Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most Brexiteers must now regret their vote?

534 replies

hoovermanouvre · 24/09/2022 09:29

If you voted Brexit, do you feel like you have been able to "Take Back Control?" If so, where? Can anyone state one positive change since Brexit - I would genuinely like to hear at least something. Anything?

YANBU - I voted Brexit but now regret it
YABU - I voted Brexit and can see a benefit

OP posts:
WhoDatDen · 26/09/2022 08:01

Can I ask a question please?

I am working class, female, kids left home. I work, but not a high earner and live on the outskirts of a big city in mid England.

What are the benefits for me if we stayed in the EU?

Everyone keeps saying we are worse off, going to hell in a handcart, will be poorer. So if we were in the EU still, how would I be better off?

Please explain to me as I struggle to understand.

TomPinch · 26/09/2022 05:33

The UK head of state performs a purely ceremonial role, so there is nothing undemocratic about him not being elected. In my view it's preferable.

There is no need to elect the head of government because the parliament that determines who the HOG will be is elected. Especially when every member of parliament has personally been voted for.

These are non-issues.

There's a lot of trashing of the UK system of government just now. Brexit should, if nothing else, teach us the dangers of ripping up things that actually do work.

BambinaJAS · 26/09/2022 02:12

StridTheKiller · 25/09/2022 19:21

It's clearly not the brexiteers who are the thick ones here, the number of sad goady remain trollers repeatedly posting this same boring crap is ridiculous. As are all the echochamber voices..
Get. The Fuck. Over. It.

You won't get over it.

You are going to be a lot poorer.

And we are all going to point and laugh at you

And no, we will NOT be helping you or anybody like you.

BambinaJAS · 26/09/2022 02:09

newsaint · 25/09/2022 18:33

@jgw1

Are you similarly disgusted that we now have new Heads of State and Government in the UK that none of us have voted for?

All of the British MPs, including Liz Truss, are elected directly by the people.

I am not a big monarchist, but believe a (small) monarchy is better than an elected head of state, because it is politically neutral and so represents everyone. And the monarchy has no power over us, whereas the European Commission did.

What do you think of the reasons I gave why Im glad we are out of the EU? Do you prefer your vote to count, or not?

You are basically a serf.

Congratulations.

scaredoff · 25/09/2022 23:34

lannistunut · 25/09/2022 18:53

I worked with a woman who used to say shit like this, she always said 'people who give to charity are just as selfish as people who don't, because they only do it to make themselves feel better'.

She was a proper twat.

Yeah, it's a circular argument.

All people who say that are really doing, is defining absolutely any basis for motivation as part of the "self". If you vote for poorer people to get more at your expense, it's to feel good about the economic altruism that you see as part of your "self". If you vote to go to war knowing you will be conscripted, it's because of the heroic notions around war that are part of your "self". etc.

And, amazingly . . . we therefore conclude that people take all these voting decisions for "selfish" reasons. Which basically just means "reasons".

DdraigGoch · 25/09/2022 23:20

GrimmTales · 25/09/2022 22:54

I wouldn’t actually call an outside loo as the marker of poor living standards -even if it was your only one. Poor living standards are mould, damp, vermin, cold, leaking roofs, no furniture, overcrowding, etc.

If you believe that going to the bottom of the garden in the middle of the night, during a thunderstorm would be an acceptable way to live, you do you.

I'll stick with regarding indoor plumbing as an important feature of our civilisation.

DdraigGoch · 25/09/2022 23:12

jgw1 · 25/09/2022 19:02

Wouldn't it be so much better if there was a safe way for these legal migrants to reach the UK?

Or perhaps a programme to provide them with Internet connections, so that they can read Mumsnet and learn about how the UK is the most dreadfulest place in the world. Then they will wonder why they were so desperate to get in.

Name1232 · 25/09/2022 23:00

Benefited us. Low income jobs to fit around family life are now much easier to find.

DdraigGoch · 25/09/2022 22:56

jgw1 · 25/09/2022 17:06

I am not sure I understand what bankers have to do with the engineers and scientists who developed better TVs, phones, washing machines and so on?
Do bankers now create new technologies and media platforms like the one we are using?

How do you think tech startups raise capital?

RootinandTootin · 25/09/2022 22:56

I didn’t vote for brexit but I can say I’ve seen LOADS more paperwork in my line of work because of it and extra cost. I see no benefit at all.

GrimmTales · 25/09/2022 22:54

DdraigGoch · 25/09/2022 22:47

Oh come on! Show me one - just one - rental property on Rightmove that still has an outside khazi as its only alternative to a chamber pot.

I wouldn’t actually call an outside loo as the marker of poor living standards -even if it was your only one. Poor living standards are mould, damp, vermin, cold, leaking roofs, no furniture, overcrowding, etc.

DdraigGoch · 25/09/2022 22:47

lannistunut · 25/09/2022 14:38

You're living in a dream land! Many rental properties are absolutely dreadful and living standards have fallen, two million children now live in poverty.

Oh come on! Show me one - just one - rental property on Rightmove that still has an outside khazi as its only alternative to a chamber pot.

jgw1 · 25/09/2022 20:59

TobyEsterhase · 25/09/2022 20:56

Once again ...

All the brainy scientists and engineers in the world such as Mr Burn cannot advance civilisation one iota without free markets deciding to allocate capital to them

Which will be why Prof Burn had working flat screens of the type that is in many smart phones without any investment from banks...

TobyEsterhase · 25/09/2022 20:56

jgw1 · 25/09/2022 20:45

Since you are keen on smart phones, shall we discuss the development of the screens in them?

How did free markets help this chap
www.science.org.au/profile/paul-burn

Discover light emitting polymers whilst a post doc researcher at the University of Cambridge? Certainly it wasn't by investing in the technology in its early years to help improve it.

Once again ...

All the brainy scientists and engineers in the world such as Mr Burn cannot advance civilisation one iota without free markets deciding to allocate capital to them

jgw1 · 25/09/2022 20:45

TobyEsterhase · 25/09/2022 20:29

Compare your life with that of your grandparents- that is the benefit of the free market.

There would be no internet or smartphones or Mumsnet were it not for the free market.

Admittedly there was far greater equality in the days before free market capitalism took off in 18th century with Industrial Revolution and you were lucky if you lived to 40.

Since you are keen on smart phones, shall we discuss the development of the screens in them?

How did free markets help this chap
www.science.org.au/profile/paul-burn

Discover light emitting polymers whilst a post doc researcher at the University of Cambridge? Certainly it wasn't by investing in the technology in its early years to help improve it.

TobyEsterhase · 25/09/2022 20:37

jgw1 · 25/09/2022 17:06

I am not sure I understand what bankers have to do with the engineers and scientists who developed better TVs, phones, washing machines and so on?
Do bankers now create new technologies and media platforms like the one we are using?

Bankers make decisions about where capital is invested

All the engineers and scientists cannot do anything to advance civilisation without capital markets

Kendodd · 25/09/2022 20:31

lannistunut · 25/09/2022 18:53

I worked with a woman who used to say shit like this, she always said 'people who give to charity are just as selfish as people who don't, because they only do it to make themselves feel better'.

She was a proper twat.

😂

TobyEsterhase · 25/09/2022 20:29

jgw1 · 25/09/2022 17:47

What are the benefits of the free market?

The inequality gap has increased dramatically in the last 12 years, is that a benefit of the free market?

Compare your life with that of your grandparents- that is the benefit of the free market.

There would be no internet or smartphones or Mumsnet were it not for the free market.

Admittedly there was far greater equality in the days before free market capitalism took off in 18th century with Industrial Revolution and you were lucky if you lived to 40.

red4321 · 25/09/2022 20:19

Perfectly proving my point..

The good news is that I can think of at least five threads on this topic in the last few months where all views have been discussed at some length.

jgw1 · 25/09/2022 20:17

red4321 · 25/09/2022 20:14

I voted to leave and don't regret it. Nor do the others I know also who voted leave (shock horror, we all have degrees, some postgraduate qualifications and jobs in professional services just to further enrage the 'All Leave voters are thick and uneducated' posters).

However, this topic has been done to death on MN so I doubt you'll find too many Leave voters volunteering to cop the vitriol and hatred that these threads inevitably descend into.

Yes it is indeed a shame that rather than engaging in discussion Leave voters descend to such vitriol, but then I suppose when you are defending a campaign headed by people who have made their living spouting hatred of those they consider "other" it is not that surprising I suppose.

red4321 · 25/09/2022 20:14

I voted to leave and don't regret it. Nor do the others I know also who voted leave (shock horror, we all have degrees, some postgraduate qualifications and jobs in professional services just to further enrage the 'All Leave voters are thick and uneducated' posters).

However, this topic has been done to death on MN so I doubt you'll find too many Leave voters volunteering to cop the vitriol and hatred that these threads inevitably descend into.

jgw1 · 25/09/2022 20:14

newsaint · 25/09/2022 20:00

@jgw1

MEPs are also elected directly by people

But as I stated before, MEPs do not hold the power. Its the European Commission which runs the EU, not MEPs, and there is no direct link between voters and it.

So if the President of the EU was a hereditary position you would prefer that.

No, because as I also stated before, the UK Monarchy has no political power over us, whereas the EU did have. Its an invalid comparison.

You are obviously pro-EU but would you accept the points I raised originally are perfectly legitimate and reasonable grounds for someone voting for Brexit?

Sorry I got rather stuck on the EU being anti-democratic and the UK having new unelected Heads of State and Government being much more democratic.

I am not pro-EU, prior to the referendum campaign I was firmly for leaving. Given that the Leave campaign singularly failed to provide any rational argument for leaving the EU, but instead was led by some whose views I found so abhorrent I could not vote the same way as them.

Since we have left the EU there have been no discernible benefits and considerable downsides so in that sense I suppose I am becoming more pro-EU, but that is more a reflection of the particular bizarre version of Brexit chosen by the Tory government.

newsaint · 25/09/2022 20:10

@Florenz

Everyone votes for selfish reasons.

I dont, I try to vote based for values - but this means there are very few suitable parties or candidates, given politics is now mostly value-free.

Instead its all about who has the most money and who is jealous and angry about this.

newsaint · 25/09/2022 20:07

Migrants coming to the UK - however they may arrive - is ultimately nothing to do with being in the EU, or not.

The reason we have high inward migration is because the UK has not has a sustainable birth rate for decades now. No other reason.

If people have children at all, it tends to be only 1 or 2, which is not sufficient to replace the population.

(The UN identifies that the replacement rate for a developed nation is 2.1 children per couple - which means couples having 3 in practice, give you cant have 0.1 of a child).

For as long as we have an inadequate birth rate, we will continue to accept high inward migration - its a necessity, not a choice.

But, of course, its better to have a well managed system of accepting desirable migrants (in terms of their language skills, education, values etc) rather than a chaotic unmanaged system.

Being out of the EU means there is more chance of this happening, if the UK - not the EU - has the final say over its own borders.

newsaint · 25/09/2022 20:00

@jgw1

MEPs are also elected directly by people

But as I stated before, MEPs do not hold the power. Its the European Commission which runs the EU, not MEPs, and there is no direct link between voters and it.

So if the President of the EU was a hereditary position you would prefer that.

No, because as I also stated before, the UK Monarchy has no political power over us, whereas the EU did have. Its an invalid comparison.

You are obviously pro-EU but would you accept the points I raised originally are perfectly legitimate and reasonable grounds for someone voting for Brexit?