Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

For wanting to do a Ouija board for a laugh?

558 replies

EbbyEbs · 24/09/2022 08:25

Next year DH and I are staying in a castle thought to be the most haunted in Britain. DH says he doesn’t believe in stuff like that, I’m on the fence really but more towards not believing. I think the most likely scenario if ghosts ARE real is that they’re historical residue and not intelligent entities. But even that is a stretch.

So, I’d like to do a ouija board when we’re there for a laugh. The castle is in the middle of nowhere so there isn’t much else to do on an evening other than drink (which I don’t do) and watch Netflix!

DH is point blank refusing saying he isn’t messing about with stuff like that. But he’s a non believer??! So what’s the harm?

If he doesn’t believe in it, am I being unreasonable to ask him to do it?

OP posts:
Miffee · 27/09/2022 19:45

DillDanding · 27/09/2022 19:36

But for some reason known only to themselves the non-believers want to push their point of view rather aggressively.

To me, it’s like trying to debate with a flat-earther.

You start of thinking explaining something will get through the fog, but then you just have to give up.

I honestly find it fascinating. These tactics work in real life really well. If your friend or collegue becomes skeptical or derisive about your belief in woo and you feign distress or claim victimhood they would back off. You don't need to engage with their argument, acting like you may get upset is enough. In a real life situation in general conversation it would be incredibly rude for your friend continue to try and explain their skepticism and ask for and explanation if you imply it would upset you. Instead you both just drop it.

That's fine in real life but you can't rely on the same tactics on a message board where the primary aim is to foster and facilitate discussion. Without that tactic people flounder, they keep trying it and wonder why it isn't working.

Imtoowettowoo · 27/09/2022 19:44

@Miffee 1-Ghosts defy all natural laws and don't even follow internal logic.
Link to research paper please. Also define ''ghost".

2-The specific phenomenon of Ouija Boards have been extensively studied.
Not only did they find no evidence of any other wordly goings on but they found exactly was what was happening.

Link to research paper(s) please.

3-There is no explanation as to why a mass-produced item such a ouija board would work to summon spirits.

That's because it doesn't. It's the intention of the participants that is purported to do that.
4-There is no explanation why they need human participants.

Who or what needs human participants ?

5-There is no consistency in the reported results of spirit communication via ouija board.

Link?

ReneBumsWombats · 27/09/2022 19:43

Imtoowettowoo · 27/09/2022 19:24

@ReneBumsWombats I'm embarrassed for you.

Ah-ha, the ubiquitous mumsnet put-down, I wondered when that was going to appear in the absence of rational arguments !

No, I get that you think you're turning my methods on me in this incredibly devastating manner. That's what makes it so embarrassing.

But sadly for you, "Kids needed counselling after using a Ouija board BUT CAUSALITY! DIDN'T THINK OF THAT, DID YOU? HAHAHAHA!" isn't even remotely on the same level as a statement as "Ouija is provably caused by ideomotor movement and if a kid needs counselling, harm has been done."

You may not know what causality or false equivalences are, but I think you do. You've just realised how very silly your recent posts are, so now you're trying to deflect again so they'll get buried. But these ones are even dafter.

Who, exactly, do you think doesn't see through this?

DillDanding · 27/09/2022 19:36

But for some reason known only to themselves the non-believers want to push their point of view rather aggressively.

To me, it’s like trying to debate with a flat-earther.

You start of thinking explaining something will get through the fog, but then you just have to give up.

Miffee · 27/09/2022 19:33

Imtoowettowoo · 27/09/2022 19:24

@ReneBumsWombats I'm embarrassed for you.

Ah-ha, the ubiquitous mumsnet put-down, I wondered when that was going to appear in the absence of rational arguments !

You must have missed some posts.

The rational arguments that Ouija Boards do not summon evil or in any way engage with ghosts/spirits or similar are numerous.

1-Ghosts defy all natural laws and don't even follow internal logic.

2-The specific phenomenon of Ouija Boards have been extensively studied. Not only did they find no evidence of any other wordly goings on but they found exactly was what was happening.

3-There is no explanation as to why a mass-produced item such a ouija board would work to summon spirits.

4-There is no explanation why they need human participants.

5-There is no consistency in the reported results of spirit communication via ouija board.

That's just off the top of my head.

Just like you I must have missed your rational arguments. Can you remind me so I can give them the proper consideration?

Imtoowettowoo · 27/09/2022 19:28

@LowbrowVictoriana By doing so they're perpetuating the myth of Ouija being 'dangerous' and unleashing evil. And as has been noted, this will attract as many as it will deter and further harm may ensue.

So what would you suggest?

That mumsnet employs it's own "censorship" and bans discussion on certain topics ?

Imtoowettowoo · 27/09/2022 19:24

@ReneBumsWombats I'm embarrassed for you.

Ah-ha, the ubiquitous mumsnet put-down, I wondered when that was going to appear in the absence of rational arguments !

LowbrowVictoriana · 27/09/2022 19:23

Imtoowettowoo · 27/09/2022 19:09

@ReneBumsWombats We've had stories here about kids who got so distressed they needed professional help afterwards.

Yup stories. And the evidence as to what caused this is ....???

That's clearly harm.

Maybe it is, maybe it isn't but has causality been proved? - I think not.

but has causality been proved? - I think not

Exactly. But people on here are reporting all sorts of bad experiences, mostly quite vague, but including the death of 6 fit and healthy 40-something friends in close succession(!), and the extreme distress and upset of some teenage girls and ascribing these to Ouija.

By doing so they're perpetuating the myth of Ouija being 'dangerous' and unleashing evil. And as has been noted, this will attract as many as it will deter and further harm may ensue.

Imtoowettowoo · 27/09/2022 19:22

@mamabear715 some people believe, some don't, & never the twain shall meet..

I agree totally.

But for some reason known only to themselves the non-believers want to push their point of view rather aggressively.

I'm not sure who they want to convince, themselves or others ? 🙂

ReneBumsWombats · 27/09/2022 19:19

Imtoowettowoo · 27/09/2022 19:09

@ReneBumsWombats We've had stories here about kids who got so distressed they needed professional help afterwards.

Yup stories. And the evidence as to what caused this is ....???

That's clearly harm.

Maybe it is, maybe it isn't but has causality been proved? - I think not.

This is your weakest attempt yet. I'm embarrassed for you.

Miffee · 27/09/2022 19:16

Yup stories. And the evidence as to what caused this is ....???
😁

Miffee · 27/09/2022 19:15

Imtoowettowoo · 27/09/2022 19:01

@Miffee
Every time this debate comes up believers try and claim some sort of victimisation.

It's not a "claim" as posts have been deleted and the posters warned of sanctions. So are you saying the Mumsnet mods are biased?

I think it's in poor taste but it's always the last (indeed only) resort.

That's your opinion, which IMO is bollocks. However, you are allowed to express it however stupid it makes you look !

I know at least one deleted post was a believer.

You are the one saying I look stupid, yet you are saying you are being called names.

I am not offended as I think it's incredibly obvious that the person saying "a bit of wood can't summon evil" is not the stupid one in the debate.

mamabear715 · 27/09/2022 19:11

Oh, please let this thread die.. no pun intended.. some people believe, some don't, & never the twain shall meet..

Imtoowettowoo · 27/09/2022 19:09

@ReneBumsWombats We've had stories here about kids who got so distressed they needed professional help afterwards.

Yup stories. And the evidence as to what caused this is ....???

That's clearly harm.

Maybe it is, maybe it isn't but has causality been proved? - I think not.

LowbrowVictoriana · 27/09/2022 19:04

strugglingwithlife · 27/09/2022 17:43

That's what I've always wondered about as well, doesn't make sense

Don't be daft. It makes perfect sense.

Not all spirits are poltergeists, you know. They can't all knock books off the shelf, hide your keys or throw your drying rack around.

Those more wispy, ectoplasmic entities and orbs are given a "voice" by Ouija; along with the groaners and the plumbing rattlers, whose ability to move things is restricted to banging pipes.

Not forgetting those many grey ladies in historic dress, trapped in castles and manor houses who can move, yes, but don't have the power to affect other things or otherwise communicate.

They all deserve to have their say.

Imtoowettowoo · 27/09/2022 19:01

@Miffee
Every time this debate comes up believers try and claim some sort of victimisation.

It's not a "claim" as posts have been deleted and the posters warned of sanctions. So are you saying the Mumsnet mods are biased?

I think it's in poor taste but it's always the last (indeed only) resort.

That's your opinion, which IMO is bollocks. However, you are allowed to express it however stupid it makes you look !

ReneBumsWombats · 27/09/2022 18:56

And who is to be the judge of what's "harmful" to others?

We've had stories here about kids who got so distressed they needed professional help afterwards. That's clearly harm.

Miffee · 27/09/2022 18:55

Imtoowettowoo · 27/09/2022 18:49

@IAcceptCookies
Where someones belief in bollocks may be harmful to themselves or others, then really, it's worth at least mentioning.

And who is to be the judge of what's "harmful" to others?

I think this thread has gone a bit past "mentioning" anything. Those that don't subscribe to the "it's bollocks" theory have been insulted and personally attacked.
So much so that the mods have had to intervene.

Some people here just don't know what civil debate is.🙄It's like the mantra of Socialists - we know what's best for you whether you like it or not !

Every time this debate comes up believers try and claim some sort of victimisation. I think it's in poor taste but it's always the last (indeed only) resort.

Miffee · 27/09/2022 18:53

Imtoowettowoo · 27/09/2022 14:52

@Miffee It perpetuates the harm. Apparently they can be frightening to the point of people requiring counselling. Perpetrating the myth that they can cause harm via the spirit world reinforces this

I don't get that argument.

If people choose to avoid them, as I said, then how is that harmful?

I can't see the point of them, and neither can anyone I know, and we all choose to leave them alone, for that reason and also just in case there is something dodgy about them.

That's common sense to me.

It's not common sense to avoid them in case they are "dodgy', it's the complete opposite. It defies all sense.

The action of avoiding then because one believes (against all reason) that they can summon evil is fine. No harm. The harm comes from saying they are dangerous or dodgy. It's not on the level of the harm from saying vaccines have microchips but it still bears challenging.

Imtoowettowoo · 27/09/2022 18:49

@IAcceptCookies
Where someones belief in bollocks may be harmful to themselves or others, then really, it's worth at least mentioning.

And who is to be the judge of what's "harmful" to others?

I think this thread has gone a bit past "mentioning" anything. Those that don't subscribe to the "it's bollocks" theory have been insulted and personally attacked.
So much so that the mods have had to intervene.

Some people here just don't know what civil debate is.🙄It's like the mantra of Socialists - we know what's best for you whether you like it or not !

Miffee · 27/09/2022 18:47

strugglingwithlife · 27/09/2022 17:43

That's what I've always wondered about as well, doesn't make sense

Ghost story bollocks never does. The complete lack of internal logic does not dissuade its proponents though.

strugglingwithlife · 27/09/2022 17:43

ReneBumsWombats · 27/09/2022 14:54

The spirits can move objects on their own but can't move the Ouija planchette unless your hand is on it.

That's what I've always wondered about as well, doesn't make sense

ReneBumsWombats · 27/09/2022 17:38

To add, most people who play Ouija do it precisely because they do think it'll contact spirits. As a PP said, people want to believe this nonsense. Spreading the idea that it's dangerous will put some people off but it'll encourage many others. Especially when, as several PPs have done, you frame it as people not being able to handle the power they're unleashing. For a lot of woo people, that amounts to "challenge accepted".

Whereas the more people understand that it's easily explained and not real and as occult as Monopoly, the less we'll have the fear and belief that are the only dangerous things about it.

ReneBumsWombats · 27/09/2022 16:33

The harm comes in perpetuating the idea that the boards could unleash evil spirits upon you. "Don't do the Ouija because you'll contact demons who can crack your mirror and crash your car although they can't move the planchette without your help" encourages the fear and belief that are the cause of anything bad that results. "Don't bother with Ouija because it's a demonstrable crock of shite that's been proven to work by ideomotor movement" is rather different.

The danger is in the belief. Anything that encourages the belief is part of that.

Remember when Derren Brown got a load of students to use the board to spell out messages from a young woman who had taken her own life and whose photo was next to them to help channel her spirit?

If you didn't see it, guess who was sitting alive and well a short distance away, waiting to be introduced?

LowbrowVictoriana · 27/09/2022 16:26

If people choose to avoid them, as I said, then how is that harmful?

If they're avoiding them because they believe it's a dangerous portal to a spirit world, then yes the harm is still potentially there. As long as this idea is perpetuated, then harm is possible.

Credulous teenagers will egg each other on, drink emboldened young people will do it for fun. Hurt will happen.

If they avoided it because it has all the power of the piece of wood pulp that it is, then there's no risk whatsoever.