Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most Brexiteers must now regret their vote?

534 replies

hoovermanouvre · 24/09/2022 09:29

If you voted Brexit, do you feel like you have been able to "Take Back Control?" If so, where? Can anyone state one positive change since Brexit - I would genuinely like to hear at least something. Anything?

YANBU - I voted Brexit but now regret it
YABU - I voted Brexit and can see a benefit

OP posts:
Walkaround · 25/09/2022 10:22

@orbitalcrisis - it was a massive UK failing in the first place that so many Russian oligarchs have so many UK assets to seize. Too many blind eyes turned to the origins of money coming into the UK for far too many years.

orbitalcrisis · 25/09/2022 10:18

@Alexandra2001 It appears it is hard, but not impossible. '...especially in the wake of Russia’s war in Ukraine, many states are struggling to freeze assets of people sanctioned by the EU for their ties to the Kremlin, or lack legal powers to confiscate frozen assets.' They are planning to make it easier, so it's a very small bonus at best! A bonus that is about to disappear! If it hasn't already! Back to the drawing board then!

www.euractiv.com/section/europe-s-east/news/eu-to-unveil-plans-for-seizing-russian-assets-frozen-by-sanctions/

Walkaround · 25/09/2022 10:18

The problem is, the EU was used as an excuse for British failings for decades, and people believed the excuses. Imvho, the only advantage of Brexit is to lay bare the reality that the failings are largely British ones, it wasn’t the EU causing them or holding the country back, it was the EU propping the country up and helping it look more successful and worthy of listening to on a world stage. Brexit has simply made our lives harder by harming trade and relationships, weakening our own continent as a result, and harming our international reputation for stability - all at the most idiotic time in history to choose to do so. Still, Trump and Putin thought Brexit was an excellent idea, so that’s alright then (and even this fact didn’t spook the majority!).

orbitalcrisis · 25/09/2022 10:12

@Alexandra2001 That's talking about business, not individuals, I believe we seized assets of these oligarchs and the EU cannot do that to their citizens.

TomPinch · 25/09/2022 10:10

Alexandra2001 · 25/09/2022 09:52

@Rinatinabina again, what the US has done, isn't what the UK will do, we are extremely short term in our out look & wont make a loss for a longer term gain.

Looking at the data, UK productivity did not change with expansion of the EU, in fact if anything, it improved very slightly, it dropped off after the GFC.

tradingeconomics.com/united-kingdom/productivity

My own view is that the average UK worker feels under paid, ignored by bosses and exploited, have done for decades & this is (another reason) why our productivity is poor.

Very interesting- I do wonder if in time the GFC will be seen as the cause of the UK's woes rather than Brexit (which I daresay hasn't helped.)

Although as an occasional visitor to the UK I did notice prices shot up after Brexit but not the GFC.

Alexandra2001 · 25/09/2022 10:04

orbitalcrisis · 25/09/2022 09:49

I know of one Brexit benefit! We were able to impose sanctions of Russian Oligarchs who have duel nationality with Finland, the rest of the EU can't as they're EU citizens. That is all.

Sorry to burst your bubble but dual nationality does not protect an EU citizen from being sanctioned.

EU sanctions create legal obligations for all EU operators, and in respect of any business conducted within the EU. Article 13 of the Regulation defines the scope of jurisdiction. Dual nationality does not release a person from EU sanctions
Last updated

11/08/2022

Like most things people blame on or say the EU does, 99.9% turn out to be incorrect.
Like the one of "ever closer union" the text is *ever closer union of the peoples of europe" ... or "We can support Ukraine more" Rubbish - down to member states to decide.
Same with EU army, no such thing, EU is 100% committed to NATO, but should Trump get in, we might all need a European Military.

Walkaround · 25/09/2022 09:59

Alexandra2001 · 25/09/2022 09:52

@Rinatinabina again, what the US has done, isn't what the UK will do, we are extremely short term in our out look & wont make a loss for a longer term gain.

Looking at the data, UK productivity did not change with expansion of the EU, in fact if anything, it improved very slightly, it dropped off after the GFC.

tradingeconomics.com/united-kingdom/productivity

My own view is that the average UK worker feels under paid, ignored by bosses and exploited, have done for decades & this is (another reason) why our productivity is poor.

The average UK worker is underpaid.
www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4639881-britain-and-the-us-are-poor-societies-with-some-very-rich-people-average-polish-family-to-be-better-off-than-the-average-uk-family-by-2024-a-far-cry-from-the-time-when-the-uk-was-the-biggest-economy-in-the-world-when-queen-elizabeth-was-crowned

Alexandra2001 · 25/09/2022 09:52

@Rinatinabina again, what the US has done, isn't what the UK will do, we are extremely short term in our out look & wont make a loss for a longer term gain.

Looking at the data, UK productivity did not change with expansion of the EU, in fact if anything, it improved very slightly, it dropped off after the GFC.

tradingeconomics.com/united-kingdom/productivity

My own view is that the average UK worker feels under paid, ignored by bosses and exploited, have done for decades & this is (another reason) why our productivity is poor.

orbitalcrisis · 25/09/2022 09:51

That was poorly written but hope it still makes sense! We can impose sanctions on a handful of people the EU cannot.

orbitalcrisis · 25/09/2022 09:49

I know of one Brexit benefit! We were able to impose sanctions of Russian Oligarchs who have duel nationality with Finland, the rest of the EU can't as they're EU citizens. That is all.

Walkaround · 25/09/2022 09:48

Auntiepaella · 25/09/2022 07:26

The thing is that Brexit could have been completely different from how it is now.
Brexit isn’t to blame for issues per se- it’s the way it was negotiated and enacted by the Tory government. I wouldn’t say the deal we ended up with was the best, and things would have been far better if we had negotiated better terms than what we ended up with and how it was enacted.
I would say that with a different government in control, it has the potential to be far better than the way it currently works.

The thing is, Brexit could not have been different from how it is now, because those pushing it had a rather obvious agenda that people chose to ignore when they voted, instead listening to the thin veneer of populist bollocks covering the obvious real agenda. And then they listened to populists again in general elections, thus ensuring those pushing the agenda continued to control the direction of flow. The moral of the story is not to vote for a fantasy.

Softplayhooray · 25/09/2022 09:36

Alexandra2001 · 25/09/2022 07:19

Meloni is to the left of Truss and Kwarteng.

I laugh when people say party X in europe is far right, the Tories are the far right party in Europe.

What's there to laugh about? It isn't funny.

And yes our Tory party is very right wing which is awful and I doubt many people don't know it very clearly already. But making that point I'd just whataboutism. Plus it ignores the horrific Mussolini like history of Italy, a sentiment that lingered over the years under many different auspices, and which Meloni has profited off of for votes.

Rinatinabina · 25/09/2022 09:26

Alexandra2001 · 25/09/2022 07:17

Thats all myth - there is no evidence that the uk used cheap labour instead of investment in tech.
Historically, UK business don't invest, they didn't in ship building, steel, cars, lorries, rail, motorcycles or bicycles - all declined or vanished, stats show that in the 50s Triumph/Norton and BSA were (combined) making equivalent profit to that of microsoft now... did they invest? or carry on making m/c based on 1930s designs?

UK companies like profit, dividend & director pay... thats what they are judged on, not R&D or productivity, as per usually, uk always takes the short tern view.
UK wages have not been that low and if they are, have been driven low, not by EU migration but by very low inflation/interest rates and by decline in union power.

As we go into a recession or perhaps a depression and global one at that, UK business wont be spending money on new technology, the opposite will happen.

Productivity in the usa has increased due to increases in automation due to a shortages in labour.

www.washingtonpost.com/business/2021/05/19/automation-labor-economy/

www.reuters.com/article/uk-britain-economy-automation-insight-idUKKCN1MO0CT

So if businesses respond to labour shortages by introducing things like automation it stands to reason they previously didn’t because there was no push to do so due to a plentiful supply of labour.

The increase in capital investment allowances for businesses up to a million should support smaller businesses to start investing in being more productive.

I’m not making a comment on the EU or immigration from the EU, just a much narrower point about UK productivity. Businesses will respond to higher production costs (whether you run a manufacturing site or a clothes shop) by trying to reduce those costs. Higher wage costs or higher regulation around employment encourage firms to invest to reduce overheads.

On an aggregate level immigration increases gdp due to increased economic activity.

ShandaLear · 25/09/2022 08:59

My mother and sister both bitterly regret voting for it and are quite vocal about how everything has turned to shit. They feel they were lied to and manipulated, which they were, in fairness.

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 25/09/2022 08:56

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

GreenGreenArse · 25/09/2022 08:53

Jgw thank you for the (grim) laughs at least!

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 25/09/2022 08:52

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

A4Document · 25/09/2022 08:37

Benefits:

We are no longer on the irreversible 'ever closer union' path to being part of a superstate.

We can make our own trade arrangements around the world, without having to wait for the agreement of 27 other countries.

We will remain fully in control of our own defences and armed forces, and will not have other nations voting us in to an EU army.

We have been able to offer more extensive help to Ukraine.

We were able to respond to COVID more quickly and effectively.

We can have a more inclusive immigration policy to welcome people from around the world on an equal footing, not just the (mostly white, as it happens) EU.

All our laws are decided in this country, by MPs who are directly elected by British constituents and can be voted out.

We don't have to endure the contrived accessories of something which isn't a country but has awarded itself a flag, anthem, motto, annual celebration day, currency, parliament, outer borders, passport and so-called 'citizenship' of itself.

We have the opportunity to replace the Common Agricultural Policy to improve the situation for British farmers.

GrimmTales · 25/09/2022 08:25

THisbackwithavengeance · 25/09/2022 07:59

Staff shortages due to fewer cheaper East European migrants meaning more job vacancies for working class Brits and resulting pay rises. For the first time since the expansion of the EU in 2004, employees are calling the shots. Certainly in my neck of the country anyway (North).

I honestly don't understand how the "socialists" on Mumsnet haven't supported Brexit. It has helped the indigenous working classes and surely all you left wingers should be chuffed to bits with that, no?

I get that most middle class mumsnetters are pissed off because they have lost their cheap domestic staff and their retirement plans to Portugal are fucked.

I was a bloody remainer as well.

This doesn’t make sense to me. “Working class” Brits generally earn more than “middle class” ones. People in trades, construction earn more than those in most office jobs.

Alexandra2001 · 25/09/2022 08:16

THisbackwithavengeance · 25/09/2022 07:59

Staff shortages due to fewer cheaper East European migrants meaning more job vacancies for working class Brits and resulting pay rises. For the first time since the expansion of the EU in 2004, employees are calling the shots. Certainly in my neck of the country anyway (North).

I honestly don't understand how the "socialists" on Mumsnet haven't supported Brexit. It has helped the indigenous working classes and surely all you left wingers should be chuffed to bits with that, no?

I get that most middle class mumsnetters are pissed off because they have lost their cheap domestic staff and their retirement plans to Portugal are fucked.

I was a bloody remainer as well.

What planet are you on?

Average pay rises in UK is approx 6%, inflation is 10% so we are getting poorer.

Pre Brexit, inflation was 1 or 2% avg pay rises 2%

Staff shortages? yes in social care, nhs, drivers, so we have even worse healthcare and supply issues, big benefit for the low paid who can't afford BUPA.

Brexit has also led to Truss and huge pay rises for the wealthy and v little for everyone else.

Most people i know who wanted to retire to europe etc were in trades, able to do up a small house, not poor but hardly M/C either.

I bet you were a remainer.

THisbackwithavengeance · 25/09/2022 07:59

hoovermanouvre · 24/09/2022 09:41

I would like to hear something positive as a result of Brexit and what the point of it was?

Staff shortages due to fewer cheaper East European migrants meaning more job vacancies for working class Brits and resulting pay rises. For the first time since the expansion of the EU in 2004, employees are calling the shots. Certainly in my neck of the country anyway (North).

I honestly don't understand how the "socialists" on Mumsnet haven't supported Brexit. It has helped the indigenous working classes and surely all you left wingers should be chuffed to bits with that, no?

I get that most middle class mumsnetters are pissed off because they have lost their cheap domestic staff and their retirement plans to Portugal are fucked.

I was a bloody remainer as well.

jgw1 · 25/09/2022 07:42

Auntiepaella · 25/09/2022 07:26

The thing is that Brexit could have been completely different from how it is now.
Brexit isn’t to blame for issues per se- it’s the way it was negotiated and enacted by the Tory government. I wouldn’t say the deal we ended up with was the best, and things would have been far better if we had negotiated better terms than what we ended up with and how it was enacted.
I would say that with a different government in control, it has the potential to be far better than the way it currently works.

The trouble with Brexit is that since Freedom Day we have had a series of Remainer Prime Ministers who haven't really believed in Brexit. Now that we have Liz Truss who is a true Brexiteer everything will get sorted out.

Auntiepaella · 25/09/2022 07:26

The thing is that Brexit could have been completely different from how it is now.
Brexit isn’t to blame for issues per se- it’s the way it was negotiated and enacted by the Tory government. I wouldn’t say the deal we ended up with was the best, and things would have been far better if we had negotiated better terms than what we ended up with and how it was enacted.
I would say that with a different government in control, it has the potential to be far better than the way it currently works.

malificent7 · 25/09/2022 07:22

I don't know why you are getting a hard time op...I want to know too.

This country is a complete shit show and yet we are not allowed to ask pertinent questions about Brexit as we might sow divisions.....er right.

Hence lots of threads asking people if they now regret voting Tory ( i want to know too).

Alexandra2001 · 25/09/2022 07:19

Softplayhooray · 25/09/2022 07:01

Thats got literally nothing to do with Brexit.

Aside from which the warning from her is welcome - Meloni is a fascist. That's the last thing Italy needs when there is the unstable Ukraine situation, far more refugees as a result, and the subsequent easy pickings dog whistle situation that that creates for foreigner hating right wingers like Meloni.

OP Brexit was a disaster but it's not possible to have a calm conversation about it online.

Meloni is to the left of Truss and Kwarteng.

I laugh when people say party X in europe is far right, the Tories are the far right party in Europe.