Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most Brexiteers must now regret their vote?

534 replies

hoovermanouvre · 24/09/2022 09:29

If you voted Brexit, do you feel like you have been able to "Take Back Control?" If so, where? Can anyone state one positive change since Brexit - I would genuinely like to hear at least something. Anything?

YANBU - I voted Brexit but now regret it
YABU - I voted Brexit and can see a benefit

OP posts:
Alexandra2001 · 25/09/2022 07:17

Rinatinabina · 25/09/2022 06:48

Yeah this is part of the problem, the UK has pretty shit productivity partly because the availability of cheap labour has meant that businesses haven’t invested in automation and efficiencies they haven’t needed to. The allowance for capital investments has now been raised to 1 million so hopefully businesses will think more about how to become more productive.

Thats all myth - there is no evidence that the uk used cheap labour instead of investment in tech.
Historically, UK business don't invest, they didn't in ship building, steel, cars, lorries, rail, motorcycles or bicycles - all declined or vanished, stats show that in the 50s Triumph/Norton and BSA were (combined) making equivalent profit to that of microsoft now... did they invest? or carry on making m/c based on 1930s designs?

UK companies like profit, dividend & director pay... thats what they are judged on, not R&D or productivity, as per usually, uk always takes the short tern view.
UK wages have not been that low and if they are, have been driven low, not by EU migration but by very low inflation/interest rates and by decline in union power.

As we go into a recession or perhaps a depression and global one at that, UK business wont be spending money on new technology, the opposite will happen.

Moonmelodies · 25/09/2022 07:02

It isn't just the people who voted for Brexit - don't forget we then had a general election when people again had the option to stop Brexit by simply voting LibDem - on that occasion they chose to go ahead with Brexit by an even greater majority.

jgw1 · 25/09/2022 07:02

Of course I don't regret voting for Brexit, it showed the foreigners what we think of them. We have taken back control of our borders, so have more people than ever risking everything to cross the channel in small boats. We have ensure that inflation in the UK is world beating and best of all we have taken back control of our laws from elected representatives in Brussels in order to have unelected Head of State and Head of Government.

Softplayhooray · 25/09/2022 07:01

Scianel · 24/09/2022 09:32

Not a Brexiteer but I would imagine that the spectacle of von der Leyen threatening the Italians if they vote the "wrong" way has made any voters feel vindicated.

Thats got literally nothing to do with Brexit.

Aside from which the warning from her is welcome - Meloni is a fascist. That's the last thing Italy needs when there is the unstable Ukraine situation, far more refugees as a result, and the subsequent easy pickings dog whistle situation that that creates for foreigner hating right wingers like Meloni.

OP Brexit was a disaster but it's not possible to have a calm conversation about it online.

BerriesOnTop · 25/09/2022 07:00

Although I really do consider UK part of Europe I. a larger sense so perhaps you will all go down together, and there’s really no avoiding it.

BerriesOnTop · 25/09/2022 06:59

The EU can use its size to spread the pain around

But it doesn’t. It left the PIGS to their fates after 2008. You may argue that is a Euro problem and not an EU problem (fair) but it’s kind of ridiculous to suggest they would choose to spread the pain around when past history doesn’t really suggest that.

Again, the UK could take an advantage being outside the EU and Eurozone, but I don’t believe they are nimble enough to pull a Singapore or Hong Kong-style economy out of their ass. (And too many Brits would think they are too Capitalistic even though they generally have higher living standards than you do).

But I also don’t think you want to go down with the rest of Europe—I truly think they have peaked economically and will only decline from here.

Rinatinabina · 25/09/2022 06:48

DdraigGoch · 25/09/2022 00:42

Not all businesses increase prices to accommodate higher wages. Cheap labour allows businesses to be lazy, carrying on as they were with no incentive to innovate. As wages rise, they are forced to look for better productivity. They might now employ one well-paid member of staff to do the job of two low-paid employees, with the help of technology.

Yeah this is part of the problem, the UK has pretty shit productivity partly because the availability of cheap labour has meant that businesses haven’t invested in automation and efficiencies they haven’t needed to. The allowance for capital investments has now been raised to 1 million so hopefully businesses will think more about how to become more productive.

Worriedaboutethics · 25/09/2022 06:28

@hoovermanouvre

zero benefits to brexit only harm.
just the facts

ClottedCreamAndStrawberries · 25/09/2022 05:20

🥱 🥱 Haven’t you got anything better to do?

ThinWomansBrain · 25/09/2022 03:26

You have to remember that a lot of the twats that voted Brexit thought it was a good way to protest - for that alone, or if they genuinely thought it was a good idea and didn't forsee a shit show, they must be missing a few braincells to start with.

lickenchugget · 25/09/2022 03:06

A Brexit thread. Again? Groundbreaking.

TooBigForMyBoots · 25/09/2022 02:43

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

You'll need to ask PM Truss that question as she plans to increase immigration.

VerinMathwin · 25/09/2022 02:40

BambinaJAS · 24/09/2022 23:24

Wrong.

The end result of your Brexit vote was always an extreme right-wing Government.

I really despise people with your mentality.

You try to deflect blame for your vote by kicking the proverbial can down the road to an imaginary future of "unicorns".

You own every single economic repercussion that is about to befall the UK.

You have actively made 50% of the population poorer.

And that is on YOU.

My main hope for the future is that eventually people with your views will be openly mocked for their delusions. As it should be.

I don't despise people with your limited mentality. Pity you, possibly.

VerinMathwin · 25/09/2022 02:36

BambinaJAS · 24/09/2022 23:12

This is the classic mistake people make who do not work in economic areas.

Artificial labour shortages will ALWAYS lead to reduced output and higher prices. That will then lead to lower economic growth, thus lower tax revenues. Public services will then deteriorate.

See Switzerland. They tried something like Brexit to stop immigratiom and it blew up in their face.

In the case of a builder in a sector who sees a labour shortage now, he will be able to negotiate higher nominal wages, but these will be mostly eroded by higher prices (inflation), thus his real wages did not grow as much.

Very few workers will be able to secure higher real wages (HGV drivers for example are another group that likely will).

In the aggregate, the increase in nominal wages of all of the groups will ALWAYS be beaten by a higher increase in prices (because businesses will cut output and raise prices to survive when they cannot source enough labour to grow), thus leading to a reduction in real wages.

And that is precisely what is happening now. Output is being cut by businesses as they cannot find enough workers, leading to higher prices, whose increase will be higher than any nominal wage increases.

The net effect is that the country as a whole is poorer.

You will see how fast services deteriorate in the UK due to the loss of tax revenus due to lower economic output (and growth).

The reality now is that the UK bar London is in terminal decline due to demographics and poor levels of immigration.

Without immigration the UK is simply poorer.

Thats how it works.

Classic dunning Kruger. You really don't understand as much as you think you do.

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 25/09/2022 02:23

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

TooBigForMyBoots · 25/09/2022 02:11

RamblingEclectic · 24/09/2022 23:56

I didn't have the right to vote then, but living in an area that had all UKIP councillors and now has their third incarnation - I don't see any evidence of regrets or why they would. It's benefited them marvelously. They used the second referendum argument to maintain power for years, which entrenched them in the communities while no one else has put the effort in. They've more councillors in my city now than when the Brexit vote happened.

I wonder if Remainers regret relying on the status quo or feel any anger towards those remain politicians who didn't bother to work on any options pre-Brexit to deal with concerns about the EU. I know I was told afterwards that remain didn't need to campaign because it was the status quo - as if incumbents never run campaigns or discuss further changes they want to put in - and that attitude, the attitude that any concern was just foolishness, being thick or racist, that attitude that there was no point in discussing how to improve things with the EU because that would be admitted it's an institution with issues as if the media hadn't been discussing that repeatedly for so long, played right into the Brexitter hands. For all the bile thrown at them, I still think what they called the remain campaign was their own downfall and they should face more of that ire these threads always pull up towards those who voted for Brexit.

Remain campaigned. Vote Leave lied and misrepresented the facts. Anyone who pointed this out was accused of Project Fear. This was ironic considering Leave manipulated people's fears into voting for them. They were also told not to listen to "experts" such as economists and business groups.🤯🤦‍♀️

TooBigForMyBoots · 25/09/2022 02:06

It's OK, PM Truss has plans to increase immigration now.

MintJulia · 25/09/2022 02:04

It depends how you define benefit. There are now many more job vacancies.

If you are looking for a job, that is a huge benefit. If you are an employer, it's harder to recruit certain workers. Any change in regulation benefits some at the expense of others.

jcyclops · 25/09/2022 01:19

The UK joined the EEC on 01/01/1973

Inflation in 1973 was 7% and stayed higher than that for 10 years, and even reached 24% in 1975. Bank base rates also remained above 7% for 10 years.

When we joined, manufacturing accounted for 28% of the economy and employed over 8000 people. When we left it was only 10% of the economy and employed 3000 people.

When we joined, unemployment was 3.8%, but grew to 12% over the next 10 years.

Was this economic hardship due to joining the EEC - probably it had hardly any effect. Was it due to poor decisions from UK governments - partly (both Labour & Tories ruled 1973-1983). Then, as now, the biggest factor was lasting worldwide economic problems resulting from a localised foreign war (Yom Kippur).

The UK will have a hard time economically for at least the next 6-8 years, and again this period could well have both Tory and Labour (maybe in coalition) governments, and very little of the pain we face can be put down to being in or out of Europe.

My view can be summed up as we got 99 problems but Brexit ain't one

trussedchicken · 25/09/2022 00:47

Though thread about Brexit. Dull.

trussedchicken · 25/09/2022 00:46

Another repetitive, boring, holier than

DdraigGoch · 25/09/2022 00:44

Right wing and Brexit are very much entwinned.

The Bennite left were against the EEC from the start, viewing it as a capitalist cartel.

DdraigGoch · 25/09/2022 00:42

BambinaJAS · 24/09/2022 23:12

This is the classic mistake people make who do not work in economic areas.

Artificial labour shortages will ALWAYS lead to reduced output and higher prices. That will then lead to lower economic growth, thus lower tax revenues. Public services will then deteriorate.

See Switzerland. They tried something like Brexit to stop immigratiom and it blew up in their face.

In the case of a builder in a sector who sees a labour shortage now, he will be able to negotiate higher nominal wages, but these will be mostly eroded by higher prices (inflation), thus his real wages did not grow as much.

Very few workers will be able to secure higher real wages (HGV drivers for example are another group that likely will).

In the aggregate, the increase in nominal wages of all of the groups will ALWAYS be beaten by a higher increase in prices (because businesses will cut output and raise prices to survive when they cannot source enough labour to grow), thus leading to a reduction in real wages.

And that is precisely what is happening now. Output is being cut by businesses as they cannot find enough workers, leading to higher prices, whose increase will be higher than any nominal wage increases.

The net effect is that the country as a whole is poorer.

You will see how fast services deteriorate in the UK due to the loss of tax revenus due to lower economic output (and growth).

The reality now is that the UK bar London is in terminal decline due to demographics and poor levels of immigration.

Without immigration the UK is simply poorer.

Thats how it works.

Not all businesses increase prices to accommodate higher wages. Cheap labour allows businesses to be lazy, carrying on as they were with no incentive to innovate. As wages rise, they are forced to look for better productivity. They might now employ one well-paid member of staff to do the job of two low-paid employees, with the help of technology.

DdraigGoch · 25/09/2022 00:12

hoovermanouvre · 24/09/2022 10:37

There is no need for people to be defensive and angry.

Yes there are other threads, but nobody can ever think of a positive.

If you can think of a positive, just explain it.

Those threads do come up with positives, but the OP just sticks their fingers in their ears, pretending not to listen.

RamblingEclectic · 24/09/2022 23:56

I didn't have the right to vote then, but living in an area that had all UKIP councillors and now has their third incarnation - I don't see any evidence of regrets or why they would. It's benefited them marvelously. They used the second referendum argument to maintain power for years, which entrenched them in the communities while no one else has put the effort in. They've more councillors in my city now than when the Brexit vote happened.

I wonder if Remainers regret relying on the status quo or feel any anger towards those remain politicians who didn't bother to work on any options pre-Brexit to deal with concerns about the EU. I know I was told afterwards that remain didn't need to campaign because it was the status quo - as if incumbents never run campaigns or discuss further changes they want to put in - and that attitude, the attitude that any concern was just foolishness, being thick or racist, that attitude that there was no point in discussing how to improve things with the EU because that would be admitted it's an institution with issues as if the media hadn't been discussing that repeatedly for so long, played right into the Brexitter hands. For all the bile thrown at them, I still think what they called the remain campaign was their own downfall and they should face more of that ire these threads always pull up towards those who voted for Brexit.

Swipe left for the next trending thread