Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most Brexiteers must now regret their vote?

534 replies

hoovermanouvre · 24/09/2022 09:29

If you voted Brexit, do you feel like you have been able to "Take Back Control?" If so, where? Can anyone state one positive change since Brexit - I would genuinely like to hear at least something. Anything?

YANBU - I voted Brexit but now regret it
YABU - I voted Brexit and can see a benefit

OP posts:
jgw1 · 25/09/2022 19:34

StridTheKiller · 25/09/2022 19:21

It's clearly not the brexiteers who are the thick ones here, the number of sad goady remain trollers repeatedly posting this same boring crap is ridiculous. As are all the echochamber voices..
Get. The Fuck. Over. It.

@StridTheKiller What was the one most important reason that you voted for Brexit?

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 25/09/2022 19:30

StridTheKiller · 25/09/2022 19:21

It's clearly not the brexiteers who are the thick ones here, the number of sad goady remain trollers repeatedly posting this same boring crap is ridiculous. As are all the echochamber voices..
Get. The Fuck. Over. It.

Perhaps we aren't bothered if you find us boring. And perhaps we aren't ready to just "get over it" because we are unhappy about the shitshow that Brexit has created.

You exercised your democratic right to vote leave. We are now free to exercise our democratic right to talk about what a terrible decision you made and to speculate about whether you've realised yet what you've done. If you find it boring, other threads are available.

StridTheKiller · 25/09/2022 19:21

It's clearly not the brexiteers who are the thick ones here, the number of sad goady remain trollers repeatedly posting this same boring crap is ridiculous. As are all the echochamber voices..
Get. The Fuck. Over. It.

1982mommaof4 · 25/09/2022 19:20

I voted leave... regret this decision now.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 25/09/2022 19:17

It's funny. When we were in the EU, we were told that we had problems with immigration because we were part of the EU. Now we're outside the EU, we're told that we have problems with immigration because everyone's trying to get out of the EU.

Either way, it seems that people are determined that it's going to be the fault of the EU.

What will they say, I wonder, when Truss is forced to sign trade deals with countries such as India that allow for a significant increase in migration? Will that be the fault of the EU too?

GrimmTales · 25/09/2022 19:10

Riapia · 25/09/2022 18:59

Meanwhile……

Record numbers cross the channel in flimsy dinghies in a desperate attempt to get away from the EU shithole.

They aren’t, though. They would rather live in the UK for many reasons, not that the EU is a shithole. Remember, in a year, lifestyles of average people in Poland will have overtaken those in the U.K, and the poorest in the UK will be 20% worse off than the poorest in Slovenia. There’s a thread about it.

jgw1 · 25/09/2022 19:02

Riapia · 25/09/2022 18:59

Meanwhile……

Record numbers cross the channel in flimsy dinghies in a desperate attempt to get away from the EU shithole.

Wouldn't it be so much better if there was a safe way for these legal migrants to reach the UK?

Riapia · 25/09/2022 18:59

Meanwhile……

Record numbers cross the channel in flimsy dinghies in a desperate attempt to get away from the EU shithole.

scaredoff · 25/09/2022 18:54

Can someone explain to me in clear words why I as a "middle class socialist" should take such pains not to offend the poor little Tory Brexiters despite their having screwed the country and my childrens' future with it, and despite their routinely describing MY social demographic in the most aggressive and insulting terms possible, particularly when we attempted to engage in reasonable debate about the facts of what was being proposed?

What people seem to forget is that some perceptions of facts ARE more accurate than others, and some ways of making decisions about the future based on those facts ARE more likely to result in better or worse outcomes. Some things, to be fair, come down to values. People who said they didn't care about the effect on the economy, they basically just wanted fewer immigrants around for cultural reasons, at least had a position that was coherent. But those who voted Leave because they believed immigration and the single market were bad for the economy and responsible for their falling living standards were wrong. That's not about my judgment of them: they were wrong on their own terms. Economists knew they were wrong and said so at the time. Now Brexit has been done and the country is going to shit, and we're all supposed to "be kind" and spare their poor little feelings? Where was that kindness when we were being called all kinds of stupid stereotypes for trying to steer the vehicle back from the cliff? When people were saying they wanted Brexit precisely in order to "stick it to" all the Liberal Metropolitan Socialist Middle Class types?

lannistunut · 25/09/2022 18:53

Florenz · 25/09/2022 18:40

Everyone votes for selfish reasons. Even those rich people that vote Labour, do so because it makes them feel better about themselves.

I worked with a woman who used to say shit like this, she always said 'people who give to charity are just as selfish as people who don't, because they only do it to make themselves feel better'.

She was a proper twat.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 25/09/2022 18:51

Florenz · 25/09/2022 18:40

Everyone votes for selfish reasons. Even those rich people that vote Labour, do so because it makes them feel better about themselves.

Yes, you can reduce it to that if you like.

Personally, I think there's a massive gulf between people who vote for what suits their own pockets without regard for the likely impact on anyone else, and those who vote for what they believe is "right" because it enables them to maintain their identity as a decent, caring human being. The outcomes of those two types of "selfishness" are likely to be quite different.

Florenz · 25/09/2022 18:45

I do not like it. If it was up to me the UK would be a loose grouping of countries, in the way that the EU was supposed to be, and each region of the UK would be independent and be able to govern itself, set it's own taxes, have different laws and rules and regulations, to suit the people of that region. It's madness to have people in London governing people in Cornwall, or the Highlands of Scotland, just like it is madness to have people in Belgium governing people in Sardinia or Cyprus or Romania. It only leads to discontentment and resentment.

jgw1 · 25/09/2022 18:41

Florenz · 25/09/2022 18:39

I don't agree with big government, and the EU is the very definition of big government. Government should be as small and as local as possible.

Do you also not like the way central government has for the past 12 years gathered more and more powers for itself at the expense of local government?

Florenz · 25/09/2022 18:40

Everyone votes for selfish reasons. Even those rich people that vote Labour, do so because it makes them feel better about themselves.

Florenz · 25/09/2022 18:39

I don't agree with big government, and the EU is the very definition of big government. Government should be as small and as local as possible.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 25/09/2022 18:37

Laurama91 · 25/09/2022 18:28

Sorry but I believe you're vote should be selfish. You should be voting for you and your family. How it effects your life. What you believe in.

That doesn't make sense.

On one hand, you're saying that people should vote selfishly, for themselves and their families and how things will affect their lives.

On the other hand, you're saying that people should vote for what they believe in.

What if those two things aren't compatible?

I'm a relatively high earner. My family is typically better off under the Tories. However, I believe in creating a humane society which cares for its most vulnerable members, so I can't vote Tory.

jgw1 · 25/09/2022 18:36

newsaint · 25/09/2022 18:33

@jgw1

Are you similarly disgusted that we now have new Heads of State and Government in the UK that none of us have voted for?

All of the British MPs, including Liz Truss, are elected directly by the people.

I am not a big monarchist, but believe a (small) monarchy is better than an elected head of state, because it is politically neutral and so represents everyone. And the monarchy has no power over us, whereas the European Commission did.

What do you think of the reasons I gave why Im glad we are out of the EU? Do you prefer your vote to count, or not?

MEPs are also elected directly by people, in fact more directly because they are not elected by a FPTP system, but you seem to have something against them.

So if the President of the EU was a hereditary position you would prefer that. Its not an argument I have heard before, but I am always open to new ideas.

MarshaBradyo · 25/09/2022 18:35

Laurama91 · 25/09/2022 18:28

Sorry but I believe you're vote should be selfish. You should be voting for you and your family. How it effects your life. What you believe in.

You raise a good point. I get the sense from some that other people owe them their vote according to their priorities. It’s a bit arrogant imo.

I don’t expect to influence how other people vote, why is it so common on the left that they do

In a democracy we all get to choose equally. That’s more important to me than telling people they are stupid etc - it implies their vote counts for less.

A party needs to win votes by offering something we each (mostly) connect with. There’s no other influence

newsaint · 25/09/2022 18:33

@jgw1

Are you similarly disgusted that we now have new Heads of State and Government in the UK that none of us have voted for?

All of the British MPs, including Liz Truss, are elected directly by the people.

I am not a big monarchist, but believe a (small) monarchy is better than an elected head of state, because it is politically neutral and so represents everyone. And the monarchy has no power over us, whereas the European Commission did.

What do you think of the reasons I gave why Im glad we are out of the EU? Do you prefer your vote to count, or not?

WatchoRulo · 25/09/2022 18:29

hoovermanouvre · 24/09/2022 09:41

I would like to hear something positive as a result of Brexit and what the point of it was?

No you wouldn't.

scaredoff · 25/09/2022 18:29

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves

We absolutely need to stop showing contempt towards those who are not intelligent and/or informed enough to understand what they are voting for, and we need to do a much better job of explaining things in a way that actually makes sense to people. Dismissing them as stupid doesn't help anyone.

As for showing less contempt towards those who are selfish, blinkered or ideologically driven? Nah, some points of view are not worthy of respect, and contempt is entirely appropriate.

Problem is there's a pretty big overlap in that Venn diagram.

Laurama91 · 25/09/2022 18:28

Sorry but I believe you're vote should be selfish. You should be voting for you and your family. How it effects your life. What you believe in.

jgw1 · 25/09/2022 18:26

newsaint · 25/09/2022 18:16

@hoovermanouvre

I would like to hear something positive as a result of Brexit and what the point of it was?

I voted for brexit and was both amazed and delighted that Leave won. I was also amazed and delighted that the efforts to quash what the people voted for did not succeed.

I voted for brexit because I believe in democracy and the EU is a major anti-democratic force in today's world.

  1. The people of the UK never voted to become part of an EU, which had powers over us and made laws affecting us. It was foisted on us. That is simply unacceptable, a form of Imperialism by stealth. We were happy enough being in the EEC, a trading block, but then this was turned into a political and currency union. No thanks!

  2. There is no direct link between voters and the people who run the EU. Voters vote in MEPs - but these are largely powerless. The real power lies with the un-elected European Commission, which appoints people based on cronyism etc. Prior to the Brexit vote, the European Commission was completely faceless to the typical British person (like me) with personalities only becoming known when they started coming out the woodwork to condemn us.

  3. The EU flagrantly ignores the wishes of people in Europe. There have been multiple referendums in various countries which were considered inconvenient to the EU and so which were either brazenly ignored or re-run until the "correct" result was achieved. Its happened twice in Ireland, once in the Netherlands and once in France - I think there are more examples. That is not democracy, its a pantomime. The people just accept this because they are ignorant patsies, too comfortable in their over-privileged lives to care. But, when the British people vote, what we vote for counts.

  4. We no longer send obscene amounts of money to Brussels, which is better spent in the UK where the money was raised. That can only be a good thing.

  5. While all politicians are greedy, the EUs MEPs really take the biscuit. My figures are a few years old now, but recently a standard MEP earned 109,000 Euros per annum salary and also got 4,500 Euros of unreceipted expenses every month. (They consider it "an invasion of privacy" to have to say what they use expenses for). Its very similar to the British Prime Minister, for example - a whole parliament of Prime Ministers! Not bad for sitting in Brussels, doing nothing, completely without scrutiny. Greedy pigs! Incase you wondered where all the money we sent would go, there is your answer.

  6. Britain can flourish outside the EU which largely operates in the interests of France and Germany alone. Look at Britain's stand-out support for Ukraine currently, for example, while the EU equivocates and directly funds Putin's war machine with their addiction to Russian gas.

  7. Britain can act as a sovereign nation outside the EU, while Brussels meddles in every aspect of the nations in its Union. Countries like Ireland, for example need to get the EU Commision to approve their annual budget before they can implement it. And so countries like Ireland in the EU have less autonomy than, for example, the devolved Scottish or Welsh Parliaments which have full control over their own budgets.

There is 7 exceptionally good reasons and improvements which Brexit has delivered. I could go on and on.

It is troubling that people buy into this false "Brexit has been a disaster" narrative. It has not. Its conditioning people, long term, to seek a return to the EU.

Yes, sometimes the petty French engineer queues at the ports etc, but they have always done that - a petulant nation trying to feel powerful and relevant. They did it when we were in the EU, and they did it before the EEC turned into the EU. So what? We, as adults, can put up with their infantilism.

Many people weigh up Brexit based on the fact it might take them 10 minutes longer to get through passport control. Spare me!

I would certainly agree that we, as yet, have not made full use of the opportunities Brexit has created. With the war in Ukraine and the cost of living etc, the Government has been very busy. Let us hope that the new Truss Government may change that.

Are you similarly disgusted that we now have new Heads of State and Government in the UK that none of us have voted for?

newsaint · 25/09/2022 18:16

@hoovermanouvre

I would like to hear something positive as a result of Brexit and what the point of it was?

I voted for brexit and was both amazed and delighted that Leave won. I was also amazed and delighted that the efforts to quash what the people voted for did not succeed.

I voted for brexit because I believe in democracy and the EU is a major anti-democratic force in today's world.

  1. The people of the UK never voted to become part of an EU, which had powers over us and made laws affecting us. It was foisted on us. That is simply unacceptable, a form of Imperialism by stealth. We were happy enough being in the EEC, a trading block, but then this was turned into a political and currency union. No thanks!

  2. There is no direct link between voters and the people who run the EU. Voters vote in MEPs - but these are largely powerless. The real power lies with the un-elected European Commission, which appoints people based on cronyism etc. Prior to the Brexit vote, the European Commission was completely faceless to the typical British person (like me) with personalities only becoming known when they started coming out the woodwork to condemn us.

  3. The EU flagrantly ignores the wishes of people in Europe. There have been multiple referendums in various countries which were considered inconvenient to the EU and so which were either brazenly ignored or re-run until the "correct" result was achieved. Its happened twice in Ireland, once in the Netherlands and once in France - I think there are more examples. That is not democracy, its a pantomime. The people just accept this because they are ignorant patsies, too comfortable in their over-privileged lives to care. But, when the British people vote, what we vote for counts.

  4. We no longer send obscene amounts of money to Brussels, which is better spent in the UK where the money was raised. That can only be a good thing.

  5. While all politicians are greedy, the EUs MEPs really take the biscuit. My figures are a few years old now, but recently a standard MEP earned 109,000 Euros per annum salary and also got 4,500 Euros of unreceipted expenses every month. (They consider it "an invasion of privacy" to have to say what they use expenses for). Its very similar to the British Prime Minister, for example - a whole parliament of Prime Ministers! Not bad for sitting in Brussels, doing nothing, completely without scrutiny. Greedy pigs! Incase you wondered where all the money we sent would go, there is your answer.

  6. Britain can flourish outside the EU which largely operates in the interests of France and Germany alone. Look at Britain's stand-out support for Ukraine currently, for example, while the EU equivocates and directly funds Putin's war machine with their addiction to Russian gas.

  7. Britain can act as a sovereign nation outside the EU, while Brussels meddles in every aspect of the nations in its Union. Countries like Ireland, for example need to get the EU Commision to approve their annual budget before they can implement it. And so countries like Ireland in the EU have less autonomy than, for example, the devolved Scottish or Welsh Parliaments which have full control over their own budgets.

There is 7 exceptionally good reasons and improvements which Brexit has delivered. I could go on and on.

It is troubling that people buy into this false "Brexit has been a disaster" narrative. It has not. Its conditioning people, long term, to seek a return to the EU.

Yes, sometimes the petty French engineer queues at the ports etc, but they have always done that - a petulant nation trying to feel powerful and relevant. They did it when we were in the EU, and they did it before the EEC turned into the EU. So what? We, as adults, can put up with their infantilism.

Many people weigh up Brexit based on the fact it might take them 10 minutes longer to get through passport control. Spare me!

I would certainly agree that we, as yet, have not made full use of the opportunities Brexit has created. With the war in Ukraine and the cost of living etc, the Government has been very busy. Let us hope that the new Truss Government may change that.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 25/09/2022 18:02

x2boys · 25/09/2022 17:53

Lots of people voted Conservative because of the sheer shambles the Labour Party was in you don't have to agree with that ,but throwing insults at people because you don't agree with how they voted is hardly going to endear them ,is it .

I'm not trying to "endear" myself to anyone. I am not standing for election and I'm not a member of any particular party.

I completely agree that Labour was in a shambles. I didn't consider that a reason for voting Tory at the time, and I still don't.

In any case, I am not throwing insults. I think it would be deeply insulting to suggest that everyone who voted Tory in the last election knew exactly what they voted for. I'm saying the opposite - that many of them didn't realise how bad the Tories would be, and that they do not therefore share the same level of guilt for the situation that we're now in as those who did know what they were voting for and voted for it anyway.