'm still not convinced returning to the EU would benefit someone like me.

Both sides think they know best - see below which has the arguments for vs the arguments against. I saw this in an argument someone was having and this is where we are with people's attitudes:

  1. "We get to live and work in 27+ nations visa free" vs "we can't control who comes to work and live here from 27 nations visa free".
  2. "We can trade freely with 27 nations" vs "we can't control the terms with those outside the EU that we can trade freely with".
  3. "We get economic benefits from being in the EU" vs "we have to pay billions to be in the EU and we believe those economic benefits can be replicated by a normal FTA".
  4. "We have the benefit of the EU having checks and balances over our national government vs "we have an unelected government and courts that can rule over our elected ones".

If we had remained in the EU we more than likely wouldn't have had Boris Johnson and Liz Truss as Prime Ministers.

We would not be having the same run on the pound as we are now, which means that anything we import including much of our domestic fuel is more expensive than it would have been otherwise.

How many benefits do you want?

GasPanic · 28/09/2022 11:06

@Alexandra2001

Not quite sure how you think "help shore up the currency" equates to "having the financial muscle to bail out the EZ".

Less shouting, more reading and thinking is in order.

I don't really follow current affairs very much no, because the interpretation tends to be noisy and full of hyperbole and desperate people trying to make political capital rather than focused on the fundamentals, which to me are the key things in assessing the long term future. I'm more of a long term analyst than a trader. Things like demographic parameters and debt to GBP are more important to me than what some politician mouthed off about last week.

Alexandra2001 · 28/09/2022 10:49

@GasPanic Funny you think the EU believes we have the financial muscle to bail out the eurozone.

Do you follow current affairs?

UnCivil · 28/09/2022 10:39

The worst is yet to come. Truss is the mouthpiece for some very self serving people who wanted to continue avoiding paying their fair share of tax. They also claim that regulations stifle the economy. What they mean is those rules that offer protections to workforce or ensure safety standards in goods and materials can be eradicated. The rich will get richer and the rest of us will be shafted. Anything that is good for a ghoul like JRM is going to be disastrous for a lot of us

GasPanic · 28/09/2022 10:15

@IpanemaChic

The EU wouldn't prevent us coming back in because of sewage.

The reason they wouldn't want us back in is because the UK in general doesn't have a positive attitude towards the EU and never really wanted to be part of it. Everything that went on in the EU we were dragged into kicking and screaming. The UK was a barrier to progress in the EU and better off out of it for both parties.

The reason they would want us back in is because of the financial burden we would shoulder in being there. In particular, I don't think they would want us back in unless we joined the EZ, and the reason they would want us back in for that is so we could help shore up the currency and mitigate the impact of the PIIGS on the EZ, which is currently being shouldered by the Germans.

In terms of countries they want to let into the EU, they want large countries that are undeveloped, to allow economic expansion. Ukraine and Turkey both fit this description. Basically Northern European exports have hollowed out the Southern European economies, there is no further growth in expanding into that area and they are looking for new markets to get into to sell Northern European products. The only places to do that are in the East, hence current run in with Russia.

Alexandra2001 · 28/09/2022 10:10

Andante57 · 28/09/2022 08:54

Polling shows (some) people have changed their minds & as we go into even more self inflicted economic hardship, an even worse NHS, we'll see EU membership become more attractive, its now 54/46 to rejoin! (this is across 6 different polls)

If that’s the case then why aren’t Labour promising to rejoin if they win the next election? If the majority of voters want this then surely it would be a vote winner.

Policy shouldn't be decided on polling & as well you know, polls can be very fickle, though if it proves to be a popular plan, maybe Truss will become a remainer again

Anyway, rejoin isn't on the agenda, there wont be another vote, EU wouldn't accept us back and as much as it pains me, the EU is better off without us.

UnCivil · 28/09/2022 10:01

WatchoRulo · 27/09/2022 16:59

That is the thing about choosing to leave - we are stuck with the consequences good or bad. They didn't end when the voting did.

This is also 100% the case if we'd voted to remain.

No it isn’t as Farage and co would have continued to lobby for leaving and would be demanding another vote.

IpanemaChic · 28/09/2022 09:37

Setting out reasons to not rejoin the EU or ‘why the EU doesn’t benefit me’, is misplaced because the UK is not going to be accepted back. Sewage in rivers/beaches, deregulation and now a rapidly tanking economy.

This year Ukraine was accepted as a candidate country to join the EU. The EU has moved on and so should you.

Andante57 · 28/09/2022 09:10

MrsHarris - yes.

MrsHarrisgoestoTimbuctoo · 28/09/2022 08:57

@Andante57
If that’s the case then why aren’t Labour promising to rejoin if they win the next election? If the majority of voters want this then surely it would be a vote winner.

They'll probably put it in the next manifesto after they've decided what a "woman" is. So don't hold your breath. 🙄

Andante57 · 28/09/2022 08:54

Polling shows (some) people have changed their minds & as we go into even more self inflicted economic hardship, an even worse NHS, we'll see EU membership become more attractive, its now 54/46 to rejoin! (this is across 6 different polls)

If that’s the case then why aren’t Labour promising to rejoin if they win the next election? If the majority of voters want this then surely it would be a vote winner.

MrsHarrisgoestoTimbuctoo · 28/09/2022 08:54

@red4321 WhoDatDen very good points. But it won't go down well on this thread as it's really just a smokescreen to abuse anyone who voted Leave as uneducated racists.
Like most of the hundreds of MN threads on this topic.

That about sums it up.
It seems the "remoaners" are well-named !

red4321 · 28/09/2022 07:40

WhoDatDen very good points. But it won't go down well on this thread as it's really just a smokescreen to abuse anyone who voted Leave as uneducated racists.

Like most of the hundreds of MN threads on this topic.

WhoDatDen · 28/09/2022 07:24

I asked earlier what the benefits are for someone like me if we had remained in the EU and only got one reply which was debunked. I'm still not convinced returning to the EU would benefit someone like me.

Both sides think they know best - see below which has the arguments for vs the arguments against. I saw this in an argument someone was having and this is where we are with people's attitudes:

  1. "We get to live and work in 27+ nations visa free" vs "we can't control who comes to work and live here from 27 nations visa free".
  2. "We can trade freely with 27 nations" vs "we can't control the terms with those outside the EU that we can trade freely with".
  3. "We get economic benefits from being in the EU" vs "we have to pay billions to be in the EU and we believe those economic benefits can be replicated by a normal FTA".
  4. "We have the benefit of the EU having checks and balances over our national government vs "we have an unelected government and courts that can rule over our elected ones".
BlackeyedSusan · 28/09/2022 07:11

Nrtft but:
None of the issues with Brexit are clearly just down to Brexit so it is easy to blame COVID/ Ukraine. People can easily dismiss any issues as caused by these.

Any issues from Brexit due to traveling is due to those europeans they have voted to leave which means it was good to leave cos they are horrible...

Government have banged on about vaccines due to not being in Europe...

Some wanted brexit for idealogical reasons; they are not going to have changed their mind

I doubt most of those who voted Brexit have changed their mind to be honest.

Alexandra2001 · 28/09/2022 06:56

red4321 · 28/09/2022 06:38

No-one I know who voted to LEAVE the EU regrets it. I know you'd like to believe most people do, but that's just not the case.

Same here, no one I know regrets it. Nor are they racist nor uneducated.

Mind you, the title of the thread didn't help. "AIBU to think that most Brexiteers must now regret their vote". Anyone having done the joys of a Geography questionnaire at school have it drummed in to them to not ask leading questions.

"Do any Leave voters regret their decision?" might have encouraged a more nuanced debate. But I'm not sure that was ever the intention of the thread.

Plenty regret their vote, anecdotes are worthless but i'll add my own... as someone said to me last week "i voted out, if i knew how things were going to turn out, i'd have voted to remain, there was no plan"

Polling shows (some) people have changed their minds & as we go into even more self inflicted economic hardship, an even worse NHS, we'll see EU membership become more attractive, its now 54/46 to rejoin! (this is across 6 different polls)

Alexandra2001 · 28/09/2022 06:48

TomPinch · 27/09/2022 18:16

As I explained yesterday there is an enormous difference between consulting the people on bridge construction and how they are governed.

Rubbish, i doubt few know how Govt/Parliament "works", let alone the influence of lobby groups... so according to you, its undemocratic!

Why the fuck should anyone in the commonwealth have FOM to the UK ? do we in the UK have FOM to NZ, Aus or Canada??? or do we have to be below a certain age, have skills etc etc....

red4321 · 28/09/2022 06:38

No-one I know who voted to LEAVE the EU regrets it. I know you'd like to believe most people do, but that's just not the case.

Same here, no one I know regrets it. Nor are they racist nor uneducated.

Mind you, the title of the thread didn't help. "AIBU to think that most Brexiteers must now regret their vote". Anyone having done the joys of a Geography questionnaire at school have it drummed in to them to not ask leading questions.

"Do any Leave voters regret their decision?" might have encouraged a more nuanced debate. But I'm not sure that was ever the intention of the thread.

Joshanddonna · 28/09/2022 03:38

Of course they don’t. All the ones I know voted to take back control and stop all the bad European laws - they couldn’t name any but they wanted to stop them.
They can now wrap themselves in their St George flags and fantasise about shagging Nigel garage.

Endlesssummer2022 · 28/09/2022 03:31

Even Tim Martin from Wetherspoons regrets Brexit:

www.independent.co.uk/news/business/news/wetherspoons-brexit-bars-eu-migration-b1858035.html?amp

Swipe left for the next trending thread