Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most Brexiteers must now regret their vote?

534 replies

hoovermanouvre · 24/09/2022 09:29

If you voted Brexit, do you feel like you have been able to "Take Back Control?" If so, where? Can anyone state one positive change since Brexit - I would genuinely like to hear at least something. Anything?

YANBU - I voted Brexit but now regret it
YABU - I voted Brexit and can see a benefit

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Alexandra2001 · 28/09/2022 20:24

The UK system is relatively simple. You elect people to parliament, which has supreme lawmaking power, and the. I think the average person understands that the result of the general election will determine who rules them

No different to the EU system then? apart from the EU Parliament have almost no impact on your life - ever since Brexit, no one ever has been able to name a single EU law UK was forced to follow that impacted their life.

Parliament isn't above the law either.

Yes you re right on a sterling crash, we need FOM to Aus.

TomPinch · 28/09/2022 20:11

Alexandra2001 · 28/09/2022 06:48

Rubbish, i doubt few know how Govt/Parliament "works", let alone the influence of lobby groups... so according to you, its undemocratic!

Why the fuck should anyone in the commonwealth have FOM to the UK ? do we in the UK have FOM to NZ, Aus or Canada??? or do we have to be below a certain age, have skills etc etc....

The UK system is relatively simple. You elect people to parliament, which has supreme lawmaking power, and the. I think the average person understands that the result of the general election will determine who rules them.

Regarding FOM and the Commonwealth, it used to be absolute but that's ancient history now. My DGF moved to the UK and fought in the British Army during WW2. No permissions needed. But in more recent times the UK government clamped down on Commonwealth immigration, probably because they wanted to me seen to be doing something about immigration and couldn't or wouldn't (I understand the latter) do anything about EU immigration.

Also my two cents worth on a couple of things BambinaJAS had said:

My DF worked many years in the NHS and he also says that the majority of its budget gets spent on fixing up the elderly. In the past they'd see a gerontologist, ie, managed decline. Now they get fixed up. The change happened in the 90s.

The other point re aging demographics: well, every Western country is dealing with this. That's why immigration is happening.

But that's my last contribution to this sterling-crash of a thread.

Alexandra2001 · 28/09/2022 20:09

MrsHarrisgoestoTimbuctoo · 28/09/2022 18:02

@BambinaJAS
All the tax you and the rest of your cohort paid over you working lifetime does NOT cover what you will extract (pensions, healthcare, social care etc.) because your average life expectancy at 65 is now 18 years.
Those 18 years used to be 10 when you were born.
We are going broke as a country because of that.

So anyone over 55 should go and shoot themselves on the rhubarb?

She isn't wrong, any visit to the GP's (if you can get f2f) or a vascular/stroke/orthopedic will show you the majority of patients are over 60, my DD works on these wards, she spends her entire day dealing with complex age related issues and trying to get them out living at home independently BUT there isn't enough younger folk to care for them at home, so they are stuck in hospital.

With the balance of tax payers to retired increasing, the only way forward is to use the assets of the elderly to pay for their care, not just EOL but all of it (where feasible)

But as Bambina states, the "grey vote" keeps the Tories in power, so there will be no change.

BTW i'm 60, i fully expect to have to fund my care going forward.

The weird thing is, the country was better able to look after the elder IN the EU than it is out, but many (not all) leave voters were too stupid to see that, though i do think the blinkers are coming off.

OldName78 · 28/09/2022 19:58

@BambinaJAS, I'd not categorise the responses like that. My original question was a very open and honest one, being ambivalent on Brexit

But it's classic, not answering the very simple fact-based question, and it why statistics are helpful for some people.

Using the label "thicko leavers" is disparaging. Not everyone has the same educational opportunities in England, and that is something we really need to address, especially in the science and tech areas

MrsHarrisgoestoTimbuctoo · 28/09/2022 19:47

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

BambinaJAS · 28/09/2022 19:44

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

MrsHarrisgoestoTimbuctoo · 28/09/2022 19:41

@OldName78 Enjoy;

www.facebook.com/bbcthree/videos/quickies-breaking-up-with-a-remoaner/2243826552508985/

OldName78 · 28/09/2022 19:32

@MrsHarrisgoestoTimbuctoo, I can't thank you for that. Specifically, your original comment related to research on education level and brexit voting patterns.

@KnightKnurse I guess the person is category 2? Post an answer, not to the question answered.

OK, at least it helps me contextualize any future responses. MN debates are the best!

MrsHarrisgoestoTimbuctoo · 28/09/2022 19:22

@OldName78 Here are some stats for you - don't thank me, my pleasure 🙂

MrsHarrisgoestoTimbuctoo · 28/09/2022 19:18

@OldName78 Just for you -

KnightKnurse · 28/09/2022 19:17

@OldName78 don't be so persistent :) I've seen if many times on MN when a person is debating facts over years here on these forums. They either silently disappear ... and don't answer the question ... or they make another irrelevant comment or criticism ... and don't answer the question. If you expect a fact-based reply you are being fairly silly.

I think the people underestimate the impact of the UKIP messaging at the time with the general public. It seemed very visible to me. As proud Englishwoman I'd agree with several of the top line statements about our country, culture. They seemed to tell a better story at the time.

OldName78 · 28/09/2022 18:46

@MrsHarrisgoestoTimbuctoo My original comment with respect to education and Brexit voting patterns, was stating a fact. You might not like it?

If you are have a basic understanding of stats you might enjoy this.
www.statsguy.co.uk/brexit-voting-and-education/

Still hoping you'll share some reputable links. Thanking you in advance 😀

BambinaJAS · 28/09/2022 18:38

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

MrsHarrisgoestoTimbuctoo · 28/09/2022 18:34

@OldName78 I'm very interested to see the links I hope you can share on education level and Brexit vote. I look forward to reading them.

Really? I'm sure someone who could speak Latin at 11 and was probably reciting the Rubáiyát of Omar Khayyám in their pram, doesn't need any help from me.

It would help enhance the credibility of your posts on this thread, with me.

And I should be bothered about your opinion because.......?

red4321 · 28/09/2022 18:34

If you disagree so strongly then feel free to disprove her "rude and ageist" posts with facts and statistics. Oh wait, you can't.

With respect, the overriding tone of the debate is hardly going to encourage participation from both sides given some of the puerile comments. Particularly ironic given one of the central arguments is level of education.

These Brexit threads tend to go one way. Remain voters hurl insults and offensive comments at Leave voters, who decide there's very little to be gained from participating in anything that is notionally couched as a debate.

Thus the thread becomes another happy echo chamber of Remain voters.

There was a brilliant thread recently about why people voted Conservative. All posts were respectful and, as a result, it was a very interesting debate with valid points raised on both sides.

Grandeur · 28/09/2022 18:26

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 28/09/2022 18:10

Also @Grandeur @BambinaJAS does not have lots of good points... She is rude and ageist!!!

I can never tell when you're being sarcastic or not tbh.

I think it's so funny how offended people are getting though, reporting all posts that include the term "boomer" which is being used in reference to the generation demographic, as if it's somehow being used as an insult.

Bambina included a lot of statistics and factual information based on economic and financial models, where age and generation are entirely relevant. If you disagree so strongly then feel free to disprove her "rude and ageist" posts with facts and statistics. Oh wait, you can't.

OldName78 · 28/09/2022 18:23

@MrsHarrisgoestoTimbuctoo I'm very interested to see the links I hope you can share on education level and Brexit vote. I look forward to reading them. It would help enhance the credibility of your posts on this thread, with me. Thanking you in advance!

BambinaJAS · 28/09/2022 18:23

Ratched · 28/09/2022 18:02

I actually have some sympathy for your argument here. I just object to the tone of it.
Why pitch old against young?
We know there is a problem with funding in this country and I absolutely agree it needs discussion. But rather than advocating mass extermination of the over 60s, why can't we work together to discuss possible solutions?

There are lots of potential money saving options that would benefit everyone, but rather than consider them, your first line of attack is at people who were simply born at the 'wrong' time.

When you have natured a little bit, we can discuss and debate😉

The reason is political.

The Grey Vote keeps the Conservatives in power via FPTP.

In order to keep staying in power, the Conservatives funnel more money and freebies to the Grey Vote to the detriment of everybody else (children and working people). This has gotten so bad over the last 20 years that the Grey Vote has the lowest poverty rate of any demographic. Working people are actually poorer than the retired folks now (which is really crazy).

I would LOVE to have a rational conversation about long-term public funding but from historical experience I can tell you:

The vast majority of the over 65s do not want to hear it. They are simply not interested. Their "feelings" are their own truth, and no "facts" will change their views.

I have come to the conclusion that this problem is being driven by a lack of education among the over 65s.

The educated over 65s (yes they do exist), are more than willing to listen to the facts, and wil be more than happy to discuss the situation. They understand funding levels, lifetime contributions, life expectancy, and economic fairness.

The less educated over 65s (these are found in the leave voting areas) will simply complain and call you ageist, a bad person, "we paid in all of our lives", etc.. They are simply not interested, and that is a function of being unable to understand (education), some degree of denial (not my problem types), and straight up bigotry (don't want my tax going to those foreigners sort of thing).

Worth saying:

The more the situation gets ignored due to politics, the worse the snap financial correction will be, primarily because at that point the funding difference (being subsidised by the working folks and public debt) will be substantial.

What you are seeing now in the markets, is a small window into the snap financial correction that I have referred to.

scaredoff · 28/09/2022 18:15

Oh I've heard of it alright. A friendly unicorn told me all about it.

MrsHarrisgoestoTimbuctoo · 28/09/2022 18:11

@scaredoff That last part doesn't follow - it can cost plenty more in healthcare and other costs for an elderly person than the price of an extension.

The people I am talking about have private healthcare, as I do.

The money spent on an extension will help keep a business running, which will provide employment for others - never heard of 'trickle-down economics'?

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 28/09/2022 18:10

Also @Grandeur @BambinaJAS does not have lots of good points... She is rude and ageist!!!

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 28/09/2022 18:09

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I'm not a boomer. Born in the early 1970s. Sorry to disappoint you HUN. Grin

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 28/09/2022 18:08

Ratched · 28/09/2022 17:54

I absolutely agree with everything you've said.

I admitted, I have been lucky, by an accident of when I was born. I can't help that, but I am being demonised for it.
I tried to put over how from the age of 17 to, probably mid to late 30s, money was extremely tight, then children being older, better salary due to experience etc,, made life a lot nicer, simply to try and show that it wasn't plain sailing for all of our/my life.
When my husband was made redundant in the crash in the 90s, he took the only job he could find to keep us afloat. He worked 300 miles away and slept on a colleagues floor while I worked full time during the day and 2 evenings a week to try and keep our house from being repossessed.

BUT - I freely acknowledge, I am one of the lucky ones. I just cannot flagellate myself enough to make some people happy 😁

Fair enough! 😘

nyteflyte · 28/09/2022 18:05

Asking people if they regret their choice is not very useful or interesting for me. We had the vote, I wanted to stay in EU, but the result in and it's over.

While it's over for now things do change and evolve over a longer timescale and people are not great on these predictions. We voted to leave now, we voted to join 50 years ago. Who knows about the future? Vote to rejoin the EU? It's possible that neither the EU or the UK will exist in their current for by them?

I'd expect re-joining would be problematic too. There are always a distinct anti-English undertone in much of the EU (just English, not for Scots or Welsh or Irish) at many levels. That will only get worse there after we win the world cup 😀

Ratched · 28/09/2022 18:02

BambinaJAS · 28/09/2022 17:38

What do do you need to do?

Thats easy.

Start paying in for your healthcare and social care.

The UK is the only developed country that does not make retired people pay in for their healthcare and social care.

Essentially,

It is working people (via NI) that fund healthcare spending.

And 80% of NHS spending is on the over 55s

We are un-productive as a country because we do not invest in the younger generation. Instead, its gets funelled to pay for the ever increasing healthcare and pension costs of the retired population.

When people say "I paid in all my life and I paid the necessary tax"....

As a GROUP, that is FALSE.

All the tax you and the rest of your cohort paid over you working lifetime does NOT cover what you will extract (pensions, healthcare, social care etc.) because your average life expectancy at 65 is now 18 years.

Those 18 years used to be 10 when you were born.

We are going broke as a country because of that.

I actually have some sympathy for your argument here. I just object to the tone of it.
Why pitch old against young?
We know there is a problem with funding in this country and I absolutely agree it needs discussion. But rather than advocating mass extermination of the over 60s, why can't we work together to discuss possible solutions?

There are lots of potential money saving options that would benefit everyone, but rather than consider them, your first line of attack is at people who were simply born at the 'wrong' time.

When you have natured a little bit, we can discuss and debate😉

Swipe left for the next trending thread